Abstract
Lupeol, betulin and betulinic acid are members of the so-called lupane-type triterpenoids. These natural products found worldwide in quite of lot of vegetables, fruits and plant species exhibit promising pharmacological activities including anti-inflammatory, anti-HIV and antitumor activities. Nevertheless, the poor pharmacokinetic properties of these cholesterol-like triterpenoids hampered further pharmaceutical developments. The synthesis of lupane-type saponins, i.e., sugar-derived lupanes, seems to be a good avenue to improve both their water solubility and pharmacological activity. The aims of this review are twofold: first, to describe the biological activity of naturally occurring lupane-type saponins, and second, report the different methodologies employed for the elaboration of glycosidic linkages at the C-3 and/or C-28 positions on the lupane core. The synthesis of both natural and unnatural lupane-type saponins is discussed with an emphasis on molecules exhibiting relevant biological activities.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- A549:
-
Human lung carcinoma
- Ara:
-
α-l-Arabinopyranose
- BF3·OEt2 :
-
Boron trifluoride diethyletherate
- CGTase:
-
Cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase
- d-Ara:
-
α-d-Arabinopyranose
- DLD-1:
-
Human colorectal adenocarcinoma
- Gal:
-
β-d-Galactopyranose
- Glc:
-
β-d-Glucopyranose
- HIV:
-
Human immunodeficiency virus
- IC50 :
-
Half maximal inhibitory concentration
- Man:
-
α-d-Mannopyranose
- PMT:
-
Prodrug monotherapy
- Rha:
-
α-l-Rhamnopyranose
- SAR:
-
Structure-activity relationships
- TCA:
-
Trichloroacetimidate
- TMSOTf:
-
Trimethylsilyl trifluoromethanesulfonate
- Xyl:
-
β-d-Xylopyranose
References
Aratanechemuge Y, Hibasami H, Sanpin K, Katsuzaki H, Imai K, Komiya T (2004) Induction of apoptosis by lupeol isolated from mokumem (Gossampinus malabarica L. Merr) in human promyelotic leukemia HL-60 cells. Oncol Rep 11:289–292
Bachran C, Bachran S, Sutherland M, Bachran D, Fuchs H (2008) Saponins in tumor therapy. Mini-Rev Med Chem 8:575–584
Baglin I, Mitaine-Offer AC, Nour M, Tan K, Cavé C, Lacaille-Dubois MA (2003a) A review of natural and modified betulinic, ursolic and echinocystic acid derivatives as potential antitumor and anti-HIV agents. Mini-Rev Med Chem 3:525–539
Baglin I, Poumaroux A, Nour M, Tan K, Mitaine-Offer AC, Lacaille-Dubois MA, Chauffert B, Cavé C (2003b) New ursolic and betulinic derivatives as potential cytotoxic agents. J Enzym Inhib Med Chem 18:111–117
Bang SC, Kim Y, Lee JH, Ahn BZ (2005a) Triterpenoid saponins from the roots of Pulsatilla koreana. J Nat Prod 68:268–272
Bang SC, Lee JH, Song GY, Kim DH, Yoon MY, Ahn BZ (2005b) Antitumor activity of Pulsatilla koreana saponins and their structure-activity relationship. Chem Pharm Bull 53:1451–1454
Bi Y, Xu JY, Wu XM (2005) Advances in research of betulinic acids. Chin J New Drugs 14:23–26
Bliard C, Massiot G, Nazabadioko S (1994) Glycosylation of acids under phase transfer conditions. Partial synthesis of saponins. Tetrahedron Lett 35:6107–6108
Bosslet K, Straub R, Blumrich M, Czech J, Gerken M, Sperker B, Kroemer HK, Gesson JP, Koch M, Monneret C (1998) Elucidation of the mechanism enabling tumor selective prodrug monotherapy. Cancer Res 58:1195–1201
Braca A, Autore G, De Simone F, Marzocco S, Morelli I, Venturella F, De Tommasi N (2004) Cytotoxic saponins from Schefflera rotundifolia. Planta Med 70:960–966
Bruneton J (2009) Pharmacognosie, phytochimie, plantes médicinales, 4th edn. Technique & Documentation, Paris
Cham BE, Daunter B (1990) Solasodine glycosides. Selective cytotoxicity for cancer cells and inhibition of cytotoxicity by rhamnose in mice with sarcoma 180. Cancer Lett 55:221–225
Chang LC, Tsai TR, Wang JJ, Lin CN, Kuo KW (1998) The rhamnose moiety of solamargine plays a crucial role in triggering cell death by apoptosis. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 242:21–25
Chatterjee P, Pezzuto JM, Kouzi SA (1999) Glucosidation of betulinic acid by Cunninghamella species. J Nat Prod 62:761–763
Chaturvedi PK, Bhui K, Shukla Y (2008) Lupeol: Connotations for chemoprevention. Cancer Lett 263:1–13
Chen X, Wu B, Wang PG (2003) Glucuronides in anti-cancer therapy. Curr Med Chem Anti-Cancer Agents 3:139–150
Cichewicz RH, Kouzi SA (2004) Chemistry, biological activity, and chemotherapeutic potential of betulinic acid for the prevention and treatment of cancer and HIV infection. Med Res Rev 24:90–114
Cioffi G, Braca A, Autore G, Morelli I, Pinto A, Venturella F, De Tommasi N (2003) Cytotoxic saponins from Schefflera fagueti. Planta Med 69:750–756
Cmoch P, Pakulski Z, Swaczynová J, Strnad M (2008) Synthesis of lupane-type saponins bearing mannosyl and 3, 6-branched trimannosyl residues and their evaluation as anticancer agents. Carbohydr Res 343:995–1003
De Graaf M, Boven E, Scheeren HW, Haisma HJ, Pinedo HM (2002) Beta-glucuronidase-mediated drug release. Curr Pharm Design 8:1391–1403
Dzubak P, Hajduch M, Vydra D, Hustova A, Kvasnica M, Biedermann D, Markova L, Urban M, Sarek J (2006) Pharmacological activities of natural triterpenoids and their therapeutic implications. Nat Prod Rep 23:394–411
Eiznhamer DA, Xu ZQ (2004) Betulinic acid: a promising anticancer candidate. IDrugs 7:359–373
Evers M, Poujade C, Soler F, Ribeill Y, James C, Lelièvre Y, Gueguen JC, Reisdorf D, Morize I, Pauwels R, De Clercq E, Hénin Y, Bousseau A, Mayaux JF, Le Pecq JB, Dereu N (1996) Betulinic acid derivatives: A new class of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 specific inhibitors with a new mode of action. J Med Chem 39:1056–1068
Fernández MA, de las Heras B, García MD, Sáenz MT, Villar A (2001) New insights into the mechanism of action of the anti-inflammatory triterpene lupeol. J Pharm Pharmacol 53:1533–1539
Flekther OB, Baltina LA, Spirikhin LV, Baikova IP, Tolstikov GA (1998) Glycosylation of betulin acetates with glycals. Russ Chem B 47:513–516
Flekther OB, Baltina LA, Tolstikov GA (2000) Glycals in the stereoselective synthesis of triterpene 2-deoxy-α-l-glycosides under conditions of acidic catalysis. J Nat Prod 63:992–994
Francis G, Kerem Z, Makkar HPS, Becker K (2002) The biological action of saponins in animal systems: a review. Brit J Nutr 88:587–605
Fujioka T, Kashiwada Y, Kilkuskie RE, Cosentino LM, Ballas LM, Jiang JB, Janzen WP, Chen IS, Lee KH (1994) Anti-AIDS agents, 11. Betulinic acid and platanic acid as anti-HIV principles from Syzigium claviflorum, and the anti-HIV activity of structurally related triterpenoids. J Nat Prod 57:243–247
Galonić DP, Gin DY (2007) Chemical glycosylation in the synthesis of glycoconjugate antitumour vaccines. Nature 446:1000–1007
Gao XD, Ye WC, Yu ACH, Zhang Y, Tan RX, Li M, Hsiao WLW (2003) Pulsatilloside A and anemoside A3 protect PC12 cells from apoptosis induced by sodium cyanide and glucose deprivation. Planta Med 69:171–174
Gauthier C, Legault J, Lebrun M, Dufour P, Pichette A (2006) Glycosidation of lupane-type triterpenoids as potent in vitro cytotoxic agents. Bioorg Med Chem 14:6713–6725
Gauthier C, Legault J, Lavoie S, Rondeau S, Tremblay S, Pichette A (2008) Synthesis of two natural betulinic acid saponins containing α-l-rhamnopyranosyl-(1 → 2)-α-l-arabinopyranose and their analogues. Tetrahedron 64:7386–7399
Gauthier C, Legault J, Pichette A (2009a) Recent progress in the synthesis of naturally occurring triterpenoid saponins. Mini-Rev Org Chem 6:321–344
Gauthier C, Legault J, Girard-Lalancette K, Mshvildadze V, Pichette A (2009b) Haemolytic activity, cytotoxicity and membrane cell permeabilization of semi-synthetic and natural lupane- and oleanane-type saponins. Bioorg Med Chem 17:2002–2008
Gauthier C, Legault J, Lavoie S, Rondeau S, Tremblay S, Pichette A (2009c) Synthesis and cytotoxicity of bidesmosidic betulin and betulinic acid saponins. J Nat Prod 72:72–81
Gauthier C, Legault J, Piochon M, Lavoie S, Tremblay S, Pichette A (2009d) Synthesis, cytotoxicity, and haemolytic activity of chacotrioside lupane-type neosaponins and their germanicane-type rearrangement products. Bioorg Med Chem Lett 19:2310–2314
Gauthier C, Legault J, Rondeau S, Pichette A (2009e) Synthesis of betulinic acid acyl glucuronide for application in anticancer prodrug monotherapy. Tetrahedron Lett 50:988–991
Geetha T, Varalakshmi P, Latha M (1998) Effect of triterpenes from Crataeva nurvala stem bark on lipid peroxidation in adjuvant induced arthritis in rats. Pharmacol Res 37:191–195
Hata K, Hori K, Ogasawara H, Takahashi S (2003) Anti-leukemia activities of lup-28-al-20(29)-en-3-one, a lupane triterpene. Toxicol Lett 143:1–7
Hayek EWH, Jordis U, Moche W, Sauter F (1989) A bicentennial of betulin. Phytochemistry 28:2229–2242
Hu K, Dong A, Yao X (1996) Antineoplastic agents; I. Three spirostanol glycosides from rhizomes of Dioscorea collettii var. hypoglauca. Planta Med 62:573–575
Ikeda T, Tsumagari H, Honbu T, Nohara T (2003) Cytotoxic activity of steroidal glycosides from Solanum plants. Biol Pharm Bull 26:1198–1201
Jäger S, Winkler K, Pfüller U, Scheffler A (2007) Solubility studies of oleanolic acid and betulinic acid in aqueous solutions and plant extracts of Viscum album L. Planta Med 73:157–162
Just MJ, Carmen Recio M, Giner RM, Cuéllar MJ, Máñez S, Bilia AR, Ríos JL (1998) Anti-inflammatory activity of unusual lupane saponins from Bupleurum fruticescens. Planta Med 64:404–407
Kashiwada Y, Hashimoto F, Cosentino LM, Chen CH, Garrett PE, Lee KH (1996) Betulinic acid and dihydrobetulinic acid derivatives as potent anti-HIV agents. J Med Chem 39:1016–1017
Kessler JH, Mullauer FB, de Roo GM, Medema JP (2007) Broad in vitro efficacy of plant-derived betulinic acid against cell lines derived from the most prevalent human cancer types. Cancer Lett 25:132–145
Kim DSHL, Pezzuto JM, Pisha E (1998) Synthesis of betulinic acid derivatives with activity against human melanoma. Bioorg Med Chem Lett 8:1707–1712
Klinotová E, Krecek V, Klinot J, Endová M, Eisenreichová J, Budešínský M, Štícha M (1997) Glycosylation of triterpene alcohols and acids of the lupane and a-secolupane series. Collect Czech Chem C 62:1776–1798
Koenigs W, Knorr E (1901) Some derivatives of grape sugars and galactose. Ber 34:957–981
Kolomitsyn IV, Holy J, Perkins E, Krasutsky PA (2007) Analysis and antiproliferative activity of bark extractives of Betula neoalaskana and B. papyrifera. Synthesis of the most active extractive component—betulin 3-caffeate. Nat Prod Commun 2:17–26
Krasutsky PA (2006) Birch bark research and development. Nat Prod Rep 23:919–942
Křen V, Martinková L (2001) Glycosides in medicine: “the role of glycosidic residue in biological activity”. Curr Med Chem 8:1313–1338
Lacaille-Dubois MA (2000) Biologically and pharmacologically active saponins from plants: recent advances. In: Oleszek O, Marston A (eds) Saponins in food, feedstuffs and medicinal plants, vol 45. Kluwer, The Netherlands, pp 205–218
Lacaille-Dubois MA (2005) Bioactive saponins with cancer related and immunomodulatory activity: recent developments. In: Rahman AU (ed) Studies in natural products chemistry, vol 32. Elsevier, The Netherlands, pp 209–246
Lautrette S, Granet R, Krausz P (2004) A new method of solvent free O- and N-glycosylation using activated carbon fiber (ACF) as a promoter. Application to the synthesis of saponin and nucleoside analogues. Chem Commun 586–587
Lee KT, Sohn IC, Park HJ, Kim DW, Jung GO, Park KY (2000) Essential moiety for antimutagenic and cytotoxic activity of hederagenin monodesmosides and bisdesmosides isolated from the stem bark of Kalopanax pictus. Planta Med 66:329–332
Levy DE, Fügedi P (2006) The organic chemistry of sugars. CRC Press, Boca Raton
Li TS, Wang JX, Zheng XJ (1998) Simple synthesis of allobetulin, 28-oxyallobetulin and related biomarkers from betulin and betulinic acid catalysed by solid acids. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1:3957–3965
Liu MJ, Wang Z, Ju Y, Zhou JB, Wang Y, Wong RNS (2004) The mitotic-arresting and apoptosis-inducing effects of diosgenyl saponins on human leukemia cell lines. Biol Pharm Bull 27:1059–1065
Mimaki Y, Yokosuka A, Kuroda M, Hamanaka M, Sakuma C, Sashida Y (2001) New bidesmosidic triterpene saponins from the roots of Pulsatilla chinensis. J Nat Prod 64:1226–1229
Moriarity DM, Huang J, Yancey CA, Zhang P, Setzer WN, Lawton RO, Bates RB, Caldera S (1998) Lupeol is the cytotoxic principle in the leaf extract of Dendropanax cf. querceti. Planta Med 64:370–372
Mukherjee R, Kumar V, Srivastava SK, Agarwal SK, Burman AC (2006) Betulinic acid derivatives as anticancer agents: structure activity relationship. Curr Med Chem-Anti-Cancer Agents 6:271–279
Mullauer FB, Kessler JH, Medema JP (2009) Betulin is a potent anti-tumor agent that is enhanced by cholesterol. Plos One 4:e1
Nakamura T, Komori C, Lee YY, Hashimoto F, Yahara S, Nohara T, Ejima A (1996) Cytotoxic activities of Solanum steroidal glycosides. Biol Pharm Bull 19:564–566
O’Brien J, Wilson I, Orton T, Pognan F (2000) Investigation of the Alamar Blue (resazurin) fluorescent dye for the assessment of mammalian cell cytotoxicity. Eur J Biochem 267:5421–5426
O’Connell MM, Bentley MD, Campbell CS, Cole BJW (1988) Betulin and lupeol in bark from four white-barked birches. Phytochemistry 27:2175–2176
Oda K, Matsuda H, Murakami T, Katayama S, Ohgitani T, Yoshikawa M (2000) Adjuvant and haemolytic activities of 47 saponins derived from medicinal and food plants. Biol Chem 381:67–74
Ohara S, Hishiyama S (1994) Utilization of triterpenoids I. Synthesis of betulin glycosides by cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase. Mokuzai Gakkaishi 40:444–451
Ohara S, Ohira T (2003) Plant growth regulation effects of triterpenoid saponins. J Wood Sci 49:59–64
Ovesná Z, Vachálková A, Horváthová K, Tóthová D (2004) Pentacyclic triterpenoic acids: new chemoprotective compounds. Neoplasma 51:327–333
Pakulski Z (2005) Regioselective glycosylation of unprotected mannosides: a convenient access to high-mannose type saponins. Polish J Chem 79:361–367
Park HJ, Kwon SH, Lee JH, Lee KH, Miyamoto KI, Lee KT (2001) Kalopanaxsaponin A is a basic saponin structure for the anti-tumor activity of hederagenin monodesmosides. Planta Med 67:118–121
Patočka J (2003) Biologically active pentacyclic triterpenes and their current medicine signification. J Appl Biomed 1:7–12
Pisha E, Chai H, Lee IS, Chagwedera TE, Farnsworth NR, Cordell GA, Beecher CWW, Fong HHS, Kinghorn AD, Brown DM, Wani MC, Wall ME, Hieken TJ, Das Gupta TK, Pezzuto JM (1995) Discovery of betulinic acid as a selective inhibitor of human melanoma that functions by induction of apoptosis. Nat Med 1:1046–1051
Pyo JS, Roh SH, Kim DK, Lee JG, Lee YY, Hong SS, Kwon SW, Park JH (2009) Anti-cancer effect of betulin on a human lung cancer cell line: a pharmacoproteomic approach using 2 D SDS PAGE coupled with nano-HPLC tandem mass spectrometry. Planta Med 75:127–131
Rao AV, Gurfinkel DM (2000) The bioactivity of saponins: triterpenoid and steroidal glycosides. Drug Metab Drug Interac 17:211–235
Safayhi H, Sailer ER (1997) Anti-inflammatory actions of pentacyclic triterpenes. Planta Med 63:487–493
Saleem M (2009) Lupeol, a novel anti-inflammatory and anti-cancer dietary triterpene. Cancer Lett 285:109–115
Salzwedel K, Martin DE, Sakalian M (2007) Maturation inhibitors: a new therapeutic class targets the virus structure. AIDS Rev 9:162–172
Sami A, Taru M, Salme K, Jari YK (2006) Pharmacological properties of the ubiquitous natural product betulin. Eur J Pharm Sci 29:1–13
Samoshina NF, Denisenko MV, Denisenko VA, Uvarova NI (2003) Synthesis of glycosides of lupane-type triterpene acids. Chem Nat Compd 39:575–582
Schmidt RR, Toepfer A (1991) Glycosylation with highly reactive glycosyl donors: efficiency of the inverse procedure. Tetrahedron Lett 32:3353–3356
Setzer WN, Setzer MC (2003) Plant-derived triterpenoids as potential antineoplastic agents. Mini-Rev Med Chem 3:540–556
Smith TA (1999) Facilitative glucose transporter expression in human cancer tissue. Brit J Biomed Sci 56:285–292
Soler F, Poujade C, Evers M, Carry JC, Hénin Y, Bousseau A, Huet T, Pauwels R, De Clercq E, Mayaux JF, Le Pecq JB, Dereu N (1996) Betulinic acid derivatives: a new class of specific inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 entry. J Med Chem 39:1069–1083
Sparg SG, Light ME, van Staden J (2004) Biological activities and distribution of plant saponins. J Ethnopharmacol 94:219–243
Steele JCP, Warhurst DC, Kirby GC, Simmonds MSJ (1999) In vitro and in vivo evaluation of betulinic acid as an antimalarial. Phytother Res 13:115–119
Sun H, Fang WS (2006) Structure-activity relationships of oleanane- and ursane-type triterpenoids. Bot Stud 47:339–368
Thibeault D, Gauthier C, Legault J, Bouchard J, Dufour P, Pichette A (2007) Synthesis and structure-activity relationship study of cytotoxic germanicane- and lupane-type 3β-O-monodesmosidic saponins starting from betulin. Bioorg Med Chem 15:6144–6157
Tiwari KP, Srivastava SD, Srivastava SK (1980) α-l-Rhamnopyranosyl-3β-hydroxy-lup-20(29)-en-28-oic acid from the stem of Dillenia pentagyna. Phytochemistry 19:980–981
Tolstikova TG, Sorokina IV, Tolstikov GA, Tolstikov AG, Flekther OB (2006) Biological activity and pharmacological prospects of lupane triterpenoids: I. Natural lupane derivatives. Russ J Bioorg Chem 32:37–49
Uvarova NI, Oshitok GI, Elyakov GB (1973) Synthesis of steroid and triterpenoid glycosides by the orthoester method. Carbohydr Res 27:79–87
Uvarova NI, Atopkina LN, Elyakov GB (1980) Synthesis of triterpene and steroid glycosides. Carbohydr Res 83:33–42
Wang Y, Zhang Y, Zhu Z, Zhu S, Li Y, Li M, Yu B (2007) Exploration of the correlation between the structure, haemolytic activity, and cytotoxicity of steroid saponins. Bioorg Med Chem 15:2528–2532
Wen Z, Stern ST, Martin DE, Lee KH, Smith PC (2006) Structural characterization of anti-HIV drug candidate PA-457 [3-O-(3′-3′-dimethylsuccinyl)-betulinic acid] and its acyl glucuronides in rat bile and evaluation of in vitro stability in human and animal liver microsomes and plasma. Drug Metab Dispos 34:1436–1442
Ye W, Zhang Q, Hsiao WWL, Zhao S, Che CT (2002) New lupane glycosides from Pulsatilla chinensis. Planta Med 68:183–186
Yogeeswari P, Sriram D (2005) Betulinic acid and its derivatives: a review on their biological properties. Curr Med Chem 12:657–666
Yoshizumi K, Hirano K, Ando H, Hirai Y, Ida Y, Tsuji T, Tanaka T, Satouchi K, Terao J (2006) Lupane-type saponins from leaves of Acanthopanax sessiliflorus and their inhibitory activity on pancreatic lipase. J Agric Food Chem 54:335–341
You YJ, Nam NH, Kim Y, Bae KH, Ahn BZ (2003) Antiangiogenic activity of lupeol from Bombax ceiba. Phytother Res 17:341–344
Yu B, Sun J (2009) Current synthesis of triterpene saponins. Chem Asian J 4:642–654
Yu B, Zhang Y, Tang P (2007) Carbohydrate chemistry in the total synthesis of saponins. Eur J Org Chem 31:5145–5161
Yuodvirshis AM, Troshchenko AT (1969) The synthesis of triterpenoid glycosides. Part 4. The synthesis of 3,28 (or 30)-bis-O-glycosides of oleanolic, ursolic, 11-keto-oleanolic, 18-beta-H-glycyrrhetic and betulinic acids. Izv Sib Otd Akad Nauk SSSR Ser Khim Nauk 2:129–138
Yuodvirshis AM, Sinyakova LG, Troshchenko AT (1968) The synthesis of triterpenoid glycosides. Part 3. 11-Keto-oleanolic, 12-ketodihydro-oleanolic and betulinic acids 28-O-glycosides. Izv Sib Otd Akad Nauk SSSR Ser Khim Nauk 2:123–127
Ziegler HL, Franzyk H, Sairafianpour M, Tabatabai M, Tehrani MD, Bagherzadeh K, Hägerstrand H, Staerk D, Jaroszewski JW (2004) Erythrocyte membrane modifying agents and the inhibition of Plasmodium falciparum growth: structure-activity relationships for betulinic acid analogues. Bioorg Med Chem 12:119–127
Ziegler HL, Staalsø T, Jaroszewski JW (2006) Loading of erythrocyte membrane with pentacylic triterpenes inhibits Plasmodium falciparum invasion. Planta Med 72:640–642
Zuco V, Supino R, Righetti SC, Cleris L, Marchesi E, Gambacorti-Passerini C, Formelli F (2002) Selective cytotoxicity of betulinic acid on tumor cell lines, but not on normal cells. Cancer Lett 175:17–25
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank Dr. Yves Janin for proof-reading this manuscript and the anonymous reviewers for helpful comments and suggestions. The financial support of the Fonds Québécois de la Recherche sur la Nature et les Technologies (FQRNT, fonds forestier 02) is gratefully acknowledged. C. G. wishes to acknowledge the Programme d’Aide Institutionnel à la Recherche de l’Université du Québec à Chicoutimi (PAIR-UQAC), the Fondation de l’UQAC as well as FQRNT for graduate scholarships.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding authors
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Gauthier, C., Legault, J., Piochon-Gauthier, M. et al. Advances in the synthesis and pharmacological activity of lupane-type triterpenoid saponins. Phytochem Rev 10, 521–544 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11101-010-9176-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11101-010-9176-y