Expert Witnesses: Voices Of Significance

Abstract

Michael Fullan in 1991 made the comment that little was known about how students viewed educational change, as no one had thought to ask them. There is a small but growing literature seeking the views of students on a range of issues associated with schooling. This paper reports the findings of a study of students’ perceptions of top–down educational change, involving school amalgamations, closures and creation of middle schools. The policy process was purportedly to involve consultation with students. The study interviewed students to explore the nature and extent of their participation in the policy enactment and their views about the changes. Several meta level themes emerged from the students’ ‘voices,’ including issues associated with disempowerment, and competing social justice and economic discourses. The findings foreground the often messy and contradictory tensions evident in policy processes. The study found that despite the policy intent to include students, they continued to be the ‘objects’ of policy initiatives, submerged in what Freire labelled a ‘culture of silence.’ It was the macro level policy elite who exerted the most influence, using their power, privilege and status to propagate particular versions of schooling. The paper concludes that students are deeply impacted by educational change and they want to participate in restructuring agendas. Therefore policy makers at all levels need to make spaces for the active engagement of students in policy processes.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in to check access.

Abbreviations

ATP:

Academic Talent Program

EDWA:

Education Department of Western Australia

LAEP:

Local Area Education Planning

TAFE:

College of Technical And Further Education

WA:

Western Australia

References

  1. M.W. Apple (2001) Educating the “Right” Way: Markets, Standards, God, and Inequality Routledge Falmer New York & London

    Google Scholar 

  2. M.W. Apple J.A. Beane (Eds) (1999) Democratic Schools: Lessons from the Chalk Face Open University Press Buckingham

    Google Scholar 

  3. S.J. Ball (1994) Education Reform, A Critical and Post Structural Approach Open Press Buckingham

    Google Scholar 

  4. R. Bowe S.J. Ball A. Gold (1992) Reforming Education & Changing Schools: Case Studies in Policy Sociology Routledge London

    Google Scholar 

  5. Corbett, D. & Wilson, B. (1995). Restructuring for Student Success. Philadelphia: Research for Better Schools ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 387 883.

  6. M. Crotty (1998) The Foundations of Social Research: Meaning and Perspective in the Research Process Allen & Unwin St Leonards

    Google Scholar 

  7. InstitutionalAuthorNameEducation Department of Western Australia, (1997) Local Area Education Planning Framework Education Department of Western Australia Perth

    Google Scholar 

  8. J. Elliott (2000) Towards a synoptic vision of educational change in advanced industrial societies H. Altrichter J. Elliot (Eds) Images of Educational Change Open University Press Buckingham

    Google Scholar 

  9. M. Fielding (2001a) ArticleTitleBeyond the rhetoric of student voice: New departures or new constraints in the transformation of 21st century schooling? Forum 43 IssueID2 100–110

    Google Scholar 

  10. M. Fielding (2001b) ArticleTitleStudents as radical agents of change Journal of Educational Change 2 123–141 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1017949213447

    Article  Google Scholar 

  11. P. Freire (1970) The Pedagogy of the Oppressed Herder and Herder New York

    Google Scholar 

  12. V.J. Friedman (1997) ArticleTitleMaking schools safe for uncertainty: Teams, teaching, and school reform Teachers College Record 99 IssueID2 335–370

    Google Scholar 

  13. M. Fullan (1991) The New Meaning of Educational Change Cassell Educational Limited London

    Google Scholar 

  14. M. Fullan (1992) Successful School Improvement: The Implementation Perspective and Beyond Open University Press Buckingham

    Google Scholar 

  15. M. Fullan (2001) The New meaning of educational change EditionNumber3 Teachers College Press New York

    Google Scholar 

  16. A. Hargreaves K. Leithwood D. Gerin-Lajoie D. Thiessen B. Cousins (1993) Years of Transition: Times for Change (Vol. Volume three: The Realities of Restructuring: Case studies of transition) Ontario Institute for Studies in Education Toronto

    Google Scholar 

  17. M. Henry S. Taylor (1997) Globalisation and national schooling policy in Australia B. Lingard P. Porter (Eds) A National Approach to Schooling in Australia? Essays on the Development of National Policies in Schools Education Australian College of Education Canberra

    Google Scholar 

  18. G.E Karlsen (2000) ArticleTitleDecentralized centralism: framework for a better understanding of governance in the field of education Journal of Educational Policy 15 IssueID5 525–538

    Google Scholar 

  19. J.L. Kincheloe P.L. McLaren (1994) Rethinking critical theory and qualitative research Y.S. Lincoln N.K. Denzin (Eds) Handbook of Qualitative Research Sage Thousand Oaks

    Google Scholar 

  20. M.D. LeCompte (1995) Some notes on power, agenda, and voice: A Researcher’s personal evolution toward critical collaborative research P.L. McLaren J.M. Giarelli (Eds) Critical Theory and Educational Research State University of New York Albany

    Google Scholar 

  21. B. Levin (2000) ArticleTitlePutting students at the centre in education reform Journal of Educational Change 1 155–172 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1010024225888

    Article  Google Scholar 

  22. J. MacBeath K. Myers H. Demetriou (2001) ArticleTitleSupporting teachers in consulting pupils abut aspects of teaching and learning, and evaluating impact Forum 43 IssueID2 78–82 Occurrence Handle10.2304/forum.2001.43.2.11

    Article  Google Scholar 

  23. L. McNeil (2000) ArticleTitleCreating new inequalities: Contradictions of reform Phi Delta Kappan 81 IssueID10 729–734

    Google Scholar 

  24. E. McWilliam C. Hatcher D. Meadmore (1999) ArticleTitleDeveloping professional identities: remaking the academic for corporate times Pedagogy, Culture and Society 7 IssueID1 55–72

    Google Scholar 

  25. M.B. Miles (1998) Finding Keys to School Change: A 40-Year Odyssey A. Hargreaves A. Lieberman A. Hargreaves M. Fullan D. Hopkins (Eds) International Handbook of Educational Change: Part One Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht

    Google Scholar 

  26. InstitutionalAuthorNameMinistry of Education (1987) Better Schools in Western Australia: A Programme for Improvement Ministry of Education Perth

    Google Scholar 

  27. Newmann F.M. & Associates (eds), (1996). Authentic Achievement: Restructuring Schools for Intellectual Quality. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

  28. S. Nieto (1994) ArticleTitleLessons from students on creating a chance to dream Harvard Educational Review 64 IssueID4 392–426

    Google Scholar 

  29. J. Ozga (2000) Policy Research in Educational Settings: Contested Terrain Open University Press Buckingham

    Google Scholar 

  30. M. Rosenmund (2000) ArticleTitleApproaches to international comparative research on curricula and curriculum-making processes Journal of Curriculum Studies 32 IssueID5 599–606 Occurrence Handle10.1080/00220270050116905

    Article  Google Scholar 

  31. J. Rudduck R. Chaplain G. Wallace (1996) School Improvement: What can Pupils Tell us? David Fulton Publishers London

    Google Scholar 

  32. J. Rudduck J. Flutter (2000) ArticleTitlePupil Participation and Pupil perspective: ‘carving a new order of experience’ Cambridge Journal of Education 30 IssueID1 75–89 Occurrence Handle10.1080/03057640050005780

    Article  Google Scholar 

  33. J. Smyth G. Shacklock (1998) Re-Making Teaching: Ideology, Policy and Practice Routledge London

    Google Scholar 

  34. D. Thiessen A. Hargreaves (1993) Conclusions and Implications: Reflections on the Cases A. Hargreaves D. Gerin-Lajoie D. Thiessen (Eds) The Realities of Restructuring: Case studies of Transition NumberInSeriesVol. 3 Ministry of Education and Training Ontario

    Google Scholar 

  35. P.B. Uhrmacher (1993) ArticleTitleComing to know the world through Waldorf Education Journal of Curriculum and Supervision 9 IssueID1 87–104

    Google Scholar 

  36. L. Vidovich (2002) Expanding the Toolbox for Policy Analysis: Some Conceptual and Practical Approaches, Occasional Paper Series, No. 2 Comparative Education Policy Research Unit Hong Kong

    Google Scholar 

  37. G. Whitty S. Power D. Halpin (1998) Devolution and Choice in Education: The School, the State and the Market ACER Press Melbourne

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Lesley Vidovich.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Oerlemans, K., Vidovich, L. Expert Witnesses: Voices Of Significance. J Educ Change 6, 363–379 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10833-005-1919-y

Download citation

Keywords

  • economic discourses
  • educational change
  • education policy
  • restructuring agendas
  • social justice discourses
  • student empowerment
  • student voice