Journal of Quantitative Criminology

, Volume 21, Issue 4, pp 439–466 | Cite as

A Meta-Analysis of Race and Sentencing Research: Explaining the Inconsistencies

  • Ojmarrh MitchellEmail author


Numerous studies have addressed the question: Are African-Americans treated more harshly than similarly situated whites? This research employs meta-analysis to synthesize this body of research. One-hundred-sixteen statistically independent contrasts were coded from 71 published and unpublished studies. Coded study and contextual features are used to explain variation in research findings. Analyses indicate that African-Americans generally are sentenced more harshly than whites; the magnitude of this race effect is statistically significant but small and highly variable. Larger estimates of unwarranted disparity are found in contrasts that examine drug offenses, imprisonment or discretionary decisions, do not pool cases from several smaller jurisdictions, utilize imprecise measures, or omit key variables. Yet, even when consideration is confined to those contrasts employing key controls and precise measures of key variables, unwarranted racial disparities persists. Further, a substantial proportion of variability in study results is explained by study factors, particularly methodological factors.


race and sentencing meta-analysis racial discrimination sentencing research 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Albonetti, C. 1997Sentencing under the federal sentencing guidelines: Effects of defendant characteristics, guilty pleas, and departures on sentence outcomes for drug offenses, 1991–1992Law Soc. Rev.31789822Google Scholar
  2. Albonetti, C. A. 1990Race and the probability of pleading guiltyJ. Quant. Criminol.6315334Google Scholar
  3. Begg, C. B. 1994Publication biasCooper, H.Hedges, L. V. eds. The Handbook of Research SynthesisRussell Sage FoundationNew York399408Google Scholar
  4. Belenko, S., Fagan, J., Chin, K. L. 1991Criminal justice responses to crackJ. Res. Crime Delinq.285574Google Scholar
  5. Bernstein, I. N., Kelly, W. R., Doyle, P. A. 1977Societal reaction to deviants: The case of criminal defendantsAm. Sociol. Rev.42743755PubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Blalock, H. 1967Toward a Theory of Minority-Group RelationsWileyNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  7. Bridges, G. S., Crutchfield, R. D. 1988Law, social standing and racial disparities in imprisonmentSocial Forces66699724Google Scholar
  8. Chiricos, T. 1996Moral panic as ideology: Race, drugs, violence and punishment in AmericaLynch, M. J.Patterson, E. B. eds. Justice with Prejudice: Race and Justice in AmericaHarrow and HestonAlbany, NY1949Google Scholar
  9. Chiricos, T. G., Bales, W. D. 1991Unemployment and punishment: An empirical assessmentCriminology29701724Google Scholar
  10. Chiricos, T. G., Crawford, C. 1995Race and imprisonment: A contextual assessment of the evidenceHawkins, D. F. eds. Ethnicity, Race, and Crime: Perspectives across Time and PlaceState University of New York PressAlbany, NY281309Google Scholar
  11. Crawford, C., Chiricos, T., Kleck, G. 1998Race, racial threat, and sentencing of habitual offendersCriminology36481511Google Scholar
  12. Engen, R. L., Gainey, R. R. 2000Modeling the effects of legally relevant and extralegal factors under sentencing guidelines: The rules have changedCriminology3812071225Google Scholar
  13. Goode, E., Beh-Yehuda, N. 1994Moral Panics: The Social Construction of DevianceBlackwell PublishersCambridge, MAGoogle Scholar
  14. Hagan, J., Bumiller, K. 1983Making sense of sentencing: A review and critique of sentencing researchBlumstein, A.Cohen, J.Martin, S. E.Tonry, M. H. eds. Research on Sentencing: The Search for ReformNational Academy PressWashington, D.C.154Google Scholar
  15. Hagan, J., Nagel, I., Albonetti, C. 1980The differential sentencing of white collar offenders in ten Federal district courtsAm. Sociol. Rev.45802820Google Scholar
  16. Harig, T. J. (1990). The Influence of Extra-Legal Factors in Youthful Offender Adjudications. Unpublished dissertation, State University of New York at Albany.Google Scholar
  17. Hasselblad, V., Hedges, L. V. 1995Meta-Analysis of screening and diagnostic testsPsych. Bull.11716778CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Hawkins, D. F. 1987Beyond anomalies: Rethinking the conflict perspective on race and criminal punishmentSocial Forces65719745Google Scholar
  19. Holmes, M. D., Hosch, H. M., Daudistel, H. C., Perez, D. A., Graves, J. B. 1996Ethnicity, legal resources, and felony disposition in two Southwestern jurisdictionsJustice Quart.131130CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Kleck, G. 1981Racial discrimination in criminal sentencing: A critical evaluation of the evidence with additional evidence on the death penaltyAm. Sociol. Rev.46783805Google Scholar
  21. Kramer, J., Steffensmeier, D. 1993Race and imprisonment decisionsSociol. Quart.34357376CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Lipsey, M. W., Wilson, D. B. 2001Practical Meta-AnalysisSage PublicationsThousand Oaks, CAGoogle Scholar
  23. Mann, C. C. 1994Can meta-analysis make policy?Science266960962PubMedGoogle Scholar
  24. Musto, D. F. 1999The American Disease: Origins of Narcotic Control3Oxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  25. Myers, M. A., Talarico, S. M. 1986The social contexts of racial discrimination in sentencingSocial Problems33236251Google Scholar
  26. Nagin, D., Paternoster, R. 2000Population heterogeneity and state dependence: State of the evidence and directions for future researchJ. Quant. Criminol.16117144CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Nelson, J. F. 1989An operational definition of prior criminal recordJ. Quant. Criminol.5333352CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Nelson, J. F. 1992Hidden disparities in case processing: New York State, 1985–1986J. Crim. Justice20145160Google Scholar
  29. Overton, R. C. 1998A comparison of fixed-effects and mixed (random-effects) models for meta-analysis of moderator variable effectsPsychol. Meth.3354379CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Petersilia, J. 1983Racial Disparities in the Criminal Justice SystemRANDSanta Monica, CAGoogle Scholar
  31. Pratt, T. C. 1998Race and sentencing: A meta-analysis of conflicting empirical research resultsJ. Crim. Justice2651323CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Pruitt, C. R., Wilson, J. Q. 1983A longitudinal study of the effect of race and sentencingLaw Soc. Rev.1761335Google Scholar
  33. Raudenbush, S. W. 1994Random effects modelsCooper, H.Hedges, L. V. eds. The Handbook of Research SynthesisRussell Sage FoundationNew York302321Google Scholar
  34. Sampson, R. J., Laub, J. H. 1993Structural variations in juvenile court processing: Inequality, the underclass, and social controlLaw Soc. Rev.27285311Google Scholar
  35. Spohn, C. 2000Thirty years of sentencing reform: The quest for a racially neutral sentencing processHorney, J. eds. Policies, Processes, and Decisions of the Criminal Justice System: Criminal Justice 2000National Institute of JusticeWashington, D.C.427501Google Scholar
  36. Spohn, C., Cederblom, J. 1991Race and disparities in sentencing: A test of the liberation hypothesisJustice Quart.8305327CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Spohn, C., DeLone, M. 2000When does race matter? An analysis of the conditions under which race affects sentence severitySociol. Crime Law Dev.2337Google Scholar
  38. Spohn, C., Holleran, D. 2000The imprisonment penalty paid by young, unemployed black and Hispanic male offendersCriminology38281306Google Scholar
  39. Steffensmeier, D., Ulmer, J., Kramer, J. 1998The interaction of race, gender, and age in criminal sentencing: The punishment cost of being Young, black and maleCriminology36763797Google Scholar
  40. Sterling, T. D., Rosenbaum, W. L., Weinkam, J. J. 1995Publication decisions revisited: The effect of the outcome of statistical tests on the decision to publish and vice versaAm. Statist.49108112Google Scholar
  41. Tonry, M. 1995Malign Neglect: Race, Crime, and Punishment in AmericaOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  42. Tonry, M. 1996Sentencing MattersOxford University PressNew YorkGoogle Scholar
  43. Unnever, J. D. (1980). Direct and Structural Discrimination in the Sentencing Process. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Duke University.Google Scholar
  44. Unnever, J. D., Hembroff, L. A. 1988The prediction of racial/ethnic sentencing disparities: An expectation states approachJ. Res. Crime Delinq.255382Google Scholar
  45. Wang, M. C., Bushman, B. J. 1999Integrating Results through Meta-Analytic Review Using SAS SoftwareSAS Institute, Inc.Cary, NCGoogle Scholar
  46. Welch, S., Gruhl, J., Spohn, C. 1984Sentencing: The influence of alternative measures of prior recordCriminology22215227Google Scholar
  47. Welch, S., Spohn, C., Gruhl, J. 1985Convicting and sentencing differences among black, Hispanic, and white males in six localitiesJustice Quart.26780CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Wilbanks, W. 1987The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice SystemBrooks/ColeMonterey, CAGoogle Scholar
  49. Wooldredge, J. D. 1998Analytical rigor in studies of disparities in criminal case processingJ. Quant. Criminol.14155179CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Zimmerman, S., Frederick, B. 1984Discrimination and the decision to incarcerateGeorges-Abeyie, D. eds. The Criminal Justice System and BlacksClark BoardmanNew York315334Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, Inc. 2005

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Division of Criminal JusticeUniversity of CincinnatiCincinnatiUSA

Personalised recommendations