Abstract
Incorporation of externalities in the Multi-Objective Network Design Problem (MO NDP) as objectives is an important step in designing sustainable networks. In this research the problem is defined as a bi-level optimization problem in which minimizing externalities are the objectives and link types which are associated with certain link characteristics are the discrete decision variables. Two distinct solution approaches for this multi-objective optimization problem are compared. The first heuristic is the non-dominated sorting genetic algorithm II (NSGA-II) and the second heuristic is the dominance based multi objective simulated annealing (DBMO-SA). Both heuristics have been applied on a small hypothetical test network as well as a realistic case of the city of Almelo in the Netherlands. The results show that both heuristics are capable of solving the MO NDP. However, the NSGA-II outperforms DBMO-SA, because it is more efficient in finding more non-dominated optimal solutions within the same computation time and maximum number of assessed solutions.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abdulaal, M., LeBlanc, L.J.: Continuous equilibrium network design models. Transp. Res. B 13B, 19–32 (1979)
Boyce, D.E., Janson, B.N.: A discrete transportation network design problem with combined trip distribution and assignment. Transp. Res. B 14B, 147–154 (1980)
Bureau of Public Roads: Traffic assignment manual, Urban Planning Division. US Department of Commerce, Washington DC (1964)
Burke, E.K., Kendall, G.: Search methodologies: introductory tutorials in optimization and decision support techniques. In: Sastry, K., Goldberg, D., Kendall, G. (eds.) Chapter 4: genetic algorithms. Springer Science + Business Media, Inc, Berlin (2005)
Cantarella, G.E., Pavone, G., Vitetta, A.: Heuristics for urban road network design: lane layout and signal settings. Euro. J. Oper. Res. 175, 1682–1695 (2006)
Chiou, S.: Bi-level programming for the continuous transport network design problem. Transp. Res. Part B 39, 361–383 (2005)
CROW (2004). Richtlijn essentiële herkenbaarheidkenmerken van weginfrastructuur: wegwijzer voor implementatie. Publicatie 203. CROW kenniscentrum voor verkeer, vervoer en infrastructuur, Ede
Dantzig, G.B., Harvey, R.P., Lansdowne, Z.F., Robinson, D.W., Maier, S.F.: Formulating and solving the network design problem by decomposition. Transp. Res. B 13B, 5–17 (1978)
Drezner, Z., Wesolowsky, G.O.: Network design: selection and design of links and facility location. Transp. Res. Part A 37, 241–256 (2003)
Deb, K.: Multi-objective optimization using evolutionary algorithms. Wiley, New York (2001)
Deb K, Agrawal S, Pratap A and Meyarivan T.: A Fast elitist no dominated sorting genetic algorithm for multi-objective optimization: NSGA-II. In: Proceedings of sixth international conference on parallel problem solving from nature (PPSN VI), Paris, France, September 2000, pp. 849–858. Springer, Berlin (2000)
Deb, K., Agrawal, S., Pratap, A., Meyarivan, T.A.: A fast elitist multi-objective genetic algorithm: NSGA-II. IEEE Trans. Evol. Comput. 6(2), 182–197 (2002)
Frank, M., Wolfe, P.: An algorithm for quadratic programming. Naval Res. Logist. Quart. 3, 95–110 (1956)
Friesz, T.L., Cho, H.J., Mehta, N.J., Tobin, R.L., Anandalingham, G.: A simulated annealing approach to the network design problem with variational inequality constraints. Transp. Sci. 26, 18–26 (1992)
Friesz, T.L., Anandalingam, G., Mehta, N.J., Nam, K., Shah, S.J., Tobin, R.L.: The multi-objective equilibrium network design problem revisited —A simulated annealing approach. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 65, 44–57 (1993)
Gao, Z., Wu, J., Sun, H.: Solution algorithm for the bi-level discrete network design problem. Transp. Res. Part B 39, 479–495 (2005)
Johnson, D.S., Lenstra, J.K., Rinooy Kan, A.H.G.: The complexity of the network design problem. Networks 8, 279–285 (1978)
Karoonsoontawong, A. and Waller, S.T.: Dynamic continuous network design problem—Linear bi-level programming and meta-heuristic approaches. Network Modeling 2006, Transp. Res. Rec., 104–117 (2006)
Konak, A., Coit, D.W., Smith, A.E.: Multi-objective optimization using genetic algorithms: a tutorial. Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf. 91, 992–1007 (2006)
LeBlanc, L.J.: An algorithm for the discrete network design problem. Transp. Sci. 9, 183–199 (1975)
LeBlanc, L.J., Abdulaal, M.: An efficient dual approach to the urban network design problem. Comput. & Math. Appl. 5, 11–19 (1978)
Loon Van, A.A.P.M., Wismans, L.J.J.: Gebiedsgericht Benutten plus Duurzaam Veilig met RBV. Verkeerskunde DVM-congres 2007 (2007)
Mathew, T. V., S. Sharma.: Continuous network design with emission pricing as a bi-level optimization problem. Applications of advanced technology in transportation. In: Proceedings of the Ninth international conference on applications of advanced technology in transportation, Chicago, IL (2006)
Mathew, T.V., Sharma, S.: Capacity Expansion Problem for Large Urban Transportation Networks. J. Transp. Eng. ASCE 135(7), 406–415 (2009)
Mathew, T.V., Sharma, S.: Multiobjective network design for emission and travel-time trade-off for a sustainable large urban transportation network. Environ. Plan. B Plan. Des. 38, 520–538 (2011)
Memon, G.Q., Bullen, A.G.R.: Multivariant optimization strategies for real-time traffic control signals. Transp. Res. Rec. 1554, 36–42 (1997)
Meng, Q., Yang, H., Bell, M.G.H.: An equivalent continuously differentiable model and a locally convergent algorithm for the continuous network design problem. Transp. Res. Part B 35, 83–105 (2001)
Ministerie van Volkshuisvesting, Ruimtelijke Ordening en Milieubeheer (VROM): Meet- en rekenvoorschriften voor luchtkwaliteit, www.vrom.nl (2006) (last visit: 14-08-2009)
Poorzahedy, H., Turnquist, M.A.: Approximate algorithms for the discrete network design problem. Transp. Res. B 16B, 45–55 (1982)
Poorzahedy, H., Rouhani, O.M.: Hybrid meta-heuristic algorithms for solving network design problem. Eur. J. Oper. Res. 182, 578–596 (2007)
Sharma, S., Ukkusuri, S.V., Mathew, T.V.: Pareto optimal multi-objective optimization for robust transportation network design problem. Transp. Res. Rec. 2090, 95–104 (2009)
Sharma, S., Mathew, T.V.: Multi-objective network design for emission and travel-time trade-off for a sustainable large urban transportation network. Environ. Plann. B 38, 520–538 (2011)
Smith, K.I.: A study of simulated annealing techniques for multi-objective optimization. Thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Computer Science at the University of Exeter, Exeter (2006)
Steenbrink, P.A.: Optimization of transport network. John Wiley, New York (1974)
Tan, K.C., Khor, E.F., Lee, T.H.: Multiobjective evolutionary algorithms and applications. Springer, London (2005)
Tzeng, G.H., Tsaur, S.H.: Application of multiple criteria decision making for network improvement. J. Adv. Transp. 31(1), 49–74 (1997)
Wismans, L.J.J., van Berkum, E.C., Bliemer, M.C.J.: Comparison of multiobjective evolutionary algorithms for optimization of externalities using dynamic traffic management measures. Transp. Res. Rec. 2263, 163–173 (2011)
Wismans, L.J.J., Brands, T., Van Berkum, E.C., Bliemer, M.C.J.: Pruning and ranking the Pareto optimal set, application for the dynamic multi-objective network design problem. J. Adv. Transp. 48(6), 588–607 (2014)
Xu, T., Wei, H., Wang, Z.: Study on continuous network design problem using simulated annealing and genetic algorithm. Exp. Syst. Appl. 36, 2735–2741 (2009)
Yang, H., Bell, M.G.H.: Models and algorithms for road network design: a review and some new developments. Transp. Rev. 18(3), 257–278 (1998)
Yin, Y.: Multiobjective bilevel optimization for transport planning and management problems. J. Adv. Transp. 36(1), 93–105 (2002)
Zhang, G., Lu, J.: Genetic algorithm for continuous network design problem. J. Transp. Syst. Eng. Inform. Technol. 7, 101–105 (2007)
Zhao, F., Zeng, X.: Simulated annealing-genetic algorithm for transit network optimization. J. Comput. Civil Eng. 20, 57–68 (2006)
Acknowledgments
The authors are grateful for the financial contributions of Goudappel Coffeng and the ATMA (Advanced Traffic MAnagement) and Pay-as-you-drive projects of the TRANSUMO program. TRANSUMO (TRANsition SUstainable MObility) is a Dutch platform for companies, governments and knowledge institutes that cooperate in the development of knowledge with regard to sustainable mobility.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Possel, B., Wismans, L.J.J., Van Berkum, E.C. et al. The multi-objective network design problem using minimizing externalities as objectives: comparison of a genetic algorithm and simulated annealing framework. Transportation 45, 545–572 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-016-9738-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-016-9738-y