Incentives and Impacts of Vertical Coordination in a Food Production-Marketing Chain: A Non-cooperative Multi-Stage, Multi-Player Analysis

Article

Abstract

Vertical coordination in the form of contracts and integration is common where changing consumer preferences require producers to adapt to changing market situations that require a steady supply of quality controlled products. We identify two vertical coordination mechanisms that are common in the real world but often ignored by the literature due to their inherent complexity. Using economic models, we measure the incentives and impact of market agents’ strategic behavior and strategies along a hypothetical food production-marketing chain. Our results reestablish the importance and value of open market and contracts in a world where both are gradually replaced by consolidation and integration. We also find that in most types of vertical coordination there is a critical limit to the levels of coordination beyond which it is not profitable to coordinate. We recommend that competitive policies could focus more on market structure where independent firms thrive rather than on the degree of coordination per se.

Keywords

Vertical coordination Vertical contract Vertical integration Tapered integration Non-cooperative oligopoly Strategic behavior Production-marketing chain 

JEL Classification

L13 Q13 

Notes

Acknowledgements

Valuable input from Dr. Susan H. Bhuyan on an earlier draft is gratefully acknowledged. This article contributes to NJAES project 02151. The usual disclaimers apply.

Comments and suggestions of anonymous reviewers and the editors have substantially improved this research article, and we are extremely thankful to them.

References

  1. Azzam AM, Pagoulatos E (1990) Testing oligopolistic and oligopsonistic behaviour: an application to the U.S. meat-packing industry. J Agric Econ 41:362–370CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Bhuyan S (2005) Does vertical integration effect market power? Evidence from U.S. food manufacturing industries. J Agric Appl Econ 37:263–276CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Buhr BL, Ginn B (2011) U.S meatpacking: Dynamic forces of change in a mature industry. Choices 26(1)Google Scholar
  4. Carlton DW, Perloff JM (2004) Modern industrial organization, 4th edn. Addison-Wesley-Longman, BostonGoogle Scholar
  5. Carstensen PC (2008) Buyer power, competition policy, and antitrust: the competitive effects of discrimination among suppliers. Antitrust Bulletin 53(2):271–331Google Scholar
  6. Chandler AD (1977) The visible hand: the managerial revolution in American business. Belknap Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  7. Chung C, Tostão E (2012) Effects of horizontal consolidation under bilateral imperfect competition between processors and retailers. Appl Econ 44(26):3379–3389. doi:10.1080/00036846.2011.577013 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Clarke R, Davies SW (1982) Market structure and price-cost margins. Economica 49(19):277–287CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Cotterill RW (2001) Dynamic explanations of industry structure and performance. Br Food J 103(10):679–714CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Frank SD, Henderson DR (1992) Transaction costs as determinants of vertical coordination in the U.S. food industries. Am J Agric Econ 74:941–950CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Gervais J, Lambert R (2010) The simple economics of hog marketing reforms in Quebec. Working Papers 102014, Structure and Performance of Agriculture and Agri-Products Industry (SPAA)Google Scholar
  12. Goodhue RE (2011) Food quality: the design of incentive contracts. Ann Rev Resour Econ 3(1):119–140. doi:10.1146/annurev-resource-040709-135037 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Greenhut ML, Ohta H (1979) Vertical integration of successive oligopolists. Am Econ Rev 69:137–141Google Scholar
  14. Hayenga M, Schroeder T, Lawrence J, Hayes D, Vukina T, Ward C, Purcell W (2000) Meat packer vertical integration and contract linkages in the beef and pork industries: an economic perspective. American Meat Institute, ArlingtonGoogle Scholar
  15. Jang J, Olson F (2010) The role of product differentiation for contract choice in the agro-food sector. Eur Rev Agric Econ 37(2):251–273. doi:10.1093/erae/jbq013 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Knoeber CR, Thurman WN (1995) “Don’t count your chickens...”: risk and risk shifting in the broiler industry. Am J Agric Econ 77(3):486CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Koontz SR, Garcia P (1997) Meat-packer conduct in fed cattle pricing: multiple-market oligopsony power. J Agric Resour Econ 22:87–103Google Scholar
  18. Lusk JL, Marsh TL, Schroeder TC, Fox JA (2001) Wholesale demand for USDA quality graded boxed beef and effects of seasonality. J Agric Resour Econ 26(1):91–106Google Scholar
  19. Martin LL (1997) Production contracts, risk shifting, and relative performance payments in the pork industry. J Agric Appl Econ 29(2):267–278 http://www.saea.org/jaae/jaae.htm CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Martinez SW (2002) A comparison of vertical coordination in the U.S poultry, egg, and pork industries. Agriculture Information Bulletin no720 (no Agriculture Information Bulletin No747–05) Washington DC: U.S Department of Agriculture, Economic Research ServiceGoogle Scholar
  21. Martinez SW (2012) Pork quality and the role of marketing contracts: a case study of the US pork industry. Br Food J 114(3):302–317. doi:10.1108/00070701211213438 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Parcell JL (2003) An empirical analysis of the demand for wholesale pork primals: seasonality and structural change. J Agric Resour Econ 28(2):335–348Google Scholar
  23. Parcell JL, Pierce VL (2000) Factors affecting wholesale poultry prices. J Agric Appl Econ 32(3):471–478CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Parcell JL, Mintert J, Plain R (2002) An empirical investigation of live hog demand. Department of agricultural economics working paper no AEWP 2002–10, University of Missouri: Department of Agricultural Economics Working Paper No. 2002–10. http://ageconsearch.umn.edu/handle/26042. Accessed 02 Oct 2015
  25. Paul CJM (2001) Market and cost structure in the U.S beef packing industry: a plant-level analysis. Am J Agric Econ 83(1):64–76CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Pruitt JR, Gillespie JM, Nehring RF, Qushim B (2012) Adoption of technology, management practices, and production systems by U.Sbeef cow-calf producers. J Agric Appl Econ 44(2):203–222 http://www.saea.org/jaae/jaae.htm CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Purcell WD, Hudson WT (2003) Risk sharing and compensation guides for managers and members of vertical beef alliances. Rev Agric Econ 25(1):44–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Richards TJ, Pofahl G (2010) Pricing Power by Supermarket Retailers: A Ghost in the Machine? Choices 25(2), Special Section p1Google Scholar
  29. Royer JS, Bhuyan S (1994) Market incentives for cooperative forward integration into processing activities. In: Cotterill RW (ed) Competitive strategy analysis for agricultural marketing cooperatives. Westview Press, Boulder and Oxford, pp 35–57Google Scholar
  30. Suominen S (1992) Effects of vertical integration on price and volume: an empirical inquiry. Empirica 19:203–219CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Taylor CR (2002) Market structure issues in the livestock industry ().Testimony to the U.S senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition and Forestry, hearing on the proposed ban on packer ownership of livestock and USDA’s enforcement of the P&S Act retrieved from http://www.auburn.edu/~taylocr/presentations/testimony.htm
  32. Traore D (2010) An analysis of supply contracts in the livestock markets of the United States. Unpublished thesis, University of Nebraska, LincolnGoogle Scholar
  33. Wise TA, Trist SE (2010) Buyer power in U.S. hog markets: A critical review of the literature. Global Development and Environment Institute Working Paper, No. 10–04Google Scholar
  34. Wu, C (1992) Strategic Aspects of Oligopolistic Vertical Integration. Series: Studies in Mathematical and Managerial Economics. ElsevierGoogle Scholar
  35. Zanaj S (2010) Successive oligopolies and decreasing. BE Journal of Theoretical Economics: Topics in Theoretical Economics 10(1):1–24Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Agribusiness EconomicsSouthern Illinois University CarbondaleCarbondaleUSA
  2. 2.Department of Agricultural, Food & Resource EconomicsRutgers UniversityNew BrunswickUSA

Personalised recommendations