Abstract
This paper sets out some findings of a research project carried out in private unaided schools in low-income areas of Hyderabad, India. The part of the research project documented here was designed to examine the question: ‘Is the regulatory regime conducive to entrepreneurial action and market discovery’ with particular reference to the low-income schools in Hyderabad. This paper is narrowly focused, setting out the results of pattern matching empirical data with the Austrian economic concepts of entrepreneurship, rivalry, and market discovery. The research discovered that two regulatory regimes exist, one that is set out ‘on paper’ in the Education Acts and associated rules, and another that operates ‘in practice’. That is, there is a combination of regulations ‘on paper’ and regulations existing in an ‘extra-legal’ sector. Generally it was found that the regulations ‘in practice’ are consistent with market principles. Conversely the regulations set out ‘on paper’ are not conducive to entrepreneurial innovation and market discovery. Recommendations for potential policy initiatives include the possibility of legitimising the ‘extra-legal’ sector by introducing self-regulation possibly via self-evaluation systems for the private unaided schools.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aggarwal, Y. (2000) Public and Private Partnership in Primary Education in India: A Study of Unrecognised Schools in Haryana. New Delhi: National Institute of Educational Planning and Administration.
Alderman, H., Orazem, P. F., and Paterno, E. M. (1996) “School Quality, School Cost and the Public/Private School Choices of Low-Income Households in Pakistan.” Working Paper Series on ‘Impact Evaluation of Education Reforms’ Paper No. 2. Washington D.C.: World Bank.
Bainton, D. M. (1983) “State Regulation of Private Religious Schools and the States Interest in Education.” Arizona Law Review, 25: 123–149.
Bashir, S. (1994) “Public versus Private in Primary Education: Comparisons of School Effectiveness and Costs in Tamil Nadu.” Unpublished Ph. D. thesis, London: London School of Economic.
Bashir, S. (1997) “The Cost Effectiveness of Public and Private Schools: Knowledge Gaps, New Research Methodologies and an Application in India.” In: Colclough, C. (Ed.) Marketizing Education and Health in Developing Countries: Miracle of Mirage? pp. 124–164, Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Bashir, S. (2002) Karnataka: Financing Education in the Context of Economic Restructuring. Washington D.C.: World Bank.
Braithwaite, J. (1982) “Enforced Self-regulation: A New Strategy for Corporate Crime Control.” Michigan Law Review, 80: 1466–1507.
Carper, J. C. and Devins, N. E. (1985) “Rendering Unto Caesar; State Regulation of Christian Day Schools.” Journal of Thought, 20: 99–113.
CfBT (2001) Quality Matters: The Standards Reading: CfBT.
Chubb, J. E. and Moe, T. M. (1990) Politics, Markets and Americas Schools. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institute.
De Soto, H. (2000) The Mystery of Capital: Why Capitalism Triumphs in the West and Fails Everywhere Else Bantam Press.
Diehl, B. (1983) “The Right to Regulate Non-Public Education.” The Urban Lawyer, 15(1): 97–111.
Dixon, P. (2003) “The Regulation of Private Schools for Low-Income Families in Andhra Pradesh, India: An Austrian Economic Approach.” Unpublished PhD thesis, Newcastle: University of Newcastle.
Drèze, J. and Sen, A. (2002) India: Development and Participation, 2nd edn. New Delhi, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Encarnation, D. J. (1983) “Public Finance and Regulation of Nonpublic Education: Retrospect and Prospect.” In: James, T. and Levin, H. M. (Eds.) Public Dollars for Private Schools Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Erickson, D. A. (1984) “Bad Fences Make Bad Neighbors: A look at State Regulation of Private Schools.” In: Carper, J. C. and Hunt, T. C. (Eds.) Religious Schooling in America, pp. 227–244. Birmingham, Alabama: Religious Education Press.
Erickson, D. A. (1986) “Choice and Private Schools: Dynamics of Supply and Demand.” In: Levy, D. C. (Ed.) Private Education: Studies in Choice and Public Policy. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 82–109.
Foley, E. B. (1996) “The Regulation of Private Schools.” Capital University Law Review, 25: 819–839.
Furst, L. G. (1985) “Indirect Government Control of Non-Public Schools: A Review of Court Decisions.” ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED263482.
Govinda, R. and Varghese, N. V. (1993) Quality of Primary Schooling in India: A Case Study of Madhya Pradesh Paris: International Institute for Educational Planning.
Harbison, R. W. and Hanushek, E. A. (1992) Educational Performance of the Poor: Lessons from Rural Northeast BrazilOxford University Press (Published for the World Bank).
Hirschoff, M. M. U. (1986) “Public Policy Toward Private Schools: A Focus on Parental Choice.” In: Levy, D. C. (Ed.) Private Education: Studies in Choice and Public Policy, pp. 33–57, Oxford and NY: Oxford University Press.
Independent Schools Association of Southern Africa (2001) The Constitution, [Internet]. Available from:〈http://www.isasa.org/docs/ISASA_C.pdf〉 [Accessed September 2002].
Independent Schools Council (2002) Independent Schools Inspectorate—ISI Handbook. [Internet], Available from: 〈http://www.isinspect.org.uk/documentation/docindex.htm#H〉 [Accessed September 2002]
Jimenez, E., Lockheed, M., and Wattanawaha, N. (1988) “The Relative Efficency of Private and Public Schools: The Case of Thailand.” The World Bank Economic Review, 2(2): 139–164.
Jimenez, E. and Cox, D. (1989) The Relative Effectiveness of Private and Public Schools: Evidence from Two Developing Countries. Washington, D. C.: The World Bank.
Kingdon, G. (1994) “An Economic Evaluation of School Management Types in Urban India: A Case Study of Uttar Pradesh.” Unpublished PhD thesis, Oxford: Oxford University.
Kingdon, G. (1996a) “The Quality and Efficiency of Private and Public Education: A Case Study in Urban India.” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 58(1): 57–81.
Kingdon, G. (1996b) Private Schools in India: Size, Nature, and Equity-Effects The Development Economics Research Programme, London: LSE STICERD Centre.
Kirzner, I. M. (1973) Competition and EntrepreneurshipChicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Kirzner, I. M. (1978) The Perils of Regulation: A Market Process Approach Coral Gables, Florida: Law and Economics Center, Miami School of Law, LEC occasional paper.
Kirzner, I. M. (1985) Discovery and the Capitalist Process Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Kirzner, I. M. (1997) How Markets Work: Disequilibrium, Entrepreneurship and Discovery London: Institute of Economic Affairs.
Koutsky, J. (1996) “Access to Higher Education in the Czech republic: From Central Regulation to a Balance of Incentives.” Higher Education Policy, 9(2): 113–124.
Maxwell, J., Provan, D., and Fielden, J. (2000) State Controlled or Market Directed? Regulation of Private Universities in the Commonwealth, CHEMS.
Mises, Ludwig von. (1949, [1996]) Human Action: A Treatise on Economics, 4th edn. San Francisco: Fox & Wilkes.
Mitra, C. (1998) The Corrupt Society: The Crimilization of India from Independence to the 1990s, New Delhi, India: Viking Penguin India.
Moja, T., et al. (1996) “Towards New Forms of Regulation in Higher Education: The Case of South Africa.” Higher Education, 32(2): 199–231.
Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad (MCH) (1998), Urban Community Development Handbook. Director of Urban Community Development, Hyderabad, India.
Murnane, R. J. (1986) “Comparisons of Private and Public Schools: The Critical Role of Regulation.” In: Levy, D. C. (Ed.) Private Education: Studies in Choice and Public Policy. Oxford and NY: Oxford University Press (chapter 5), pp. 138–152.
Randall, E. V. (1992) “Private Schools and State Regulation.” The Urban Lawyer, 24(2): 341–378.
Randall, E. V. (1994) Private Schools and Public Power: A Case for Pluralism N.Y.: Teachers College Press.
Richardson, G. and Fielden, J. (1997) “Measuring the Grip of the State: The Relationship Between Governments and Universities in Selected Commonwealth Countries.” A discussion paper, Commonwealth Higher Education Management Service.
Sen, A. (1999) Development as FreedomNew York: Knopf.
Singh, R. P. (1997). Census of India 1991, Series 2, Andhra Pradesh: District Census Handbook Hyderabad. Government of Andhra Pradesh, India.
Smolin, D. M. (1986) “State Regulation of Private education: Ohio Law in the Shadow of the United States Supreme Court Decision.” University of Cincinnati Law Review, 54: 1003–1033.
The Andhra Pradesh Education Act, 1982, in Rao, V. J. (2000) Law of Education in Andhra Pradesh: Second Edition Vol. I Hyderabad: J.D. Gogia for S. Gogia & Company.
The Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions (Establishment, Recognition, Administration and Control of Schools Under Private Management) Rules, 1993, in Rao, V. J. (2000) Law of Education in Andhra Pradesh: Second Edition, Vol. I, pp. 936–958. Hyderabad: J.D. Gogia for S. Gogia & Company.
The Andhra Pradesh Educational Institutions (Inspection and Visits) Rules, 1988, in Rao, V. J. (2001) Law of Education in Andhra Pradesh, 2nd edn. Vol. II, pp. 1152–1174, Hyderabad: S. Gogia & Company.
The Andhra Pradesh (Integrated) Education Rules (1966) Elementary (Primary) Schools in Rao, V. J. (2000) Law of Education in Andhra Pradesh: Second Edition Vol. I, pp. 673–878, Hyderabad: J.D. Gogia for S. Gogia & Company.
The Andhra Pradesh Private Educational Institutions Employees (Conduct) Rules, 1985, in Rao, V. J. (2001) Law of Education in Andhra Pradesh: Second Edition Vol. II, pp. 1719–1735, Hyderabad: J.D. Gogia for S. Gogia & Company.
The Andhra Pradesh Registered Schools (Establishment, Recognition, Registration and Regulation) Rules, 1987 in Rao, V. J. (2001) Law of Education in Andhra Pradesh, 2nd edn. Vol. II, pp. 999–1030, Hyderabad: J.D. Gogia for S. Gogia & Company.
The Probe Team (1999) Public Report on Basic Education in IndiaOxford and New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Tooley, J. (2001) The Global Education Industry, 2nd edn. London: Institute of Economic Affairs.
Tooley, J. and Dixon, P. (2003) “Providing Education to the World’s Poor: A Case Study of the Private Sector in India.” In: Davies, B. and West-Burnham, J. (Eds.) Handbook of Educational Leadership and Management pp. 342–354, London: Pearson Education.
Unni Krishnan, J. P. v State of A. P. (1993) Air 1993 Supreme Court 2179. Hyderabad: J. D. Gogia for S. Gogia & Company
Watkins, K. (2000) The Oxfam Education Report Oxford: Oxfam in Great Britain.
World Education Forum (2000) Education For All: Meeting Our Collective Commitments, [Internet] UNESCO. Available from: http://www.unesco.org/education/efa/ed_for_all/dakfram_eng.shtml [Accessed September 2002].
Yilmaz, Y. (1998) “Private Regulation: A Real Alternative for Regulatory Reform.” In: Desai, A. V. (Ed.) Self Regulation in the Civil Society New Delhi, Centre for Civil Society, pp. 5–35.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dixon, P., Tooley, J. The Regulation of Private Schools Serving Low-Income Families in Andhra Pradesh, India. Rev Austrian Econ 18, 29–54 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11138-005-5592-4
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11138-005-5592-4