Abstract
Respect for personal autonomy in decision-making is one of the four ethical principles in medical circumstances. This paper aims to present evidence that can be considered good exemplars in the clarification of the ethical viewpoints of the western and Shi’i Islamic perspectives on this issue. The method followed was originally a search in international indexing services in April 2016. Our findings point towards various controversies on individuals’ autonomy lead to different decision making outcomes by health workers in both different traditions. We concluded that although Shi’i Islamic jurisprudence does not seem to allow for personal autonomy in the sense it is understood in a western context, evidence indicates that Shi’i Islamic jurisprudence respects personal autonomy.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aksoy, S., and A. Elmali. 2002. The core concepts of the ‘four principles’ of bioethics as found in Islamic tradition. Medicine and Law 21: 211–224.
Aksoy, S., A. Tenik. 2002: BMC Medical Ethics 3: 4. Available at: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472/6939/3/4.
American Medical Association. 1847. Code of ethics.
American Medical Association. 1990. Council on ethical and judicial affairs (CEJA). Chicago: Current Opinions.
Anderson, R. M., and M. M. Funnell. 2005. Patient empowerment: Reflections on the challenge of fostering the adoption of a new paradigm. Patient education and counseling 57(2): 153–157.
Beauchamp, T.L., and J.F. Childress. 1994. Principles of biomedical ethics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Barth-Roger, Y., and A. Jotkowitz. 2009. Executive autonomy, multiculturalism and traditional medical ethics. American Journal Of Bioethics 9(2): 39–40.
Chattopadhyay, S., and R. De Varis. 2013. Respect for cultural diversity in bioethics is an ethical imperative. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy, England 16(4): 639–645.
Chin, J.J. 2002. Doctor patient relationship: From medical paternalism to enhanced autonomy. Singapore Medical Journal 43(3): 152–155.
da Rocha, A.C. 2009. Toward a comprehensive concept of patient autonomy. American Journal Of Bioethics (AJOB) 9(2): 37–38.
De Marco, J.P., and D.O. Stewart. 2009. Expanding autonomy: Contracting informed consent. American Journal Of Bioethics (AJOB) 9(2): 35–36.
Etchells, E., G. Sharp, and P.A. Singer. 1996a. Bioethics for clinicians: 3: Capacity. Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) 155(6): 657–661.
Etchells, E., G. Sharpe, P. Walsh, J.R. Williams, and P.A. Singer. 1996b. Bioethics for clinicians: 1. Informed consent. Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) 155(2): 177–180.
Etchells, E., G. Sharpe, M.S. Dykeman, E.M. Meslin, and P.A. Singer. 1996c. Bioethics for clinicians: 4. Voluntariness. Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) 155(8): 1083–1086.
Hedayat, K.M. 2007. The possibility of a universal declaration of biomedical ethics. Journal of Medical Ethics 33(1): 17–20.
Jonas, M. 2010. Obesity, autonomy and the harm principle. Journal of Primary Care 2(4): 343–346.
Mustafa, Y. 2014. Islam and the four principles of medical ethics. Journal of Medical Ethics 40(7): 479–483.
Packer, S. 2011. Informed consent with a focus on Islamic views. The Journal of IMA 43(3): 215.
Pollard, B. J. (1992). Autonomy and paternalism in medicine. The Medical journal of Australia 159(11–12): 797–802.
Quill, T.E., and H. Brody. 1996. Physician recommendations and patient autonomy: Finding a balance between physician recommendations and patient autonomy. Annals of Internal Medicine 125: 763–769. The American College for Physicians, USA.
Ryan, C.J. 2010. Ethical issues, part 2: Ethics, psychiatry and end of life issues. Psychiatry Times 27(6): 26–27.
Russell, B. 2009. Patient autonomy writ large. American Journal Of Bioethics (AJOB) 9(2): 32–34.
Tsai, D.F. 2008. Virtual mentor. Medicine and Society, USA 10(3): 171–176.
Wehr, H., and J.M. Cowan. 1979. A dictionary of modern written. La Guayra: Otto Harrassowitz Verlag.
Westra, A.E., D.L. Willems, and B.J. Smit. 2009. Communicating with muslim parents: “The four principles” are not as culturally neutral as suggested. European Journal of Pediatrics 168(11): 1383–1387.
References (Persian/Arabic)
Al Bahr ul-Uloom, Seyyed Muhammad, 1403 AH, Bulghat ul Fighhyiah (vol 4, Commentary and Appendices by Muhammad Baqi Al-e Bahr ul-Uloom, Maktabat us-Sadeq Publications, Tehran.
Armstrong David 1378 AH (solar), Jame’ehshenassi ye Pezeshki (Medical Sociology), tr. Muhammad Tavakkol, Sina Cultural and Legal Institute, Tehran.
Hussayni Maraghi, Mir Abd ul-Fattah, 1417 AH, Al ʽAnaaween al-Fighhiyah, 1st impression, Nashr ul-Islami Institute, Qum.
Ibn Manzoor, Muhammad Ibn Mukram, 1408 AH, Lisan ul-Arab, Dar ul-Ihya at-Tarath Publications, Beirut.
Islamic Penal Code, 1393 AH (solar), Kelksavar Publication, Tehran.
Javadi Amoli, Abdullah, 1391 AH (solar), Mafatih ul-Hayah, 51st impression, Isra’ Publications, Qum.
Kulayni, Muhammad ibn Ya’qub, 1407 AH, Al Kafi, vol 2, Fourth Impression, Daftar Entesharat Islami, Qum.
Mostafavi, Seyyed Muhammad Kazem, 1421 AH, Ma’ah Qa’idatu Fiqhhiyyah, vol 1, Fourth Impression, Daftar Entesharat Islami, Qum.
Mousavi Bojnourdi, Muhammad, 1387 AH (solar), Qava’id Fiqhiyyah, vol 1, Fourth Impression, Majd Publications, Tehran.
Muhammadi Reyshahri, Muhammad, 1386 AH (solar), Mizan ul-Hikmah, vol 7, Dar ul-Hadith Publications, Qum.
Shahid al-Thani, Zayn ud-Din ibn Al Jab’yy Al A’amili, Al-Rowdatun al-Bahiyatun fi al-Sharhi al-Lowmat-i al-Damishqiyyah (ed. Seyyed Muhammad Kalantar, Jama’atu Al-Najaf Al-Diniyya, Bita Publications, Najaf.
Shojaee, Amir Ahmad, 1389 AH (solar): ‘Fasting and Patient Autonomy’, Journal of Medical Ethics and History, 2nd year, 3rd cycle, no 3: 74-75.
The Holy Quran.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Naji, Z., Zamani, Z., Koutlaki, S.A. et al. Personal autonomy in health settings and Shi’i Islamic Jurisprudence: a literature review. Med Health Care and Philos 20, 435–441 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-016-9738-x
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-016-9738-x