Abstract
This study compares and analyzes separate court rulings in three countries on “mini-cup jelly” (a firm jelly containing konjac and packaged in bite-sized plastic cups) from a food ethics perspective. While the Korean and US courts decided that the mini-cup jelly was defective, and that the manufacturers or importers were liable for damages in these cases, the Japanese court took an opposing stance in favor of the manufacturer. However, from an absolute and fundamental viewpoint, the jelly was unacceptable, ethically as well as legally, because it was unsafe, unwholesome, and unfit for children’s consumption. I argue that the ignoring or sidelining of fundamental principles of food ethics, especially “respect for life,” was at the core of these cases. If the manufacturers and importers had considered and prioritized the principles of food ethics over and above big sales and profits, the choking accidents could have been prevented. To conclude, it is very important to minimize risks by applying the principles of food ethics at the outset before any accidents can occur.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anonymous. (2003). Judge awards $50 M in candy choking death. Silicon Valley Business Journal. http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/stories/2003/09/08/daily14.html. Accessed 2 Oct 2013.
Blades, M. (2009). Food and happiness. Nutrition & Food Science, 39(4), 449–454.
Coff, C. (2006). The taste for ethics: An ethic of food consumption (pp. 21–30). Dordrecht: Springer.
Council of Europe. (2008). The principle of the best interests of the child—What it means and what it demands from adults. https://wcd.coe.int/ViewDoc.jsp?id=1304019. Accessed 2 Oct 2013.
EuroSafe. (2012). How safety conscious are European countries towards children. http://www.childsafetyeurope.org/publications/info/child-safety-report-cards-europe-summary-2012.pdf. Accessed 3 Oct 2013.
FAO. (2006). Strengthening national food control systems: Guidelines to assess capacity building needs. http://gametlibrary.worldbank.org/FILES/1317_Guidelines%20for%20assessing%20NGO%20capacity%20building%20needs-FAO.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2013.
Food Safety Commission of Japan. (2010). Risk assessment report: Choking accidents caused by foods. (pp. 40–43, 85–89, 101–104). https://www.fsc.go.jp/english/topics/choking_accidents_caused_by_foods.pdf. Accessed Oct 3, 2013.
Hansson, S. O. (2003). Ethical criteria of risk acceptance. Erkenntnis, 59, 291–309.
Hepting, D. H., Jaffe, J., & Maciag, T. (2013). Operationalizing ethics in food choice decisions. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics,. doi:10.1007/s10806-013-9473-8.
Himeji Branch, Kobe District Court. (2010). Himeji Branch, Kobe District Court 17 Nov 2010, 1340, Hanrei Times 206.
Kawawa, N. (2013). Jelly mini-cups containing konjac: Is a warning enough to protect vulnerable consumers? Australian Journal of Asian Law, 13(2), 1–18.
Kim, S. S. (2011a). Food ethics approach to court case of inferior quality mandu stuffing. Korean Journal of Food Culture, 26(5), 437–444.
Kim, J. C. (2011b). A study on the supreme court’s interpretation of state compensation law regarding the case of the children’s death from suffocation by jelly mini cups-Case (I): The supreme court 2010. 11. 25. Sentence 2008 da 67828 judgment, case (II): The supreme court 2010. 9. 9. Sentence 2008 da 77795 judgment. Chung-Ang Journal of Legal Studies, 35(2), 139–185.
Korean Food and Drug Administration. (2007a). Disclosure of information on mini-cup jelly (Aug 28, 2007). http://www.mfds.go.kr/index.do?mid=15&seq=24165&cmd=v. Accessed 24 Aug 2013.
Korean Food and Drug Administration. (2007b). KFDA Notification No. 68, Oct 18, 2007. http://www.mfds.go.kr/index.do?mid=95&seq=2460&cmd=v. Accessed Oct 3, 2013.
Modin, P. G., & Hansson, S. O. (2011). Moral and instrumental norms in food risk communication. Journal of Business Ethics, 101, 313–324.
Moore, M. S. (2012). The various relations between law and morality in contemporary legal philosophy. Ratio Juris, 25(4), 435–471.
Nonore, T. (2002). The necessary connection between law and morality. Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 22(3), 489–495.
New York State. (2013). Choking prevention for children. http://www.health.ny.gov/prevention/injury_prevention/choking_prevention_for_children.htm. Accessed 22 Aug 2013.
Osaka High Court. (2012). Osaka High Court 25 May, 2012, LEXDB 25481410.
Powell, S., Langlands, S., & Dodd, C. (2011). Feeding children’s desires? Child and parental perceptions of food promotion to the “under 8s”. Young Consumers: Insight and Ideas for Responsible Marketers, 12(2), 96–109.
Preston, C. (2005). Advertizing to children and social responsibility. Young Consumers: Insight and Ideas for Responsible Marketers, 6(4), 61–67.
Report Information from ProQuest. (2003). Texas family wins big award in gel-candy death. Available at http://search.proquest.com/docview/463933819?accountid=10373. Accessed 22 Aug 2013.
Safe Kids Worldwide. (2013). Home safety fact sheets (2013). http://www.safekids.org/sites/default/files/documents/2013%20Home.pdf. Accessed 22 Aug 2013.
Seoul Central District Court. (2006). Seoul Central District Court Case No. 32369, Aug 17, 2006. http://glaw.scourt.go.kr/wsjo/panre/sjo100.do?contId=2036442&q=2005%EA%B0%80%ED%95%A932369&nq=&w=yegu§ion=yegu_tot&subw=&subsection=&subId=&csq=&groups=&category=&outmax=1&msort=&onlycount=&sp=&d1=&d2=&d3=&d4=&d5=&pg=0&p1=&p2=01&p3=&p4=&p5=&p6=&p7=&p8=&p9=&p10=&p11=&p12=&sysCd=&tabGbnCd=&saNo=&joNo=&lawNm=&hanjaYn=N&userSrchHistNo=&poption=&srch=&range=&tabId=. Accessed 22 Oct 2013.
Seoul High Court. (2008). Seoul High Court Case No. 7074, Sept 11, 2008. http://glaw.scourt.go.kr/wsjo/panre/sjo100.do?contId=2035804&q=2007%EB%82%987074&nq=&w=yegu§ion=yegu_tot&subw=&subsection=&subId=&csq=&groups=&category=&outmax=1&msort=&onlycount=&sp=&d1=&d2=&d3=&d4=&d5=&pg=0&p1=&p2=01&p3=&p4=&p5=&p6=&p7=&p8=&p9=&p10=&p11=&p12=&sysCd=&tabGbnCd=&saNo=&joNo=&lawNm=&hanjaYn=N&userSrchHistNo=&poption=&srch=&range=&tabId=. Accessed 22 October 2013.
Small, M. W., & Dickie, L. (1999). A cinematograph of moral principles: Critical values for contemporary business and society. Journal of Management Development, 18(7), 628–638.
Statistics Korea. (2013). Cause of death statistics. http://kosis.kr/abroad/abroad_01List.jsp?parentId=D#jsClick. Accessed 2 Oct 2013.
Supreme Court of Korea. (2010). Supreme Court of Korea Case No. 77795, September 9, 2010. Available at http://glaw.scourt.go.kr/wsjo/panre/sjo100.do?contId=2058907&q=2008%EB%8B%A477795&nq=&w=yegu§ion=yegu_tot&subw=&subsection=&subId=&csq=&groups=&category=&outmax=1&msort=&onlycount=&sp=&d1=&d2=&d3=&d4=&d5=&pg=0&p1=&p2=01&p3=&p4=&p5=&p6=&p7=&p8=&p9=&p10=&p11=&p12=&sysCd=&tabGbnCd=&saNo=&joNo=&lawNm=&hanjaYn=N&userSrchHistNo=&poption=&srch=&range=&tabId=. Accessed 22 Oct 2013.
Taipei Times. (2002). Consumer group slams inaction on candies. http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/biz/archives/2002/11/09/0000178928. Accessed 22 Aug 2013.
Taipei Times. (2003). Foundation warns over gel candies. http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/biz/archives/2003/07/16/2003059656. Accessed 22 Aug 2013.
UNICEF. (2001). Child deaths by injury in rich nations. http://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/pdf/repcard2e.pdf. Accessed 3 Oct 2013.
United Nations. (2009). Convention on the rights of the child. http://www.coe.int/t/dg3/children/participation/CRC-C-GC-12.pdf. Accessed 3 Oct 2013.
World Health Organization. (2010). Number of deaths: World by cause. http://apps.who.int/gho/data/node.main.CODWORLD?lang=en. Accessed 3 Oct 2013.
World Health Organization Europe. (2008). Available at http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/83757/E92049.pdf. Accessed 3 Oct 2013.
Yvonne and Gil Enrile v. Sheng Hsiang Foods. (2004). 2004 Cal. App. 6 Dist. No. H026982. pp. 1, 4–5, 8, 25.
Zwart, H. (2000). A short history of food ethics. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 12(2), 113–126.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the Catholic University of Korea Research Fund, 2013.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kim, S.S. The Mini-Cup Jelly Court Cases: A Comparative Analysis from a Food Ethics Perspective. J Agric Environ Ethics 27, 735–748 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-013-9487-2
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-013-9487-2