Abstract
After the devastating hurricane season of 2005, shortcomings with the Saffir–Simpson Hurricane Scale’s (SSHS) ability to characterize a tropical cyclone’s potential to generate storm surge became widely apparent. As a result, several alternative surge indices were proposed to replace the SSHS, including Powell and Reinhold’s integrated kinetic energy (IKE) factor, Kantha’s Hurricane Surge Index (HSI), and Irish and Resio’s Surge Scale (SS). Of the previous, the IKE factor is the only surge index to date that truly captures a tropical cyclone’s integrated intensity, size, and wind field distribution. However, since the IKE factor was proposed in 2007, an accurate assessment of this surge index has not been performed. This study provides the first quantitative evaluation of the IKEs ability to serve as a predictor of a tropical cyclone’s potential surge impacts as compared to other alternative surge indices. Using the tightly coupled Advanced Circulation and Simulating Waves Nearshore models, the surge and wave responses of Hurricane Ike in 2008 and 78 synthetic tropical cyclones were evaluated against the SSHS, IKE, HSI, and SS. Results along the northwestern Gulf of Mexico coastline demonstrate that the HSI performs best in capturing the peak surge response of a tropical cyclone, while the IKE accounting for winds greater than tropical storm intensity (IKETS) provides the most accurate estimate of a tropical cyclone’s regional surge impacts. These results demonstrate that the appropriate selection of a surge index ultimately depends on what information is of interest to be conveyed to the public and/or scientific community.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Berg R (2009) Tropical cylone report: hurricane ike 1–14 September 2008. National Hurricane Center, University Park
Booij N, Ris RC, Holthuijsen LH (1999) A third-generation wave model for coastal regions: 1. Model description and validation. J Geophys Res 104(C4):7649–7666. doi:10.1029/98JC02622
Cañizares R, Irish JL (2008) Simulation of storm-induced barrier island morphodynamics and flooding. Coast Eng 55:1089–1101
Cobell Z, Zhao H, Roberts HJ, Clark FR, Zou S (2013) Surge and wave modeling for the Louisiana 2012 coastal master plan. J Coast Res 67:88–108
Dietrich JC, Bunya S, Westerink JJ, Ebersole BA, Smith JM, Atkinson JH, Jensen R, Resio DT, Luettich RA, Dawson C, Cardone VJ, Cox AT, Powell MD, Westerink HJ, Roberts HJ (2010) A high-resolution coupled riverine flow, tide, wind, wind wave, and storm surge model for Southern Louisiana and Mississippi. Part II: synoptic description and analysis of hurricanes Katrina and Rita. Mon Weather Rev 138:378–404
Dietrich JC, Westerink JJ, Kennedy AB, Smith JM, Jensen RE, Zijlema M, Holthuijsen LH, Dawson C, Luettich RA, Powell MD, Cardone VJ, Cox AT, Stone GW, Pourtaheri H, Hope ME, Tanaka S, Westerink LG, Westerink HJ, Cobell Z (2011a) Hurricane Gustav (2008) waves and storm surge: hindcast, synoptic analysis, and validation in Southern Louisiana. Mon Weather Rev 139:2488–2522
Dietrich JC, Zijlema M, Westerink JJ, Holthuijsen LH, Dawson C, Luettich RA, Jensen RE, Smith JM, Stelling GS, Stone GW (2011b) Modeling hurricane waves and storm surge using integrally-coupled, scalable computations. Coast Eng 58(1):45–65
Dorst N (2014) What is the average forward speed of a hurricane?. In: Hurricane research division frequently asked questions. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/hrd/tcfaq/G16.html. Accessed 15 Dec 2015
Dresback KM, Fleming JG, Blanton BO, Kaiser C, Gourley JJ, Tromble EM, Luettich RA, Kolar RL, Hong Y, Van Cooten S, Vergara HJ, Flamig ZL, Lander HM, Kelleher KE, Nemunaitis-Monroe KL (2013) Skill assessment of a real-time forecast system utilizing a coupled hydrologic and coastal hydrodynamic model during hurricane irene (2011). Cont Shelf Res 71:78–94
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) (2011) Flood insurance study: coastal counties. Texas
Glahn B, Taylor A, Kurkowski N, Shaffer WA (2009) The role of the SLOSH model in National Weather Service storm surge forecasting. Natl Weather Dig 33(1):4–14
Grzegorzewski AS, Cialone MA, Wamsley TV (2011) Interaction of barrier islands and storms: implications for flood risk reduction in Louisiana and Mississippi. J Coast Res 59:156–164
Holland G (1980) An analytical model of the wind and pressure profiles in hurricanes. Mon Weather Rev 108(8):1212–1218
Hope ME, Westerink JJ, Kennedy AB, Kerr PC, Dietrich JC, Dawson C, Bender CJ, Smith JM, Jensen RE, Zijlema M, Holthuijsen LH, Luettich RA, Powell MD, Cardone VJ, Cox AT, Pourtaheri H, Roberts HJ, Atkinson JH, Tanaka S, Westerink HJ, Westerink LG (2013) Hindcast and validation of Hurricane Ike (2008) waves, forerunner, and storm surge. J Geophys Res Oceans 118:4424–4460
Irish JL, Resio DT (2010) A hydrodynamics-based surge scale for hurricanes. Ocean Eng 37:69–81
Irish JL, Resio DT, Ratcliff JJ (2008) The influence of storm size on hurricane surge. J Phys Oceanogr 38:2003–2013
Kantha L (2006) Time to replace the Saffir–Simpson Hurricane Scale? EOS Trans Am Geophys Union 87(1):3–6
Kantha L (2008) Comments: tropical cyclone destructive potential by integrated kinetic energy. Bull Am Meteorolog Soc 88(4):513–526
Kantha L (2010) Discussion of “A hydrodynamics-based surge scale for hurricanes.”. Ocean Eng 37:1081–1084
Kimberlain TB, Blake ES, Cangialosi JP (2016) Tropical cyclone report: hurricane patricia 20–24 October 2015. National Hurricane Center, University Park
Landsea CW, Franklin JL (2013) Atlantic hurricane database uncertainty and presentation of a new database format. Mon Weather Rev 141:3576–3592
Luettich RA, Westerink HJ (2004) Formulation and numerical implementation of the 2D/3D ADCIRC finite element model version 44. XX
Moyer AC, Evans JL, Powell M (2007) Comparison of observed gale radius statistics. Meteor Atmos Phys 97:41–55
National Geophysical Data Center (2015) ETOPO1 1-minute gridded bathymetric data. https://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/mgg/global/global.html. doi:10.7289/V5C8276M. Accessed 18 Feb 2016
National Weather Service (2007) The Saffir–Simpson Hurricane Scale. http://www.nhc.noaa.gov/aboutsshws.php. Accessed 25 Mar 2016
Powell MD (2012) Use cases for IKE from operational quantities. http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/hrd/ike/Calculator_AllQuad.php. Accessed 5 Aug 2015
Powell MD, Ginis I (2006) Drag coefficient distribution and wind speed dependence in tropical cyclones. In: Final report to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Joint Hurricane Testbed (JHT) Program
Powell MD, Reinhold TA (2007) Tropical cyclone destructive potential by Integrated Kinetic Energy. Bull Am Meteorolog Soc 88(4):513–526
Powell MD, Houston SH, Amat LR, Morisseau-Leroy N (1998) The HRD real-time hurricane wind analysis system. J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn 77–78:53–64
Powell MD, Vickery PJ, Reinhold TA (2003) Reduced drag coefficient for high wind speeds in tropical cyclones. Nature 422:279–283
Rappaport EN, Franklin JL, Avila LA, Baig SR, Beven JL, Blake ES, Burr CA, Jiing JG, Juckins CA, Knabb RD, Landsea CW, Mainelli M, Mayfield M, McAdie CJ, Pasch RJ, Sisko C, Stewart SR, Tribble AN (2009) Advances and challenges at the National Hurricane Center. Weather Forecast 24:395–419
Rego JL, Li C (2009) On the importance of the forward speed of hurricanes in storm surge forecasting: a numerical study. Geophys Res Lett 36(7). doi:10.1029/2008GL036953
Sebastian A, Proft J, Dietrich JC, Du W, Bedient PB, Dawson CN (2014) Characterizing hurricane storm surge behavior in galveston bay using the SWAN+ADCIRC model. Coast Eng 88:171–181
Simpson RH (1974) The hurricane disaster-potential scale. Weatherwise 27:169–186
Thompson EF, Cardone VJ (1996) Practical modeling of hurricane surface wind fields. J Waterw Port Coast Ocean Eng 122:195–205
Torres JM, Bass B, Irza N, Fang Z, Proft J, Dawson C, Kiani M, Bedient P (2015) Characterizing the hydraulic interactions of hurricane storm surge and rainfall-runoff for the Houston-Galveston region. Coast Eng 106:7–19
Wesiberg RH, Zheng L (2006) Hurricane storm surge simulations for Tampa Bay. Estuar Coasts 29:899–913
Westerink JJ, Luettich RA, Feyen JC, Atkinson JH, Dawson C, Roberts HJ, Powell MD, Dunion JP, Kubatko EJ, Pourtaheri H (2008) A basin- to channel-scale unstructured grid hurricane storm surge model applied to Southern Louisiana. Mon Weather Rev 136:833–864
Acknowledgments
This research was supported by the Houston Endowment under the Severe Storm Prediction, Education, and Evacuation from Disasters (SSPEED) Center. C. Dawson also acknowledges the support of National Science Foundation grant ACT-1339801, the Extreme Science and Engineering Discovery Environment (XSEDE) grant TG-DMS080016N, and the Texas Advanced Computing Center for the use of their computing resources. The authors would also like to thank Saffir and Simpson, Powell and Reinhold, Kantha, and Irish and Resio for their contributions toward developing a reliable surge index.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bass, B., Irza, J.N., Proft, J. et al. Fidelity of the integrated kinetic energy factor as an indicator of storm surge impacts. Nat Hazards 85, 575–595 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-016-2587-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-016-2587-3