Advertisement

Review of Accounting Studies

, Volume 22, Issue 3, pp 1048–1083 | Cite as

Is there a dark side to exchange traded funds? An information perspective

  • Doron Israeli
  • Charles M. C. Lee
  • Suhas A. SridharanEmail author
Article

Abstract

We examine whether an increase in ETF ownership is accompanied by a decline in pricing efficiency for the underlying component securities. Our tests show an increase in ETF ownership is associated with (1) higher trading costs (bid-ask spreads and market liquidity), (2) an increase in “stock return synchronicity,” (3) a decline in “future earnings response coefficients,” and (4) a decline in the number of analysts covering the firm. Collectively, our findings support the view that increased ETF ownership can lead to higher trading costs and lower benefits from information acquisition. This combination results in less informative security prices for the underlying firms.

Keywords

Exchange traded funds (ETFs) Informed and unformed traders Trading costs Informational efficiency Pricing efficiency 

JEL classifications

G11 G14 M41 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We gratefully acknowledge research assistance from Woo Young Park and Padmasini Venkatachari. We thank Inessa Liskovich and Harrison Hong for kindly providing us with their data on Russell 2000 reconstitutions. We are grateful for helpful suggestions and comments from Russell Lundholm (Editor), Ira Yeung (Discussant), an anonymous referee, Will Cong, Larry Glosten, Ananth Madhavan, Ed Watts, Frank Zhang as well as seminar participants at Emory University, Interdisciplinary Center (IDC) Herzliya, Tel Aviv University, UCLA, the University of Iowa, Duke University, and Harvard University (IMO Conference 2016).

References

  1. Admati, A. R. (1985). A noisy rational expectations equilibrium for multi-asset securities markets. Econometrica, 53, 629–657.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Amihud, Y. (2002). Illiquidity and stock returns: Cross-section and time-series effects. Journal of Financial Markets, 5, 31–56.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Barth, M. E., Kasznik, R., & McNichols, M. (2001). Analyst coverage and intangible assets. Journal of Accounting Research, 39, 1–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Ben-David, I., Franzoni, F., & Moussawi, R. (2015). Do ETFs increase volatility? Working Paper: Ohio State University.Google Scholar
  5. Bhattacharya, A., & O’Hara, M. (2016). Can ETFs increase market fragility? Effect of information linkages on ETF markets. Working paper: Cornell University.Google Scholar
  6. Black, F. (1986). Noise. Papers and proceedings of the forty-fourth annual meeting of the American Finance association. Journal of Finance, 41, 529–543.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Broman, M. S. (2013). Excess co-movement and limits-to-arbitrage: Evidence from exchange-traded funds. Working paper: York University.Google Scholar
  8. Chan, K., & Chan, Y. C. (2014). Price informativeness and stock return synchronicity: Evidence from the pricing of seasoned equity offerings. Journal of Financial Economics, 114, 36–53.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Chang, Y. C., Hong, H., & Liskovich, I. (2015). Regression discontinuity and the price effects of stock market indexing. Review of Financial Studies, 28, 212–246.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Chen, G., & Strother, T. S. (2008). On the contribution of index exchange traded funds to price discovery in the presence of price limits without short selling. Working paper: University of Otago, New Zealand.Google Scholar
  11. Choi, J., Myers, L. A., Zang, Y., & Ziebart, D. A. (2011). Do management EPS forecasts allow returns to reflect future earnings? Implications for the continuation of management’s quarterly earnings guidance. Review of Accounting Studies, 16, 143–182.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Collins, D., Kothari, S., Shanken, J., & Sloan, R. (1994). Lack of timeliness versus noise as explanations for low contemporaneous return-earnings association. Journal of Accounting & Economics, 18, 289–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Cong, L. W., & Xu, D. (2016). Rise of factor investing: Asset prices, informational efficiency, and security design. Working paper: University of Chicago.Google Scholar
  14. Copeland, T., & Galai, D. (1983). Information effects on the bid-ask spread. The Journal of Finance, 38, 1457–1469.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Corwin, S., & Schultz, P. (2012). A simple way to estimate bid-ask spreads from daily high and low prices. The Journal of Finance, 67, 719–759.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Crawford, S. S., Roulstone, D. T., & So, E. C. (2012). Analyst initiations of coverage and stock return synchronicity. The Accounting Review, 87, 1527–1553.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Da, Z., & Shive, S. (2013). Exchange-traded funds and equity return correlations. Working paper: University of Notre Dame.Google Scholar
  18. Diamond, D. W., & Verrecchia, R. E. (1981). Information aggregation in noisy rational expectations model. Journal of Financial Economics, 9, 221–235.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Durnev, A., Morck, R., Yeung, B., & Zarowin, P. (2003). Does greater firm-specific return variation mean more or less informed stock pricing? Journal of Accounting Research, 41, 797–836.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Durnev, A., Morck, R., & Yeung, B. (2004). Value-enhancing capital budgeting and firm-specific stock return variation. The Journal of Finance, 59, 65–105.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Ettredge, M., Kwon, S. Y., & Smith, D. (2005). The impact of SFAS no. 131 business segment data on the market’s ability to anticipate future earnings. The Accounting Review, 80, 773–804.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Fama, E., & French, K. (1992). The cross-section of expected returns. Journal of Finance, 46, 427–466.Google Scholar
  23. Fang, Y., & Sang, G. C. (2012). Index price discovery in the cash market. Working paper: Louisiana State University.Google Scholar
  24. Glosten, L., & Harris, L. (1999). Estimating the components of the bid/ask spread. Journal of Financial Economics, 21, 123–142.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Glosten, L., Nallareddy, S., & Zou, Y. (2016). ETF trading and informational efficiency of underlying securities. Working paper: Columbia University.Google Scholar
  26. Gorton, G. B., & Pennacchi, G. G. (1993). Security baskets and index-linked securities. The Journal of Business, 66, 1–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Gow, I., Ormazabal, G., & Taylor, D. (2010). Correcting for cross-sectional and time-series dependence in accounting research. The Accounting Review, 85, 483–512.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Goyenko, R. Y., Holden, G. W., & Trzcinka, C. A. (2009). Do liquidity measures measure liquidity? Journal of Financial Economics, 92, 153–181.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Grossman, S. (1989). The informational role of prices. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
  30. Grossman, S., & Stiglitz, J. E. (1980). On the impossibility of informationally efficient markets. American Economic Review, 70, 393–408.Google Scholar
  31. Hamm, S. J. W. (2014). The effects of ETFs on stock liquidity. Working paper: Ohio State University.Google Scholar
  32. Hasbrouck, J. (2003). Intraday price formation in U.S. equity index markets. The Journal of Finance, 58, 2375–2399.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Hayek, F. A. (1945). The use of knowledge in society. The American Economic Review, 35, 519–530.Google Scholar
  34. Hellwig, M. R. (1980). On the aggregation of information in competitive markets. Journal of Economic Theory, 22, 477–498.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Holden, C. (2009). New low-frequency spread measures. Journal of Financial Markets, 12, 778–813.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hutton, A., Marcus, A., & Tehranian, H. (2009). Opaque financial reports, R2, and crash risk. Journal of Financial Economics, 94, 67–86.Google Scholar
  37. Ivanov, S. I., Jones, F. J., & Zaima, J. K. (2013). Analysis of DJIA, S&P 500, S&P 400, NASDAQ 100 and Russell 2000 ETFs and their influence on price discovery. Global Finance Journal, 24, 171–187.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Jiambalvo, J., Rajgopal, S., & Venkatachalam, M. (2002). Institutional ownership and the extent to which stock prices reflect future earnings. Contemporary Accounting Research, 19, 117–145.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Jin, L., & Myers, S. (2006). R-squared around the world: New theory and new tests. Journal of Financial Economics, 79, 257–292.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Kothari, S., & Sloan, R. (1992). Information in prices about future earnings: Implications for earnings response coefficients. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 15, 143–171.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Krause, T., Ehsani, S., & Lien, D. (2014). Exchange-traded funds, liquidity and volatility. Working paper. University of Texas at San Antonio.Google Scholar
  42. Kyle, A. S. (1985). Continuous auctions and insider trading. Econometrica, 53, 1315–1335.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Kyle, A. S. (1989). Informed speculation with imperfect competition. Review of Economic Studies, 56, 317–356.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Lakonishok, J., Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. (1994). Contrarian investment, extrapolation, and risk. Journal of Finance, 49, 1541–1578.Google Scholar
  45. Lang, M., & Lundholm, R. (1996). Corporate disclosure policy and analyst behavior. The Accounting Review, 71, 467–492.Google Scholar
  46. Lee, C. M. C., & So, E. (2015). Alphanomics: The informational underpinnings of market efficiency. Foundations and Trends in Accounting, 9, 59–258.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Lesmond, D., Ogden, J., & Trzcinka, C. (1999). A new estimate of transactions costs. Review of Financial Studies, 12, 1113–1141.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Li, B., Rajgopal, S., & Venkatachalam, M. (2014). R2 and idiosyncratic risk are not inter-changeable. The Accounting Review, 89, 2261–2295.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Lundholm, R., & Myers, L. (2002). Bringing the future forward: The effect of disclosure on the returns-earnings relation. Journal of Accounting Research, 40, 809–839.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Madhavan, A., & Sobczyk, A. (2014). Price dynamics and liquidity of exchange-traded funds. BlackRock Inc: Working paper.Google Scholar
  51. Milgrom, P., & Stokey, N. (1982). Information, trade and common knowledge. Journal of Economic Theory, 26, 17–27.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Pedersen, L. H. (2015). Efficiently inefficient: How Smart Money Invests & Market Prices are Determined. Princeton: Princeton University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Piotroski, J. D., & Roulstone, D. T. (2004). The influence of analysis, institutional investors, and insiders on the incorporation of market, industry, and firm-specific information into stock prices. The Accounting Review, 79, 1119–1151.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Pisani, R. (2015). Here is why ETFs are a growing part of total trading value, CNBC. http://www.cnbc.com/2015/07/02/heres-why-etfs-are-a-growing-part-of-total-trading-value.html Accessed 2 July 2015.
  55. Ramaswamy, S. (2011). Market structures and systemic risks of exchange-traded funds. Working paper: Bank For International Settlements.Google Scholar
  56. Roll, R. (1984). A simple implicit measure of the effective bid-ask spread in an efficient market. The Journal of Finance, 39, 127–1139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Rubinstein, M. (1989). Market basket alternatives. Financial Analysts Journal, 45, 20–29.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Subrahmanyam, A. (1991). A theory of trading in stock index futures. The Review of Financial Studies, 4, 17–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Sullivan, R., & Xiong, J. (2012). How Index Trading Increases Market Vulnerability. Financial Analysts Journal, 68, 70–84. doi:  10.1007/s11142-017-9400-8.
  60. Verrecchia, R. (1982). Information acquisition in a noisy rational expectations economy. Econometrica, 50, 1415–1430.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Wurgler, J. (2000). Financial markets and the allocation of capital. Journal of Financial Economics, 58, 187–214.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Yu, L. (2005). Basket securities, price formation, and informational efficiency. Working paper: University of Notre Dame. doi:  10.2139/ssrn.862604.

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  • Doron Israeli
    • 1
  • Charles M. C. Lee
    • 2
  • Suhas A. Sridharan
    • 3
    Email author
  1. 1.Arison School of Business, The Interdisciplinary Center (IDC) HerzliyaHerzliyaIsrael
  2. 2.Graduate School of BusinessStanford UniversityStanfordUSA
  3. 3.Goizueta Business SchoolEmory UniversityAtlantaUSA

Personalised recommendations