Philosophical Studies

, Volume 121, Issue 2, pp 99–125 | Cite as

Suffering without subjectivity


This paper argues that it is possible for suffering to occur in the absence of phenomenal consciousness – in the absence of a certain sort of experiential subjectivity, that is. (‘‘Phenomenal’’ consciousness is the property that some mental states possess, when it is like something to undergo them, or when they have subjective feels, or possess qualia.) So even if theories of phenomenal consciousness that would withhold such consciousness from most species of non-human animal are correct, this needn’t mean that those animals don’t suffer, and aren’t appropriate objects of sympathy and concern.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Bermúdez, J. 1995‘Non-conceptual Content’Mind and Language.10333369Google Scholar
  2. Block, N. 1986‘Advertisement for a Semantics for Psychology’Midwest Studies in Philosophy.10615678Google Scholar
  3. Block, N. 1995’A Confusion About a Function of Consciousness’Behavioral and Brain Sciences18227261Google Scholar
  4. Byrne, R. 1995The Thinking ApeOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  5. Byrne, R., Whiten, A. 1988Machiavellian IntelligenceOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  6. Carruthers, P. 1989‘Brute Experience’Journal of Philosophy.86258269Google Scholar
  7. Carruthers, P. 1992The Animals IssueCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  8. Carruthers, P. 1999‘Sympathy and Subjectivity’Australasian Journal of Philosophy.77465482Google Scholar
  9. Carruthers, P. 2000Phenomenal Consciousness. A Naturalistic TheoryCambridge University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  10. Carruthers, P. 2004a‘Phenomenal Concepts and Higher-order Experiences’Philosophy and Phenomenological Research.67316336Google Scholar
  11. Carruthers, P. 2004b

    HOP over FOR, HOT Theory

    Gennaro, R. eds. Higher Order Theories of ConsciousnessJohn BenjaminsPhiladelphia
    Google Scholar
  12. Carruthers, P. 2004c‘On Being Simple Minded’American Philosophical Quarterly.41205220Google Scholar
  13. Carruthers P. (2005). ‘Why the Question of Animal Consciousness Might Not Matter Very Much’. Philosophical Psychology. 18Google Scholar
  14. Clark, A. 2002‘Visual Experience and Motor Action: Are the Bonds too Tight?’Philosophical Review.110495520Google Scholar
  15. Crane, T. 1998

    Intentionality as the Mark of the Mental

    O’Hear, A. eds. Current Issues in Philosophy of MindCambridge University PressCambridge229252
    Google Scholar
  16. Damasio, A. (1994): Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason and the Human Brain, New York: Putnam’s Sons.Google Scholar
  17. Dickinson, A., Balleine, B. 2000

    Causal Cognition and Goal-directed Action

    Heyes, C.Huber, L. eds. The Evolution of CognitionMA: MIT PressCambridge
    Google Scholar
  18. Dretske, F. 1995Naturalizing the MindMA: MIT PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  19. Feinberg, J. 1977

    Harm and Self-interest

    Hacker, P.Raz, J. eds. Law, Morality and SocietyOxford University PressOxford285308
    Google Scholar
  20. Kelly, S. 2001‘Demonstrative Concepts and Experience’Philosophical Review.110397420Google Scholar
  21. Loar, B. (1981): Mind and Meaning, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  22. Lycan, W. 1996Consciousness and ExperienceMA: MIT PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  23. Martin, M. 1995

    Bodily Awareness: A Sense of Ownership

    Bermúdez, J.Eilan, N.Marcel, A. eds. The Body and the SelfMA: MIT PressCambridge
    Google Scholar
  24. McDowell, J. 1994Mind and WorldMA: Harvard University PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  25. McGinn, C. 1989Mental ContentBlackwellOxfordGoogle Scholar
  26. Millikan, R. 1984Language, Thought, and Other Biological CategoriesMA: MIT PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  27. Millikan, R. 1989BiosemanticsJournal of Philosophy86281297Google Scholar
  28. Milner, D., Goodale, M. 1995The Visual Brain in ActionOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  29. Nagel, T. 1979Death’, in Mortal QuestionsCambridge University PressCambridge110Google Scholar
  30. Papineau, D. 1987Reality and RepresentationBlackwellOxfordGoogle Scholar
  31. Papineau, D. 1993Philosophical NaturalismBlackwellOxfordGoogle Scholar
  32. Peacocke, C. 1992A Study of Concepts CambridgeMA: MIT PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  33. Povinelli, D. 2000Folk Physics for ApesOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  34. Ramachandran, V., Blakeslee, S. 1998Phantoms in the BrainFourth EstateNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  35. Ramachandran, V., Rogers-Ramachandran, D., Cobb, S. 1995Touching the Phantom LimbNature377489490Google Scholar
  36. Rolls, E. 1999Emotion and the BrainOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  37. Rosenthal, D. 1993

    Thinking That One Thinks

    Davies, M.Humphreys, G. eds. ConsciousnessBlackwellOxford197223
    Google Scholar
  38. Searle, J. 1992The Rediscovery of the Mind MIT PressMA:CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  39. Smith, P. 1996

    Language and the Evolution of Mind-reading

    Carruthers, P.Smith, P. eds. Theories of Theories of MindCambridge University PressCambridge
    Google Scholar
  40. Tye, M. 1995Ten Problems of ConsciousnessMA: MIT PressCambridgeGoogle Scholar
  41. Tye, M. 1997The Problem of Simple MindsPhilosophical Studies88289317Google Scholar
  42. Tye, M. 2000Consciousness, Color and Content MIT PressMA:CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  43. Weiskrantz, L. 1997Consciousness Lost and FoundOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of PhilosophyUniversity of MarylandCollege ParkUSA

Personalised recommendations