Abstract
In physics, there are two distinct paradoxes, which are both known as the “Gibbs paradox”. This article is concerned with only one of them: the false increase in entropy, which is calculated from the process of combining two gases of the same kind consisting of distinguishable particles. In the following, this paradox will be referred to as the Gibbs paradox of the first kind (GP1). (Two particles are said to be distinguishable if they are either non-identical, that is, if they have different properties, or if they are identical and there are microstates which change under transposition of the two particles.) The GP1 is demonstrated and subsequently analyzed. The analysis shows that, for (quantum or classical) systems of distinguishable particles, it is generally uncertain of which particles they consist. The neglect of this uncertainty is the root of the GP1. For the statistical description of a system of distinguishable particles, an underlying set of particles, containing all particles that in principle qualify for being part of the system, is assumed to be known. Of which elements of this underlying particle set the system is composed, differs from microstate to microstate. Thus, the system is described by an ensemble of possible particle compositions. The uncertainty about the particle composition contributes to the entropy of the system. Systems for which all possible particle compositions are equiprobable will be called harmonic. Classical systems of distinguishable identical particles are harmonic as a matter of principle; quantum or classical systems of non-identical particles are not necessarily harmonic, since for them the composition probabilities depend individually on the preparation of the system. Harmonic systems with the same underlying particle set are always correlated; hence, for harmonic systems, the entropy is no longer additive and loses its thermodynamic meaning. A quantity derived from entropy is introduced, the reduced entropy, which, for harmonic systems, replaces the entropy as thermodynamic potential. For identical classical particles, the equivalence (in particular with respect to the second law of thermodynamics) between distinguishability and indistinguishability is proved. The resolution of the GP1 is demonstrated applying the previously found results.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Baierlein, R.: The fraction of “all different” combinations: Justifying the semi-classical partition function. Am. J. Phys. 65, 314–316 (1997)
Ben-Naim, A.: On the so-called Gibbs paradox, and on the real paradox. Entropy 9, 132–136 (2007)
Boyer, T.H.: Sharpening Bridgman’s resolution of the Gibbs paradox. Am. J. Phys. 38, 771–773 (1970)
Bridgman, P.W.: The Nature of Thermodynamics, pp. 168–169. Harper, New York (1961)
Casper, B.M., Freier, S.: “Gibbs paradox” paradox. Am. J. Phys. 41, 509–511 (1973)
Cheng, C.H.: Thermodynamics of the system of distinguishable particles. Entropy 11, 326–333 (2009)
Denbigh, K.G., Redhead, M.L.G.: Gibbs’ paradox and non-uniform convergence. Synthese 81, 283–312 (1989)
Diu, B., Guthmann, C., Lederer, D., Roulet, B.: Grundlagen der Statistischen Physik, p. 170. de Gruyter, Berlin (1994)
Diu, B., Guthmann, C., Lederer, D., Roulet, B.: Grundlagen der Statistischen Physik, p. 375. de Gruyter, Berlin (1994)
Diu, B., Guthmann, C., Lederer, D., Roulet, B.: Grundlagen der Statistischen Physik, pp. 762–763, 804–805. de Gruyter, Berlin (1994)
Ehrenfest, P., Ehrenfest, T.: The Conceptual Foundations of the Statistical Approach in Mechanics, p. 54, 98. Cornell University Press, Ithaca (1959)
Ehrenfest, P., Oppenheimer, J.R.: Note on the statistics of nuclei. Phys. Rev. 37, 333–338 (1931)
Ehrenfest, P., Trkal, V.: Ableitung des Dissoziationsgleichgewichtes aus der Quantentheorie und darauf beruhende Berechnung der chemischen Konstanten. Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 65(370), 609–628 (1921). Remark of Ehrenfest on p. 628
Einstein, A., Podolsky, B., Rosen, N.: Can quantum-mechanical description of physical reality be considered complete? Phys. Rev. 47, 777–780 (1935)
Gemmer, J., Michel, M., Mahler, G.: Quantum Thermodynamics, 2 edn., pp. 129–131. Springer, Berlin (2009)
Gibbs, J.W.: Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics, pp. 206–207. Scribner’s, New York (1902). Reprinted by Dover, New York (1960)
Gibbs, J.W.: Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics, p. 188. Scribner’s, New York (1902). Reprinted by Dover, New York (1960)
Gibbs, J.W.: On the equilibrium of heterogeneous substances. In: The Scientific Papers of J. Willard Gibbs, vol. 1, pp. 165–168. Dover, New York (1961). First published in Transactions of the Connecticut Academy of Arts and Sciences, vol. 3, New Haven (1875–1878)
Hestenes, D.: Entropy and indistinguishability. Am. J. Phys. 38, 840–845 (1970)
Home, D., Sengupta, S.: Extensivity of entropy and modern form of Gibbs paradox. Pramana 17, 509–514 (1981)
Huang, K.: Statistical Mechanics, pp. 153–155. Wiley, New York (1963)
Jaynes, E.T.: The Gibbs paradox. In: Smith, C.R. et al. (ed.) Maximum Entropy and Bayesian Methods, Seattle, 1991, pp. 1–21. Kluwer, Dordrecht (1992)
Landé, A.: New Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, pp. 64–66. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1965)
Landé, A.: New Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, pp. 61–64. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1965)
Lyuboshitz, V.L., Podgoretskii, M.I.: The Gibbs paradox. Sov. Phys. Usp. 14, 662–666 (1972)
Messiah, A.: Quantum Mechanics, vol. 2, pp. 619–626. North-Holland, Amsterdam (1962)
Messiah, A.: Quantum Mechanics, vol. 2, pp. 600–603. North-Holland, Amsterdam (1962)
Messiah, A.M.L., Greenberg, O.W.: Symmetrization postulate and its experimental foundation. Phys. Rev. 136, B248–B267 (1964)
Nagle, J.F.: Regarding the entropy of distinguishable particles. J. Stat. Phys. 117, 1047–1062 (2004)
Pathria, R.K.: Statistical Mechanics, 2 edn., pp. 22–26, 122. Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford (1996)
Planck, M.: Vorlesungen über die Theorie der Wärmestrahlung, 4th edn., pp. 209–210. Barth, Leipzig (1921)
Planck, M.: Absolute Entropie und chemische Konstante. Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 66(371), 365–372 (1921). Reprinted in Planck, M.: Physikalische Abhandlungen und Vorträge, vol. 2, pp. 527–534. Vieweg, Braunschweig (1958)
Pniower, J.C.: Particles, objects, and physics. Ph.D. thesis. Oxford University, Oxford (2005)
Rushbrooke, G.S.: Introduction to Statistical Mechanics, pp. 36–39. Clarendon, Oxford (1949)
Rushbrooke, G.S.: Introduction to Statistical Mechanics, pp. 40–44, 61–63. Clarendon, Oxford (1949)
Saunders, S.: On the explanation for quantum statistics. Stud. Hist. Philos. Mod. Phys. 37, 192–211 (2006)
Schrödinger, E.: Gasentartung und freie Weglänge. Phys. Z. 25, 41–45 (1924). Reprinted in Schrödinger, E.: Gesammelte Abhandlungen, vol. 1, pp. 319-323. Österreichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Wien (1984)
Schrödinger, E.: Statistical Thermodynamics, pp. 58–62. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1948)
Swendsen, R.H.: Statistical mechanics of classical systems with distinguishable particles. J. Stat. Phys. 107, 1143–1166 (2002)
Swendsen, R.H.: Response to Nagle’s criticism of my proposed definition of the entropy. J. Stat. Phys. 117, 1063–1070 (2004)
Swendsen, R.H.: Statistical mechanics of colloids and Boltzmann’s definition of the entropy. Am. J. Phys. 74, 187–190 (2006)
ter Haar, D.: Elements of Statistical Mechanics, pp. 71–72. Rinehart, New York (1954)
Tetrode, H.: Die chemische Konstante der Gase und das elementare Wirkungsquantum. Ann. Phys. (Leipzig) 38(343), 434–442 (1912)
van Kampen, N.G.: The Gibbs paradox. In: Parry, W.E. (ed.) Essays in Theoretical Physics in Honour of Dirk ter Haar, pp. 303–312. Pergamon, Oxford (1984)
van Kampen, N.G.: The Gibbs paradox. In: Parry, W.E. (ed.) Essays in Theoretical Physics in Honour of Dirk ter Haar, p. 308. Pergamon, Oxford (1984)
von Neumann, J.: Mathematical Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, pp. 370–376. Princeton University Press, Princeton (1955)
Warren, P.B.: Combinatorial entropy and the statistical mechanics of polydispersity. Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1369–1372 (1998)
Wehrl, A.: General properties of entropy. Rev. Mod. Phys. 50, 221–260 (1978)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0), which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
About this article
Cite this article
Peters, H. Statistics of Distinguishable Particles and Resolution of the Gibbs Paradox of the First Kind. J Stat Phys 141, 785–828 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-010-0077-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-010-0077-7