Although social scientists have been investigating the nature and impact of job satisfaction for many decades, economists only started to investigate job satisfaction systematically in the late 1980′s. Almost from the first systematic studies of job satisfaction by economists, the research potential of the notion of pay level comparisons was realized. The idea of pay level comparisons in job satisfaction has proven particularly useful also because it has important implications for a number of standard theoretical and economic policy results. However, the inclusion of the variable of comparison wage in job satisfaction and the resulting supporting empirical findings, are in sharp contrast to the orthodox approach, given that in mainstream economic theory an individuals’ utility is usually assumed to be a function of absolute income only. Despite the important theoretical and policy implications, mainstream economic theory has not paid much heed to the job satisfaction conceptual formulations and empirical findings. The paper argues that there are methodological reasons for this state of affairs which seem to be linked to the subjective well-being research in general, and to the job satisfaction literature in particular. A strong mistrust against the method of stated preferences and the still inherent methodological bias against the integration of psychological findings, are suggested as the two prime reasons. Although a few prominent figures in job satisfaction research have realized the mainstream methodological attitude, it is necessary that job satisfaction specialists should consider more seriously the methodological limitations of traditional mainstream economics that relate to their research field.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT for USA
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
This is the net price. Taxes to be calculated in checkout.
For a historical account of psychological research on job satisfaction, see Latham and Budworth 2007.
The idea that people compare their incomes with others, has a continuous presence in the history of economics. It can be found for example, in the works of T. Veblen, A.C. Pigou and J. Duesenberry. However, it has not made significant inroads into mainstream theory (for a detailed discussion, see Drakopoulos 2016).
For a discussion of the definition and nature of mainstream economics, see Lawson 2006.
Apart from the economics literature, psychological studies have also identified a number of crucial job satisfaction determinants such as salary, job autonomy, opportunities for promotion, quality of supervision, and good working conditions (e.g. Barling et al. 2003).
A representative statement in this respect can be found in Robert Frank: “In traditional economic models, individual utility depends only on absolute consumption. These models lie at the heart of claims that pursuit of individual self-interest promotes aggregate welfare.” (Frank 2005: 137).
It is also interesting to note that the authors point out that economists have paid little attention to the relevant psychological findings (Caplin and Leahy 2001: 55).
The case of corrective taxes is also weakened in the framework of mental goods and bads (for a detailed discussion, see Ho 2016).
In more technical terms: The additional tax paid by an individual who does an extra hour of work should equal the money value of the harm done to others in terms of status. It is also worth noticing that in the extreme case where net income is not valued for its own sake at all and all persons have the same wage, the optimal marginal tax is unity (for a detailed discussion, see Layard 1980: 738–739).
I am grateful for this point to an anonymous referee.
For other types of defense of mainstream economics against the “attacks” by behavioural economists and psychologists, see McKenzie 2010.
Adams, J. S. (1963). Towards an understanding of inequity. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology,67, 422–436.
Adams, J. S. (1965). Inequity in social exchange. In L. Berkowitz (Ed.), Advances in experimental social psychology (Vol. 2, pp. 267–299). New York: Academic Press.
Akerlof, G. (1997). Social distance and social decisions. Econometrica,65, 1005–1027.
Akerlof, G. A., Rose, A. K., Yellen, J. L., Ball, L., & Hall, R. E. (1988). Job switching and job satisfaction in the US labor market. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,2, 495–594.
Argyle, M. (1989). The social psychology of work. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Barling, J., Kelloway, E. K., & Iverson, R. D. (2003). High: Quality work, job satisfaction and occupational injuries. Journal of Applied Psychology,88, 276–283.
Berg, N. (2003). Normative behavioral economics. Journal of Socio-Economics,32, 411–427.
Berg, N. (2006). Behavioral Labor Economics. In M. Altman (Ed.), Hand book of contemporary behavioral economics (pp. 457–478). New York: M.E. Sharpe.
Bertrand, M., & Mullainathan, S. (2001). Do people mean what they say? Implications for subjective survey data. American Economic Review,91, 67–72.
Binmore, K. (1999). Why experiment in economics? Economic Journal,109, F16–F24.
Blanchflower, D., & Oswald, A. (2004). Well-being over time in Britain and the USA. Journal of Public Economics,88, 1359–1386.
Blinder, A. (1991). Why are prices sticky? Preliminary results from an interview study. American Economic Review,81, 89–96.
Böckerman, P., & Ilmakunnas, P. (2008). Interaction of working conditions, job satisfaction, and sickness absences: Evidence from a representative sample of employees. Social Science and Medicine,67, 520–528.
Bok, D. (2011). The politics of happiness: What government can learn from the new research on well-being. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Bonsang, E., & Van Soest, A. (2012). Satisfaction with job and income among older individuals across European countries. Social Indicators Research,105(2), 227–254.
Borjas, G. J. (1979). Job satisfaction, wages and unions. Journal of Human Resources,14, 21–40.
Boulier, B., & Goldfarb, R. (1998). On the use and nonuse of surveys in economics. Journal of Economic Methodology,5, 1–21.
Boyce, C., Brown, G. D. A., & Moore, S. (2010). Money and happiness: Rank of income, not income, affects life satisfaction. Psychological Science,21, 471–475.
Bridges, J. (2003). Stated preference methods in health care evaluation: an emerging methodological paradigm in health economics. Applied Health Economics and Health Policy,2, 213–224.
Brown, G., Gordon, D., Gardner, J., Oswald, A., & Qian, J. (2008). Does wage rank affect employees’ wellbeing? Industrial Relations,47, 355–389.
Bruni, L., & Sugden, R. (2007). The road not taken: How psychology was removed from economics, and how it might be brought back. The Economic Journal,117, 146–173.
Bryson, A., Barth, E., & Dale-Olsen, H. (2012). Do higher wages come at a price? Journal of Economic Psychology,33, 251–263.
Bygren, M. (2004). Pay reference standards and pay satisfaction: what do workers evaluate their pay against? Social Science Research,33, 206–224.
Caplin, A., & Leahy, J. (2001). Psychological expected utility and anticipatory feelings. Quarterly Journal of Economics,116, 55–80.
Cappelli, P., & Sherer, P. D. (1988). Satisfaction, market wages and labour relations: An airline study. Industrial Relations,27, 56–73.
Card, D., Mas, A., Moretti, E., & Saez, E. (2012). Inequality at work: The effect of peer salaries on job satisfaction. American Economic Review,102, 2981–3003.
Clark, A. (1996). ‘L’utilité est-elle relative? Analyse à l’aide de données sur les ménages’. Economie et Prévision,121, 151–164.
Clark, A. (1997). Job satisfaction and gender: Why are women so happy at work? Labour Economics,4, 341–372.
Clark, A. (2001). What really matters in a job? Hedonic measurement using quit data. Labour Economics,8, 223–242.
Clark, A., Kristensen, N., & Westergaard-Nielsen, N. (2009). Job satisfaction and co-worker wages: Status or signal? Economic Journal,119, 430–447.
Clark, A., & Oswald, A. (1996). Satisfaction and comparison income. Journal of Public Economics,61, 359–381.
Clark, A., & Senik, C. (2010). ‘Who compares to whom? The anatomy of income comparisons in Europe. Economic Journal,120, 573–594.
Clark, A., & Senik, C. (2014). Income comparisons in China. In A. Clark & C. Senik (Eds.), Happiness and economic growth: Lessons from developing countries (pp. 216–239). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Davis, J. B. (2003). The theory of the individual in economics: Identity and value. London: Routledge.
Davis, J. B. (2010). Individuals and identity in economics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Davis, L. (2018) Growth, inequality and tunnel effects: A formal mode. Journal of Happiness Studies. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10902-018-9991-1.
Di Tella, R., Haisken De-New, J., & MacCulloch, R. (2010). Happiness adaptation to income and to status in an individual panel. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,76, 834–852.
Dow, S. (2002). Economic methodology: An inquiry. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Drakopoulos, S. (2016). Comparisons in economic thought: Economic interdependency reconsidered. London: Routledge.
Drakopoulos, S., & Grimani, K. (2013). Injury: Related absenteeism and job satisfaction: Insights from Greek and UK data. The International Journal of Human Resource Management,24, 3496–3511.
Drakopoulos, S., & Katselidis, I. (2015). From edgeworth to econophysics: A methodological perspective. Journal of Economic Methodology,22, 77–95.
Drakopoulos, S., & Theodossiou, I. (1997). Job Satisfaction and target earnings. Journal of Economic Psychology,18, 694–704.
Easterlin, R. (2004). The reluctant economist: Perspectives on economics. Economic History and Demography, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Fafchamps, M., & Shilpi, F. (2008). Subjective welfare, isolation and relative consumption. Economic Development and Cultural Change,88, 83–60.
Fehr, E., & Schmidt, K. (2006). The economics of fairness, reciprocity and altruism-Experimental evidence and new theories. In S. Kolm & J. M. Ythier (Eds.), Handbook of the economics of giving, altruism and reciprocity (pp. 615–684). Oxford: North-Holland.
Ferrer-i-Carbonell, A. (2005). Income and well-being: An empirical analysis of the comparison income effect. Journal of Public Economics,89, 997–1019.
Fisher, I. (1892)  Mathematical Investigations in the Theory of Value and Prices, New Haven: Yale University Press.
Fourcade, M., Ollion, E., & Algan, Y. (2015). The superiority of economists. Journal of Economic Perspectives,29, 89–114.
Frank, R. (2005). Positional externalities cause large and preventable welfare losses. American Economic Review,95(2), 137–141.
Frank, R. (2008). Should public policy respond to positional externalities? Journal of Public Economics,92, 1777–1786.
Frantz, R. (Ed.). (2009). Renaissance in behavioral economics: Essays in honour of Harvey Leibenstein. London: Routledge.
Freeman, R. B. (1978). Job satisfaction as an economic variable. American Economic Review,68, 135–141.
Frey, B. (2008). Happiness: A revolution in economics. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Frey, B. (2018). Economics and Well-Being. In V. Zeigler-Hill & T. K. Shackelford (Eds.), The SAGE handbook of personality and individual differences (pp. 552–567). London: SAGE Publication Ltd.
Frey, B., & Benz, M. (2004). From Imperialism to inspiration: A survey of economics and psychology. In J. Davis, A. Marciano, & J. Runde (Eds.), The Elgar companion to economics and philosophy (pp. 61–83). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Gao, W., & Smyth, R. (2010). ‘Job satisfaction and relative income in economic transition: Status or signal? The case of urban China. China Economic Review,21, 442–455.
Godeshot, O., & Senik, C. (2015). Wage comparisons in and out of the firm. Evidence from a matched employer-employee French database. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization,117, 395–410.
Goodwin, C. (2016). Economics and psychology: Why the great divide? History of Political Economy,48(suppl. 1), 71–169.
Hagerty, M. (2000). Social comparisons of income in one’s community: Evidence from national surveys of income and happiness. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,78, 764–771.
Hamermesh, D. (1977). Economic aspects of job satisfaction. In O. Ashenfelter & W. Oates (Eds.), Essays in labor market analysis (pp. 53–72). Toronto: John Wiley and Son.
Hamermesh, D. (2001). The changing distribution of job satisfaction. Human Resources,36, 1–30.
Hands, W. (2010). Economics, psychology, and the history of consumer choice theory. Cambridge Journal of Economics,34(4), 633–648.
Hauret, L., & Williams, D. R. (2017). Relative income and pay satisfaction: Further evidence on the role of the reference group’. Journal of Happiness Studies. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10902-017-9950-2.
Heffetz, O., & Frank, R. (2011). Preferences for status: Evidence and economic implications. In J. Benhabib, A. Bisin, & M. Jackson (Eds.), Handbook of social economics (Vol. 1A, pp. 69–91). Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Hirschman, A. O., & Rothschild, M. (1973). The changing tolerance for income inequality in the course of economic development. Quarterly Journal of Economics,87, 544–566.
Ho, L. S. (2016). The psychology and economics of happiness: Love, life and positive living. London: Routledge.
Homans, G. (1961). Social behaviour: Its elementary forms. New York: Harcourt Brace.
Hopkins, E., & Kornienko, T. (2004). Running to keep in the same place: Consumer choice as a game of status. American Economic Review,94, 1085–1107.
Hyman, H. (1942). The psychology of status. Archives of Psychology,38(269), 147–165.
Ireland, N. (1998). Status-seeking, income taxation and efficiency. Journal of Public Economics,70, 99–113.
Ireland, N. (2001). Optimal income tax in the presence of status effects. Journal of Public Economics,81, 193–212.
Judge, T., Weiss, H., Kammeyer-Mueller, J., & Hulin, C. (2017). Job attitudes, job satisfaction, and job affect: A century of continuity and of change. Journal of Applied Psychology,102(3), 356–374.
Kifle, T. (2014). Do comparison wages play a major role in determining overall job satisfaction? Evidence from Australia. Journal of Happiness Studies,15, 613–638.
Knight, J., & Gunatilaka, R. (2011). Income, aspirations and the hedonic treadmill in a poor society. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,82, 67–81.
Latham, G. P., & Budworth, M. H. (2007). The study of work motivation in the 20th century. In L. L. Koppes (Ed.), Historical perspectives in industrial and organizational psychology (pp. 353–381). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Lawson, T. (2006). The nature of heterodox economics. Cambridge Journal of Economics,30(4), 483–505.
Layard, R. (1980). Human satisfactions and public policy. Economic Journal,90, 737–750.
Layard, R. (2006). Happiness and public policy: A challenge to the profession. Economic Journal,116(510), C24–C33.
Lecouteux, G. (2013). Reconciling normative and behavioural economics. Cahier de Recherche, 2013-09, hal-00819763.
Levine, D. (2012). Is behavioral economics doomed? The ordinary versus the extraordinary. Cambridge: Open Book Publishers.
Levitt, S. D., & List, J. A. (2008). Homo economicus evolves. Science,319(5865), 909–910.
Lewin, S. (1996). Economics and psychology: Lessons for our own day from the early Twentieth Century. Journal of Economic Literature,XXXIV, 1293–1323.
List, J., Berrens, R., Bohara, A., & Kerkvliet, J. (2004). Examining the role of social isolation on stated preferences. The American Economic Review,94(3), 741–752.
Locke, E. A. (1976). The Nature and Causes of Job Satisfaction. In M. Dunnette (Ed.), Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology (pp. 1297–1349). Chicago: Rand McNally.
Manski, C. (2004). Measuring expectations. Econometrica,72, 1329–1376.
McBride, M. (2001). Relative-income effects on subjective well-being in the cross-section. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,45, 251–278.
McKenzie, R. (2010). Predictably rational? In search of defences for rational behavior in economics. Dordrecht: Springer.
McLure, M. (2010). Pareto and Pigou on ophelimity, utility and welfare: Implications for public finance. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought,17, 635–657.
Miller, P. (1990). Trade unions and job satisfaction. Australian Economic Papers,29, 226–248.
Montero, R., & Vasquez, D. (2015). Job satisfaction and reference wages: Evidence for a developing country. Journal of Happiness Studies,16, 1493–1507.
Ng, Y.-K. (1987). Diamonds are a government’s best friend: Burden-free taxes on goods valued for their values. American Economic Review,77(1), 186–191.
Ng, Y.-K. (2003). From preference to happiness: Towards a more complete welfare economics. Social Choice and Welfare,20, 307–350.
Ott, J. (2011). Government and happiness in 130 nations: Good governance fosters higher level and more equality of happiness. Social Indicators Research,102, 3–22.
Pareto V. (1906)  Manual of political economy, (A. Schrier, Trans.). London: Macmillan.
Pearce, D. (2002). An intellectual history of environmental economics. Annual Review of Energy and the Environment,27, 57–81.
Postlewaite, A. (2011). Social norms and preferences. In J. Benhabib, A. Bisin, & M. Jackson (Eds.), Handbook of social economics (Vol. 1A, ch2, pp. 31–67). Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Powdthavee, N. (2007). Economics of happiness: A review of literature and applications. Chulalongkorn Journal of Economics,19(1), 51–73.
Powdthavee, N. (2009). How important is rank to individual perception of economic standing? A within community analysis. Journal of Economic Inequality,7, 225–248.
Rabin, M. (2002). A perspective on psychology and economics. European Economic Review,46, 657–685.
Robbins, L. (1932). An essay on the nature and significance of economic science. London: Macmillan.
Ross, D. (2014). Philosophy of economics. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Runciman, W. G. (1966). Relative deprivation and social justice. Henley: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Samuelson, P. (1938). A note on the pure theory of consumer’s behaviour. Economica,5, 61–71.
Samuelson, P. (1947)  Foundations of economic analysis, Cambridge (Mass.): Harvard University Press.
Sen, A. (2002). Rationality and freedom. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Senik, C. (2004). When information dominates comparison. Learning from Russian subjective panel data. Journal of Public Economics,88, 2099–2133.
Senik, C. (2008). Ambition and jealousy: Income interactions in the “Old Europe” versus the “New Europe” and the United States. Economica,75, 495–513.
Senik, C. (2009). Direct evidence on income comparisons and their welfare effects. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization,72, 408–424.
Sent, E.-M. (2004). Behavioral economics: how psychology made its (limited) way back into economics. History of Political Economy,36, 735–760.
Shields, M., & Price, S. (2002). Racial harassment, job satisfaction and intentions to quit: Evidence from British Nursing profession. Economica,69, 295–362.
Sloane, P., & Ward, M. (2001). Cohort effects and job satisfaction of academics. Applied Economics Letters,8, 787–791.
Sloane, P. J., & Williams, H. (2000). Job satisfaction, comparison earnings and gender. Labor,14, 473–502.
Sobel, J. (2005). Interdependent preferences and reciprocity. Journal of Economic Literature,XLIII, 392–436.
Sousa-Poza, A., & Sousa-Poza, A. (2000). Well-being at work: a cross-national analysis of the levels and determinants of job satisfaction. Journal of Socio-economics,29, 517–538.
Spector, P. E. (1997). Job satisfaction: application, assessment, causes and consequences. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
Stewart, N., Chater, N., & Brown, G. D. A. (2006). Decision by sampling. Cognitive Psychology,53(1), 1–26.
Stigler, G., & Becker, G. (1977). De gustibus non est disputandum. The American Economic Review,67, 76–90.
Theodossiou, I. & Panos, G. (2007) Earnings aspirations and job satisfaction: The affective and cognitive impact of earnings comparisons. University of Aberdeen Centre for European Labour Market Research, No 2007-1 (pp. 1–38).
Van Praag, B. (1991). Ordinal and cardinal utility: An Integration of the two dimensions of the welfare concept. Journal of Econometrics,50, 69–89.
Van Praag, B. (2011). Well-being inequality and reference groups: An agenda for new research. The Journal of Economic Inequality,9, 111–127.
Van Praag, B., & Ferrer-i-Carbonel, A. (2004). Happiness quantified: A satisfaction calculus approach. New York: Oxford University Press.
Warr, P. B. (2007). Work, happiness, and unhappiness. New York: Routledge.
Zouboulakis, M. (2014). The varieties of economic rationality. London: Routledge.
The author wishes to thank Prof. Y. Venieris and two anonymous referees of this Journal for useful comments and suggestions. The usual disclaimer applies.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Drakopoulos, S.A. Pay Level Comparisons in Job Satisfaction Research and Mainstream Economic Methodology. J Happiness Stud 21, 825–842 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10902-019-00111-z
- Job satisfaction
- Pay level comparisons
- Economic methodology