Abstract
Social, political, and economic environments play an active role in nurturing professional virtue. Yet, these environments can also lead to the erosion of virtue. As such, professional virtue is fragile and vulnerable to environmental shifts. While physicians are often considered to be among the most virtuous of professional groups, concern has also always existed about the impact of commercial arrangements on physicians’ willingness and capacity to enact their professional virtues. This article examines the ways in which commercial arrangements have been negotiated to secure medical virtue from real or perceived threats of erosion. In particular, we focus on the concern surrounding conflicts of interest arising from commercial arrangements that have developed as a result of neoliberal economic and social policies. The deregulation of medical markets and privatization of services have produced new commercial relationships that are often misunderstood by patients, publics, and physicians themselves. ‘Conflicts of interest’ policies have been introduced in an attempt to safeguard ethical conduct and medical practice. However, a number of virtue ethicists have critiqued these policies as inadequate for securing virtue. We examine the ways in which commercial arrangements have been seen to impact upon medical virtue, both historically and in the context of modern medicine (using the example of fertility services in Australia). We then describe and critique current efforts to restore clinical virtue through both conflict of interest policies and through virtue ethics. Finally, we suggest some possible ways of addressing the corrosive effects of neoliberalism on medical virtue.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
IVF Australia and Melbourne IVF (branches of Virtus IVF) were approached by the authors, but refused to supply their conflicts of interest policies for clinicians.
Virtus IVF is an example of the latter, taking their very name from the Roman conception of virtue—an interesting choice for an IVF company considering that virtus had a strong emphasis on manliness in the public domain and was rarely used to describe women.
References
Oakley, Justin, and Dean Cocking. 2001. Virtue ethics and professional roles. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Kenny, Nuala, and Wayne Shelton. 2006. Lost virtue: Professional character development in medical education. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Pellegrino, Edmund D, and David C. Thomasma. 1993. The virtues in medical practice. New York: Oxford University Press.
Miles, Steven H. 2005. The Hippocratic Oath and the ethics of medicine. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kotzee, Ben, and Agnieszka Ignatowicz. 2015. Measuring ‘virtue’in medicine. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy. doi:10.1007/s11019-015-9653-6.
DuBois, James M., Elena M. Kraus, Anthony A. Mikulec, Salvador Cruz-Flores, and Erin Bakanas. 2013. A humble task: Restoring virtue in an age of conflicted interests. Academic Medicine 88(7): 924–928.
Sandel, Michael J. 2012. What money can’t buy: The moral limits of markets. Straus and Giroux: Farrar.
Rodwin, Marc. 1993. Medicine, money, and morals: Physicians’ conflicts of interest. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mahar, Maggie. 2006. Money driven medicine: The real reason health care costs so much. New York: Collins.
Jain, Anita, Samiran Nundy, and Kamran Abbasi. 2014. Corruption: Medicine’s dirty open secret. BMJ 348: g4184.
Brody, Howard. 2007. Hooked: Ethics, the medical profession, and the pharmaceutical industry. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
Plato, 1997. Republic. In Plato complete works, ed. John M. Cooper and D.S. Hutchinson. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company.
MacIntyre, Alasdair. 1975. How virtues become vices: values, medicine and social context. In Evaluation and explanation in the biomedical sciences, ed. H. Tristram Engelhardt, Jr. and Stuart F. Spicker, 97–111. Berlin: Springer.
Horstmanshoff, H.F.J. 1990. The ancient physician: Craftsman or scientist? Journal of the History of Medicine 45: 176–197.
Kudlien, Fridolf. 1976. Medicine as a ‘liberal art’ and the question of the physician’s income. Journal of the History of Medicine XXXI(4): 448–459.
Arendt, Hannah. 1998. The human condition, 2nd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Temkin, Owsei. 1979. Medical ethics and honoraria in late antiquity. In Health and history: Essays for George Rosen, ed. Charles E. Rosenberg, 6–26. New York, NY: Science History Publications.
Brain, Peter. 1977. Galen on the ideal of the physician. South African Medical Journal 52(6): 936–938.
Pollock, Allyson. 2005. NHS plc: The privatisation of our health service. London: Verso.
Terris, Milton. 1999. The neoliberal triad of anti-health reforms: Government budget cutting, deregulation, and privatization. Journal of Public Health Policy 20(2): 149–167.
Beeson, Mark, and Ann Firth. 1998. Neoliberalism as a political rationality: Australian public policy since the 1980s. Journal of Sociology 34(3): 215–231.
Pusey, Michael. 2010. 25 years of neo-liberalism in Australia. In Goodbye to all that? On the failure of neoliberalism and the urgency of change, ed. David McKnight and Robert Manne, 125–146. Melbourne: Black Inc.
van Loendersloot, L.L., M. van Wely, J. Limpens, P.M.M. Bossuyt, S. Repping, and F. van der Veen. 2010. Predictive factors in in vitro fertilization (IVF): A systematic review and meta-analysis. Human Reproduction Update 16(6): 577–589.
Chambers, Georgina M., Peter J. Illingworht, and Elizabeth A. Sullivan. 2011. Assisted reproductive technology: Public funding and the voluntary shift to single embryo transfer in Australia. Medical Journal of Australia 195(10): 594–598.
Australian Government Department of Health. 2015. Assisted reproductive technology (ART) services. MBS online. http://www9.health.gov.au/mbs/search.cfm?q=13200&sopt=S. Accessed April 9, 2015.
Fertility Society of Australia. 2015. Patient information. http://www.fertilitysociety.com.au/patients-information/. Accessed Sept 28, 2015.
Featherstone, Tony. 2014. In-vitro fertilisation is a big trend—Stocks to benefit. The Bull. https://www.thebull.com.au/premium/a/46975-in-vitro-fertilisation-is-a-big-trend—stocks-to-benefit.html. Accessed Nov 6, 2014.
Baker, Jordan. 2014. IVF baby business is booming since since Monash University created the world’s first ‘test tube’ baby in 1973. The Daily Telegraph, August 10. http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/nsw/ivf-baby-business-is-booming-since-since-monash-university-created-the-worlds-first-test-tube-baby-in-1973/news-story/3722f8f66900f3563113094d60274a86. Accessed June 18, 2015.
Hansen, Jane. 2015. St Clair couple crowd funding to raise money for IVF to make a baby. The Daily Telegraph, March 8. http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/nsw/st-clair-couple-crowd-funding-to-raise-money-for-ivf-to-make-a-baby/story-fni0cx12-1227252864323. Accessed June 18, 2015.
Medew, Julia, and Mark Baker. 2013. Making babies. The Sydney Monring Herald, October 19. http://www.smh.com.au/national/health/making-babies-20131018-2vhbk.html. Accessed Aug 18, 2015.
Aubusson, Kate. 2015. Baby-booming: The business of IVF. Australian Doctor, January 21. http://www.australiandoctor.com.au/news/news-review/baby-booming-the-business-of-ivf. Accessed Aug 12, 2015.
Gardner, Jessica. 2014. Inside the booming baby business. Fianacial Review, September 6. http://www.afr.com/business/health/inside-the-booming-baby-business-20140905-jeqti. Accessed Aug 12, 2015.
Medew, Julia, and Mark Baker. 2015. IVF costs soar as infertility business booms. The Sydney Morning Herald, October 18. http://www.smh.com.au/national/ivf-costs-soar-as-infertility-business-booms-20131018-2vryx.html. Accessed Aug 12, 2015.
Barnes, Terry. 2014. Big money riding on the hopes and dreams of the unwilling childless. The Age, July 1. http://www.theage.com.au/comment/big-money-riding-on-the-hopes-and-dreams-of-the-unwilling-childless-20140630-zsr1m.html. Accessed Aug 10, 2015.
Monash IVF Group. 2015. Corporate governance. http://ir.monashivfgroup.com.au/Investor-Centre/?page=Corporate-Governance. Accessed April 22, 2015.
Monash IVF Group. 2015. Homepage. http://www.monashivfgroup.com.au/. Accessed April 22, 2015.
Virtus Group. 2015. Fertility reproductive health care. http://virtushealth.com.au/virtus-health-network/fertility-reproductive-health-care. Accessed April 21, 2015.
Leatherdale, Verity. 2014. Gift transforms university’s approach to fertility research and treatment. http://sydney.edu.au/news/84.html?newsstoryid=13714. Accessed July 2, 2015.
Westmead Fertility Centre. 2015. Welcome. https://www.westmeadivf.com.au/welcome. Accessed April 22, 2015.
Westmead Fertility Centre. 2015. FAQs. https://www.westmeadivf.com.au/faqs/. Accessed April 22, 2015.
Stossel, Thomas P. 2007. Regulation of financial conflicts of interest in medical practice and medical research: A damaging solution in search of a problem. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 50(1): 54–71.
Barton, David, Thomas Stossel, and Lance Stell. 2014. After 20 years, industry critics bury skeptics, despite empirical vacuum. International Journal of Clinical Practice 68(6): 666–673.
Rosenbaum, Lisa. 2015. Beyond moral outrage—Weighing the trade-offs of COI regulation. New England Journal of Medicine 372(21): 2064–2068.
Steinbrook, Robert, Jerome P. Kassirer, and Marcia Angell. 2015. Justifying conflicts of interest in medical journals: A very bad idea. British Medical Journal 350: h2942.
Godlee, Fiona. 2015. Conflict of interest: Forward not backward. British Medical Journal 350: h3176.
Oakley, Justin. 2014. A virtue ethics analysis of disclosure requirements and financial incentives as responses to conflicts of interest in physician prescribing. In The future of bioethics: International dialogues, ed. Akira Akabayashi, 669–677. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Campbell, Alastair V. 2014. Dealing with conflicts of interest: Is virtue ethics tough enough? In The future of bioethics: International dialogues, ed. Akira Akabayashi, 678–682. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Manea, Teodora. 2015. Medical bribery and the ethics of trust: The Romanian case. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 40(1): 26–43.
Perlis, Clifford, and Noah Shannon. 2012. Role of professional organizations in setting and enforcing ethical norms. Clinics in Dermatology 30(2): 156–159.
McCullough, Laurence B. 2015. Medicine as a profession: A hyopthetical imperative in clinical ethics. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 40(1): 1–7.
American Medical Student Association. 2014. About the AMSA Scorecard. http://amsascorecard.wpengine.com/about/. Accessed Sept 23, 2015.
Komesaroff, Paul, Ian Kerridge, David Isaacs, and Peter Brooks. 2015. The scourge of managerialism and the Royal Australasian College of physicians. Medical Journal of Australia 202(10): 519–521.
Komesaroff, Paul, and Ian Kerridge. 2011. It is time to move beyond a culture of unexamined assumptions, recrimination, and blame to one of systematic analysis and ethical dialogue. The American Journal of Bioethics 11(1): 31–33.
Mayes, Christopher. 2012. On the importance of the institution and social self in a sociology of conflicts of interest. Journal of Bioethical Inquiry 9(2): 217–218.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mayes, C., Blakely, B., Kerridge, I. et al. On the fragility of medical virtue in a neoliberal context: the case of commercial conflicts of interest in reproductive medicine. Theor Med Bioeth 37, 97–111 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-016-9353-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-016-9353-0