The typology of head movement and ellipsis
Lipták and Saab (2014) argue that the availability of both XP-ellipsis and X-movement out of XP within a particular language implicates the availability of the X-stranding XP-ellipsis pattern in that language, as seen in the verbal domains of Hebrew and Irish for example. They further argue that this implication can be used to diagnose the absence of X-movement in a language (i.e. if it has XP-ellipsis but lacks the X-stranding pattern). In this reply, I show that this diagnostic is flawed: a language can have the relevant ingredients and yet lack the X-stranding pattern that the authors predict to be present, as in Mainland Scandinavian, which has verb-second but lacks verb-stranding VP-ellipsis. I argue that such exceptions are principled: the X-stranding pattern arises only if the operations responsible for these phenomena are timed such that the trigger for X-movement out of XP is merged earlier than, or at the same time as, the trigger for XP-ellipsis. I revise Lipták and Saab’s (2014) implicational statement accordingly.
KeywordsX-stranding XP-ellipsis Verb phrase ellipsis Verb-stranding Verb movement Verb second
Special thanks to Maziar Toosarvandani for contributions to early versions of this work. For helpful feedback, thanks also go to Jason Merchant, Gary Thoms, and Mark de Vries; to audiences at the LSA Annual Meeting 2015, Cambridge SyntaxLab 2016, the University of Konstanz, and Ulster University; and, to three anonymous reviewers.
- Chomsky, Noam. 2001. Derivation by phase. In Ken Hale: A life in language, ed. Michael Kenstowicz, 1–52. Cambridge: MIT Press. Google Scholar
- Chomsky, Noam. 2008. On phases. In Foundational issues in linguistic theory: Essays in honor of Jean-Roger Vergnaud, eds. Robert Freidin, Carlos Otero, and María Luisa Zubizarreta, 133–166. Cambridge: MIT Press. Google Scholar
- den Besten, Hans. 1977. On the interaction of root transformations and lexical deletive verbs. Ms., MIT and University of Amsterdam. Also published in den Besten 1989: 14–88. Google Scholar
- Doron, Edit. 1999. V-movement and VP ellipsis. In Fragments: Studies in ellipsis and gapping, eds. Shalom Lappin and Elabbas Benmamoun, 124–140. New York: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
- Goldberg, Lotus. 2005. Verb-stranding VP ellipsis: A cross-linguistic study. PhD diss., McGill University. Google Scholar
- Hankamer, Jorge, and Ivan Sag. 1976. Deep and surface anaphora. Linguistic Inquiry 7: 391–426. Google Scholar
- Houser, Michael, Line Mikkelsen, and Maziar Toosarvandani. 2008. Verb phrase pronominalization in Danish: Deep or surface anaphora? In Western Conference on Linguistics (WECOL) 34, eds. Erin Brainbridge and Brian Agbayani, 183–195. Google Scholar
- Johnson, Meredith. 2015. Ellipsis is derivational: Evidence from Hoca̧k VPE. In Proceedings of the 49th Annual Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society. Google Scholar
- Koopman, Hilda, and Anna Szabolcsi. 2000. Verbal complexes. Vol. 34 of Current studies in linguistics. Cambridge: MIT Press. Google Scholar
- Lechner, Winfried. 2007. Interpretive effects of head movement, Ms., Universität Stuttgart. Available at http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/000178. Accessed 9 November 2017.
- Lobeck, Anne. 1995. Ellipsis: Functional heads, licensing, and identification. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
- Merchant, Jason. 2001. The syntax of silence: Sluicing, islands, and the theory of ellipsis. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
- Merchant, Jason. 2016. Ellipsis: A survey of analytical approaches. For The Oxford handbook of ellipsis, eds. Jeroen van Craenenbroeck and Tanja Temmerman. Ms., University of Chicago. Google Scholar
- Ørsnes, Bjarne. 2011. Non-finite do-support in Danish. In Empirical issues in syntax and semantics 8, eds. Olivier Bonami and Patricia Cabredo Hofherr, 409–434. Available at http://www.cssp.cnrs.fr/eiss8. Accessed 9 November 2017.
- Pollock, Jean-Yves. 1989. Verb movement, Universal Grammar, and the structure of IP. Linguistic Inquiry 20: 365–424. Google Scholar
- Rouveret, Alain. 2005. Welsh VP-ellipsis and the representation of aspect. In Organizing grammar: Linguistic studies in honor of Henk van Riemsdijk, eds. Hans Broekhuis, Norbert Corver, Riny Huybregts, Ursula Kleinhenz, and Jan Koster. Vol. 86 of Studies in generative grammar, 554–562. Berlin: de Gruyter. Google Scholar
- Sailor, Craig. 2009. Tagged for deletion: A typological approach to VP ellipsis in tag questions. Master’s thesis, UCLA. Google Scholar
- Sailor, Craig. 2013. Tag questions and the typology of VP ellipsis. Ms., UCLA. Google Scholar
- Sailor, Craig. 2014. The variables of VP ellipsis. PhD diss., UCLA. Google Scholar
- Schoorlemmer, Erik, and Tanja Temmerman. 2012. Head movement as a PF-phenomenon: Evidence from identity under ellipsis. In West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics (WCCFL) 29, eds. Jaehoon Choi, E. Alan Hogue, Jeffrey Punske, Deniz Tat, Jessamyn Schertz, and Alex Trueman, 232–240. Somerville: Cascadilla Proceedings Project. Google Scholar
- Ström Herold, Jenny. 2009. Proformen und Ellipsen: Zur Syntax und Diskurspragmatik prädikativer Anaphern im Deutschen und im Schwedischen. PhD diss., Lund University. Google Scholar
- Thoms, Gary. 2012. Verb movement and ellipsis in Scandinavian. Ms., University of Edinburgh. Google Scholar
- Travis, Lisa. 1984. Parameters and effects of word order variation. PhD diss., MIT. Google Scholar
- van Craenenbroeck, Jeroen. 2010. The syntax of ellipsis: Evidence from Dutch dialects. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar
- van Craenenbroeck, Jeroen, and Anikó Lipták. 2008. On the interaction between verb movement and ellipsis: New evidence from Hungarian. In West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics (WCCFL) 26, eds. Charles B. Yang and Hanna J. Haynie, 138–146. Somerville: Cascadilla Proceedings Project. Google Scholar
- Vikner, Sten. 1995. Verb movement and expletive subjects in the Germanic languages. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar