Abstract
The sol–gel coating method is considered to be simple and easy to implement to lead to organic/inorganic hybrid coatings. In addition, the application of thin films by this technique is inexpensive and applicable on large substrates without form restriction. In this context, thin sol–gel coatings based on a mixture of three alkoxysilanes and synthesized in purely aqueous phase with different thicknesses and with the presence or not of ZrO2 nanoparticles, were applied on metallic and glass substrates. After application and curing, the mechanical properties of sol–gel coatings were characterized by Berkovich nanoindentation with continuous stiffness measurement mode (CSM). The effective elastic moduli as well as the hardness values were estimated for each coating along the indentation depth and as a function of the substrate material and sol–gel characteristics. The effect of a annealing at higher temperature was also studied. Then, the failure modes of sol–gel coatings were investigated using both Berkovich nanoindentation and nanoscratch technique with a 5 µm radius spherical diamond tip. Careful microscopic observations of residual imprints and residual grooves both exhibit chipping in case of thick coating especially on glass substrate and no dramatic failure for thin coating applied on both substrates. It is shown in this work that the mechanical properties of the sol–gel and the mechanical stability of coatings on substrates are influenced dramatically by the presence of nanoparticles and the thermal treatment. Finally, interfacial fracture toughness of sol–gel coatings on substrate was estimated using analytical model from the literature and Ashby map based on experimental results was created using performance indices in order to proceed to sol–gel coating selection.
Highlights
-
Mechanical characterization of sol–gel coatings using a combination of different nanomechanical experiments.
-
Effects of nanoparticles addition and thermal treatment on mechanical coating stability.
-
Construction of Ashby map using experimental results for sol–gel coating selection.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aparicio M et al. (2016) Corrosion Protection of AISI 304 Stainless Steel with Melting Gel Coatings. Electrochim Acta 202(Supplement C):325–332
Ćurković L, Ćurković HO, Salopek S, Renjo MM, Šegota S (2013) Enhancement of corrosion protection of AISI 304 stainless steel by nanostructured sol–gel TiO2 films. Corros Sci 77:176–184
Feng Z, Liu Y, Thompson GE, Skeldon P (2010) Sol–gel coatings for corrosion protection of 1050 aluminium alloy. Electrochim Acta 55(10):3518–3527
Vignesh RB, Edison TNJI, Sethuraman MG (2014) ‘Sol–Gel coating with 3-Mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane as precursor for corrosion protection of aluminium metal. J Mater Sci Technol 30(8):814–820
Nezamdoust S, Seifzadeh D (2017) Application of CeH–V/ sol–gel composite coating for corrosion protection of AM60B magnesium alloy. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China 27(2):352–362
Martini C, Ceschini L (2011) A comparative study of the tribological behaviour of PVD coatings on the Ti-6Al-4V alloy. Tribol Int 44(3):297–308
Damasceno JC, Camargo SS, Cremona M (2002) Deposition and evaluation of DLC–Si protective coatings for polycarbonate materials. Thin Solid Films 420–421:195–199
Dave BC, Hu X, Devaraj Y, Dhali SK (2004) Sol–gel-derived corrosion-protection coatings. J Sol–Gel Sci Technol 32(1–3):143–147
Wang D, Bierwagen GordonP (2009) Sol–gel coatings on metals for corrosion protection. Prog Org Coat 64(4):327–338
Zheng S, Li J (2010) Inorganic–organic sol gel hybrid coatings for corrosion protection of metals. J Sol–Gel Sci Technol 54(2):174–187
Fabes BD, Uhlmann DR (1990) Strengthening of glass by sol-gel coatings. J Am Ceram Soc 73(no. 4):978–988
Guglielmi M (1997) Sol-Gel Coatings on Metals. J Sol–Gel Sci Technol 8(1–3):443–449
Mammeri F, Le Bouhris E, Rozes L, Sanchez C (2005) Mechanical properties of hybrid organic–inorganic materials. J Mater Chem 15(35–36):3787–3811
S Zhang (2010) Nanostructured thin films and coatings: mechanical properties. CRC Press, USA
Levy D, Zayat M (2015) The sol–gel handbook: synthesis, characterization and applications, 3–volume set. Wiley VCH, Weinheim
Tlili B, Barkaoui A, Walock M (2016) Tribology and wear resistance of the stainless steel. The sol–gel coating impact on the friction and damage. Tribol Int 102:348–354
F-X Perrin, ‘Films inorganiques et hybrides protecteurs obtenus par voie sol-gel’, Techniques de l’ingénieur Traitements de surface des métaux en milieu aqueux. vol. base documentaire: TIB359DUO, no. ref. article: m1722, 2007.
Osborne JH et al. (2001) Testing and evaluation of nonchromated coating systems for aerospace applications. Prog Org Coat 41(4):217–225
Yang Y-Q, Liu L, Hu J-M, Zhang J-Q, Cao C-N (2012) Improved barrier performance of metal alkoxide-modified methyltrimethoxysilane films. Thin Solid Films 520(6):2052–2059
Rauter A, Slemenik Perše L, Orel B, Bengű B, Sunetci O, Šurca Vuk A (2013) Ex situ IR and Raman spectroscopy as a tool for studying the anticorrosion processes in (3-glycidoxypropyl)trimethoxysilane-based sol–gel coatings. J Electroanal Chem 703:97–107
Kunst SR et al. (2014) Corrosion resistance of siloxane–poly(methyl methacrylate) hybrid films modified with acetic acid on tin plate substrates: Influence of tetraethoxysilane addition. Appl Surf Sci 298:1–11
Dias SAS, Lamaka SV, Nogueira CA, Diamantino TC, Ferreira MGS (2012) Sol–gel coatings modified with zeolite fillers for active corrosion protection of AA2024. Corros Sci 62:153–162
Lamaka SV et al. (2008) Novel hybrid sol–gel coatings for corrosion protection of AZ31B magnesium alloy. Electrochim Acta 53(14):4773–4783
Garcia RBR, da Silva FS, Kawachi EY (2013) New sol–gel route for SiO2/ZrO2 film preparation. Colloids Surf A Physicochem Eng Asp 436:484–488
Capelossi VR, Poelman M, Recloux I, Hernandez RPB, de Melo HG, Olivier MG (2014) Corrosion protection of clad 2024 aluminum alloy anodized in tartaric-sulfuric acid bath and protected with hybrid sol–gel coating. Electrochim Acta 124:69–79
Roussi E, Tsetsekou A, Skarmoutsou A, Charitidis CA, Karantonis A (2013) Anticorrosion and nanomechanical performance of hybrid organo-silicate coatings integrating corrosion inhibitors. Surf Coat Technol 232:131–141
Fedel M, Olivier M, Poelman M, Deflorian F, Rossi S, Druart M-E (2009) Corrosion protection properties of silane pre-treated powder coated galvanized steel. Prog Org Coat 66(2):118–128
Nicolay A et al. (2015) Elaboration and characterization of a multifunctional silane/ZnO hybrid nanocomposite coating. Appl Surf Sci 327:379–388
Sabzi M, Mirabedini SM, Zohuriaan-Mehr J, Atai M (2009) Surface modification of TiO2 nano-particles with silane coupling agent and investigation of its effect on the properties of polyurethane composite coating. Prog Org Coat 65(2):222–228
Peng B, Huang Y, Chai L, Li G, Cheng M, Zhang X (2007) Influence of polymer dispersants on dispersion stability of nano-TiO2 aqueous suspension and its application in inner wall latex paint. J Cent South Univ Technol 14(4):490–495
Luo K, Zhou S, Wu L (2009) High refractive index and good mechanical property UV-cured hybrid films containing zirconia nanoparticles. Thin Solid Films 517(21):5974–5980
Piwoński I, Soliwoda K (2010) The effect of ceramic nanoparticles on tribological properties of alumina sol–gel thin coatings. Ceram Int 36(1):47–54
Banerjee DA, Kessman AJ, Cairns DR, Sierros KA (2014) Tribology of silica nanoparticle-reinforced, hydrophobic sol–gel composite coatings. Surf Coat Technol 260:214–219
Song J, Liu Y, Liao Z, Wang S, Tyagi R, Liu W (2016) Wear studies on ZrO2-filled PEEK as coating bearing materials for artificial cervical discs of Ti6Al4V. Mater Sci Eng C 69:985–994
Atanacio AJ, Latella BA, Barbé CJ, Swain MV (2005) Mechanical properties and adhesion characteristics of hybrid sol–gel thin films. Surf Coat Technol 192(2–3):354–364
Fabes BD, Oliver WC (1990) Mechanical properties of sol-gel coatings. J Non-Cryst Solids 121(1):348–356
Chan CM, Cao GZ, Fong H, Sarikaya M, Robinson T, Nelson L (2000) Nanoindentation and adhesion of sol-gel-derived hard coatings on polyester. J Mater Res 15(01):148–154
Latella BA, Gan BK, Barbé CJ, Cassidy DJ (2008) Nanoindentation hardness, Young’s modulus, and creep behavior of organic–inorganic silica-based sol-gel thin films on copper. J Mater Res 23(09):2357–2365
J Hay (2009) Mechanical characterization of sol–gel coatings using a nano indenter G200. Application Notes from Agilent Technologies. https://www.agilent.com/
Piombini H, Ambard C, Compoint F, Valle K, Belleville PSanchez C (2015) Indentation hardness and scratch tests for thin layers manufactured by sol–gel process. In: CLEO: Applications and Technology
Ballarre J, Jimenez-Pique E, Anglada M, Pellice SA, Cavalieri AL (2009) Mechanical characterization of nano-reinforced silica based sol–gel hybrid coatings on AISI 316L stainless steel using nanoindentation techniques. Surf Coat Technol 203(20–21):3325–3331
Malzbender J, de With G, den Toonder JMJ (2000) Determination of the elastic modulus and hardness of sol–gel coatings on glass: influence of indenter geometry. Thin Solid Films 372(1–2):134–143
BA Latella, MV Swain, M Ignat (2012) Indentation and fracture of hybrid sol-gel silica films. In: J Nemecek (ed.) Nanoindentation in materials science, IntechOpen, London (UK)
Latella BA, Ignat M (2012) Interface fracture surface energy of sol–gel bonded silicon wafers by three-point bending. J Mater Sci Mater Electron 23(1):8–13
Den Toonder JD, Malzbender J, With GD, Balkenende R (2002) Fracture toughness and adhesion energy of sol–gel coatings on glass. J Mater Res 17(01):224–233
BA Latella, M Ignat, CJ Barbé, DJ Cassidy, H Li (2004) Cracking and decohesion of sol–gel hybrid coatings on metallic substrates. J Sol–Gel Sci Technol 31(1–3):143–149
Malzbender J, Den Toonder JMJ, Balkenende AR, De With G (2002) Measuring mechanical properties of coatings: a methodology applied to nano-particle-filled sol–gel coatings on glass Mater Sci Eng R Rep 36(2):47–103
Chen L, Yeap KB, She CM, Liu GR (2011) A computational and experimental investigation of three-dimensional micro-wedge indentation-induced interfacial delamination in a soft-film-on-hard-substrate system. Eng Struct 33(12):3269–3278
Mercier D, Mandrillon V, Parry G, Verdier M, Estevez R, Bréchet Y, Maindron T (2017) Investigation of the fracture of very thin amorphous alumina film during spherical nanoindentation. Thin Solid Films 638:34–47. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tsf.2017.07.040
Thouless MD (1998) An analysis of spalling in the microscratch test. Eng Fract Mech 61(1):75–81
Malzbender J, de With G (2002) A model to determine the interfacial fracture toughness for chipped coatings. Surf Coat Technol 154(1):21–26
Xie Y, Hawthorne HM (2003) Measuring the adhesion of sol–gel derived coatings to a ductile substrate by an indentation-based method. Surf Coat Technol 172(1):42–50
Bull SJ, Berasetegui EG (2006) An overview of the potential of quantitative coating adhesion measurement by scratch testing. Tribol Int 39(2):99–114
Granta Design Ltd. (2019) CES Selector version 2019, Cambridge (UK). https://grantadesign.com
MF Ashby (2011) Materials selection in mechanical design, 4th edn. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford (UK)
Oliver WC, Pharr GM (1992) An improved technique for determining hardness and elastic modulus using load and displacement sensing indentation experiments. J Mater Res 7(06):1564–1583
Oliver WC, Pharr GM (2004) Measurement of hardness and elastic modulus by instrumented indentation: advances in understanding and refinements to methodology. J Mater Res 19(1):3–20
King RB (1987) Elastic analysis of some punch problems for a layered medium. Int J Solids Struct 23(12):1657–1664
Makishima A, Mackenzie JD (1975) Calculation of bulk modulus, shear modulus and Poisson’s ratio of glass. J Non-Cryst Solids 17(2):147–157
Ledbetter HM (1981) Stainless‐steel elastic constants at low temperatures. J Appl Phys 52(3):1587–1589
Fischer-Cripps AC (2011) Nanoindentation, 3rd edn. Springer-Verlag, New York (USA)
Mercier D et al. (2010) Mesure de module d’Young d’un film mince à partir de mesures expérimentales de nanoindentation réalisées sur des systèmes multicouches, Matériaux & Techniques 99. https://doi.org/10.1051/mattech/2011029
Mercier D (2016) NIMS version 3.2. https://github.com/DavidMercier/NIMS, https://doi.org/10.13140/RG.2.2.13901.03045
Lawn BR, Evans AG (1977) A model for crack initiation in elastic/plastic indentation fields. J Mater Sci 12:2195–2199
Malzbender J, de With G (2001) The use of the indentation loading curve to detect fracture of coatings. Surf Coat Technol 137(1):72–76
Li X, Bhushan B (1998) Measurement of fracture toughness of ultra-thin amorphous carbon films. Thin Solid Films 315(1):214–221
Attar F, Johannesson T (1996) Adhesion evaluation of thin ceramic coatings on tool steel using the scratch testing technique. Surf Coat Technol 78(1–3):87–102
Burnett PJ, Rickerby DS (1987) The relationship between hardness and scratch adhesion. Thin Solid Films 154(1–2):403–416
Bull SJ, Rickerby DS, Matthews A, Leyland A, Pace AR, Valli J (1988) The use of scratch adhesion testing for the determination of interfacial adhesion: the importance of frictional drag. Surf Coat Technol 36(1):503–517
Bull SJ, Rickerby DS (1990) New developments in the modelling of the hardness and scratch adhesion of thin films. Surf Coat Technol 42(2):149–164
Bull SJ, Berasetegui EG (2006) An overview of the potential of quantitative coating adhesion measurement by scratch testing. Tribol Int 39(2):99–114
Lai C-M, Lin K-M, Rosmaidah S (2012) Effect of annealing temperature on the quality of Al-doped ZnO thin films prepared by sol–gel method. J Sol–Gel Sci Technol 61(1):249–257
Bull SJ (1997) Failure mode maps in the thin film scratch adhesion test. Tribol Int 30(7):491–498
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the MecaTech Cluster and the Walloon region for the financial support, in the frame of the Nanosol project. The authors would also like to thank the Walloon region for financial support in the frame of the INDMAT project (BEWARE FELLOWSHIPS), co-funded by the European Union (FP7—Marie Curie Actions). The authors are grateful to Luiza Bonin (UMons) for the 3D microscopic visualization and to Recayi Bilgic (CRM Group) for the AFM observations of residual indents and scratches.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mercier, D., Nicolay, A., Boudiba, A. et al. Mechanical properties and decohesion of sol–gel coatings on metallic and glass substrates. J Sol-Gel Sci Technol 93, 229–243 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10971-019-05196-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10971-019-05196-9