The Bell Curve in Psychological Research and Practice: Myth or Reality? Article DOI:
Cite this article as: Sartori, R. Qual Quant (2006) 40: 407. doi:10.1007/s11135-005-6104-0 Abstract
The expression “the bell curve” designs both a kind of statistical distribution and the title of a famous and controversial book by Herrnstein and Murray. The first is so attractive that the second refers to it to give more credibility to its questionable theories on intelligence. The point is that, during the 20th century, the bell curve has assumed a more and more important role in psychological research and practice and have become both a reality and a myth. In the first case (reality) we can assist to appropriate applications of a real useful statistical concept. In the second (myth) we can have two kinds of attitudes: one attitude is typical of those researchers who search for normality in all their data and variables, just as Parsifal used to search for the Holy Graal (we call this “the Parsifal attitude”); the other is typical of those researchers who give normality for granted and act as if it were a Platonic Idea (we call this “the Plato attitude”). The article discusses the role of the normal distribution in psychological research and practice and shows how it can be dangerous to treat the bell curve as a God or an Idol.
Keywords normal distribution psychological measurement and testing intelligence and IQ scores References Anastasi, A. 1968Psychological Testing MacMillan New York Google Scholar Abramowitz, M., Stegun, I.A. 1972Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables Dover New York Google Scholar Bateson, D.J. 1995 How can the bell curve be taken seriously? Alberta Journal of Educational Research 41 271 273 Google Scholar Braden, J.P. 1995 For whom “The Bell” tolls: Why the bell curve is important for school psychologists School Psychology Review 24 27 35 Google Scholar Calkins, D.S. 1974 Some effects of non-normal distribution shape on the magnitude of the Pearson product moment correlation coefficient Revista Interamericana de Psicologia 8 261 288 Google Scholar Cronbach, L.J. 1970Essentials of Psychological Testing Harper and Row New York Google Scholar Darlinghton, R.B. 1996 On race and intelligence: A commentary on affirmative action, the evolution of intelligence, the regression analyses in The Bell Curve, and Jensen’s two-level theory Psychology, Public Policy, and Law 2 635 645 CrossRef Google Scholar Doob, J.L. 1996 The development of rigor in mathematical probability (1900–1950) American Mathematical Monthly 103 586 595 CrossRef Google Scholar Fischer, R.A. 1922The Mathematical Theory of Probability MacMillan New York Google Scholar Fischer, C.S., Hout, M., Jankowski, M.S., Lucas, S.R., Swidler, A., Voss, K. 1996Inequality by Design: Cracking the Bell Curve Myth University Press Princeton Google Scholar Fraser, S. 1995The Bell Curve Wars: Race, Intelligence, And The Future Of America Basics Books New York Google Scholar Galton, F. 1889Natural Inheritance MacMillan London Google Scholar Gardner, H. 1983Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences Basic Books New York Google Scholar Gardner, H. 1993Multiple Intelligences: The Theory in Practice Basic Books New York Google Scholar Gardner, H. 1999Intelligence Reframed Basic Books New York Google Scholar
Goertzel T., Fashing J. (1981). The myth of the normal curve: A theoretical critique and examination of its role in teaching and research.
Humanity and Society 5, 14–31; reprinted in 1986 in: Readings in Humanist Sociology, General Hall; adapted and condensed by Goertzel T. in: http://www.crab.rutgers.edu/~goertzel/normalcurve.htm; http://www.etext.org/Politics/Progressive.Sociologists/psn-archives/the_Bell_Curve. Goleman, D. 1997Emotional Intelligence: Why It Can Matter More Than IQ Bantam New York Google Scholar Goodenough, F. 1949Mental Testing Reinehart New York Google Scholar Gould, S.J. 1997The Mismeasure of Man Norton and Company New York Google Scholar Graves, J.L., Johnson, A. 1995 The pseudoscience of psychometry and the bell curve Journal of Negro Education, 64 277 294 CrossRef Google Scholar Herrnstein, R.J., Murray, C. 1994The Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in American Life Free Press New York Google Scholar Jacoby, R., Glauberman, N. 1995The Bell Curve Debate: History, Documents, Opinions Times Books New York Google Scholar Kincheloe, J.L, Steinberg, S.R., Gresson, A.D. 1997Measured Lies: The Bell Curve Examined St. Martin’s Press New York Google Scholar Kenney, J.F., Keeping, E.S. 1951Mathematics of Statistics Pt.22 Van Nostrand Princeton, NJ Google Scholar
Kenney J.F., Keeping E.S. (1961). Kurtosis, in
Mathematics of Statistics. Pt.1, 3rd edn. Princeton, NJ: Van Nostrand, pp.102–103
Kenney J.F., Keeping E.S. (1961). Skewness, in
Mathematics of Statistics, Pt.1, 3rd edn. Princeton, NJ: Van Nostrand, pp.100–101 Krishnan, P. 1995 The bell curve: Some statistical concerns Alberta Journal of Educational Research 41 274 276 Google Scholar Laming, D. 1997The Measurement of Sensation University Press Oxford Google Scholar Leverett, H.M. 1947 Notes on the use of the normal distribution in psychometrics Journal of Educational Psychology 38 283 289 Google Scholar
Likert R. (1932). A technique for the measurement of attitudes.
Archives of Psychology 140 Livingstone, D.W. 1995 For whom the bell curve tolls Alberta Journal of Educational Research 41 335 341 Google Scholar Michell, J. 1997 Quantitative Science and the definition of measurement in psychology British Journal of Psychology 85 355 383 Google Scholar Moors, J.J.A. 1986 The meaning of kurtosis: Darlington reexamined Journal of The American Statistical Association 40 283 284 Google Scholar
Press W.H., Flannery B.P., Teukolsky S.A., Vetterling W.T. (1992). Moments of a Distribution: Mean, Variance, Skewness, and So Forth. In
Numerical Recipes in FORTRAN: The Art of Scientific Computing, 2nd edn. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press, pp. 604–609 Rogers, K.B. 1996 What the bell curve says and doesn’t say: Is a balanced view possible? Roeper Review 18 252 255 Google Scholar Rupert, D. 1987 What is Kurtosis? An influence function approach Journal of The American Statistical Association 41 1 5 Google Scholar Snell, J.C. 1996 The bell curve, IQ, and assessment testing Journal of Instructional Psychology 23 305 306 Google Scholar Sorokin, P.A. 1956Fads and Foibles in Modern Sociology and Related Sciences Henry Regnery Chicago Google Scholar Wangler, D.G. 1995 Is the bell curve a ringer? Alberta Journal of Educational Research 41 360 366 Google Scholar Wechsler, D. 1935The Range of Human Abilities William and Wilkins Baltimore Google Scholar Zenderland, L. 1997 The bell curve and the shape of history Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 33 135 139 CrossRef Google Scholar