Journal of Quantitative Criminology

, Volume 30, Issue 4, pp 651–676 | Cite as

The Impact of Leadership Removal on Mexican Drug Trafficking Organizations

  • Matthew DickensonEmail author
Original Paper



Has the Mexican government’s policy of removing drug-trafficking organization (DTO) leaders reduced or increased violence? In the first 4 years of the Calderón administration, over 34,000 drug-related murders were committed. In response, the Mexican government captured or killed 25 DTO leaders. This study analyzes changes in violence (drug-related murders) that followed those leadership removals.


The analysis consists of cross-sectional time-series negative binomial modeling of 49 months of murder counts in 32 Mexican states (including the federal district).


Leadership removals are generally followed by increases in drug-related murders. A DTO’s home state experiences more subsequent violence than the state where the leader was removed. Killing leaders is associated with more violence than capturing them. However, removing leaders for whom a $30m peso bounty was offered is associated with a smaller increase than other removals.


DTO leadership removals in Mexico were associated with an estimated 415 additional deaths during the first 4 years of the Calderón administration. Reforming Mexican law enforcement and improving career prospects for young men are more promising counter-narcotics strategies. Further research is needed to analyze how the rank of leaders mediates the effect of their removal.


Leadership Violence Murders Drug trafficking 


  1. Asall V, Gill P, Rethemeyer R, Horgan J (2013) Killing range: explaining lethality variance within a terrorist organization. J Confl Resolut. doi: 10.1177/0022002713508927
  2. Bailey J, Taylor M (2007) Evade, corrupt, or confront? Organized crime and the state in Mexico and Brazil. In: Latin American Studies Association’s Annual Meeting, Montreal, CanadaGoogle Scholar
  3. BATF (2010) Project gunrunner: a cartel focused strategy. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and ExplosivesGoogle Scholar
  4. Berman E (1998) Sect, subsidy, and sacrifice: an economist’s view of ultra-orthodox jews. Technical report, National Bureau of Economic ResearchGoogle Scholar
  5. Berman E, Laitin D (2008) Religion, terrorism and public goods: testing the club model. J Public Econ 92(10–11):1942–1967CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Boyle MJ (2012) Progress and pitfalls in the study of political violence. Terror Polit Violence 24(4):527–543CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Byman D (2006) Do targeted killings work? Foreign Aff 85:95–111CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Currie D (2011) Mexico agonistes. National review onlineGoogle Scholar
  9. Flanigan ST (2012) Terrorists next door? A comparison of Mexican drug cartels and middle eastern terrorist organizations. Terror Polit Violence 24(2):279–294CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Freeman L (2006) State of siege: drug-related violence and corruption in Mexico. Washington office on latin America special report, JuneGoogle Scholar
  11. Friman H (2009) Drug markets and the selective use of violence. Crime Law Soc Change 52(3):285–295CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Gambetta D (2009) Codes of the underworld: how criminals communicate. Princeton University Press, PrincetonGoogle Scholar
  13. González F (2009) Mexico’s drug wars get brutal. Curr History 108(715):72–76Google Scholar
  14. Grayson GW (2010) La familia drug cartel: implications for US-Mexican security. Strategic Studies Institute, USAGoogle Scholar
  15. Guerrero-Gutiérrez E (2011) Security, drugs and violence in Mexico: a survey. In: Prepared for the 7th North American Forum, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  16. Hafez M, Hatfield J (2006) Do targeted assassinations work? A multivariate analysis of Israeli counter-terrorism effectiveness during Al-Aqsa uprising. Stud Confl Terror 29:359–382CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Honig O (2007) Explaining Israel’s misuse of strategic assassinations. Stud Confl Terror 30(6):563–577CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Iannaccone L (1992) Religious markets and the economics of religion. Social Compass 39(1):123CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Ingram M, Shirk D (2010) Judicial reform in Mexico: toward a new criminal justice system. Trans-Border Institute special reportGoogle Scholar
  20. Johnston P (2012) Does decapitation work? Assessing the effectiveness of leadership targeting in counterinsurgency campaigns. Int Secur 36(4):47–79CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Jordan J (2009) When heads roll: assessing the effectiveness of leadership decapitation. Secur Stud 18(4):719–755CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Kalyvas S et al (2006) The logic of violence in civil war. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Kellner T, Pipitone F (2010) Inside Mexico’s drug war. World Policy J 27(1):29–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Kenney M (2007) From Pablo to Osama: trafficking and terrorist networks, government bureaucracies, and competitive adaptation. Penn State Press, PennsylvaniaGoogle Scholar
  25. LaFree G, Dugan L, Xie M, Singh P (2012) Spatial and temporal patterns of terrorist attacks by eta 1970 to 2007. J Quant Criminol 28(1):7–29CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Lawrence A (2010) Triggering nationalist violence: competition and conflict in uprisings against colonial rule. Int Secur 35(2):88–122CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. McDowall D, Loftin C, Pate M (2012) Seasonal cycles in crime, and their variability. J Quant Criminol 28(3):389–410CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Miller E (2012) Patterns of onset and decline among terrorist organizations. J Quant Criminol 28:77–101CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Natarajan M (2000) Understanding the structure of a drug trafficking organization: a conversational analysis. Crime Prevent Stud 11:273–298Google Scholar
  30. Natarajan M (2006) Understanding the structure of a large heroin distribution network: a quantitative analysis of qualitative data. J Quant Criminol 22(2):171–192CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Olson E, Shirk D, Selee A (eds) (2010) Shared responsibility: U.S.-Mexico policy options for confronting organized crime. The Woodrow International Center for Scholars and the Trans-Border Institute, University of San Diego, Washington, DC/San DiegoGoogle Scholar
  32. Pyrooz D, Sweeten G, Piquero A (2013) Continuity and change in gang membership and gang embeddedness. J Res Crime Delinq 50(2):239–271Google Scholar
  33. Reuter P (2009) Systemic violence in drug markets. Crime Law Soc Change 52(3):275–284CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Rios V (2011) Understanding Mexico’s drug war. Harvard University, manuscriptGoogle Scholar
  35. Rios V, Shirk D (2011) Drug violence in Mexico: data and analysis through 2010. Trans-Border Institute, San DiegoGoogle Scholar
  36. Sabet K, Rios V (2009) Why violence has increased in Mexico and what can we do about it? Technical report, unpublished working paper, November 28, 2009. As of October 4, 2010.
  37. Salazar M, Olson E (2007) A profile of Mexicos major organized crime groups. Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Mexico InstituteGoogle Scholar
  38. Schelling T (1971) What is the business of organized crime? J Publ L 20:71Google Scholar
  39. Shirk D (2011a) Drug violence and state responses in Mexico. University of San Diego, manuscriptGoogle Scholar
  40. Shirk D (2011b) The drug war in Mexico: confronting a shared threat. Council on Foreign Relations Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  41. Skaperdas S (2001) The political economy of organized crime: providing protection when the state does not. Econ Gov 2(3):173–202CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Skarbek D (2011) Governance and prison gangs. Am Polit Sci Rev 105:702–716CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Snyder R, Duran-Martinez A (2009) Does illegality breed violence? Drug trafficking and state-sponsored protection rackets. Crime Law Soc Change 52(3):253–273CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Sullivan J (2012) Criminal insurgency: Narcocultura, social banditry, and information operations. Small Wars J 3(4):30Google Scholar
  45. Sung H (2004) State failure, economic failure, and predatory organized crime: a comparative analysis. J Res Crime Delinq 41(2):111–129CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Tiernay M (2013) Killing Kony leadership change and civil war termination. J Confl Resolut (in press).
  47. Tita G, Radil S (2011) Spatializing the social networks of gangs to explore patterns of violence. J Quant Criminol 27(4):1–25Google Scholar
  48. Turbiville G (2007) Private security infrastructure abroad: Criminal-terrorist agendas and the operational environment. Technical report, DTIC DocumentGoogle Scholar
  49. Turbiville G (2010) Firefights, raids, and assassinations: tactical forms of cartel violence and their underpinnings. Small Wars Insurg 21(1):123–144CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Varese F (2005) The Russian Mafia: private protection in a new market economy. Oxford University Press, USAGoogle Scholar
  51. Villarreal A (2002) Political competition and violence in mexico: hierarchical social control in local patronage structures. Am Sociolog Rev 67:477–498Google Scholar
  52. Williams P (2012) The debate over mexican drug trafficking violence. Terror Polit Violence 24(2):259–278CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Wilner A (2010) Targeted killings in Afghanistan: measuring coercion and deterrence in counterterrorism and counterinsurgency. Stud Confl Terror 33(4):307–329CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Political ScienceDuke UniversityDurhamUSA

Personalised recommendations