Abstract
The present article challenges reports claiming to have demonstrated the Parity Violating Energetic Difference (PVED) between enantiomorphous D- and L-crystals. Apart from PVED, the presence of minute quantities and differing profiles of impurities incorporated during their different history of preparation will affect the physical properties of D- and L-crystals. These impurities are anticipated to play a much greater role in affecting crystallization behavior than PVED. The effect of impurities on the growth and dissolution of enantiomorphous crystals is illustrated with some representative examples.
Shinitzky et al. (2002) reported recently dramatic differences in the growth and dissolution properties of the D- and L-crystals of tyrosine. We have repeated these experiments using commercial samples from different sources and employing a validated enantioselective gas chromatographic technique. We attribute Shinitzky's findings either to the use of inappropriate analytical techniques for the determination of enantiomeric composition and/or to the presence of unidentified contaminants in the commercial tyrosine samples. Related caveats hold also for the recently published claims by Shinitzky (2006) and Scolnik et al. (2006) to have observed experimentally PVED between enantiomeric helices of poly-glutamic acid composed of 24 repeating units.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Addadi, L., Weinstein, S., Gati, E., Weissbuch, I. and Lahav, M.: 1982, Resolution of Conglomerates with the Assistance of Tailor-made Impurities. Generality and Mechanistic Aspects of the “Rule of Reversal”. A New Method for Assignment of Absolute Configuration, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 104, 4610.
Armstrong, D. W., Kullman, J. P., Chien, X. and Rowe, M.: 2001, Composition and Chirality of Amino Acids in Aerosols/Dust from Laboratory and Residential Enclosures, Chirality 13, 153.
Avalos, M., Babiano, R., Cintas, P., Jimenez, J. L. and Palcios, J. C.: 2000, From Parity to Chirality: Chemical Implications Revisited, Tetrahedron Asymm. 11, 2845.
Bernstein, J.: 2001, Disappearing and Reappearing Polymorphs. The Benzocaine:picric Acid System, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123, 1834.
Bonner, W. A.: 2000, Parity Violation and the Evolution of Biomolecular Homochirality, Chirality 12, 114.
Cintas, P.: 2001, Elementary Asymmetry and Biochirality: No Longer Twinned, ChemPhysChem. 2, 409.
Dunitz, J. D. and Bernstein, J.: 1995, Disappearing Polymorphs, Acc. Chem. Res. 28, 193.
Figureau, A., Duval, E. and Boukenter, A.: 1995, Can Biological Chirality Result From a Phase Transition? Origin Life Evol. Biosphere 25, 211.
Frank, H., Nicholson, G. J. and Bayer, E.: 1977, Rapid Gas Chromatographic Separation of Amino Acid Enantiomers with a Novel Chiral Stationary Phase, J. Chrom. Sci, 15, 174.
Frank, H., Nicholson, G.J. and Bayer, E.: 1978, Enantiomer Labelling, a Ethod for the Quantitative Analysis of Amino Acids, J. Chromatogr. 167, 186.
Japp, F. R.: 1898, Stereochemistry and Vitalism, Nature, 58, 452.
Keszthelyi, L.: 1994, Possibilities to Measure the Parity-Violating Energy Difference, J. Biol. Phys. 20, 241.
Keszthelyi, L.: 2001, Homochirality of Biomolecules: Counterarguments Against Critical Notes, Orig. Life Evol. Biosphere 31, 249.
Kitayama, T., Kiyonaga, H., Morihashi, K., Takahashi, O. and Kikichi, O.: 2002, J. Mol. Struct. (THEOCHEM) 589/590, 183.
Lahamer, A. S., Mahurin, S. M., Compton, R. N., House, D., Laerdahl, J. K., Lein, M. and Schwerdtfeger, P.: 2000, Search for a Parity Violating Energy Difference Between Enantiomers of a Chiral Iron Complex, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 4470.
MacDermott, A. J.: 1993, Chemical Evolution: Origins of Life, Ponnamperuma, C., Chela-Flores, J. Eds., Deepak Publishing, Hampton, VA, 85.
MacDermott, A. J.: 1995, Electroweak Enantioselection and the Origin of Life, Orig. Life Evol. Biospere 25, 191.
MacDermott, A. J. and Tranter, G. E.: 1989, The Search for Large Parity-Violating Energy Differences Between Enantiomers, Chem. Phys. Lett. 163, 1.
Mason, S. F.: 1984, Origins of Handedness, Nature 311, 19.
Mason, S. F. and Tranter, G. E.: 1984, The Parity-Violating Energy Differences Between Enantiomeric Molecules, Mol. Phys. 53, 1091.
Perlovich, G. L., Hansen, L. K. and Bauer-Brandl, A.: 2001, The Polymorphism of Glycine: Thermochemical and Structural Aspects, J Therm. Anal. Cal. 66, 699.
Popovitz-Biro, R., Majewski, J., Margulis, L., Cohen, S., Leiserowitz, L. and Lahav, M.: 1994, Inhibition of Self-Aggregation of Alpha, Omega-Docosanediol into 3D Crystallites by Tailor-Made Amphiphilic Auxiliaries, Adv. Mater. 6, 956.
Quack, M.: 1989, Structure and Dynamics of Chiral Molecules, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 28, 571.
Quack, M.: 2002, How Important is Parity Violation for Molecular and Biomolecular Chirality? Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 41, 4618.
Salam, A.: 1991 The Role of Chirality in the Origin of Life, J. Mol. Evol. 33, 105.
Shimon, L. J. W., Lahav, M. and Leiserowitz, L.: 1986, Stereoselective Etchants for Molecular Crystals. Resolution of Enantiomorphs and Assignment of Aabsolute Structure of Chiral Molecules and Polar Crystals, Nouveau J. Chem. 10, 723.
Shimon, L. J. W., Zbaida, D., Addadi, L., Lahav, M. and Leiserowitz, L.: 1988, Design of Stereospecific Inhibitors for Crystal Dissolution, Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. 161, 138.
Shinitzky, M., Nudelman, F., Barda, Y., Haimovitz, R., Chen, E. and Deamer, D. W.: 2002, Unexpected Differences Between D- and L-Tyrosine Lead to Chiral Enhancement in Racemic Mixtures, Origins Life Evol. Biosphere 32, 285.
Shinitzky, M.: 2006, PCCP Hot Paper: Parity violation and the riddle of the origin of life interview with the author.
Schurig, V.: 1995, Determination of Enantiomeric Purity by Direct Methods in Houben-Weyl: Stereoselective Synthesis, Vol. E21a, 147–192
Scolnik, Y., Portnaya, I., Cogan, U., Tal, S., Haimovitz, R., Fridkin, M., Elitzur, A. C., Deamer, D. W., Shinitzky, M.: 2006, Subtle Differences in Structural Transitions Between Poly-L- and Poly-D-amino Acids of Equal Length in Water, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 8, 333.
Sullivan, R., Pyda, M. and Pak, J., Wunderlich, B., Thompson, J. R., Pagni, R., Barnes, C., Schwerdtfeger, P. and Compton, R.: 2003, Search for electroweak Interactions in Amino Acid Crystals. II. The Salam Hypothesis, J. Phys. Chem. A 107, 6674.
Szabo-Nagy, A., Keszthelyi, L.: 1999, Demonstration of the Parity-Violating Energy Difference Between Enantiomers, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 96, 4252.
Thiemann, W. and Wagener, K.: 1970, Demonstration of the Parity-Violating Energy Difference Between Enantiomers, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 9, 740.
Tranter, G. E.: 1985, The Parity Violating Energy Differences Between Enantiomers of α-Amino Acids, Mol Phys. 56, 825.
Tranter, G. E.: 1986, Preferential Stabilization of the D-Sugar Series by the Parity-Violating Weak Interactions, J. Chem Soc. Chem. Commun. 60.
Vaida, M., Shimon, LJW., Weisinger-Lewin, Y., Frolow, F., Lahav, M., Leiserowitz, L. and McMullan, R.: 1988, The Structure and Symmetry of Crystalline Solid-Solutions - A General Revision, Science 241, 1475.
Wagener, K.: 1974, Amplification Processes for Small Primary Differences in the Properties of Enantiomers, J. Mol. Evol. 4, 77.
Wald, G.: 1957, Amplification Might Occur Via Formation of α-Helical Secondary Structure of Proteins, Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 69, 352.
Wang, W., Min, W., Zhu, C. and Fang, Y.: 2003, Temperature Dependent Ultrasonic Study on Parityviolating Phase Transitions of D- and L-Alanine Single Crystals, PhysChemChemPhys 5, 4000.
Wang, W. Q., Yi, F., Ni, Y. M., Zhao, Z. X., Jin, X. and Tang, Y.: 2000, Parity Violations of Electroweak Force in Phase Transitions of Single Crystals of D- and L-Alanine and Valine, J. Biol. Phys. 26, 51.
Weinbach, S., Kjaer, K., Bouwman, W. G., Grubel, G., Legrand, J. F., Als-Nielsen, J., Lahav, M. and Leiserowitz, L.: 1994, Control of Structure and Growth of Polymorphic Crystalline Thin-Films of Amphiphilic Molecules on Liquid Surfaces, Science 264, 1566.
Weissbuch, I., Addadi, L., Berkovitch-Yellin, Z., Gati, E., Weinstein, S., Lahav, M., Leiserowitz, L.: 1983, Centrosymmetric Crystals for the Direct Assignment of the Absolute Configuration of Chiral Molecules. Application to the α-Amino Acids by Their Effect on Glycine Crystals, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 105. 6615.
Weissbuch, I., Zbaida, D., Addadi, L., Lahav, M., and Leiserowitz, L.: 1987, Design of Polymorphic Inhibitors for the Control of Crystal Polymorphism - Induced Enantiomeric Resolution of Racemic Histidine by Crystallization at 25-degrees-C, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 109, 1869.
Weissbuch, I., Addadi, L., Lahav, M. and Leiserowitz, L.: 1991, Molecular Recognition at Crystal Interfaces, Science 53, 637.
Weissbuch. I., Leiserowitz, L. and Lahav, M.: 1994, Tailor-made and Change-Transfer Auxiliaries for the Control of the Crystal Polymorphism of Glycine, Adv. Mater. 6, 952.
Wesendrup, R., Laerdahl, J. K., Compton, R. N. and Schwerdtfeger, P.: 2003 Biomolecular Homochirality and Electroweak Interactions. I. The Yamagata Hypothesis, J. Phys. Chem. A 107, 6668.
Yamagata, Y.: 1966, A Hypothesis for the Asymmetric Appearance of Biomolecules on Earth J. Theor. Biology 11, 495.
Zbaida, D., Lahav, M., Drauz, K., Knaup, G. and Kottenhahn, M.: 2000, A Cyclic Continuous Process for Converting Conglomerates into Optically Pure Enantiomers by Crystallization and Dissolution with the Assistance of ‘Tailor-Made’ Polymers, Tetrahedron 56, 6645.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding authors
Additional information
We maintain the term enantiomorphous crystals despite the fact that D- and L crystals differ by PVED
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lahav, M., Weissbuch, I., Shavit, E. et al. Parity Violating Energetic Difference and Enantiomorphous Crystalsp-Caveats; Reinvestigation of Tyrosine Crystallization. Orig Life Evol Biosph 36, 151–170 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11084-005-9000-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11084-005-9000-7