30 years after the nobel: James Buchanan’s political philosophy
There are three main foundations of Public Choice theory: methodological individualism, behavioral symmetry, and “politics as exchange.” The first two are represented in nearly all work that identifies as “Public Choice,” but politics as exchange is often forgotten or de-emphasized. This paper—adapted from a lecture given on the occasion of the 30th year after Buchanan’s Nobel Prize—fleshes out Buchanan’s theory of politics as exchange, using four notions that are uniquely central to his thought: philosophical anarchism, ethical neutrality, subjectivism, and the “relatively absolute absolutes.” A central tension in Buchanan’s work is identified, in which he seems simultaneously to argue both that nearly anything agreed to by a group could be enforced within the group as a contract, and that there are certain types of rules and arrangements, generated by decentralized processes, that serve human needs better than state action. It is argued that it is a mistake to try to reconcile this tension, and that both parts of the argument are important.
KeywordsJames Buchanan Public choice Subjectivism Methodological individualism Institutions
JEL classificationB31 B52 B53 D71
This paper was presented at the Mercatus/George Mason symposium “40 Years After the Nobel,” in Fairfax, VA on October 6, 2016, and again at a plenary session of the Australasian Public Choice Society meetings at the Australian National University, Canberra, Australia, December 9, 2016. The comments received after those two sessions were invaluable in extending, and in several cases correcting, portions of the paper. I wish to thank Michael Brooks, Keith Dowding, Timothy Groseclose, Jonathan Pincus, David Schmidtz, Barry Weingast, and Larry White for helpful comments. Two guides offered nearly heroic aid and suggestions: Peter Boettke and Chris Coyne, and the finished paper uses many of their suggestions verbatim without (other than herein) acknowledgement. Finally, since it goes without saying it must be said: the errors the paper still contains are no one’s fault by mine.
- Block, W. (2003) “Toward a libertarian theory of inalienability,” Journal of Libertarian Studies, 17(2), 39–85Google Scholar
- Boettke, P. (2013). Living economics: Yesterday, today, and tomorrow. Oakland: Independent Institute.Google Scholar
- Brennan, G. (1999). Notes on Buchanan and methodological individualism. Research School in Social Sciences. Canberra: Australian National University http://publicchoice.info/Buchanan/files/brennan.htm Google Scholar
- Brennan, G. And J. Buchanan (1985) Reason of Rules: Constitutional Political Economy. New York: Cambridge University press. Vol. 10 of The Collected Works of James Buchanan. Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.Google Scholar
- Brennan, G., & Lomasky, L. (1997). Democracy and decision: The pure theory of electoral preference. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Buchanan, J. (1969) Cost and Choice: An Inquiry in Economic Theory. Chicago: Markham Pub. Co. Reprinted in vol. 6 of The Collected Works of James Buchanan, 1999. Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.Google Scholar
- Buchanan, J. (1975). The Limits of Liberty: Between Anarchy and Leviathan. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Vol. 7 of The Collected Works of James Buchanan. Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.Google Scholar
- Buchanan, J. (1979) Politics Without Romance: A Sketch of the Positive Public Choice Theory and Its Implications. Inaugural Lecture, Institute for Advanced Studies. Vienna. IHS-Journal, Zeitschrift des Instituts für Höhere Studien, Wien 3 (1979): B1–B11. Reprinted in The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Liberty, 1999. Vol. 1 of the Collected Works of James Buchanan, 45–59. Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.Google Scholar
- Buchanan, J. (1985). Order defined in the process of its emergence. In Liberty, Market, and State: Political Economy in the 1980s. New Washington Square: NYU press. Pp. 73–74. Reprinted in The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Liberty, 1999. Vol. 1 of The Collected Works of James Buchanan (pp. 244–246). Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.Google Scholar
- Buchanan, J. (1990) The Domain of Constitutional Economics. Constitutional Political Economy Vol I No.1 (1990) p. 13-14. Reprinted in The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Liberty, 1999. Vol. 1 of The Collected Works of James Buchanan, 377–395. Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.Google Scholar
- Buchanan, J. (1991). The foundations of normative individualism. In The Economics and the Ethics of Constitutional Order. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Reprinted in The Logical Foundations of Constitutional Liberty, 1999. Vol. 1 of The Collected Works of James Buchanan (pp. 281–292). Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Buchanan, J., and G. Brennan. (2001) The intellectual portrait series: A conversation with James M. Buchanan, liberty fund, Indianapolis. http://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/buchanan-the-intellectual-portrait-series-a-conversation-with-james-m-buchanan-part-1 and http://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/buchanan-the-intellectual-portrait-series-a-conversation-with-james-m-buchanan-part-2.
- Buchanan, J., & Devletoglou, N. (1970). Academia in Anarchy: An Economic Diagnosis. Pheonix: Basic Books.Google Scholar
- Hume, D. [1739–40] (1978) A Treatise of Human Nature, L. a. Selby-Bigge and P. H. Nidditch (eds.) Oxford, Oxford university press, 2nd ed.Google Scholar
- Hume, D. (1987) Of the Original Contract. Pp. 465–487, In Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary. Eugene F. Miller, ed. 1987. Library of economics and liberty. 30 December 2016. http://www.econlib.org/library/LFBooks/Hume/hmMPL.html.
- Lekachman, R. (1986) A controversial Nobel choice. New York Times. October 26, http://www.nytimes.com/1986/10/26/business/business-forum-controversial-nobel-choice-turning-these-conservative-times.html.
- Nietzsche, F. (1997). Beyond Good and Evil: Prelude to a Philosophy of the Future. (Helen Zimmern, trans) (William Kaufman, ed). Dover publishing.Google Scholar
- Richman, S. (2013) James Buchanan’s subjectivist economics. Foundation for Economic Education. http://www.fff.org/explore-freedom/article/james-buchanans-subjectivist-economics/.
- Rousseau, J.J.  (1973) The Social Contract, translated by G. D. H. Cole. London: Dent.Google Scholar
- Shughart, W. (2008) Public choice. Concise encyclopedia of economics, library of liberty, http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PublicChoice.html accessed 12/26/2016.
- Weber, M. (1922/2013). Economy and Society. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Wicksell, K.  (1958) Finanztheoretische Untersuchungen. Jena: Gustav Fischer Verlag. Partially reprinted as Wicksell, Knut. 1958 a new principle of just taxation. In Classics in the theory of public finance, edited by Richard A. Musgrave and Alan T. Peacock, London, 72–118. Macmillan.Google Scholar
- Wolff, R.P.  (1998) In Defense of Anarchism, 3rd edition, Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar