Abstract
Robustness, imperceptibility and embedding capacity are the preliminary requirements of any watermarking technique. However, research concluded that these requirements are difficult to achieve at same time. In this paper, we review various recent robust and imperceptible watermarking methods in spatial and transform domain. Further, the paper introduces elementary concepts of digital watermarking, characteristics and novel applications of watermark in detail. Furthermore, various analysis and comparison of different notable watermarking techniques are discussed in tabular format. We believe that our survey contribution will helpful for fledgling researchers to develop robust and imperceptible watermarking algorithms for various practical applications.
References
Ali M, Ahn CW (2018) An optimal image watermarking approach through cuckoo search algorithm in wavelet domain. Int J Syst Assur Eng Manag 9(3):602–611
Al-Nabhani Y, Lalab HA, Wahid A, Noor RM (2015) Robust Watermarking Algorithm for Digital Images using Discrete Wavelet and Probabilistic Neural Network. Journal of King Saud University -Computer, and Information Sciences 27(4):393–401
Andalibi M, Chandler DM (2015) Digital Image Watermarking via Adaptive Logo Texturization. IEEE Trans Image Process 24(12):5060–5073
Aslantas V (2008) A Singular-value Decomposition –based Image Watermarking using Genetic Algorithm. Int J Electron Commun 62(5):386–394
Bas P, Chassery JM, Macq B (2002) Geometrically invariant watermarking using feature points. IEEE Trans Image Process 11(6):1014–1028
Bhatnagar G, Wu QMJ, Raman B (2012) A new robust adjustable logo watermarking scheme. Computers and Security 31(1):40–58
Bouslimi D, Coatrieux G, Roux C (2011) A Joint Watermarking/Encryption Algorithm for Verifying Medical Image Integrity and Authenticity in Both Encrypted and Spatial domains. International Conference of the IEEE EMBS:8066–8069
Celik MU, Lemma AN, Katzenbeisser S, Veen MV (2007) Secure Embedding of Spread Spectrum Watermarks Using Look-Up-Tables. IEEE-ICASSP 2:II-153–II-156
Chang CC, Chen TS, Chung LZ (2002) A Steganographic method Based upon JPEG and quantization table modification. Inf Sci 141(1-2):123–138
Chang CC, Tsai P, Lin CC (2005) SVD- based digital image watermarking scheme. Pattern Recogn Lett 26(10):1577–1586
Chauhan DS, Singh AK, Adarsh A, Kumar B, Saini JP (2017) Combining Mexican hat wavelet and spread spectrum for adaptive watermarking and its statistical detection using medical images. Multimedia Tool and Applications, pp.1-15
Chen TS, Lee WB, Chen J, Kao YH, Hou PW (2013) Reversible privacy preserving data mining: a combination of difference expansion and privacy preserving. J Supercomput 66(2):907–917
Coatrieux G, Guillou CL, Cauwin JM (2009) Reversible Watermarking for Knowledge Digest Embedding and Reliability control in Medical Images. IEEE Trans Inf Technol Biomed 13(2):158–165
Cox IJ, Kilian J, Leighton T, Shamoon TG (1997) Secure spread spectrum watermarking for multimedia. IEEE Trans Image Process 6(12):1673–1687
Delaigle JF, Vleeschouwer CD, Macq B (1998) Watermarking Algorithm Based on a Human Visual Model. Signal Processing (Elsevier) 66(3):319–335
Deng C, Gao X, Li X, Tao D (2010) Local histogram based geometric invariant image watermarking. Signal Process 90(12):3256–3264
Dharwadkar NV, Kulkarni GK, Melligeri TY, Amberker BB (2012) The image watermarking scheme using edge information in YCbCr color space. International Proceedings of Computer Science and Information Technology 56
Dhole VS, Patil NN (2015) Self embedding fragile watermarking for image tampering detection and image recovery using self recovery blocks. In: Computing Communication Control and Automation, International Conference on IEEE (ICCUBEA), pp. 752-757
Dittmann J, Ferri LC, Vielhauer C (2001) Hologram watermarks for document authentications. IEEE International Conference on Information Technology: Coding and Computing: 60-64
Duy TP, Tran D, Ma W (2017) An intelligent learning- based watermarking scheme for outsourced biomedical time series data. IEEE- IJCNN, pp. 4408-4415
El’arbi M, Amar CB (2014) Image authentication algorithm with recovery capabilities based on neural networks in the DCT domain. IET Image Process 8(11):619–626
Fan MQ, Wang HX, Li SK (2008) Restudy on SVD-based watermarking scheme. Appl Math Comput 203(2):926–930
Fazli S, Moeini M (2016) A robust image watermarking method based on DWT, DCT and SVD using a new technique for correction of main geometric attacks. Optik 127(2):964–972
Feng LP, Zheng LB, Cao P (2010) A DWT-DCT based blind watermarking algorithm for copyright protection. In: Computer Science and Information Technology (ICCSIT), 3rd International Conference on IEEE, vol.7, pp. 455-458
Fist E, Qi X (2007) A composite approach for blind grayscale logo watermarking. Proc IEEE International Conference on Image Processing 3:III–265
Fung BCM, Wang K, Yu PS (2007) Anonymizing classification data for privacy preservation. IEEE Trans Knowl Data Eng 19(5):711–725
Ganic E, Eskicioglu AM (2004) Robust DWT-SVD domain image watermarking: embedding data in all frequencies. In: Proceedings of the 2004 Workshop on Multimedia and Security, ACM, vol. 166-174
Ganic E, Eskicioglu AM (2005) Robust embedding of visual watermarks using discrete wavelet transform and singular value decomposition. Journal of electronic imaging 14(4):043004
Gao X, Deng C, Li X (2010) Geometric Distortion Insensitive Image Watermarking in Affine Covariant regions. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, And Cybernetics 40(3):278–286
Ghafoor A, Imran M (2012) A non-blind color image watermarking scheme resistent against geometric attacks. Radioengineering 21(4):1246–1251
Gunjal BL (2011) Wavelet based color image watermarking scheme giving high robustness and exact correlation. International Journal of Emerging Trends in Engineering and Technology 1(1):21–30
Gupta AK, Raval MS (2012) A robust and secure watermarking scheme based on singular values replacement. Sadhana 37(4):425–440
Hall M, Frank E, Holmes G, Pfahringer B, Reutemann P, Witten IH (2009) The WEKA data mining software: an update. ACM SIGKDD Explorations Newsletter 11(1):10–18
Harish NJ, Kumar BBS, Kusagur A (2013) Hybrid robust watermarking techniques based on DWT, DCT and SVD. International Journal of Advanced Electrical and Electronics Engineering 2(5):137–143
Hel-Or HZ (2001) Watermarking and copyright labelling of printed images. Journal of Electronic Imaging 10(3):794–803
Hong W, Chen TS, Shiu CW (2009) Reversible Data Hiding for High-Quality Images using Modification of Prediction Errors. The Journal of Systems and Software 82(11):1833–1842
Iftikhar S, Kamran M, Anwar Z (2015) RRW- A Robust and Reversible Watermarking Technique for Relational Data. IEEE Trans Knowl Data Eng 27(4):1132–1145
Iftikhar S, Kamran M, Munir EU, Khan SU (2017) A Reversible Watermarking Technique for Social Network Data Sets for Enabling Data Trust in Cyber, Physical and Social Computing. IEEE Syst J 11(1):197–206
Jero SE, Ramu P, Ramakrishnan S (2014) Discrete Wavelet Transform and Singular Value Decomposition Based ECG Steganography for Secured Patient Information Transmission. J Med Syst 38(10):1–11
Jero E, Ramu P, Swaminathan R (2016) Imperceptibility-Robustness tradeoff studies for ECG steganography using Continuous Ant Colony Optimization. Expert Syst Appl 49:123–135
Jin C, Tao F, Fu Y (2006) Image watermarking based HVS characteristic of wavelet transform. Intelligent Information Hiding and Multimedia Signal Processing, pp. 71-74
Kamran M, Farooq M (2012) An information-preserving watermarking scheme for right protection of EMR systems. IEEE Trans Knowl Data Eng 24(11):1950–1962
Kamran M, Farooq M (2013) A Formal Usability Constraints Model for Watermarking of Outsourced Datasets. IEEE Transactions on Information Forensic and Security 8(6):1061–1072
Kamstra LHJ, Heijmans AM (2005) Reversible data embedding into images using wavelet techniques and sorting. IEEE Trans Image Process 14(12):2082–2090
Kapoor P, Sharma KK, Bedi SS, Kumar A (2011) Colored Image Watermarking Technique based on HVS using HSV color model. In: Proceedings of International Conference on Advances in Computer Engineering, pp. 20-24
Khan MI, Rahman M, Sarker M, Hasan I (2013) Digital watermarking for image authentication based on combined DCT, DWT and SVD transformation. Int J Comput Sci Math 10(5):223–230
Kirovski D, Malvar HS (2003) Spread Spectrum Watermarking for Audio Signals. IEEE Trans Signal Process 51(4):1020–1033
Koch E, Zhao J (1995) Towards robust and hidden image copyright labelling. IEEE Workshop on Nonlinear Signal and Image Processing Marmaras Greece 1174:452–455
Kulkarni AS, Lokhande SS (2013) Imperceptible and Robust Digital Image Watermarking Techniques in Frequency Domain. International Journal of Computer Technology and Electronics Engineering (IJCTEE) 3:33–36
Kumar C, Singh AK, Kumar P (2017) A Recent Survey on Image Watermarking Techniques and Its Applications in e-governance. Multimed Tools Appl 77(3):3597–3622
Kumar C, Singh AK, Kumar P (2018) Improved wavelet-based image watermarking through SPIHT. Multimedia Tools and Applications 1-14
Kundur D, Hatzinakos D (1998) Digital watermarking using multiresolution wavelet decomposition. ICASSP 5:2969–2972
Kutter M, Jordan F, Bossen F (1997) Digital Signature of color images using amplitude modulation. Storage and retrieval for Image and Video Databases 2952:518–526
Lai CC, Tsai CC (2010) Digital image watermarking using discrete wavelet transform and singular value decomposition. IEEE Trans Instrum Meas 59(11):3060–3063
Langelaar GC, Lagendijk RL, Biemond J (1997) Robust labelling methods for copy protection of images. Storage and retrieval for Image and Video Databases 3022:289–309
Lee SH, Kim TS, Kim BJ, Kwon SG, Kwon KR, Lee K (2003) 3D Polygon Meshes Watermarking Using Normal Vector Distributions. IEEE-ICME 3:III–105
Lee S, Yoo CD, Kalker T (2007) Reversible image watermarking based on integer-to-integer wavelet transform. IEEE Transaction on Information Forensics Security 2(3):321–330
Li CT, Yang FM (2003) One-Dimensional Neighbourhood Forming Strategy for Fragile Watermarking. Journal of Electronic Imaging 12(2):284–292
Li J, Yu C, Gupta BB, Ren X (2018) Color image watermarking scheme based on quaternion Hadamard transform and Schur decomposition. Multimed Tools Appl 77(4):4545–4561
Lin CY (2006) A Reversible Data Transform Algorithm Using Integer Transform for Privacy Preserving Data Mining. The Journal of Systems & Software 117(7):104–112
Lin SD, Shie S, Guo JY (2010) Improving the robustness of DCT- based image watermarking against JPEG compression. Computer Standards and Interfaces 32(1-2):54–60
Liu Y, Ju L, Hu M, Ma X, Zhao H (2015) A robust Reversible Data Hiding Scheme For H.264 without Distortion Drift. Neurocomputing (Elsevier) 151(3):1053–1062
Liu Y, Li Z, Ma X (2012) Reversible data hiding scheme based on H.264/AVC without distortion drift. JSW 7(5):1059–1065
Liu R, Tan T (2002) An SVD-based watermarking scheme for protecting right ownership. IEEE Transactions on Multimedia 4(1):121–128
Loukhaoukha K, Nabti M, Zebbiche K (2014) A Robust SVD- based Image Watermarking Using a Multi-Objective Particle Swarm Optimization. Opto-Electronics Review 22(1):45–54
Malakooti M, Majlesi J (2012) Digital image watermarking based on the multiple discrete wavelets transform and singular value decomposition. Multimedia Process 1(4)
Mathon B, Cayre F, Bas P (2014) Optimal Transport for Secure Spread – Spectrum Watermarking for Still Images. IEEE Trans Image Process 23(4):1694–1705
Meerwald P (2001) Digital watermarking in the wavelet transform domain. Master’s Thesis, Department of Scientific Computing, University of Salzburg
Mehta R, Rajpal N (2016) LWT-QR Decomposition based Robust and Efficient Image Watermarking scheme using Lagrangian SVR. Multimedia Tools and Applications (Springer) 75(7):4129–4150
Mohammad AA, Alhaj A, Shaltaf S (2008) An improved SVD- based watermarking scheme for protecting rightful ownership. Signal Process 88(9):2158–2180
Mohanty SP, Sengupta A, Guturu P, Kougianos E (2017) Everything you want to know about watermarking: From Paper marks to hardware protection. IEEE Consumer Electronics Magazine 6(3):83–91
Naderahmadian Y, Hosseini-Khayat S (2010) Fast watermarking based on QR decomposition in wavelet domain. In: Intelligent Information Hiding and Multimedia Signal Processing (IIH-MSP), pp. 127-130
Najih A, Al-Haddad SAR, Ramli AR, Hashim SJ, Nematollahi MA (2017) Digital Image watermarking based on Angle Quantization in Discrete Contourlet Transform. Journal of King Saud University-Computer and Information Sciences 29(3):288–294
Neviere XR, Doerr G, Alliez P (2014) Spread transform and roughness-based shaping to improve 3D watermarking based on quadratic programming. IEEE- ICIP, 4777-4781
Nguyen TV, Patra JC (2008) A Simple ICA-based Digital Image Watermarking Scheme. Digital Image Processing 18:762–776
Ni Z, Shi YQ, Ansari N, Su W (2006) Reversible Data Hiding. IEEE Transactions on circuits and systems for video technology 16(3):354–362
Noore A, Tungala N, Houck MM (2004) Embedding Biometric identifiers in 2D barcodes for improved security. Computers & Security (Elsevier) 23(8):679–686
Parah SA, Sheikh JA, Ahad F, Loan NA, Bhat GM (2017) Information hiding in medical images:a robust medical image watermarking system for E-healthcare. Multimed Tools Appl 76(8):10599–10633
Patel SB, Mehta TB, Pradhan SN (2011) A Unified Technique for Robust Digital Watermarking of Colour Images using Data Mining and DCT. International Journal Internet Technology and Secured Transactions 3(1):81–96
Patra B, Patra JC (2012) CRT-based fragile self-recovery watermarking scheme for image authentication and recovery. In: IEEE International Symposium on Intelligent Signal Processing and Communications Systems (ISPACS), pp. 430-435
Pei SC, Guo JM (2003) Hybrid Pixel-Based Data Hiding and Block-Based Watermarking for Error-Diffused Halftone Images. IEEE transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology 13(8):867–884
Peng H, Wang J, Wang W (2010) Image watermarking method in multiwavelet domain based on support vector machines. J Syst Softw 83(8):1470–1477
Pham TD, Tran D, Ma W (2015) A proposed blind DWT-SVD watermarking scheme for EEG data. In: International Conference on Neural Information Processing, pp. 69-76
Preda RO (2014) Self-recovery of unauthentic images using a new digital watermarking approach in the wavelet domain. In: Communications 10th International conference on IEEE, pp. 1-4
Qiang YZ, Ip HHS, Kowk LF (2003) Robust watermarking of 3D polygonal models based on vertice scrambling. Proceedings of Computer Graphics International IEEE, pp. 254-257
Reddy VP, Varadarajan S (2010) An effective wavelet-based watermarking scheme using human visual system for protecting copyrights of digital images. International Journal of Computer and Electrical Engineering 2(1):32–40
Rosiyadi D, Horng SJ, Fan P, Wang X (2012) Copyright protection for e-government document images. IEEE Multimedia 19(3):62–73
Sachnev V, Kim HJ, Nam J, Suresh S, Shi YQ (2009) Reversible Watermarking Algorithm Using Sorting and Prediction. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology 19(7):989–999
Said A, Pearlman AW (1996) A new, fast and efficient image codec based on set partitioning in hierarchical trees. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology 6(3):243–250
Santhi V, Thangavelu A (2011) DC coefficients based watermarking technique for color images using singular value decomposition. International Journal of Computer and Electrical Engineering 3(1):8–16
Senapati RK, Patil UC, Mahapatra KK (2014) Reduced memory, low complexity embedded image compression algorithm using hierarchical listless discrete Tchebichef transform. IET Image Process 8(4):213–238
Seo JS, Yoo CD (2004) Localized image watermarking based on feature points of scale-space representation. Pattern Recogn 37(7):1365–1375
Shehab A, Elhoseny M, Muhammad K, Sangaiah AK, Yang P, Huang H, Hou G (2018) Secure and Robust fragile watermarking scheme for medical images. IEEE-Access 6:10269–10278
Shen JJ, Hsu PW (2008) A Fragile Associative Watermarking on 2D Barcode for Data Authentication. International Journal of Network Security 7(3):301–309
Shen JJ, Ren JM (2010) A robust associative watermarking technique- based on vector quantization. Digital Signal Processing, pp. 1408-1423
Sherekar S, Thakare VM, Jain S (2011) Attacks and Countermeasures on Digital Watermarks: Classification, Implications, Benchmarks. Int J Comput Sci Appl 4(2):32–45
Shi H, Lv F, Cao Y (2014) A Blind Watermarking technique for color image based on SVD with circulation. Journal of software 9(7):1749–1756
Shivani JLD, Senapati RK (2017) Robust Image Embedded Watermarking using DCT and Listless SPIHT. Future Intermet 9(3):33
Singh AK (2017) Improved Hybrid Algorithm for Robust and Imperceptible Multiple Watermarking using Digital Images. Multimedia Tools Applications (Springer) 76(6):8881–8900
Singh AK, Dave M, Mohan A (2014) Wavelet-Based Image Watermarking: futuristic concepts in Information Security. Proceedings of National Academy emerging of Sciences India Section A: Physical Sciences 84(3):345–359
Singh AK, Dave M, Mohan A (2014) Hybrid Technique for Robust and Imperceptible image watermarking in DWT-DCT-SVD domain. National Academy Science Letters 37(4):351–358
A.K. Singh, M. Dave and, A. Mohan, " Multilevel Encrypted Text Watermarking on Medical Images Using Spread-Spectrum in DWT Domain," Wireless Personal Communication (Springer), vol. 83, issue 3, pp. 2133-2150, 2015
Singh AK, Dave M, Mohan A (2016) Hybrid Technique for robust and imperceptible multiple watermarking using medical images. Journal of Multimedia Tools and Applications (Springer) 75(14):8381–8401
Singh AK, Kumar B, Dave M, Mohan A (2015) Multiple watermarking on medical images using selective discrete wavelet transform coefficients. Journal of Medical Imaging and Health Informatics 5(3):607–614
Singh AK, Kumar B, Singh SK, Ghrera SP, Mohan A (2016) Multiple Watermarking Technique for Securing Online Social Network Contents using Back Propagation Neural Network. Future Generation Computer Systems (Elsevier) 86:926–939
Singh AK, Kumar B, Singh G, Mohan A (2017) Medical image watermarking: techniques and applications. Book series on Multimedia Systems and Applications, Springer, ISBN: 978-3319576985
Singh D, Singh SK (2017) DWT-SVD and DCT based Robust and Blind Watermarking Scheme for Copyright Protection. Multimed Tools Appl 76(11):13001–13024
Singh A, Tayal A (2012) Choice of wavelet from wavelet families for DWT-DCT-SVD image watermarking. Int J Comput Appl 48(17):9–14
Song W, Hou JJ, Li ZH, Huang L (2011) Chaotic system and QR factorization based robust digital image watermarking algorithm. J Cent S Univ Technol 18(1):116–124
Srivastava A, Saxena P (2013) DWT-DCT-SVD based semiblind image watermarking using middle frequency bands. IOSR Journal of Computer Engineering 12(2):63–66
Su Q, Niu Y, Wang Q, Sheng G (2013) A blind color image watermarking based on DC component in the spatial domain. Optik 124(23):6255–6260
Tang CW, Hang HM (2003) A feature- based robust digital image watermarking scheme. IEEE Trans Signal Process 51(4):950–959
Thakkar FN, Srivastava VK (2017) A blind medical image watermarking: DWT-SVD based robust and secure approach for telemedicine applications. Multimed Tools Appl 76(3):3669–3697
Thakur S, Singh AK, Ghrera SP, Mohan A (2018) Chaotic based secure watermarking approach for medical images. Multimed Tools Appl:1–14. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11042-018-6691-0
Thodi DM, Rodriguez JJ (2004) Reversible watermarking by prediction-error expansion. IEEE Southwest Symposium on Image Analysis and Interpretation: 21-25
Thodi DM, Rodriguez JJ (2007) Expansion embedding techniques for reversible watermarking. IEEE Trans Image Process 16(3):721–730
Tian J (2003) Reversible data embedding using a difference expansion. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology 13(8):890–896
Tsai JS, Huang WB, Kuo YH, Horng MF (2012) Joint Robustness and Security Enhancement for Feature-based Image Watermarking Using Invariant feature regions. Signal Processing (Elsevier) 92(6):1431–1445
Tsai HH, Jhuang YJ, Lai YS (2012) An SVD-based Image Watermarking in Wavelet Domain using SVR and PSO. Applied Soft Computing (Elsevier) 12(8):2442–2453
Vacavant A (2016) A novel definition of robustness for image processing algorithms. In: International Workshop on Reproducible Research in Pattern Recognition (pp. 75-87). Springer, Cham
Vallabha VH (2003) Multiresolution watermark based on wavelet transform for digital images. Cranes Software International Limited, Bangalore
Van DWD, Nachtegael M, Kerre EE (2003) A new similarity measure for image processing. Journal of Computational Methods in Sciences and Engineering 3(2):209–222
Voloshynovskiy S, Pereira S, Pun T, Eggers JJ, Su JK (2001) Attacks on digital watermarks: classification, estimation-based attacks, and benchmarks. IEEE Communication Magazine 39(8):118–126
Wang Z, Bovik AC (2002) A universal image quality index. IEEE Signal Processing Letters 9(3):81–84
Wang Z, Bovik AC, Sheikh HR, Simoncelli EP (2004) Image quality assessment: from error visibility to structural similarity. IEEE Trans Image Process 13(4):600–612
Wang HJ, Su PC, Kuo CCJ (1998) Wavelet based digital image watermarking. Opt Express 3(12):491–496
Wang X, Wu J, Niu P (2007) A new digital image watermarking algorithm resilient to desynchronization attacks. IEEE Transaction on Information Forensics Security 2(4):633–655
Wu HC, Chang CC (2005) A novel digital image watermarking scheme based on the vector quantization technique. Computers and Security 24(6):460–471
Wu X, Guan ZH (2007) A novel digital watermark algorithm based on chaotic maps. Phys Lett A 365(5-6):403–406
Xia Z, Wang X, Zhang L, Qin Z, Sun X, Ren K (2016) A privacy preserving and copy deterrence content-based image retrieval scheme in cloud computing. IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security 11(11):2594–2608
Xing Y, Tan J (2010) A color image watermarking scheme resistent against Geometrical Attacks. Radioengineering 19(1):62–67
Xiong X (2015) A new robust color image watermarking scheme based on 3D-DCT. World Journal of Engineering and Technology 3(03):177–183
Xuan G, Shi YQ, Chai P, Cui X, Ni Z, Tong X (2007) Optimum histogram pair based image lossless data embedding. International Workshop on Digital Watermarking: 264-278
Zear A, Singh AK, Kumar P (2018) A proposed secure multiple watermarking technique based on DWT, DCT and SVD for application in medicine. Multimed Tools Appl 77(4):4863–4882
Zhao M, Dang Y (2008) Color image copyright protection digital watermarking algorithm based on DWT and DCT. In: Wireless Communications, Networking and Mobile Computing 4th international conference on IEEE, pp. 1-4
Zheng Z, Saxena N, Mishra KK, Sangaiah AK (2018) Guided Dynamic Particle Swarm Optimization for Optimizing Digital Image Watermarking in Industry Applications. Futur Gener Comput Syst 88:92–106
Zhou X, Zhang H, Wang C (2018) A Robust Image Watermarking Technique Based on DWT, APDCBT, and SVD. Symmetry MDPI 10(3):1–15
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Agarwal, N., Singh, A.K. & Singh, P.K. Survey of robust and imperceptible watermarking. Multimed Tools Appl 78, 8603–8633 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11042-018-7128-5
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11042-018-7128-5