Abstract
The allowed rate of return (AROR) is a critical input in the regulatory assessment of revenue requirements, price caps and other controls. Errors in estimating AROR impact on investment incentives and price setting and hence can induce welfare loss. It is often suggested that the welfare losses that arise from under-estimation of the AROR may be significantly greater than arise from over-estimation. However, to date, this proposition has not been examined in any detail. This paper assesses the extent of welfare loss asymmetry and its implications for the choice of AROR.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Australian Consumer and Competition Commission. (2005). Assessment of Telstra’s ULLS and LSS monthly charge undertakings, Draft decision, August 2005, Appendix C. Available at www.accc.gov.au.
Baron D., Myerson R. (1982) Regulating a monopolist with unknown cost. Econometrica 50: 1231–1262
Besanko D., Spulber D. (1992) Sequential equilibrium investment by regulated firms. Rand Journal of Economics 23(2): 153–170
Bowman, R. G. (2004). Response to WACC issues in commerce—Commissioner’s draft report on the Gas control Enquiry. Report prepared for PowerCo, June. Available at: www.comcom.govt.nz/RegulatoryControl/GasPipelines/ContentFiles/Documents/Submission%20-%20Powerco%20WACC%
Bowman, R. G. (2005). Queensland Rail—Determination of regulated WACC, Report, available at www.qca.org.au/www/rail/Sub_QRat-tach7_2005%20DAU%20Draft.pdf.
Brealey R., Franks J. (2009) Indexation, investment and utility prices. Oxford review of economic policy 25(3): 435–450
Brennan M. J., Schwartz E. S. (1982) Consistent regulatory policy under uncertainty. Bell Journal of Economics 13(2): 506–521
BT. (2005). Ofcom’s approach to risk in the assessment of the cost of capital: BT’s response to the Ofcom consultation document. 5/4/2005, available at http://www.btplc.com/responses.
Butler J. S., Schachter B. (1989) The investment decision: Estimation risk and risk adjusted discount rates. Financial Management 4: 13–22
CAA. (2008). Economic Regulation of Heathrow and Gatwick Airports 2008–2013—CAA Decision, available at http://www.caa.co.uk/docs/5/ergdocs/heathrowgatwickdecision_mar08.pdf.
Competition Commission. (2007). BAA Ltd: A report on the economic regulation of the London airports companies (Heathrow Airport Ltd and Gatwick Airport Ltd) available at http://www.competition-commission.org.uk/.
Dixit A., Pindyck R. (1994) Investment under uncertainty. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Dobbs I.M. (2004) Intertemporal price cap regulation under uncertainty. Economic Journal 114: 421–440
Dobbs I. M. (2008) Setting the regulatory allowed rate of return using simulation and loss functions—the case for standardizing procedures. Competition and Regulation of Network Industries 9(3): 229–246
Evans L. T., Guthrie G. A. (2005) Risk, price regulation and irreversible investment. International Journal of Industrial Organization 23: 109–128
Evans L. T., Guthrie G. A. (2006) Incentive regulation of prices when costs are sunk. Journal of Regulatory Economics 29(3): 239–264
First Economics. (2007). Automatic annual adjustment of the cost of capital: A discussion paper. 30 March 2007. Available at www.xfi.ex.ac.uk/conferences/costofcapital/papers/earwaker_automatic_adjustment_of_the_cost_of_capital.pdf.
Guthrie G. A. (2006) Regulating infrastructure: The impact of risk and investment. Journal of Economic Literature 44: 925–972
Judd K. L. (1999) Numerical methods in economics. MIT press, Cambridge, MA
Leland H. (1974) Regulation of natural monopolies and the fair rate of return. Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 5(1): 3–15
Lewis T. R., Sappington D. E. (1988) Regulating a monopolist with unknown demand and cost functions. Rand Journal of Economics 19: 438–457
McDonald R., Siegel D. (1986) The value of waiting to invest. Quarterly Journal of Economics 101: 707–728
Newbery D. (1999) Privatization, restructuring and regulation of network industries. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
New Zealand Commerce Commission. (2004). Gas Control Inquiry Final Report, 29 Nov., 2004, available at www.med.govt.nz/ers/gas/final-report/final-report.pdf.
Ofcom. (2005). Ofcom’s approach to risk in the assessment of the cost of capital, 26/1/2005. Available at: http://www.ofcom.org.uk/consult/condocs/cost_capital2/.
Pindyck R. S. (1988) Irreversible investment, capacity choices and the value of the firm. American Economic Review 78: 969–985
PWC. (2006). TenneT TSO Comparison study of the WACC, Report to TenneT, May 8, 2006. Available at http://www.dte.nl/images/Comparison%20study%20of%20the%20WACC-%20Mei%202006_tcm7-87013.pdf.
SFG. (2005). A framework for quantifying estimation error in regulatory WACC. Report for Western Power in relation to the Economic Regulation Authority’s 2005 Network Access Review, 19/5/2005. Available at: http://www.wpcorp.com.au/documents/AccessArrangement/2006/Revised_AAI_Appendix_4_WACC_SFG_MAY2005.pdf.
Wright, S., Mason, R., & Miles, D. (2003). A study of certain aspects of the cost of capital for regulated utilities in the U.K., 13/2/2003. The Smithers & Co. report commissioned by the UK regulators and the office of Fair Trading. Available at: www.ofcom.org.uk/static/archive/oftel/publications/pricing/2003/capt0203.pdf.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dobbs, I.M. Modeling welfare loss asymmetries arising from uncertainty in the regulatory cost of finance. J Regul Econ 39, 1–28 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11149-010-9131-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11149-010-9131-2