Abstract
Divestiture of generation assets by vertically integrated electric utilities has been a key element of restructuring in the U.S. The resulting generation sector has received much attention, but the standalone distribution sector that has been simultaneously created has received very little. This paper addresses the effects of divestiture policy on the operating efficiency of the resulting distribution utilities. Using data envelopment analysis to measure operating efficiency, we examine 73 utilities in the period 1994–2003 and find that the major divestitures that were required by state regulators had large adverse effects on efficiency, whereas utilities that divested at their own initiative had at worst neutral efficiency outcomes. These results raise serious questions about one of the centerpieces of electricity restructuring.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bushnell J., Mansur E., Saravia C. (2008) Vertical arrangements, market structure, and competition: An analysis of restructured US electricity markets. American Economic Review 98(1): 237–266
Bushnell, J., & Wolfram, C. (2005). Ownership change, incentives and plant efficiency: The divestiture of U.S. generation plants. University of California Energy Institute, Working Paper, No. 140.
Carrington R., Coelli T., Groome E. (2002) International benchmarking for monopoly price regulation: The case of Australian gas distribution. Journal of Regulatory Economics 21(2): 191–216
Chen A., Merville L. J. (1986) An analysis of divestiture effects resulting from deregulation. Journal of Finance 41(5): 997–1010
Cho M.-H., Cohen M. A. (1997) The economic causes and consequences of corporate divestiture. Managerial and Decision Economics 18(5): 367–374
Church J., Ware R. (2000) Industrial organization: A strategic approach. McGraw-Hill, New York
Coelli T., Rao D. S., Battese G. E. (1998) An introduction to efficiency and productivity analysis. Kluwer, London
CPB. (2005). Vertical separation of the energy distribution industry, an assessment of several options for unbundling. CPB Document 84, The Hague
Delmas M., Tokat Y. (2005) Deregulation, governance structures and efficiency: The U.S. electric utility sector. Strategic Management Journal 26(6): 441–460
Domah P. D., Pollitt M. G. (2001) The restructuring and privatisation of the regional electricity companies in England and Wales: A social cost benefit analysis. Fiscal Studies 22(1): 107–146
Energy Information Agency. (2000). The changing structure of the electric power industry 2000: An update. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Energy.
Fabrizio K., Rose N., Wolfram C. (2007) Do markets reduce costs? Assessing the impact of regulatory restructuring on U.S. electric generation efficiency. American Economic Review 97(4): 1250–1277
Färe R., Grosskopf S., Margaritis D. (2008) Efficiency and productivity: Malmquist and more. In: Fried H. O., Knox Lovell C. A., Schmidt S. S. (eds) The measurement of productive efficiency and productivity change. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 522–622
Fraquaelli G., Piancenza M., Vannoni D. (2005) Cost savings from generation and distribution with an application to Italian electric utilities. Journal of Regulatory Economics 28(3): 289–308
Gilsdorf K. (1994) Vertical integration efficiencies and electric utilities: A cost complementarily perspective. Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 34(3): 261–282
Greene R. (1993) Econometric analysis. Macmillan, New York
Hattori T., Jamasb T., Pollitt M. (2005) Electricity distribution in the UK and Japan: A comparative efficiency analysis 1985–1998. Energy Journal 26(2): 23–47
Hayashi P., Goo J., Chamberlain W. C. (1997) Vertical economies: The case of the U.S. electric industry, 1983–87. Southern Economic Journal 63: 710–725
Henderson S. (1985) Cost estimation for vertically integrated firms: The case of electricity. In: Crew M. (eds) Analyzing the impact of regulatory change in public utilities. Lexington Books, Lexington
Jamasb T., Pollitt M. (2001) Benchmarking and regulation: International electricity experience. Utilities Policy 9(3): 107–130
Jamasb T., Pollitt M. (2003) International benchmarking and regulation: An application to European electricity distribution utilities. Energy Policy 31(15): 1609–1622
Kaserman D., Mayo J. (1991) The measurement of vertical economies and the efficient structure of the electric utility industry. Journal of Industrial Economics 39(5): 483–502
Kwoka J. (2002) Vertical economies in electric power: Evidence on integration and its alternatives. International Journal of Industrial Organization 20(5): 653–671
Kwoka J. (2006) Electric power distribution: Economies of scale, mergers and restructuring. Applied Economics 37(20): 2373–2386
Lee B.-J. (1995) Separability test for the electricity supply industry. Journal of Applied Econometrics 10(1): 49–60
Mansur E. (2007) Upstream competition and vertical integration in electricity markets. Journal of Law and Economics 50(1): 125–156
Michaels R. J. (2006) Vertical integration and the restructuring of the U.S. electricity industry. Policy Analysis 572: 1–31
Nemoto J., Goto M. (2004) Technological externalities and economies of vertical integration in the electric utility industry. International Journal of Industrial Organization 22(1): 676–681
Ofgem. (1999). Reviews of public electricity suppliers 1998 to 2000. Distribution price control review, final proposals, consultation document, December. London: Office of Gas and Electricity Markets.
Ofgem. (2004). Electricity distribution price control review, final proposals, 265/04, November. London: Office of Gas Electricity Markets.
Ravenscraft D. J., Scherer F. M. (1987) Mergers, selloffs and economic efficiency. Brookings Institution, Washington, DC
Thanassoulis E. (2000) The use of data envelopment analysis in the regulation of UK water utilities: Water distribution. European Journal of Operational Research 126(2): 436–453
Thanassoulis E., Portela M. C., Allen R. (2004) Incorporating value judgements in DEA. In: Cooper W. W., Seiford L. M., Zhu J. (eds) Handbook of data envelopment analysis. Kluwer, Boston, pp 99–138
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kwoka, J., Pollitt, M. & Sergici, S. Divestiture policy and operating efficiency in U.S. electric power distribution. J Regul Econ 38, 86–109 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11149-010-9122-3
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11149-010-9122-3