Skip to main content
Log in

Visible Minorities and Job Mobility: Evidence from a Workplace Panel Survey

  • Published:
The Journal of Economic Inequality Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

We use Canadian linked employer-employee data to examine whether visible minority Canadian-borns experience any differences in their inter-firm and intra-firm job mobility, as well as wage returns associated with them, compared to white Canadian-borns. Our results suggest that both male and female visible minority Canadian-borns experience substantial differences in probability of promotion, number of times promoted, and wage returns to promotions, compared to their white peers. For male visible minorities, these differences with their white peers mainly operate within firms. For female visible minorities however, almost half of the gap is driven by their crowding into firms with fewer promotion opportunities. In terms of inter-firm mobility, while male visible minorities are similarly likely to move between firms compared to their white peers, female visible minorities are less likely to change employer. Both groups however receive similar wage returns to their inter-firm mobility compared to their white peers. This seems to suggest that lower chances for upward mobility within firms do not translate into more inter-firm mobility or higher returns to inter-firm mobility for visible minorities. We find no evidence that these differences in intra-firm mobility could be driven by differences in hierarchical level, career path, or immigration background. Labour market discrimination however remains a potential contributor to these differences, which is also consistent with some of our findings. Our results also suggest that for female visible minorities, different family responsibilities driven potentially by different cultural norms or family dynamics could also contribute to these differences.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Abowd, J.M., Kramarz, F., Margolis, D.N.: High wage workers and high wage firms. Econometrica. 67(2), 251–334 (1999)

  • Adsera, A., Chiswick, B.R.: Are there gender and country of origin differences in immigrant labour market outcomes across European destinations? J. Popul. Econ. 20(3), 495–526 (2007)

  • Aeberhardt, R., & Pouget, J. (2007). National origin wage differentials in france: Evidence from matched employer-employee data IZA Discussion Paper No. 2779

  • Akbari, A.: Ethnicity and earnings discrimination in canadian labour markets: Some evidence from the 1986 census. Multiculturalism and Citizenship, Ottawa (1992)

  • Akerlof, G.A., Rose, A.K., Yellen, J.L., Ball, L., Hall, R.E.: Job switching and job satisfaction in the US labour market. Brook. Pap. Econ. Act. 1988(2), 495–594 (1988)

  • Albrecht, J., Bjorklund, A., Vroman, S.: Is there a glass ceiling in Sweden? J. Labour Econ. 21(1), 145–177 (2003)

  • Algan, Y., Dustmann, C., Glitz, A., Manning, A.: The economic situation of first and second-generation immigrants in France, Germany and the United Kingdom. Econ. J. 120(542), (2010)

  • Altonji, J.G., Blank, R.M.: Race and gender in the labour market. Handb. Labor Econ. 3, 3143–3259 (1999)

  • Baker, M., Benjamin, D.: Ethnicity, foreign birth and earnings: A Canada/US comparison. Transit. Struct. Chang. N. Am. Labour Market. 281–313 (1997)

  • Baldwin, J.: The promotion record of the United States Army: glass ceilings in the officer corps. Public Adm. Rev. 56(2), 199–206 (1996)

  • Bauer, T., Zimmermann, K.F.: Unemployment and wages of ethnic Germans. Q. Rev. Econ. Financ. 37, 361–377 (1997)

  • Bell, B.D.: The performance of immigrants in the United Kingdom: evidence from the GHS. Econ. J. 107(441), 333–344 (1997)

  • Bellemore, F.A.: Racial and ethnic employment discrimination: promotion in Major League Baseball. J. Sports Econ. 2(4), 356–368 (2001)

  • Bertrand, M., Mullainathan, S.: Are Emily and Greg more employable than Lakisha and Jamal? A field experiment on labour market discrimination. Am. Econ. Rev. 94(4), 991–1013 (2004)

  • Blackaby, D.H., Leslie, D.G., Murphy, P.D., O'Leary, N.C.: Born in britain: how are native ethnic minorities faring in the British labour market? Econ. Lett. 88(3), 370–375 (2005)

  • Blau, F.D., DeVaro, J.: New evidence on gender differences in promotion rates: an empirical analysis of a sample of new hires. Ind. Relat. J. Econ. Soc. 46(3), 511–550 (2007)

  • Booth, A.L., Francesconi, M., Garcia-Serrano, C.: Job tenure and job mobility in Britain. ILR Rev. 53(1), 43–70 (1999)

  • Booth, A., Francesconi, M., Frank, J.: A sticky floors model of promotion, pay, and gender. Eur. Econ. Rev. 47, 295–322 (2003)

  • Borjas, G.J.: Assimilation, changes in cohort quality, and the earnings of immigrants. J. Labor Econ. 3(4), 463–489 (1985)

  • Borjas, G.J.: National origin and the skills of immigrants in the postwar period. In: Borjas, G.J., Freeman, R.B. (eds.) Immigration and the workforce: Economic consequences for the United States and source areas, pp. 17–48. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1992)

  • Brewer, R.M., Conrad, C.A., King, M.C.: The complexities and potential of theorizing gender, caste, race, and class. Fem. Econ. 8(2), 3–17 (2002)

  • Browne, I., Misra, J.: The intersection of gender and race in the labor market. Annu. Rev. Sociol. 29(1), 487–513 (2003)

  • Cain, G.G.: The economic analysis of labour market discrimination: a survey. Handb. Labour Econ. 1, 693–785 (1986)

  • Carlsson, M., Rooth, D.O.: Evidence of ethnic discrimination in the Swedish labour market using experimental data. Labour Econ. 14(4), 716–729 (2007)

  • Cassidy, H., DeVaro, J., Kauhanen, A.: The signaling role of promotions: New evidence from european firms. Mimeo, Department of Economics, California State University, East Bay (2012)

  • Chiswick, B.R.: The earnings of white and coloured male immigrants in Britain. Economica. 47(185), 81–87 (1980)

  • Chiswick, B.R.: Is the new immigration less skilled than the old? J. Labour Econ. 4(2), 168–192 (1986)

  • Cobb-Clark, D.A.: Getting ahead: The determinants of and payoffs to internal promotion for young U.S. men and women. In: Polachek, S. (ed.) Gender Convergence in the Labor Market (Research in Labour Economics, Volume 20), pp. 339–372. Emerald Bingley, UK (2001)

  • de Silva, A., Doherty, C.: Discrimination against visible minority men. Human Resources Development Canada, Applied Research Branch, Strategic Policy Human Resources. Development Canada (1996)

  • Dustmann, C., Theodoropoulos, N.: Ethnic minority immigrants and their children in Britain. Oxf. Econ. Pap. 62(2), 209–233 (2010)

  • Farber, H.S.: The analysis of inter-firm worker mobility. J. Labour Econ. 12(4), 554–593 (1994)

  • Francesconi, M.: Determinants and consequences of promotions in Britain. Oxf. Bull. Econ. Stat. 63(3), 279–310 (2001)

  • Freeman, R.B.: Job satisfaction as an economic variable. Am. Econ. Rev. 68(2), 135–141 (1978)

  • Fuligni, A.J., Tseng, V., Lam, M.: Attitudes toward family obligations among American adolescents with Asian, Latin American, and European backgrounds. Child Dev. 70(4), 1030–1044 (1999)

  • Heath, A.F., Cheung, S.Y.: Unequal chances: Ethnic minorities in western labour markets. Published for The British Academy by Oxford University Press vol. 137 Oxford, UK: Oxford Univ. Press(2007)

  • Hou, F., Coulombe, S.: Earnings gaps for Canadian-born visible minorities in the public and private sectors. Can. Public Policy. 36(1), 29–43 (2010)

  • Howland, J., Sakellariou, C.: Wage discrimination, occupational segregation and visible minorities in Canada. Appl. Econ. 25(11), 1413–1422 (1993)

  • Hum, D., Simpson, W.: The legacy of immigration: labour market performance and education in the second generation. Appl. Econ. 39(15), 1985–2009 (2007)

  • Grieco, E. M., et al.: The size, place of birth, and geographic distribution of the foreign-born population in the United States: 1960 to 2010. US Census Bureau, Population Division (2012).

  • Javdani, M.: Glass ceilings or glass doors? The role of firms in male-female wage disparities. Can. J. Econ. 48(2), 529–560 (2015)

  • Javdani, M., McGee, A.: Moving up or falling behind? Gender, promotions, and wages in Canada. Industrial Relations: J. Econ. Soc. 58(2), 189–228 (2019)

  • Judge, T.A., Thoresen, C.J., Bono, J.E., Patton, G.K.: The job satisfaction–job performance relationship: a qualitative and quantitative review. Psychol. Bull. 127(3), 376–407 (2001)

  • Kahn, L.M.: Discrimination in professional sports: a survey of the literature. ILR Rev. 44(3), 395–418 (1991)

  • Kosteas, V.D.: Job level changes and wage growth. Int. J. Manpow. 30(3), 269–284 (2009)

  • Koys, D.J.: The effects of employee satisfaction, organizational citizenship behavior, and turnover on organizational effectiveness: a unit-level, longitudinal study. Pers. Psychol. 54(1), 101–114 (2001)

  • Kunze, A. (2015). The family gap in career progression. NHH Dept. of Economics Discussion Paper, Res. Labor Econ vol. 41,115–142

  • Landau, J.: The relationship of race and gender to managers' ratings of promotion potential. J. Organ. Behav. 16(4), 391–400 (1995)

  • Mangione, T.W., Quinn, R.P.: Job satisfaction, counterproductive behavior, and drug use at work. J. Appl. Psychol. 60(1), 114–116 (1975)

  • McEvoy, G.M., Cascio, W.F.: Strategies for reducing employee turnover: a meta-analysis. J. Appl. Psychol. 70(2), 342–353 (1985)

  • Milgrom, P., Oster, S.: Job discrimination, market forces, and the invisibility hypothesis. Q. J. Econ. 102(3), 453–476 (1987)

  • Munasinghe, L., Sigman, K.: A hobo syndrome? Mobility, wages, and job turnover. Labour Econ. 11(2), 191–218 (2004)

  • Oreopoulosa, P.: Why do skilled immigrants struggle in the labour market? A field experiment with thirteen thousand resumes. Am. Econ. J. Econ. Pol. 3(4), 148–171 (2011)

  • Parrado, E., Caner, A., Wolff, E.N.: Occupational and industrial mobility in the United States. Labour Econ. 14(3), 435–455 (2007)

  • Patterson, M., Warr, P., West, M.: Organizational climate and company productivity: the role of employee affect and employee level. J. Occup. Organ. Psychol. 77(2), 193–216 (2004)

  • Paulin, E.A., Mellor, J.M.: Gender, race, and promotions within a private-sector firm. Ind. Relat. J. Econ. Soc. 35(2), 276–295 (1996)

  • Pendakur, K., Pendakur, R.: The colour of money: earnings differentials among ethnic groups in Canada. Can. J. Econ. 31, 518–548 (1998)

  • Pendakur, K., Pendakur, R.: Colour my world: have earnings gaps for Canadian-born ethnic minorities changed over time? Can. Public Policy. 28(4), 489–512 (2002)

  • Pendakur, K., Woodcock, S.: Glass ceilings or glass doors? Wage disparity within and between firms. J. Bus. Econ. Stat. 28(1), 181–189 (2010)

  • Pergamit, M.R., Veum, J.R.: What is a promotion? ILR Rev. 52(4), 581–601 (1999)

  • Pudney, S., Shields, M.: Gender, race, pay and promotion in the British nursing profession: estimation of a generalized ordered probit model. J. Appl. Econ. 367–399 (2000a)

  • Pudney, S., Shields, M.A.: Gender and racial discrimination in pay and promotion for NHS nurses. Oxf. Bull. Econ. Stat. 62(s1), 801–835 (2000b)

  • Schmidt, C.M.: Immigrant performance in Germany: labour earnings of ethnic German migrants and foreign guest-workers. Q. Rev. Econ. Financ. 37, 379–397 (1997)

  • Silberman, R., Fournier, I.. Is French society truly assimilative? Immigrant parents and offspring on the French labour market. In Proceedings-British Academy vol. 1(137), pp 221–270. Oxford University Press (2007)

  • Skuterud, M.: The visible minority earnings gap across generations of Canadians. Can. J. Econ. 43(3), 860–881 (2010)

  • Statistics Canada: Projections of the diversity of the Canadian population. The Daily, March 9 (http://www.statcan.gc.ca/daily-quotidien/100309/dq100309a-eng.htm) (2010). Accessed 18 Feb 2020

  • Statistics Canada.Visible minority of person https://www23.statcan.gc.ca/imdb/p3Var.pl?Function=DEC&Id=45152 (2015). Accessed 18 Feb 2020

  • Swidinsky, R., Swidinsky, M.: The relative earnings of visible minorities in Canada: new evidence from the 1996 census. Ind. Relat. 630–659 (2002)

  • Topel, R.H., Ward, M.P.: Job mobility and the careers of young men. Q. J. Econ. 107(2), 439–479 (1992)

  • Trejo, S.J.: Why do Mexican Americans earn low wages? J. Polit. Econ. 105(6), 1235–1268 (1997)

  • Yee, R.W., Yeung, A.C., Cheng, T.E.: The impact of employee satisfaction on quality and profitability in high-contact service industries. J. Oper. Manag. 26(5), 651–668 (2008)

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Mohsen Javdani.

Additional information

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Electronic supplementary material

ESM 1

(DOCX 52 kb)

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Javdani, M. Visible Minorities and Job Mobility: Evidence from a Workplace Panel Survey. J Econ Inequal 18, 491–524 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10888-020-09460-9

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10888-020-09460-9

Keywords

JEL Codes

Navigation