Abstract
The evaluation of error or uncertainty in shoreline change studies is an issue of prime importance for providing an adequate framework for calculated rates of change and to allow the establishment of threshold values above which the rates would be significant. In this note, a practical, easy-to-use method is presented to estimate error involved in the calculation of shoreline changes on aerial photographs, including the three most used types of shoreline indicators: high water line, dune/cliff toe and cliff top. This approach takes into account the specific characteristics of each shoreline proxy, such as relief in the case of the cliff top or tidal oscillations in the case of the high water line. At the same time it includes the error components that are independent from the proxy, basically related to the technical aspects of the process such as photo scanning and georeferencing. A practical example of application of the method is provided for several types of data inputs, based on shoreline changes around the Bay of Cádiz (SW Spain).
References
Allan JC, Komar PD, Priest GR (2003) Shoreline variability on the high-energy Oregon coast and its usefulness in erosion-hazard assessments. J Coast Res SI 38:83–105
Anders FJ, Byrnes MR (1991) Accuracy of shoreline change rates as determined from maps and aerial photographs. Shore and Beach 59(1):17–25
Boak EH, Turner IL (2005) Shoreline definition and detection: a review. J Coast Res 21(4):688–703
Catalão J, Catita C, Miranda J, Dias JA (2002) Photogrammetric analysis of coastal erosion in the Algarve (Portugal). Geomorphologie 2:119–126
Cooper JAG, Anfuso G, Del Río L (2009) Bad beach management: European perspectives. Geol Soc Am S 460:167–179
Coyne MA, Fletcher CH, Richmond BM (1999) Mapping coastal erosion hazards in Hawaii: observations and errors. J Coastal Res SI 28:171–184
Crowell M, Leatherman SP, Buckley MK (1991) Historical shoreline change: error analysis and mapping accuracy. J Coast Res 7(3):839–852
Crowell M, Leatherman SP, Buckley MK (1993) Shoreline change rate analysis: long term versus short term data. Shore and Beach 61(2):13–20
Crowell M, Douglas BC, Leatherman S (1997) On forecasting future US shoreline positions: a test of algorithms. J Coast Res 13(4):1245–1255
Del Río L (2007) Riesgos de erosión costera en el litoral atlántico gaditano. PhD Dissertation, Universidad de Cádiz
Del Río L, Gracia FJ (2009) Erosion risk assessment of active coastal cliffs in temperate environments. Geomorphology 112:82–95
Del Río L, Gracia FJ, Benavente J (2012) Shoreline change patterns in sandy coasts: a case study in SW Spain. Geomorphology. doi:10.1016/j.geomorph.2012.07.027
Dolan R, Fenster MS, Holme SJ (1991) Temporal analysis of shoreline recession and accretion. J Coast Res 7(3):723–744
Fenster MS, Dolan R, Morton RA (2001) Coastal storms and shoreline change: signal or noise? J Coast Res 17(3):714–720
Ferreira O, García T, Matias A, Taborda R, Alveirinho Dias J (2006) An integrated method for the determination of set-back lines for coastal erosion hazards on sandy shores. Cont Shelf Res 26:1030–1044
Fletcher C, Rooney J, Barbee M, Lim S, Richmond BM (2003) Mapping shoreline change using digital ortophotogrammetry on Maui, Hawaii. J Coast Res SI 38:106–124
Garcia T, Ferreira O, Matias A, Alveirinho Dias J (2010) Overwash vulnerability assessment based on long-term washover evolution. Nat Hazards 54(2):225–244
Genz AS, Fletcher CH, Dunn RA, Frazer LN, Rooney J (2007) The predictive accuracy of shoreline change rate methods and alongshore beach variation on Maui, Hawaii. J Coast Res 23(1):87–105
Gorman L, Morang A, Larson R (1998) Monitoring the coastal environment. Part IV: mapping, shoreline changes, and bathymetric analysis. J Coast Res 14(1):61–92
Hapke CJ, Richmond BM (2000) Monitoring beach morphology changes using small-format aerial photography and digital softcopy photogrammetry. Environ Geosci 7(1):32–37
Honeycutt MG, Crowell M, Douglas BC (2001) Shoreline-position forecasting: impact of storms, rate-calculation methodologies, and temporal scales. J Coast Res 17(3):721–730
Hughes ML, McDowell PF, Marcus WA (2006) Accuracy assessment of georectified aerial photographs: implications for measuring lateral channel movement in a GIS. Geomorphology 74:1–16
Lehmbeck DR, Urbach JC (2004) Image quality for scanning. In: Marshall GF (ed) Handbook of optical and laser scanning. Taylor and Francis, New York, pp 154–300
Moore LJ (2000) Shoreline mapping techniques. J Coast Res 16(1):111–124
Moore LJ, Griggs GB (2002) Long-term cliff retreat and erosion hotspots along the central shores of the Monterey Bay National Marine Sanctuary. Mar Geol 181:265–283
Morton RA, Miller TA, Moore LJ (2004) National assessment of shoreline change: Part 1—Historical shoreline changes and associated coastal land loss along the US Gulf of Mexico. USGS OFR 2004-1043
Muñoz JJ, de San Román BL, Gutiérrez-Mas JM, Moreno L, Cuena GJ (2001) Cost of beach maintenance in the Gulf of Cádiz (SW Spain). Coast Eng 42:143–153
Pajak MJ, Leatherman SP (2002) The high water line as shoreline indicator. J Coast Res 18(2):329–337
Pierre G (2006) Processes and rate of retreat of the clay and sandstone sea cliffs of the northern Boulonnais (France). Geomorphology 73(1–2):64–77
Schwarzer K, Diesing M, Larson M, Niedermeyer R, Schumacher W, Furmanczyk K (2003) Coastline evolution at different time scales—examples from the Pomeranian Bight, southern Baltic Sea. Mar Geol 194:79–101
Shoshany M, Golik A, Degani A, Lavee H, Gvirtzman G (1996) New evidence for sand transport direction along the coastline of Israel. J Coast Res 12(1):311–325
Stathopoulou M, Cartalis C (2009) Downscaling AVHRR land surface temperatures for improved surface urban heat island intensity estimation. Remote Sens Environ 113(12):2592–2605
Thieler ER, Danforth WW (1994) Historical shoreline mapping (I): improving techniques and reducing positioning errors. J Coast Res 10(3):549–563
Thieler ER, Himmelstoss EA, Zichichi JL, Miller TL (2005) Digital Shoreline Analysis System (DSAS) version 3.0: An ArcGIS extension for calculating shoreline change. USGS Open-File Report 2005-1304
Vanderstraete T, Goosens R, Ghabour TK (2003) Remote sensing as a tool for bathymetric mapping of coral reefs in the Red Sea (Hurghada—Egypt). BELGEO 3:257–267
Weeks AR (1996) Fundamentals of electronic image processing. SPIE Optical Engineering Press, Bellingham
Wolf PR, Dewitt BA (2000) Elements of photogrammetry with applications in GIS. McGraw-Hill, Madison
Zviely D, Klein M (2004) Coastal cliff retreat rates at Beit-Yannay, Israel, in the 20th century. Earth Surf Proc Land 29:175–184
Acknowledgments
This work is a contribution to the research group RNM-328 of the Andalusian Research Plan (PAI).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Del Río, L., Gracia, F.J. Error determination in the photogrammetric assessment of shoreline changes. Nat Hazards 65, 2385–2397 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-012-0407-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-012-0407-y