LCR polymer
The liquid crystalline resin (LCR) used here is composed of 6-hydroxy-2-naphthoic acid (HNA) and 4-hydroxybenzoic acid (HBA) precursors (Fig. 1), forming a resin of oligomers of a well defined molecular weight terminated with reactive phenylethynyl end-groups. The synthesis of these polymer systems is described in detail elsewhere [11, 12].
When selecting the molecular weight and backbone composition most appropriate for this work, a low melt viscosity was considered as being the main criterion to yield adequate processability as the polymer seems to have intrinsically good wettability. Earlier work [11] has shown that for a given molecular weight LCR polymers with a 50/50 HBA/HNA backbone ratio exhibit the lowest melt viscosity. Thus, for the preparation of the composite material a polymer with a backbone composition of 50/50 mol% HBA/HNA ratio and a molecular weight of 5,000 g/mol was selected. This polymer will be referred to as 50-LCR-5k in the remainder of this work. The polymer was synthesized and ground to powder with particles typically being less than 0.5 mm in diameter. A molecular weight of 5,000 g/mol was selected as this combines a low enough viscosity, good final mechanical properties and a sufficient number of reactive end groups to form both a strong network and an excellent adhesion to the PZT particles.
In addition, an LCR variant with a higher molecular weight and different backbone structure was selected, in order to have an indication of the effect of matrix variation on composite properties. A 9,000 g/mol polymer with an HBA/HNA ratio of 73/27 was used for this purpose (73-LCR-9k).
PZT powder
The PZT powder used in this research is a pre-sintering powder for PZT5-A4 grade PZT, a ‘soft’ PZT with 1 mol% Nb added as a dopant. The powder was used both in the as received and the calcinated state. The as received PZT-powder is a pre-sintering PZT powder. X-ray diffraction studies revealed that in this powder the calcining reaction, needed to obtain a Perovskite phase, was not fully completed. The XRD spectrum revealed the presence of multiple phases, indicating locally fluctuating solute concentrations of PbZrO3 and PbTiO3. In this work this powder is referred to as PZT. The base powder was further annealed in order to complete the calcining reaction and establish a 100% Perovskite PZT phase and improve the dielectric properties of the PZT powder. The calcination process was performed as follows. An amount of 213 g of as received PZT powder was put in an Al2O3 crucible, covered with ZrO2 plates and placed in a Lint-Elektronik HT-1880 high temperature sintering oven, and annealed for one hour at 1,000 °C. The agglomerated powder was left to cool to room temperature and de-agglomerated by wet milling in cyclohexane for 12 min in a planetary ball mill. The calcinated PZT powder was dried in a vacuum oven at 120 °C for 16 h to remove all remaining cyclohexane and moisture acquired during storage and transport. In this work the post-annealed PZT powder is referred to as PZTc. The particle size distribution of both powders was measured by laser diffraction analysis on a Beckman Coultier LS 230 particle analyzer operating at a laser wavelength of 750 nm. The particle size distribution parameters are listed in Table 1.
Table 1 Typical particle size distribution parameters of as received and calcinated PZT powder
The crystal structural changes due to the calcination process are revealed by X-ray Diffraction (XRD) and are shown in Fig. 2. All diffraction measurements were performed on a Brucker-AXS D5005 diffractometer equipped with an incident beam monochromator and a position sensitive counter. Analysis was conducted using a CuKα1 X-rays (λ = 0.1540562 nm) operated at 40 keV.
The as received powder shows the existence of multiple phases, both with tetragonal and rhombohedral crystal structures. The peaks belonging to rhombohedral crystal structures (i.e. phases with high PbZrO3 content) seem to be predominant. A small amount of pure PbTiO3 (e.g. at 2θ angles of 22.2, 31 and 38.5°) is also present in this powder as well as very small non-Perovskite phase (at a 2θ angle of 28.2°). These observations are all indications that the calcining reaction has not been completed, which is typical for pre-sintering ceramic powder.
The calcination of the PZT powder significantly changed the phase distribution in the material. The rombohedral phase is still clearly present, but the pure PbTiO3 fraction seems to have dissolved and the composition seems to have homogenised further. Figure 2 also contains the diffractogram of the material in its optimally sintered structure, taken from a sample of sintered PZT5-A4, which was ground to a powder. In contrast to the as received and calcinated material the PZT powder in its optimally sintered state has a largely tetragonal crystal structure. This tetragonal phase can only form properly if the PbZrO3 and PbTiO3 phases are fully dissolved. It is a well known fact that the magnitude of the piezoelectric effect in PZT is extremely composition dependent. A 48 mol% (tetragonal) or 54 mol% (rhombohedral) solid solution of PbZrO3 in PbTiO3 exhibit only approximately half of the piezoelectric activity of a 52 mol% PbZrO3 in PbTiO3 solution near the MPB [14]. Hence, although the calcining step certainly raised the piezoelectric properties, further improvement is still possible. However, as the aim of the work was to demonstrate the potential of the PZT-LCR composites, the calcinated PZT powder still served its purpose.
PZT-LCR composites manufacturing
To synthesize these composites, appropriate amounts of PZT powder and LCR powder were weighed using a laboratory balance (Deltarange AG204). These powder mixtures were subsequently mixed in air at 15 °C above melting temperature of the resin in an open 20 cm3 batch mixer powered by a Brabender Plasticorder (model PLE 651) for 5 min, left to cool to room temperature and removed from the mixer. The mixing speed was set at 20 rpm. The composite mixtures were ground to fine powders for further processing. Subsequently, two consolidation routes, route I and route II, were explored, which are shown in Fig. 3. Consolidation route I was derived from earlier measurements on pure LCR resins [11], such that some degree of cross linking was induced in the resin but the degree is such that the polymer maintains a large part of its initial thermoplastic character. Initial pressing attempts resulted in porous films. Therefore, a second high temperature high pressure step was employed to densify the composites. At a temperature of 270 °C the polymer matrix was found to be soft enough to densify under pressure. In consolidation route II, a more technologically relevant pressing cycle was used and the composite powders were dried for 16 h in vacuum at 120 °C before pressing. The composite resin was heated to a higher temperature for a shorter time, leading to a similar degree of cross-linking. Finally, the partly cured composite was subjected to a higher pressure in the densification step. Finally, the cured films, with a typical thicknesses of 200 μm, were cut to shape using a modelling knife, and the edges were smoothened by grinding.
In total six composite variants were produced, with compositions and processing conditions as specified in Table 2.
Table 2 Definition of composite labels, identifying their constituent volume fractions and consolidation routes
The final processing step involves electroding and poling the composite material. Square composite samples (of 5–10 mm side lengths) were electroded by sputtering gold on both sides, leaving a 1 mm border uncovered to inhibit sparking during the poling process. Poling was performed in air at 200 °C by placing the sample on a hot plate and applying the appropriate dc poling voltage for the designated amount of time using a dc high voltage supply (Bertan systems model 205DB-20H). After poling the electric field was removed, the composite was removed from the hot plate and cooled in air to room temperature. Typical poling time was set at 30 min to ascertain maximal poling. No attempts were made to minimise this poling time.
Characterisation techniques
Dielectric characterization
Dielectric spectroscopy was performed using a Novocontrol alpha analyser broadband dielectric spectrometer. Samples were tested in a nitrogen atmosphere in a temperature range of −140 to 250 °C. Composite dielectric constant (ɛ′) and loss factor (ɛ′′) was measured over a frequency range of 0.01 Hz to 3.5 MHz.
Dielectric characterization
The piezoelectric charge constant d
33 was measured at room temperature at a fixed frequency of 110 Hz. Measurements were performed on a piezoelectric d
33 meter (KCF Technologies, model PM3001). The d
33 constant was measured for each sample directly after poling.
Mechanical characterisation
Tensile tests were conducted in a Zwick Roell 20 kN tensile bench fitted with a 1 kN load cell. Six tensile testing samples of each composite (40 mm effective length) were tested, at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/min. The test bench was fitted with rubber grips to ensure uniform stress transfer from the grips to the samples in order to decrease the chance of sample failure at the grips. Both sides of the tensile test sample clamping areas were coated with a 0.5 mm layer of rigid epoxy for the same reason. Therefore, only maximum tensile stress was evaluated, as sample stiffness and elongation at break were not measurable using this test method. Reference samples of pure 50-LCR-5k and 73-LCR-9k polymer were also tested in the same manner.
Dynamic mechanical thermal analysis was performed using a Perkin Elmer Pyris DMTA in a nitrogen atmosphere. A reference sample of pure 50-LCR-5k polymer was also tested. The measurements were performed at 0.1, 1 and 10 Hz, over a temperature range of −100 to 300 °C.