Advertisement

Lessons for African Economies from Irish and East Asian Industrial Policy

  • David Bailey
  • Helena LenihanEmail author
  • Ajit Singh
Article

Abstract

When comparisons in terms of industrial policy lessons to be learned have taken place, it has tended to be solely vis-a-vis the ‘development state’ East Asian experience. This paper broadens the analysis and considers lessons which African countries can learn from other so-called ‘tiger’ economies including Ireland and the East and South Asian countries. We recognise that the latter are indeed clearly significant as many African countries at the time of independence had economic structures and levels of income quite similar to East Asian countries, yet have grown at vastly different rates since then. Exploring why this has been the case can thus offer important insights into possibilities for industrial policy. Yet this comes with some health warnings over East Asian experience. We suggest that another important contribution can come by looking at the Irish example, given its emphasis on corporatism rather than simply relying on state direction in the operation of industrial policy. The Irish model is also more democratic in some senses and has protected workers’ rights during the development process in contrast to the often highly dirigisite East Asian model. Overall we suggest that some immediate actions are needed, notably with regard to the financial system in small African economies. Without such changes, a poorly functioning financial system will continue to keep investment at low levels. In relation to the small size of the African economies, the paper recommends regional integration and sufficient overseas development assistance (ODA) for infrastructural development. It is also critical to note that the various small African economies each face their own industrial and economic development challenges, and that a ‘one size fits all’ approach is not appropriate; rather the key is to tailor policies and systems to the unique opportunities and development challenges in each African country.

Keywords

industrial policy Ireland East Asia economic development FDI small firms 

JEL Classification

F23 L52 L53 O2 P16 

Notes

Acknowledgements

Helena Lenihan worked on this paper whilst a Visiting Fellow at the CBR, Judge Business School, University of Cambridge and concurrently at Wolfson College, University of Cambridge, UK and finally at CSME, Warwick Business School, University of Warwick, UK.

References

  1. Acs, Z., O’Gorman, C., Szerb, L., and Terjesen, S., “Could the irish miracle be repeated in hungary,” Small Business Economics, vol. 28, pp. 123–42, 2007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Ahluwalia, I.J., Industrial Growth in India: Oxford University Press, 1992.Google Scholar
  3. Amin, A. and Tomaney, J., “The regional development potential of inward investment in the less favoured regions of the european community,” in Amin, A. and Tomaney, J. (eds.), Behind the Myth of the European Union. London (Routledge), pp. 201–220, 1995.Google Scholar
  4. Aiginger, K., “Industrial Policy: A Dying Breed or a Re-emerging Phoenix,” Journal of Industry, Competition and Trade, vol. 7, no. 3/4 pp. 297–323, 2007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Amsden, A., Asia’s Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialization. Oxford (Oxford University Press), 1989.Google Scholar
  6. Amsden, A.H. and Singh, A., “The optimal degree of competition and dynamic efficiency in Japan and Korea,” European Economic Review, vol. 38, no. 3/4pp. 941–951, 1994.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Andreosso-O’Callaghan, B. and Lenihan, H., “Is Ireland a role model for SME development in the new member States?,” Journal of European Integration, vol. 28, no. 3pp. 277–303, 2006.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Barry, F., (ed.) Understanding Ireland’s Economic Growth. Macmillan, Great Britain, 1999.Google Scholar
  9. Barry, F., Bradley, J., and Hannan, A., “The single market, the structural funds and Ireland’s recent economic growth,” Journal of Common Market Studies, vol. 39, no. 3pp. 537–52, 2001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Barry, F., Van Egeraat, C., “The Decline of the Computer Hardware Sector: How Ireland Adjusted,” Quarterly Economic Commentary, Spring 2008, ESRI, 2008.Google Scholar
  11. Bailey, D., “FDI in Japan: An ‘open door’ or a legacy of ‘non-institutional’ barriers?,” The Journal of World Investment, vol. 4, no. 2, 2003.Google Scholar
  12. Bailey, D. and Sugden, R., “Kūdōka, restructuring and possibilities for industrial policy in Japan,” in Bailey, D., Coffey, D., and Tomlinson, P. (eds.), Crisis or Recovery in Japan? State and Industrial Economy. Cheltenham (Edward Elgar), 2007.Google Scholar
  13. Bailey, D., de Ruyter, A., and Kavanagh, N., “Lisbon, sapir and industrial policy: evaluating the irish experience,” International Review of Applied Economics, vol. 21, no. 3pp. 453–467, 2007.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Boyle, R., Evaluation Capacity Development in the Republic of Ireland (ECD Working Paper Series, No 14: June). the World Bank Washington, DC (The World Bank Operations Evaluation Department), 2005.Google Scholar
  15. Bradley, J., Wright, J., and Whelan, K., Stabilization and Growth in the EC Periphery: A Study of the Irish Economy. Aldershot (Avebury), 1993.Google Scholar
  16. Blomström, M. and Kokko, A., Multinational Corporations and Spillovers. CEPR Discussion Paper 1365, 1996.Google Scholar
  17. Blomström, M., Kokko, A., and Globerman, S., “The Determinants of Host Country Spillovers from Foreign Direct Investment,” in Pain, N. (ed.), Inward Investment, Technological Change and Growth. pp. 34–65, 2000.Google Scholar
  18. Braunerhjelm, P., Faini, R., Norman, V., Ruane, F., and Seabright, P., Integration and the Regions of Europe: How the Right Policies can Prevent Polarisation. London (Centre of Economic Policy Research), 2000.Google Scholar
  19. Brown, C.J.F., Industrial policy and planning in Japan and France. NIESR Economic Review, 1980.Google Scholar
  20. Buckley, R., Multinational Enterprises, Productivity Spillovers and the Growth and Development of the Irish Software Industry, unpublished PhD thesis. Ireland (University of Limerick), 2005.Google Scholar
  21. Buckley, P.J. and Ruane, F., “Foreign direct investment in Ireland: Policy implications for emerging economics,” The World Economy, vol. 29, no. 11pp. 1611–1628, 2006.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Buckley, R., Leddin, A., and Lenihan, H., An assessment of the contribution of MNEs to the Irish Economy. Logrono, La Rioga, Spain (ILL Foro de Economia Regional, FPRG Economico de la Rioja), 2006.Google Scholar
  23. Chakravarty, S. and Singh, A., The Desirable Forms of Economic Openness in the South, World Institute for Development Economics Research (WIDER): Helsinki, 1988.Google Scholar
  24. Coates, D., “The rise and fall of Japan as a model of ‘progressive capitalism,” in Bailey, D., Coffey, D., and Tomlinson, P. (eds.), Crisis or Recovery in Japan? State and Industrial Economy. Cheltenham (Edward Elgar), 2007.Google Scholar
  25. Chang, H.-J., “Industrial policy in East Asia—lessons for Europe,” EIB Papers, vol. 11, no. 2pp. 106–133, 2006.Google Scholar
  26. Culliton, J., A Time for Change: Industrial Policy for the 1990s (Report of the Industrial Policy Review Group). Dublin (Stationery Office), 1992.Google Scholar
  27. European Commission, The Regions in the 1990s (Fourth Periodic Report on the Social and Economic Situation in the Regions of the Community). Brussels (Commission of the European Community), 1991.Google Scholar
  28. Forfás, Technological Innovation in Irish Manufacturing Industry: Report for the Policy and Advisory Board for Industrial Development in Ireland by A. Fitzgerald & M. Breathnach, Dublin, 1994.Google Scholar
  29. Forfás, Innovation Networks. Dublin (Forfás), 2004.Google Scholar
  30. Gleeson A.M., Ruane F. and Sutherland J., Promoting Industrial Clusters: Evidence from Ireland’ Institute for International Integration Studies, Discussion Paper No 89/Oct, 2005.Google Scholar
  31. Global Entrepreneurship Monitor How Entrepreneurial is Ireland? The Irish Report, Fitzsimons P., O’Gorman C. & Roche F. University College Dublin, 2001.Google Scholar
  32. Goodbody Economic Consultants, Entrepreneurship in Ireland. Dublin (Goodbody Economic Consultants), 2002.Google Scholar
  33. Görg, H. and Ruane, F., “An analysis of backward linkages in the irish electronics sector,” The Economic and Social Review, vol. 31, no. 3pp. 215–235, 2000.Google Scholar
  34. Görg, H. and Ruane, F., “Multinational companies and linkages: panel-data evidence for the irish electronics sector,”,” International Journal of the Economics of Business, vol. 8, no. 1pp. 1–18, 2001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Görg, H. and Strobl, E., “Multinational companies and indigenous development: an empirical analysis,” European Economic Review, vol. 46, no. 7pp. 1305–1322, 2002.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Görg, H. and Strobl, E., “Multinational companies, technology spillovers and plant survival,” Scandinavian Journal of Economics, vol. 105, no. 4pp. 581–595, 2003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Gottheil, F., “Ireland: what’s celtic about the celtic tiger?,” Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, vol. 43, pp. 720–734, 2003.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Greenspan, A., Testimony before the Committee on Banking and Financial Service, US House of Representatives, January 30, 1998.Google Scholar
  39. Heanue K. and Jacobson D., “Low tech policy” PILOT-Newsletter 1, May, DCU Business School, Dublin City University, 9–18, 2003.Google Scholar
  40. Hitchens, D. and Bernie, E., “Evaluating the Culliton Report,” The Irish Banking Review, Summer, 28–40, 1992.Google Scholar
  41. House, D. and McGrath, K., “Innovative governance and development in the New Ireland,” Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration and Institutions, vol. 17, no. 1pp. 29–58, 2004.Google Scholar
  42. IMF, “World Economic Outlook.” International Monetary Foundation Publications, April 2008Google Scholar
  43. ILO, World Employment Report. Geneva (ILO), 2007.Google Scholar
  44. Industrial Development Authority (IDA) Ireland Annual Reports (various years).Google Scholar
  45. Katz R. Japan. The System that Soured. The Rise and Fall of the Japanese Economic Miracle. M E Sharpe, London. 1998Google Scholar
  46. Kearns, A. and Ruane, F., “The tangible contribution of R&D spending foreign-owned plants to a host region: a plant level study of the Irish manufacturing sector (1980–1996),” Research Policy, vol. 30, pp. 227–244, 2001.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Kennedy, K., “Reflections on the process of irish economic growth,” Journal of the Statistical and Social Inquiry Society of Ireland, vol. 30, pp. 123–39, 2001.Google Scholar
  48. Krugman, P.R., “Good news from Ireland: A geographical perspective,” in Gray, A.W. (ed.), International Perspectives on the Irish Economy. Dublin (Indecon Economic Consultants), pp. 38–53, 1997.Google Scholar
  49. Lall, S., Is African Industry Competing? QEH Working paper series No.121. Queen Elizabeth House (Oxford University), 2005.Google Scholar
  50. Lall, S., “Industrial policy in developing countries: What can we learn from East Asia?,” in Bianchi, P. and Labory, S. (eds.), International Handbook on Industrial Policy. Cheltenham (Edward Elgar), 2006.Google Scholar
  51. Lenihan, H., “An evaluation of regional development agency’s grants in terms of deadweight and displacement,” Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, vol. 17, pp. 303–318, 1999.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Lenihan, H., “Estimating irish industrial policy in terms of deadweight and displacement: A quantitative methodological approach,” Applied Economics, vol. 36, no. 3pp. 229–252, 2004.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Lenihan, H. and Hart, M., “The use of counterfactual scenarios as a means to assess policy deadweight : An irish case study,” Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, vol. 22, no. 6pp. 817–839, 2004.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Lenihan, H. and Sugden, R., “Policy on business networking in ireland: a review, and prospects for evaluation,” in Araguren, M., Iturrioz, C., and Wilson, J. (eds.), Networks, Governance and Economic Development: Bridging Disciplinary Frontiers. Cheltenham (Edward Elgar), 2008.Google Scholar
  55. Lenihan H., Hart M. and Roper S., ‘Developing an Evaluative Framework for Industrial Policy in Ireland: Fulfilling the Audit Trail or an Aid to Policy Development?’ Quarterly Economic Commentary, The Economic and Social Research Institute, Ireland. Summer, June, 69–85, 2005.Google Scholar
  56. Lynch, C., Can we learn from Ireland’s Experience? An Irishman’s Perspective, Policy Backgrounder, No.6, June 2005.Google Scholar
  57. Metcalfe, J., “Evolutionary economics and technology policy,” Economic Journal, vol. 104, no. 425pp. 931–944, 1994.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. McAleese, D., “Ireland’s Economic Recovery,” Irish Banking Review, Summer 1990, 18–32, 1990.Google Scholar
  59. McKinley, T., Economic Alternatives for Sub-Saharan Africa: “Poverty Traps”, MDG-based Strategies and Accelerated Capital Accumulation. New York (UNDP draft paper for G-24 Meeting), 2005.Google Scholar
  60. Mkandawire, T., “Maladjusted African economies and Globalisation,” Africa Development, vol. XXX, no. 1 & 2pp. 1–33, 2005.Google Scholar
  61. National Economic and Social Council (NESC), ‘Strategy 2006: People, Productivity and Purpose’ Report No. 114. December 2005. Dublin. Available at: http://www.nesc.ie/press/press_detail.asp?newsId=82&zoneId=4&catId=19, 2005.
  62. Pfeffermann, G., Into Africa, available at www.elmg.org/globalfocus, 2008a.
  63. Pike, A., Rodríguez-Pose, A., and Tomaney, J., Local and Regional Development. London (Routledge), 2006.Google Scholar
  64. Rist, R.C., Policy Evaluation Linking Theory to Practice. Cheltenham (Elgar Reference Collection), 1995.Google Scholar
  65. Ruane, F., “Reflections on linkage policy in Irish manufacturing-policy chasing a moving target,” paper presented at the UNECE/ERBD Expert Meeting on Financing for Development: Enhancing the benefits of FDI and improving the flow of corporate finance in transition economies, Geneva, 2001.Google Scholar
  66. Salt J., Current Trends in International Migration in Europe, Council of Europe. CMJD. 2005.2. 2005.Google Scholar
  67. Sapir A., Aghion P., Bertola G., Hellwig M., Pisani-Ferry J., Rosati D., Viňals J. & Wallace H., ‘An Agenda for a Growing Europe: Making the EU Economic, 2003.Google Scholar
  68. Schweiger C. and Wickham J., ‘Is the Tiger Eating Its Children? The Two Sides Of the Irish Employment Model’ Dynamics of National Employment Models (DYNAMO) Project, Country Study (Draft). http://iat-info.iatge.de/projekt/2005/dynamo/publications.html, 2005.
  69. Singh, A., The causes of Fast Economic Growth in East Asia, UNCTAD Review 1995. 91–127, 1995.Google Scholar
  70. Singh, A., “Savings, investment and the corporation in the East Asian miracle, Study 9,” The Journal of Development Studies, vol. 34, no. 6pp. 112–37, 1998.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Singh, A., ““Asian Capitalism and the financial crisis,”,” in Michie, J. and Grive-Smith, J. (eds.), Global Institutions. London (Routledge), 1999.Google Scholar
  72. Singh, A. and Weisse, B., The Asian Model: A Crisis Foretold, International Social Science Journal No. 160, 1999.Google Scholar
  73. Singh, A., “The Past, Present and Future of Industrial Policy in India: Adapting to the Changing Domestic and International Environment” in Cimol, M., Dosi, G. and Stiglitz, J. (eds.), Industrial Policies and Development Oxford University Press, 2009.Google Scholar
  74. Small Business Forum, Small business is big business: report of the Small Business Forum. Dublin (Small Business Forum), 2006.Google Scholar
  75. Storey, D., ““Six Steps to Heaven: evaluating the impact of public policies to support small business in developed countries,”,” in Sexton, D.L. and Landström, H. (eds.), The Blackwell Handbook of Entrepreneurship. Oxford (Blackwell), 2000.Google Scholar
  76. Summers L.H., Quoted in an article by Gaerard Baker “US looks to G7 backing on Asia Crisis” Financial Times, February 19, 1998.Google Scholar
  77. Task Force on Small Business, “Task Force on Small Business Report”. Government of Ireland, Dublin (Stationary Office), 1994.Google Scholar
  78. The Economist ‘Africa’s Prospects’, 11th–17th October, 33, 2008.Google Scholar
  79. Thornton, S.H. and Thornton, W.H., Development without Freedom. Ashgate, Aldershot (The Politics of Asian Globalization), 2008.Google Scholar
  80. Telesis Consultancy Group, A Review of Industrial Policy. Dublin (Report 64 National Economic and Social Council), 1982.Google Scholar
  81. Ugur, A. and Ruane, F. ‘Export Platform FDI and dualistic development’, Institute for International Integration Studies Discussion Paper, No 28/July 2004.Google Scholar
  82. United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), UNCTAD WID Country Profile Ireland. New York (United Nations), 2005.Google Scholar
  83. UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development), Trade and Development Report: Regional Cooperation for Development. New York (United Nations), 2007a.Google Scholar
  84. UNCTAD, Economic Development in Africa: Reclaiming Policy Space. Domestic Resource Mobilization and Developmental States. New York (United Nations), 2007b.Google Scholar
  85. UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development), Trade and Development Report: Commodity Prices, Capital Flows and the Financing of Investment. New York (United Nations), 2008.Google Scholar
  86. World Bank, “World Development Report.” World Bank Publications, 2007.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2009

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Applied ManagementCoventry University Business School, UKCoventryUK
  2. 2.Department of Economics, Kemmy Business SchoolUniversity of LimerickLimerickIreland
  3. 3.Judge Business SchoolUniversity of CambridgeCambridgeUK
  4. 4.University of Birmingham Business SchoolBirminghamUK

Personalised recommendations