Abstract
The second half of the twentieth century witnessed the development of a crusading spirit and massive technical aid aimed at reducing fertility levels and rates of population growth in developing countries, and also the involvement of demographers in these events. The demographers at Princeton University’s Office of Population Research, Frank Notestein and his colleagues, have been singled out by recent authors as playing a unique role in bringing about these changes, and they have been criticized for encouraging demographers to become involved, so eroding their scientific objectivity. This paper examines the development of relevant population thought and theory in the English-language literature over the first half of the twentieth century. It concludes that in the circumstances of the second half of the twentieth century, it was inevitable that developed countries and their demographers would become involved in controlling fertility levels in developing countries. The OPR story should be seen largely in terms of how the world’s leading demographic center and its demographic transition theory were swept along by global changes. As those developments started, attitudes to population change in densely settled Asia became Malthusian, even as population growth accompanied by mortality decline in Asia demonstrated that, at least in the short term, the positive checks were disappearing.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
M.C. Balfour R.F. Evans F.W. Notestein I.B. Taeuber (1950) Public health and demography in the Far East: Report of a survey trip, September 13–December 13, 1948 The Rockefeller Foundation New York
L. Birch (1936) The demand for colonies: Territorial expansion, over-population and raw materials League of Nations Union London
V.W. Bladen (1939) ArticleTitleThe population problem Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science 5 IssueID4 528–547
Boudreau, F.G. & Kiser, C.V. (1950), Preface, in Modernization programs in relation to human resources and population problems. Milbank Memorial Fund
Bulatao, R.A. & Casterline, J.B. (eds.) (2001), Global fertility transition, supplement to Population and Development Review 27
G.I. Burch E. Pendell (1947 [1945]) Human breeding and survival. Population roads to peace and war (revised edition) Penguin New York
J.C. Caldwell (1982a) Theory of fertility decline Academic Press London
J.C. Caldwell (1982b) The failure of theories of social and economic change to explain demographic change: Puzzles of modernization or westernization J.L. Simon P.H. Lindert (Eds) Research in Population Economics NumberInSeriesVol. 4 JAI Press Greenwich 297–332
J.C. Caldwell (1996) ArticleTitleDemography and social science Population Studies 50 IssueID3 305–333 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0032472031000149516 Occurrence Handle11618372
J.C. Caldwell (1998) ArticleTitleMalthus and the less developed world: The pivotal role of India Population and Development Review 24 IssueID4 675–696
J.C. Caldwell P. Caldwell (1986) Limiting population growth, and the Ford Foundation contribution Francis Pinter London
J.C. Caldwell P. Caldwell (2001) ArticleTitleRegional paths to fertility decline Journal of Population Research 18 IssueID2 91–117
J.C. Caldwell H. Ware (1973) ArticleTitleThe evolution of family planning in Australia Population Studies 27 IssueID1 7–31 Occurrence Handle11630535
E. Cannan (1930 [1914]) Wealth King London
A.M. Carr-Saunders (1922) The population problem: A study in human evolution Clarendon Oxford
A.M. Carr-Saunders (1936) World population: Past growth and future trends Frank Cass London
E. Charles (1934) The twilight of parenthood Norton New York
W.W. Cleland (1936) The population problem in Egypt Science Press Lancaster, PA
W.W. Cleland (1944) ArticleTitleA population plan for Egypt Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 22 IssueID4 409–423
A.J. Coale E.M. Hoover (1958) Population growth and economic development in low-income Countries: A case study of India’s prospects Princeton University Press Princeton
H. Cox (1922) The problem of population Jonathan Cape London
W.R. Crocker (1931) The Japanese population problem Allen & Unwin London
R.K. Das (1927) Population and food supply in India M. Sanger (Eds) Proceedings of the World Population Conference held at the Salle Centrale, Geneva, August 29th to September 3rd, 1927 Edward Arnold London 114–118
K. Davis (1944) ArticleTitleDemographic fact and policy in India Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 22 IssueID3 236–278
K. Davis (1946) ArticleTitleHuman fertility in India American Journal of Sociology 52 IssueID3 243–254 Occurrence Handle10.1086/219990
K. Davis (1951) ArticleTitlePopulation and the further spread of industrial society Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 95 IssueID1 8–19
E.M. East (1926) Mankind at the crossroads Scribner’s New York
H.P. Fairchild (1927) Optimum population M. Sanger (Eds) Proceedings of the World Population Conference held at the Salle Centrale, Geneva, August 29th to September 3rd, 1927 Edward Arnold London 72–85
P. Fryer (1967 [1965]) The birth controllers Corgi London
D.V. Glass (1936) The struggle for population Clarendon Oxford
M. Grant (1923 [1916]) The passing of the Great Race EditionNumber4 Scribner’s New York
P.K. Hatt (1952) Backgrounds of human fertility in Puerto Rico Princeton University Press Princeton
N.E. Himes (1963 [1936]) Medical history of contraception Gamut (first published 1936 by National Committee on Maternal Health) New York
D. Hodgson (1983) ArticleTitleDemography as social science and policy science Population and Development Review 9 IssueID1 1–34
J.H. Hutton (1933) Census of India, 1931, Part 1, Report Government of India, Manager of Publications Delhi
India Famine Inquiry Commission (1945), Final Report. Madras. Government Press:
India Health Survey and Development Committee (Bhore Committee). (1946), Report of the Health Survey and Development Committee (Final Report, Vol. 2). Delhi: Government of India Press
W.S. Jevons (1865) The coal question: An inquiry concerning the progress of the nation, and the probable exhaustion of the coal mines Macmillan London
J. Keynes (1919) The economics of peace Macmillan London
B-e. Khuda J.C. Caldwell B. Caldwell I. Pieris P. Caldwell (2001) The global fertility transition: New light from Bangladesh experience F. James Phillips Zeba Ayesha Sathar (Eds) Fertility transition in South Asia Oxford University Press Oxford 364–385
D. Kirk (1944) ArticleTitlePopulation changes and the postwar world American Sociological Review 9 IssueID1 28–35
C.V. Kiser (1944) ArticleTitleImplications of population trends for postwar policy Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 22 IssueID2 111–130
Knibbs, G.H. (1917), The mathematical theory of population, of its character and fluctuations, and of the factors which influence them, Appendix A, Vol. 1, 1911 Census of the Commonwealth of Australia. Melbourne: Commonwealth Government of Australia, Minister of State for Home and Territories
G.H. Knibbs (1928) The shadow of the world’s future Ernest Benn London
P.H. Landis (1943) Population problems: A cultural interpretation American Book Company New York
P.H. Landis P.K. Hatt (1954) Population problems: A cultural interpretation American Book Company New York
R. Ledbetter (1976) A history of the Malthusian League Ohio State University Press Columbus
F. Lorimer F. Osborn (1934) Dynamics of population: Social and biological significance of changing birth rates in the United States Macmillan New York
R.S. Lynd H.M. Lynd (1929) Middletown: A study in American culture Harcourt Brace New York
T.R. Malthus (1959 [1798]) Population: The first essay University of Michigan Press (first published 1798) Ann Arbor
T. McKeown R.G. Brown (1955) ArticleTitleMedical evidence related to population changes in the eighteenth century Population Studies 9 IssueID2 119–141
T. McKeown R.G. Record (1962) ArticleTitleReasons for the decline in mortality in England and Wales during the nineteenth century Population Studies 16 IssueID2 94–122
W.E. Moore (1951) Industrialization and Labor: Social aspects of economic development Cornell University Press Ithaca
A. Myrdal (1951) ArticleTitlePopulation trends in densely populated areas Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 95 IssueID1 1–7
F.W. Notestein (1944a) ArticleTitleSome implications of population change for post-war Europe Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 87 IssueID2 165–174
F.W. Notestein (1944b) ArticleTitleProblems of policy in relation to areas of heavy population pressure Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 22 IssueID4 424–444
F.W. Notestein (1945) Population – the long view T.W. Schultz (Eds) Food for the world University of Chicago Press Chicago 36–57
F.W. Notestein (1951) ArticleTitlePolicy of the Indian government on family limitation Population Index 17 IssueID4 254–263
Notestein, F.W. (1953), The economics of population and food supplies, pp. 13–31, in Proceedings of the Eighth International Conference of Agricultural Economists, 1952, London: Oxford University Press
F.W. Notestein (1982) ArticleTitleDemography in the United States: A partial account of the development of the field Population and Development Review 8 IssueID4 651–687
F.W. Notestein I.B. Taeuber D. Kirk A.J. Coale L.K. Kaiser (1944) The future population of Europe and the Soviet Union: Population projections, 1940–1970 League of Nations Geneva
J.E. Orchard (1928) ArticleTitleThe pressure of population in Japan Geographical Review 18 IssueID3 374–401
R. Pearl (1925) The biology of population growth Knopf New York
R. Pearl (1934) ArticleTitleContraception and fertility in 4945 married women: A second report on a study of family limitation Human Biology 6 335–401
E.F. Penrose (1934) Population theories and their application with special reference to Japan Stanford University Food Research Institute Stanford, CA
E.B. Reuter (1923) Population problems Lippincott Philadelphia
E.A. Ross (1927) Standing room only? Century New York
N.B. Ryder (1984) ArticleTitleFrank Wallace Notestein (1902–1983) Population Studies 38 IssueID1 5–20
M. Sanger (Eds) (1927) Proceedings of the World Population Conference held at the Salle Centrale, Geneva, August 29th to September 3rd, 1927 Edward Arnold London
M. Sanger (1938) An autobiography W.W. Norton New York
K.T. Shah (Eds) (1947) Population: Report of the Population Sub-committee of the National Planning Committee Vora Bombay
J. Simon (1981) The ultimate resource Princeton University Press Princeton
J. Spengler (1938) France faces depopulation Duke University Press Durham, NC
R. Stix F. Notestein (1934) ArticleTitleEffectiveness of birth control Milbank Memorial Fund Quarterly 12 IssueID1 57–68
R. Stix F. Notestein (1940) Controlled fertility: An evaluation of clinic service Williams and Wilkins Baltimore
L. Stoddard (1924) The rising tide of color against white world-supremacy Chapman and Hall London
J. Swinburn (1924) Population and the social problem George Allen London
S. Szreter (1993) ArticleTitleThe idea of demographic transition and the study of fertility change: A critical intellectual history Population and Development Review 19 IssueID4 659–701
I.B. Taeuber F.W. Notestein (1947) ArticleTitleThe changing fertility of the Japanese Population Studies 1 IssueID1 2–28
W.S. Thompson (1929) ArticleTitlePopulation American Journal of Sociology 34 IssueID6 959–975 Occurrence Handle10.1086/214874
W.S. Thompson (1942 [1930]) Population problems McGraw Hill (first published 1930) New York
W.S. Thompson (1946) Population and peace in the Pacific Chicago University Press Chicago
J. Toye (2000) Keynes on population Oxford University Press Oxford
United Nations (1951), The past and future growth of world population in a long-range view, Population Bulletin 1: 1–12
InstitutionalAuthorNameUnited Nations (1953) The determinants and consequences of population growth United Nations New York
United Nations (1961), The Mysore Population Study. Population Studies No. 34, St/SOA/Series A/34, New York
W. Vogt (1949) Road to survival Gollancz London
P.K. Wattal (1916) The population problem in India Bennett, Coleman Bombay
W.F. Willcox (1916) ArticleTitleThe nature and significance of the changes in birth and death rates in recent years American Statistical Association 15 IssueID113 1–15
Willcox, W.F. (1931), Increase in the population of the earth and the continents since 1650, pp. 33–82, and Appendix, pp. 639–644, in W.F. Willcox (ed.), International migrations, vol. 2.: Interpretations. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research
W.F. Willcox (1940) Studies in American demography Cornell University Press Ithaca
A.B. Wolfe (1928a) ArticleTitleThe population problem since the World War: A survey of literature and research Part 1 Journal of Political Economy 36 IssueID5 529–559 Occurrence Handle10.1086/253976
A.B. Wolfe (1928b) ArticleTitleThe population problem since the World War: A survey of literature and research Part 2 Journal of Political Economy 36 IssueID6 662–685 Occurrence Handle10.1086/253985
A.B. Wolfe (1929) ArticleTitleThe population problem since the World War: A survey of literature and research Part 3 Journal of Political Economy 37 IssueID1 87–120 Occurrence Handle10.1086/253998
F.C. Wright (1939) Population and peace League of Nations. International Institute of Intellectual Co-operation Paris
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Caldwell, J.C. Demographers’ Involvement in Twentieth-Century Population Policy: Continuity or Discontinuity?. Popul Res Policy Rev 24, 359–385 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-005-1290-y
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11113-005-1290-y