Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy

, Volume 7, Issue 3, pp 269–279

From human ability to ethical principle: An intercultural perspective on autonomy

Scientific Contribution

Abstract

Based on an empirical study regarding ethical challenges within intercultural health care, the focus of this article is upon autonomy and disclosure, discussed in light of philosophy and anthropology. What are the consequences for patients if the patients’ right to be autonomous and to participate in treatment and care decisions by health care workers is interpreted as an obligation to participate? To force a person to make independent choices who is socio-culturally unprepared to do so, may violate his/her integrity. This may in turn jeopardise the respect, integrity and human worth the principle of autonomy was meant to ensure, and if so, may damage any relationship of trust that may exist between patient and health care worker. There is necessarily a link between autonomy and disclosure. Western disclosure practices may make the relationship between patients and health care workers difficult -- even distrustful. To confront a patient with a very serious diagnosis may be seen not only as a tactless action, but also an unforgivable one. Hence, among many ethnic groups it is a family member’s duty to shield patients from bad or disquieting news, e.g., a cancer diagnosis. If a family member is used to interpret in such situations, will the information given equal the information communicated by that interpreter? Even though respect for a person’s autonomy is part of the respect for a person, one’s respect for the person in question should not depend on his/her ability or aptitude to act autonomously.

Keywords

autonomy culture disclosure individualism versus collectivism respect 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Beachamp, T.L., Childress, J.F. 2001Principles of Biomedical EthicsOxford University PressOxfordGoogle Scholar
  2. Berger, J.: 1999, ‘Culture and Ethnicity in Clinical Care’, in: Archives of Internal Medicine, Ovid FullText, 24 March pp. 1–14.Google Scholar
  3. Bhanumathi, P.P. 1983‘Nurses’ Conception of ‘Sick Role’ and ‘Good Patient’ Behaviour: A Cross-Cultural Comparison’International Nursing Review242024Google Scholar
  4. Childress, J. 1989

    ‘Autonomy’

    Veatch, RM eds. Cross Cultural Perspectives in Medical Ethics: ReadingsJones and Bartlett PublishersBoston233240
    Google Scholar
  5. Fox, R., DeMarco, J.P. 1986

    ‘The Challenge of Applied Ethics’

    DeMarco, JPFox, RM eds. New Directions in EthicsRoutlegdeNew York
    Google Scholar
  6. Greipp, M.E. 1995‘Culture and Ethics: A Tool for Analysing the Effects of Biases on the Nurse–Patient Relationship’Nursing Ethics2211221PubMedGoogle Scholar
  7. Hansen, K.M. 2000‘Gud kjenner ikke til normale mennesker–et teologisk foredrag’Diakoninytt1171014Google Scholar
  8. Hanssen, I. 2002Facing Differentness An Empirical Inquiry into Ethical Challenges in Intercultural Nursing [Doctoral Dissertation]The Institute of Nursing, University of OsloOsloGoogle Scholar
  9. Hofstede, G. 1983‘National Cultures Revisited’Behavior Science Research18285305Google Scholar
  10. Holm, S.: 2000, Developing a European Biomedical Ethics–Can American Biomedical Ethics be Transferred Without Modification? Offprint. Copenhagen/Manchester.Google Scholar
  11. Hylland Eriksen, T. 1993Små steder–store spørsmålUniversitetsforlagetOsloGoogle Scholar
  12. Johnstone, MJ 1999Bioethics–a nursing perspective3Harchourt Saunders Australia Pty Ltd.SidneyGoogle Scholar
  13. Kant, I 1958The Moral Law. Analysis and notes by H.J. PatenLondonHutchinson(reprinted 1948 version)Google Scholar
  14. Kelly, B 1990

    ‘Respect and Caring: Ethics and Essence of Nursing’

    Leininger, MM eds. Ethical and Moral Dimensions of CareWayne State University PressDetroit6779
    Google Scholar
  15. Keyserlingk, E. 1990

    ‘Ethical Guidelines and Codes–Can They be Universally Applicable in a Multi-Cultural World?’

    Allebeck, PJansson, B eds. Ethics in MedicineRaven PressNew York137149
    Google Scholar
  16. Leininger, M.M. 1990

    ‘Culture the Conspicuous Missing Link to Understand Ethical and Moral Dimensions of Human Care’

    Leininger, MM eds. Ethical and Moral Dimensions of CareWayne State University PressDetroit4966
    Google Scholar
  17. Lewis, R.D. 2000When Cultures CollideNicholas Brealey PublishingLondonGoogle Scholar
  18. Lov av 2. juli 1999 nr. 63 om pasientrettigheter [The Pasients’ Rights Act]. Oslo: Cappelen Akademisk Forlag/Lovdata.Google Scholar
  19. Løgstrup, K.E. 1997The Ethical DemandUniversity of Notre Dame PressNotre DameGoogle Scholar
  20. Markus, H.R., Kitayama, S. 1991‘Culture and Self: Implications for Cognition, Emotion, and Motivation’Psychological Review98224253CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Meleis, A.I., Jonsen, A.R. 1983‘Ethical Crises and Cultural Difference’Western Journal of Medicine138889893PubMedGoogle Scholar
  22. Orona, C., Koenig, B.A., Davis, A.J. 1994‘Cultural Aspects of Nondisclosure’Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics3338346PubMedGoogle Scholar
  23. Pellegrino, E.D. 1990

    ‘The Relationship of Autonomy and Integrity in Medical Ethics’

    Allebeck, PJansson, B eds. Ethics in MedicineRaven PressNew York321
    Google Scholar
  24. Pellegrino, ED 1992a‘Is Truth Telling to the Patient a Cultural Artefact?’JAMA26817341735CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Pellegrino, E.D. 1992b

    ‘Prologue: Intersections of Western Biomedical Ethics and World Culture’

    Pellegrino, EMazzarella, PCorsi, P eds. Transcultural Dimensions in Medical EthicsUniversity Publishing GroupFrederick Maryland
    Google Scholar
  26. Pellegrino, E.D. 1992c‘Intersections of Western Biomedical Ethics and World Culture: Problematic and Possibility’Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics3191196Google Scholar
  27. Rasinski-Gregory, D.C., Miller, R.B., Kutner, F.R. 1989‘Improving Hospital Ethics Committees: Cross Cultural Concerns and Their Procedural Implications’H.E.C.Forum1137150CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Ray, M.A. 1994‘Transcultural Nursing Ethics. A framework and Model for Transcultural Ethical Analysis’Journal of Holistic Nursing12251264PubMedGoogle Scholar
  29. Sachs, L 1990

    ‘Integrity and Autonomy from an Anthropological Point of View’

    Allebeck, PJansson, B eds. Ethics in MedicineRaven PressNew York3351
    Google Scholar
  30. Schwartz, R.L. 1994‘Multiculturalism, Medicine, and the Limits of Autonomy: The Practice of Female Circumcision’Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics3431441PubMedGoogle Scholar
  31. Spence, J.T. 1985‘Achievement American Style. The Rewards and Costs of Individualism’American Psychologist4012851295CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Surbone, A. 1992‘Truth Telling to the Patient’JAMA26816611662CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
  33. Thiederman, S.B. 1986‘Ethnocentrism: A Barrier to Effective Health Care’Nurse Practitioner,115356Google Scholar
  34. Veatch, R.M.: 1981, ‘Nursing Ethics, Physician Ethics, and Medical Ethics’, Law, Medicine and Health Care, 17–19.Veatch, R.M.: 1981, ‘Nursing Ethics, Physician Ethics, and Medical Ethics’, Law, Medicine and Health Care, 17–19.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2004

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Lovisenberg Deaconal University CollegeOsloNorway

Personalised recommendations