Abstract
Excavations in the former Roman provincial capital of Pannonia Superior, Carnuntum, 40 km east of Vienna revealed damaged masonry structures from many parts of the ancient settlements. A compilation of structurally damaged buildings has formerly been given by Kandler (Acta Archaeol Acad Sci Hung, 41:313–336, 1989), who related damage to an earthquake in the middle of the fourth century a.d. This paper reviews and supplements these data, and discusses the significance of the style of damage. It is concluded that seismic damage is the only likely interpretation for the damaging mechanism. Although archaeological age dating for the individual collapsed buildings only constrains the timing of their destruction to a few decades around 350 a.d., we assume a single damaging event. In spite of the restrictions on damage assessment by the nature of the archaeological data, it is possible to give a reasonable appraisal of macroseismic intensity. The tentative seismological interpretation of damage leads to an intensity estimate of about nine of the European macroseismic scale (EMS-1998). Comparison with macroseismic data of modern earthquakes in the region, which show a rapid decrease of intensity with distance form the epicentre, indicate a near-by seismic source unless exceptionally high epicentral intensities are assumed for the fourth century event. The most likely source is an active sinistral strike-slip fault (Lassee Fault) passing about 8 km NW of the archaeological site. The fault belongs to Vienna Basin fault system with about 2 mm sinistral movement per year. The system is characterized by fault segmentation and distinct seismicity along the different segments. Moderate seismicity during the last centuries at the southern segments (e.g., Schwadorf 1927, I 0=8) strongly contrasts from the Lassee fault segment with Carnuntum as the only known severe earthquake. The earthquake of Carnuntum provides evidence for the overall seismic style of deformation along this segment, which previously has not been regarded seismically active. Also, the fourth century earthquake is the strongest event known from the Vienna Basin fault so far.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
ACORN (2004) Catalogue of earthquakes in the region of the Alps–Western Carpathians–Bohemian Massif for the period from 1267 to 2004, Computer file, Vienna (Central Institute for Meteorology and Geodynamics, Department of Geophysics)-Brno (Institute of Physics of the Earth, University Brno)
Albarello D, Berardi A, Margottino C, Cucciarelli M (1995) Macro-seismic estimates of magnitude in Italy. PAGEOPH 145:297–312
Blake A (1941) On the estimation of focal depth from macroseismic data. Bull Seismol Soc Am 31:225–231
Decker K, Peresson H (1996) Tertiary kinematics in the Alpine Carpathian Pannonian system: links between thrusting, transform faulting and crustal extension. In: Wessely G, Liebl W (eds) Oil and gas in Alpidic thrustbelts and basins of central and eastern Europe. EAGE Spec Publ 5:69–77
Decker K, Peresson H, Hinsch R (2005) Active tectonics and quaternary basin formation along the Vienna Basin transform fault. Quat Sci Rev 24:305–322
Dell J (1893) Ausgrabungen im Jahre 1891. Archäologisch–epigraphische Mitteilungen aus Österreich–Ungarn 16:141–177
Drimmel J (1980) Rezente Seismizität und Seismotektonik des Alpenostraums. In: Oberhauser R (ed) Der geologische Aufbau Österreichs. Vienna (Geol. B.–A.):505–527
Fuchs W, Grill R (1984) Geologische Karte von Wien und Umgebung 1:200.000. Vienna (Geol. B.–A.)
Gangl G (1975) Seismotektonische Untersuchungen am Alpenostrand. Mitt Geol Ges Wien 66–67:33–48 (1973–1974)
Grenerczy G (2002) Tectonic processes in the Eurasian–African plate boundary zone revealed by space geodesy. In: Stein S, Freymueller JT (eds) Plate boundary zones. AGU Monogr Geodyn Ser 30:67–86
Grenerczy G, Kenyeres A, Fejes I (2000) Present crustal movement and strain distribution in Central Europe inferred from GPS measurements. J Geophys Res 105(B9):21835–21846
Grünewald M (1974) Die Gefäßkeramik des Legionslagers Carnuntum (Grabungen 1968–1974), Vienna (Austrian Academy of Sciences). Der römische Limes in Österreich 29:58
Grünthal G (ed) (1998) European Macroseismic Scale 1998. Cahiers du Centre Européen de Géodynamique et de Séismologie, vol 19. Luxembourg, p 99
Gutdeutsch R, Aric K (1988) Seismicity and neotectonics of the East Alpine–Carpathian and Pannonian area. AAPG Mem 45:183–194
Gutdeutsch R, Hammerl C (1999) An uncertainty parameter of historical earthquakes – the record threshold. J Seismol 3:351–362
Gutdeutsch R, Lenhardt W (1996) Seismological interpretation of the South Alpine earthquake of January 25th, 1348, ESC general assembly Reykjavik abstract W1.19
Gutdeutsch R, Kaiser D, Jentzsch G (2002) Estimation of earthquake magnitudes from epicentral intensities and other focal parameters in central and southern Europe. Geophys J Int 151:824–834
Heiling I (1995) KG Bruckneudorf. Fundber Österr 34:686
Hinsch R, Decker K (2003) Do seismic slip deficits indicate an underestimated earthquake potential along the Vienna Basin transform fault system? Terra Nova 15(5):343–349
Hinsch R, Decker K, Wagreich M (2005) 3-D mapping of segmented active faults in the southern Vienna Basin. Quat Sci Rev 24:321–336
Jobst W (1978) Die Theateranlage im römischen Tempelbezirk auf dem Pfaffenberg. Mitteilungen der Gesellschaft der Freunde Carnuntums 1978(4):10–16
Jobst W (2001) Das Heidentor von Carnuntum. Ein spätantikes Triumphalmonument am Donaulimes. Austrian Academy of Sciences, Vienna, p 264
Kandler M (1980) Archäologische Beobachtungen zur Baugeschichte des Legionslagers Carnuntum am Ausgang der Antike. In: Wofram H, Daim F (eds) Die Völker an der mittleren und unteren Donau im fünften und sechsten Jahrhundert, Denkschriften der philosophisch–historischen Klasse der österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften 145:83–93
Kandler M (1989) Eine Erdbebenkatastrophe in Carnuntum? Acta Archaeol Acad Sci Hung 41:313–336. Akademia Kiado, Budapest
Kandler M (2003) Die Erforschung des Kultbezirkes. In: Eschbaumer P, Gassner V, Jilek S, Kandler M, Kremer G, Pfisterer M, Radbauer S, Winter H (eds) Der Kultbezirk des Iuppiter Optimus Maximus Heliopolitanus in den östlichen Canabae von Carnuntum. Carnuntum Jahrbuch 2003(2004):117–167
Kandler M, Zabehlicky H (1987) Untersuchungen in den canabae legionis von Carnuntum im Jahr 1986. Pro Austria Rom 37:12–15
Kandler M, Decker K, Gangl G (2006) Archäologische Befunde von Erdbebenschäden im Raum von Carnuntum und ihre seismotektonische Interpretation. Geographica Historica (in press)
Lenhardt WA (1995) Regional earthquake hazard in Austria. In: Duma G (ed) 10th European conference on earthquake engineering. Vienna, Austria. Balkema, Rotterdam, pp 63–68
Reinecker J, Lenhardt WA (1999) Present-day stress field and deformation in eastern Austria. Int J Earth Sci 88:532–550
Schenk V, Schenková Z, Kottnauer P, Guterch B, Labák P (2000) Earthquake hazard for the Czech Republic, Poland and Slovakia – contribution to the ILC/IASPEI global seismic hazard assessment program. Nat Hazards 21:331–345
Schenková Z, Schenk V, Pospisil L, Kottnauer P (1995) Seismogeological pattern of a transition area between the eastern Alps and the western Carpathians. Tectonophysics 248:235–245
Sefara J, Kovac M, Plasienka D, Sujan M (1998) Seismogenic zones in the eastern Alpine–western Carpathian–Pannonian junction area. Geol Carpath 49(4):247–260
Shebalin NV, Leydecker G (1998) Earthquake catalogue for central and southeastern Europe 342 b.c.–1990 a.d. European commission, report no. ETNU CT 93-0087, Brussels, 1998
Staník I, Turčan V (2001) Zum Untergangshorizont der römischen Station in Stupava, Anodos. Studies of the Ancient World 1:209–213
Stiglitz H, Jilek S (1997) Das Auxiliarkastell von Carnuntum. Bericht über die Grabungen 1977–1988. In: Stiglitz H (ed) Das Auxiliarkastell Carnuntum 1. Sonderschriften des Österr. Archäologischen Instituts 29:13–146
Stiros SC (1996) Identification of earthquakes from archaeological data: methodology, criteria and limitation. In: Stiros S, Jones RE (eds) Archaeoseismology, Fitch Laboratory, British School at Athens, pp 129–152
Swoboda F (1964) Carnuntum. Seine Geschichte und seine Denkmäler, Römische Forschungen in Niederösterreich, vol 1. Böhlau, Graz-Köln, p 316
Van Gils JM, Leydecker G (1991) Catalogue of European earthquakes with intensities higher than 4, Commission of the European communities – nuclear science and technology, 353 pp, 14 fig, 1 tab – ISBN 92-826-2506-0, Catalogue number: CD-NA-13406-EN-C. Brussels, Luxembourg
Von Groller-Mildensee M (1900) Limesstation und Tempelbezirk auf dem Pfaffenberg bei Deutsch–Altenburg. Der römische Limes in Österreich 1:65
Zabehlicky H (2004) Zum Abschluß der Grabungen im Hauptgebäude der Villa von Bruckneudorf, Jahreshefte des Österreichischen Archäologischen Instituts in Wien, vol 73
ZAMG – Zentralanstalt für Meteorologie und Geodynamik (2003) Catalogue of felt earthquakes in Austria 1201–2002, computer file. ZAMG, Vienna
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Decker, K., Gangl, G. & Kandler, M. The earthquake of Carnuntum in the fourth century a.d. – archaeological results, seismologic scenario and seismotectonic implications for the Vienna Basin fault, Austria. J Seismol 10, 479–495 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10950-006-9032-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10950-006-9032-0