Our study, the first to test the impact of self-regulation on industrial accidents, examines Responsible Care (RC) in the US chemical manufacturing sector. RC requires members to adhere to codes of conduct on production safety and pollution prevention. Using our author-constructed database of 1,867 firms that own 2,963 plants between 1988 and 2001, we instrument for firms’ self-selection into RC using pollution-related regulatory pressure on firms that influences their probability of joining RC, but not plant-level accidents. We find that participation in RC reduces the likelihood of accidents by 2.99 accidents per 100 plants in a given year, or by 69.3%. Participation in RC also reduces the likelihood of process safety accidents and accidents related to violations of RC codes by 5.75 accidents per 100 plants in a given year, or by 85.9%. Alternatively, estimates using Propensity Score Matching (PSM) methods indicate that participation in RC reduces the likelihood of accidents by 0.66 accidents per 100 plants in a given year. The reduction in the likelihood of accidents, due to participation in RC, contributes to economically significant averted losses, with savings, even based on the smaller PSM estimates, totaling $180 million per year.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Aakvik A. (2001) Bounding a matching estimator: The case of a norwegian training program. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 63(1): 115–143
Allen D. T., Shonnard D. R. (2001) Green engineering: Environmentally conscious design of chemical processes and products. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ
Altonji J. G., Elder T. E., Taber C. R. (2005) Selection on observed and unobserved variables: Assessing the effectiveness of Catholic schools. The Journal of Political Economy 113(1): 151–184
American Chemistry Council (ACC) (Renamed Chemical Manufacturers’ Association). (1990). Responsible care: Codes of management practices. Archived at the International Labor Organization Corporate Codes of Conduct.
Angrist J. D. (1999) Estimation of limited dependent variable models with dummy endogenous regressors: Simple strategies for empirical practice. Journal of Business and Economics Statistics 19(1): 2–28
Armenti, K. (2004). Pollution prevention and worker protection. In U.S. general services administration. Sustainable development and society (pp. 41–48). Washington, DC: GSA Office of Governmental Policy.
Armenti K., Moure-Eraso R., Slatin C., Geiser K. (2003) Joint occupational and environmental pollution prevention strategies: A model for primary prevention. New Solutions, A Journal of Environmental and Occupational Health Policy 13(3): 241–259
Baker Report. (2007). The report of the BP U.S. refineries independent safety review panel.
Baram M. S. (1986) Public health and the law: Chemical industry accidents, liability, and community right to know. American Journal of Public Health 76(5): 568–572
Barkenbus J. N. (1983) Is self-regulation possible?. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 2(4): 576–588
Belke J. C., Dietrich D. Y. (2005) The post-Bhopal and post-9/11 transformations in chemical emergency prevention and response policy in the United States. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 18: 375–379
Bhattacharya J., Goldman D., McCaffrey D. (2006) Estimating probit models with self-selected treatments. Statistics in Medicine 25(3): 389–413
Blacconiere W. G., Patten D. M. (1994) Environmental disclosures, regulatory costs and changes in firm value. Journal of Accounting and Economics 18: 357–377
Booker K., Sass T. R., Gill B., Zimmer R. (2011) The effects of charter high schools on educational attainment. Journal of Labor Economics 29(2): 377–415
Bomsel O., Börkey P., Glachant M., Lévêque F. (1996) Is there room for environmental self-regulation in the mining sector?. Resources Policy 22(1–2): 79–86
Börkey, P., Glachant, M., Lévêque, F. (2000). Voluntary approaches for environmental policy in OECD countries: An assessment. Center for Industrial Economics, Paris School of Mines and OECD.
Broder I. E., Morrall J. F. (1991) Incentives for firms to provide safety: Regulatory authority and capital market reactions. Journal of Regulatory Economics 3(4): 309–322
Caliendo M., Hujer R., Thomson S. (2008) The employment effects of job creation schemes in germany: A microeconometric evaluation. In: Fomby T., Hill R. C., Millimet D. L., Smith J. A. (Eds.) Advances in econometrics, volume 21: Estimating and evaluating treatment effects in econometrics. Emerald Group Publishing Ltd, Bingley, pp 383–428
Capelle-Blancard G., Laguna M.-A. (2010) How does the stock market respond to chemical disasters?. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 59(2): 192–205
Charles River Associates, Inc. (1989). Industrial profile and cost assessment of a proposed OSHA. Standard concerning process hazard managements in the chemical and petroleum industries. Prepared for the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, Boston, MA.
Chemical Safety Board (CSB-First Chemical Corp). (2003). Investigation report: Explosion and fire: First chemical corp. Chemical Safety Board: Washington, DC.
Chemical Safety Board (CSB-Texas City). (2007). Final investigation report: Refinery explosion and fire. Texas City, TX: BP American Refinery Explosion.
Chiburis, R. C., Das, J., & Lokshin, M. (2011). A practical comparison of the bivariate probit and linear IV estimators. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 5601.
Christen, P. (2008). FEBRL: A freely available record linkage system with a graphical user interface. In Proceedings of the second Australasian workshop on health data and knowledge management (Vol. 80, pp. 17–25). Wollongong, NSW.
Cohen, M. A., Gottlieb, M., Linn, J., & Richardson, N. (2011). Deepwater drilling: Law, policy, and economics of firm organization and safety. Resources for the Future Discussion Paper 10-65.
Cosslett S. (1981) Efficient estimation of discrete-choice models. In: Manski C. F., McFadden D. (Eds.) Structural analysis of discrete data with econometric applications. MIT Press, Cambridge, pp 51–111
Dawson N. L., Segerson K. (2008) Voluntary agreements with industries: Participation incentives with industry-wide targets. Land Economics 84(1): 97–114
Dechy N., Bourdeaux T., Ayrault N., Kordek M.-A., Le Coze J.-C. (2004) First lessons of the Toulouse ammonium nitrate disaster, 21st September 2001, AZF plant, France. Journal of Hazardous Materials 111(1–3): 131–138
Deepwater Horizon Study Group. (2011). Final report on the investigation of the macondo well blowout. Center for Catastrophic Risk Management, University of California at Berkeley.
Deily M. E., Gray W. B. (2007) Agency structure and firm culture: OSHA, EPA, and the steel industry. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 23(3): 685–709
Dlouhy, J. A. (2011). Safety plans could clash: Offshore drillers pressured to form watchdog. Houston Chronicle January 9, 2011.
Elliott M. R., Wang Y., Kleindorfer P. R., Lowe R. A. (2004) Environmental justice: Community pressure and frequency and severity of U.S. chemical industry accidents. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 58(1): 24–30
Er J., Kunreuther H. C., Rosenthal I. (1998) Utilizing third-party inspections for preventing major chemical accidents. Risk Analysis 18(2): 145–153
Evans W. N., Schwab R. M. (1995) Finishing high school and starting college: Do catholic schools make a difference?. Quarterly Journal of Economics 110(4): 947–974
Fellegi I. P., Sunter A. B. (1969) A theory for record linkage. Journal of the American Statistical Association 64(328): 1183–1210
Gamper-Rabindran S. (2006) Did the EPA’s voluntary industrial toxics program reduce plants’ emissions? A gis analysis of distributional impacts and a by-media analysis of substitution. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 52(1): 391–410
Gamper-Rabindran, S., & Finger, S. (2012). Does self-regulation reduce pollution? Responsible care program in the chemical industry. Journal of Regulatory Economics, forthcoming.
Garber S., Hammitt J. K. (1998) Risk premiums for environmental liability: Does superfund increase the cost of capital?. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 36(3): 267–294
Glachant M. (2007) Non-binding voluntary agreements. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 54(1): 32–48
Gray W. B., Jones C. A. (1991) Are OSHA health inspections effective? A longitudinal study in the manufacturing sector. Review of Economics and Statistics 73(3): 504–508
Gray W. B., Mendeloff J. M. (2005) The declining effects of OSHA inspections on manufacturing injuries: 1979 to 1998. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 58(4): 571–587
Gray W. B., Scholz J. T. (1993) Does regulatory enforcement work? A panel analysis of OSHA enforcement. Law and Society Review 27(1): 177–213
Greene W. (2004) The behaviour of the maximum likelihood estimator of limited dependent variable models in the presence of fixed effects. Econometrics Journal 7: 98–119
Hamilton J. T. (1995) Testing for environmental racism: Prejudice, profits, political power?. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 14(1): 107–132
Heckman J. J. (1978) Dummy endogenous variables in simultaneous equation system. Econometrica 46(6): 931–959
Heckman J. J., Ichimura H., Todd P. E. (1997) Matching as an econometric evaluation estimator: Evidence from evaluating a job training programme. The Review of Economic Studies 64(221): 605–654
Heyes A. (2005) A signalling motive for self-regulation in the shadow of coercion. Journal of Economics and Business 57(3): 238–246
Hofmann D. A., Jacobs R., Landy F. L. (1995) High reliability process industries: Individual, micro, and macro organizational influences on safety. Journal of Safety Research 26(3): 131–149
Hopkins A. (2000) Lessons from Longford: The Esso gas plant explosion. CCH Australia Limited, North Ryde
Khanna M., Damon L. (1999) EPA’s voluntary 33/50 program: Impact on toxic releases and economic performance of firms. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 37(1): 1–25
King A. A., Lenox M. J. (2000) Industry self-regulation without sanctions: The chemical industry’s responsible care program. Academy of Management Journal 43(4): 698–716
Klein L. R. (1953) A textbook of econometrics. Row, Peterson & Co, Evanston, IL, p 258
Kleindorfer P. R., Belke J. C., Elliott M. R., Lee K., Lowe R. A., Feldman H. I. (2003) Accident epidemiology and the U.S. chemical industry: Accident history and worst-case data from RMP info. Risk Analysis 23(5): 865–881
Kleindorfer P. R., Elliott M. R., Wang Y., Lowe R. (2004) drivers of accident preparedness and safety: Evidence from the RMP rule. Journal of Hazardous Material 115(1–3): 9–16
Kleindorfer, P. R., Kunreuther, H. C. (Eds.) (1987) Insuring and managing hazardous risks: From Seveso to Bhopal and beyond. Springer, New York
Konar S., Cohen M. A. (2001) Does the market value environmental performance?. Review of Economics and Statistics 83(2): 281–289
Krause R. T. (2004) Influencing the behavior of senior leadership: What makes a great safety leader?. Professional Safety 49(6): 29–33
Levinson A. (2004) Review of new tools for environmental protection: Education, information, and voluntary measures. Journal of Economic Literature 42(1): 171–231
Lyon T. P., Maxwell J. W. (2004) Corporate environmentalism and public policy. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Maddala G. S. (1983) Limited-dependent and qualitative variables in econometrics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
Maxwell J. W., Lyon T., Hackett S. (2000) Self-regulation and social welfare: The political economy of corporate environmentalism. Journal of Law and Economics 63(43): 583–617
Mendeloff J. M., Gray W. B. (2005) Inside the black box: How do OSHA inspections lead to reductions in workplace injuries?. Law and Policy 27(2): 219–237
Mendeloff J. M., Kagey B. T. (1990) Using OSHA accident investigations to study patterns in work fatalities. Journal of Occupational Medicine 32(11): 1117–1123
Morgenstern R., Pizer W. A. (2007) Reality check: The nature and performance of voluntary environmental programs in the United States, Europe, and Japan. RFF Press, Washington, DC
Monfardini C., Radice R. (2008) Testing exogeneity in the bivariate probit model: A Monte Carlo study. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 70(2): 271–282
National Academy of Engineering National Research Council (2010) Interim report on causes of the deepwater horizon oil rig blowout and ways to prevent such events. The National Academies Press, Washington, D.C
National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill and Offshore Drilling (NCBP). (2011). deep water: The gulf oil disaster and the future of offshore drilling. Part I: Report to the President. Part II Recommendations.
Nichols, A. (2011). Causal inference for binary regression. In Stata conference Chicago, (version June 14, 2011).
Pidgeon N., O’Leary M. (2000) Man-made disasters: Why technology and organizations (sometimes) fail. Safety Science 34(1–3): 15–30
Prakash A. (2000) Responsible care: An assessment. Business & Society 39(2): 183–209
Reason J. (1997) Managing the risks of organizational accidents. Ashgate Publishing Ltd, Burlington, VT
Rees J. V. (1997) The development of communitarian regulation in the chemical industry. Law and Policy 17(4): 477–528
Sandy R., Elliott R. F. (1996) Unions and risk: Their impact on the level of compensation for fatal risk. Economica 63(250): 291–309
Scholz J. T., Gray W. B. (1990) OSHA enforcement and workplace injuries: A behavioral approach to risk assessment. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 3(3): 283–305
Sivin, D. (2002). Impact of a pollution prevention program on occupational exposures. In American Public health association 130th annual meeting, Philadelphia, PA.
Slovic P., Fischhoff B., Lichtenstein S. (1982) Why study risk perception?. Risk Analysis 2(2): 83–93
Smith J. A., Todd P. E. (2005) Does matching overcome Lalonde’s critique of nonexperimental estimators?. Journal of Econometrics 125(1–2): 305–353
Spellman F. R. (1997) A guide to compliance for process safety management/risk management planning. Technomic Publishing Co, Lancaster, PA
Tai E. (2000) OSHA compliance management: A guide for long-term health care facilities. CRC Press, New York
Van Asten M., Martinson C. (2005) MON MACT impact. Products Finishing 70(3): 54
Vidovic M., Khanna N. (2007) Can voluntary pollution control programs fulfill their promises? Further evidence from EPA’s 33/50 program. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 53: 180–195
Weil D. (1996) If OSHA is so bad, why is compliance so good?. Rand Journal of Economics 27(3): 618–640
Wilde J. (2000) Identification of multiple equation probit models with endogenous dummy regressors. Economics Letters 69: 309–312
Wooldridge J. (2010) Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. MIT Press, Cambridge
Yosie T. F. (2003) Peer reviewed: Responsible care at 15 years. Environmental Science & Technology 37(21): 400A–406A
Authors are listed alphabetically.
Electronic Supplementary Material
The Below is the Electronic Supplementary Material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Finger, S.R., Gamper-Rabindran, S. Testing the effects of self-regulation on industrial accidents. J Regul Econ 43, 115–146 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11149-012-9201-8
- Corporate social responsibility
- Industry self-regulation
- Industrial accidents
- Environmental and health safety
- Chemical industry