Advertisement

Journal of Seismology

, Volume 9, Issue 3, pp 329–340 | Cite as

Historical earthquakes in Jerusalem – A methodological discussion

  • N. AmbraseysEmail author
Article

Abstract

This article is of an inter-disciplinary nature, relevant to the fields of both earth sciences and historiography, which come together in the investigation of long-term earthquake hazard. The paper emphasises the need for systematic and consistent analysis of historical earthquake data and sets out an example for such a task. The results from the historical study of earthquakes will be of value to earth scientists and engineers only when historical information is converted into “numbers” representing epicentral location and magnitude of the events, accompanied by an estimate of the reliability of their assessment. However, as we go further back in time before our era, the historical record gradually disappears and the archaeological record takes over. Unfortunately, the archaeological record is too coarse and ambiguous, without any precise internal archaeological indicators. Dating is based on, or influenced by the very few historical records, such as in the Bible and inscriptions, which provide an example of how their assumed accuracy may influence archaeologists' interpretation and dating. Quite often this develops into a circular process in which archaeological assumptions or theories are transformed into facts and used by earth scientists to confirm the dates and size of their proposed events. In this article we discuss the problems that arise when Biblical and archaeological information is used at face value to assess earthquakes in the Holy Land. This combination may produce earthquakes of hypothetical location and of grossly exaggerated magnitude with consequences for the assessment of seismic hazard.

Keywords

earthquakes historical seismicity Jerusalem 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Aharoni, Y., 1973, Beer-Sheba I, excavations at Tel Beer-Sheba 1969–1971 seasons, Tel Aviv Institute of Archaeology, Tel Aviv.Google Scholar
  2. Amiran, D.H., E. Arieh E., et al., 1994, Earthquakes in Israel and adjacent areas. Macroseismic observations since 100 B.C.E., Israel Exploration Journal 44, 260–305.Google Scholar
  3. Ambraseys, N. and Karcz, I., 1992, The earthquake of 1546 in the Holy Land, Terra 4, 254–263.Google Scholar
  4. Atlas of Israel, 1985, Physical and human geography, 3rd Ed., p. 17, The Survey of Israel, Jerusalem.Google Scholar
  5. Austin, S.A., Franz, G.W. and Frost, E.G. 2000, Amos's earthquake: An extraordinary Middle East seismic event of ca.750 BC, Intern. Geology Review 42, 657–671.Google Scholar
  6. Balensi, J., 1980, Les fouilles de R.W. Hamilton a Tell Abu Hawam: Niveaux IV et V, Diss. Strasbourg.Google Scholar
  7. Ben-Menahem, A., 1979, Earthquake catalogue for the Middle East (92 BC–980 AD), Boll. Geof. Teor. Applic. 21, 262.Google Scholar
  8. Courville, D.A., 1971, The Exodus problem and its ramifications, 2 vols.Google Scholar
  9. Crisler, V., 2004, The archaeology of Samaria (Rough draft), http://vernerable.tripod.com/samaria.htm
  10. Dever, W.G., 1992, A case-study in biblical archaeology: The earthquake of ca. 760 BCE, Eretz-Israel 23, 27–35.Google Scholar
  11. Dever, W.G. and Younker R.W., 1991, Tel Gezer, Israel Explor. J. 41, 282–286.Google Scholar
  12. Dever, W.G., 1992, A Case-Study in Biblical Archaeology: The Earthquake of ca. 760 BCE, Eretz-Israel 23, 27–35.Google Scholar
  13. Dever, W.G., 1997, Bethel, in: E.M. Meyers (ed.), The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East, vol. I pp. 300–301.Google Scholar
  14. Dever, W.G. and Younker, 1991, Tel Gezer, 1990, Israel Exploration Journal 41, 282–286.Google Scholar
  15. Dothan, T. and Dunayevsky, I., 1993, Tel Qasile. Excavations in area A and B, in: E. Stern (ed.), The New Encyclopaedia of Archaeological excavations in the Holy Land, http://www.hum.huji.ac.il/tellqasile/article.htm.
  16. Eusebius, Chronicle, ed. Schoene, Zurich, 1967 (2 vols.); Ecclesiastical History, ed. & tr. K. Lake, LCL, 1926–1932.Google Scholar
  17. Finkelstein, I. and Ussishkin, D., 2003, The cache of egyptianized vessels from Megido; a stratigraphical update, Tel Aviv Journ. Tel Aviv Univ., Inst. Of Archaeology 30, 27–42.Google Scholar
  18. Firpo, G., 1989, Il terremoto del 31 a.c. in palestina e la cronologia della passione, in Fenomen: naturali e avvenimenti storici nell' antichità, pp. 184–218, Pubb. Univ. Cattolica Sacro Cuore.Google Scholar
  19. Franken, H.J., 1961, Excavations at Deir 'Alla in Jordan, 2nd season, Vetus Testamentum 11, 362–372.Google Scholar
  20. Franken, H., 1964, Excavations at Deir 'Alla in Jordan, Season 1964, Vetus Testamentum 14, 417–322.Google Scholar
  21. Franken, H.J., 1976, Archaeological evidence relating to the interpretation of the text: in: J. Hoftijzer and C. Van der Kooij (ed.) Aramaic texts from Deir Alla, pp. 3–16, Leiden.Google Scholar
  22. Franz, G., 1992, The earthquake in the days of King Uzziah: An arcaeologica and theological appraisal, mentioned in Dever (1992) 34* notes 2 and 10.Google Scholar
  23. Franz, G., 2005, Biblical research, Bible Encyclopaedia.Google Scholar
  24. Frydman, S., 1997, Geotechnical problems in the Holyland – then and now, Electronic Journ. Geotechn. Eng. 2, 1–28.Google Scholar
  25. Georgius Monachus, 1904, Georgii Monachi Chronicon, PG vol.110; 232/376 ed. de Boor, CSHB.Google Scholar
  26. Gil, D., 1996, The geology of the city of David and its ancient subterranean waterworks, in Excavations at the city of David 1978–1985, vol.4, pp. 1–28, ends D.T. Ariel, A. De Groot, in QEDEM, Monographs of the Institutes of Archaeology, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, no. 35, eds A. Belfer-Cohen, Mazar A., Stern E., Tsafrir Y.Google Scholar
  27. Herzog, Z., 1997, Beersheba, in: E.M. Meyers (ed.) The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Near East, vol. I, pp. 287–291.Google Scholar
  28. Herzog, Z., 2002, The fortress mound at Tel Arad. An interim report, Tel Aviv 29(1), 3–109.Google Scholar
  29. Hieronymus, 1984, (Jerome) Chronicle, ed. Helm, Eusebius Werke, vol. 7, Berlin.Google Scholar
  30. Ibrahim, M.M., Kooij, G. van der, 1979, Excavations at Tell Deir Alla, Season 1979, Annual of the Dept., of Antiquities of Jordan, vol. 23, pp. 32, 41–50.Google Scholar
  31. Israeli, A., 1977, Geotechnical map of Jerusalem and surroundings, Rep. M. M./12/77 Geol. Survey of Israel. Jerusalem.Google Scholar
  32. Josephus, Flavius, Antiquities of the Jews, Whiston ed. &”, ed. & tr. H. Thackeray & R. Marcus, LCL, 1934.Google Scholar
  33. Kitchen, K.A., 1986, The Third Intermediate Period in Egypt 1100-650 B.C., 2nd ed. Westminster.Google Scholar
  34. Knauf, E.A., 1998, Tell Kinneret. Ist die “Biblische Archäologie” eine Fortsetzung der Exegese mit anderen Mitteln?, UNI Press, Forschung und Wissensschaft der Universität Bern 97, Beitrag 9.Google Scholar
  35. Knauf, E.A., 2002, Excavating Biblical History, Revelations from Megiddo, The Newsletter of the Megiddo Expedition 6, Techn. Univ. Tel Aviv.Google Scholar
  36. Lavvas, G., 1998, The rock of Calvary: Uncovering Christ's Crucifixion site, Jewish Art 24, 147–150.Google Scholar
  37. Lavvas, G., 2004, The Holy church of the resurrection in Jerusalem: The first construction phase during Constantine the Great, Corpus, No. 60, pp. 30–47, Athens (G).Google Scholar
  38. Lemaire, A., 1997, Deir 'Alla Inscriptions, in: E.M. Meyers (ed.), The Oxford Encyclopedia of Archaeology in the Near East, vol. II, pp. 138–140.Google Scholar
  39. Malalas, John, 1986, Chronicle, PG 97; The Chronicle of John Malalas, 241/369ed. & tr. Elizabeth Jeffreys et al, Melbourne.Google Scholar
  40. Mazar, A., 1993, Archaeology of the land of the Bible.Google Scholar
  41. Nathan ha-Bavli, 1887, Avot de Rabbi Nathan, ed. S. Schechter, London.Google Scholar
  42. Ng, Joel, 2004, Introduction to Biblical Archaeology: 4, Ascendance and decline.Google Scholar
  43. Nur, A. and Ron, H., 1996, And the Walls Came Tumbling Down: Earthquake History in the Holyland, in: Stiros and Jones, pp. 75–85.Google Scholar
  44. Oldrich Prefat z Vlkanova, 1947, (1563) Cesta z Prahy do Benatak a odtud potom po mori az Palestyny ... leta Pane 1546, pp. 107, 124–137, 164, ed K. Hrdina, Vesmir, Praha.Google Scholar
  45. Oppolzer, T., 1887 “Canon der Finsternisse”, Denkschr.K.Akad. Wiss.math.-naturw.Kl., vol. 52; repr. New York, Dover, 1962.Google Scholar
  46. Orosius, Historiarum adversum paganos, ed. Zangemeister, Hist. vii.iv.13 Vienna, 1883.Google Scholar
  47. Pratt, J.P., 1991, Newton's date for the Crucifixion, Quart. Journ. R. Astron. Soc. 32, 301–304.Google Scholar
  48. Phlegon of Tralles, 1887, in C. Müller, Fragm. Hist. Graec. III. xv/607.Google Scholar
  49. Rotstein, Y., 1987, Gausian probability for a large earthquake occurrence in the Jordan Valley, Dead Sea Rift, Tectonophysics 141, 95–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Shmulik, M. and A. Amotz, A., 2002, Armageddon Quakes, Revelations from Megiddo, The Newsletter of the Megiddo Expedition 6 Techn. Univ. Tel Aviv (April 2002). Available on http://megiddo.tau.ac.il/revelations6.html.
  51. Sieberg, A., 1932a, “Die Erdbeben”, in: B. Gutenberg Handbuch der Geophysik (ed.), vol. 4, Berlin.Google Scholar
  52. Sieberg, A., 1932b, Untersuchungen ueber Erdbeben und Bruchschollenbau in oestlichen Mittelmeergebiet, Denksschr. Mediz. naturwiss. Gesellsch. z. Jena, vol. 8, Jena.Google Scholar
  53. Singer-Avitz, L., 2002, The Iron age pottery assemblage, Tel Aviv 29, 110–215.Google Scholar
  54. Soggin, A., 1970, “Das Erdbeben von Amos 1 und die Chronologie der Könige Ussia und Jotham von Juda”, Zeitschr.Alttest.Wissensch. 82, 120.Google Scholar
  55. Stern, E., 1993, (ed.), The New Encyclopaedia of Archaeological Excavations in the Holy Land revised edition, New York.Google Scholar
  56. Stern, E. and Sharon, I., 1993, Tel Dor, 1992: Preliminary Report, Israel Exploration Journal 43, 126–150.Google Scholar
  57. Stiros, S. and Jones, R.E., 1996, (eds), Archaeoseismology, Fitich Laboratory Occasional Paper7, British School at Athen.Google Scholar
  58. Ussishkin, D., 1977, The Destruction of Lachish by Sennacherib and the Dating of the Royal Judean Storage Jars, Tel Aviv. Journal of the Tel Aviv University Institut of Archaeology 4, 28–60.Google Scholar
  59. Ussishkin, D., 1992, Lachish, in: D.N. Freedmann (ed.) The Anchor Bible Dictionary, vol. 4, p. 121.Google Scholar
  60. Ussishkin, D., 1992, Lachish, in: D.N. Freedmann (ed.) The Anchor Bible Dictionary, vol. 4, p. 121.Google Scholar
  61. Wachs, D. and Lewitte, D., 1984, Earthquakes in Jerusalem and the Mount of Olives landslides, Israel Land & Nature 3, 118–121.Google Scholar
  62. Warren, H. V., 1989, Aegean Bronze age chronology, Bristol.Google Scholar
  63. Wilson, C., 1886, Ordnance survey of Jerusalem, H.M.T, London.Google Scholar
  64. Yadin, Y., 1975, Hazor. The Rediscovery of a Great Citadel of the Bible London.Google Scholar
  65. Younker, R.W., 1991, A preliminary report of the 1990 season at Tel Gezer. Excavations of the “outer wall” and the “Solomon wall” July to August 10, 1990-, Andrews University Seminar Studies No. 29, pp. 19–60.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science + Business Media, Inc. 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Environmental EngineeringImperial CollegeLondonUK

Personalised recommendations