Abstract
In the United States, mine reclamation has been regulated under the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act (SMCRA) since 1977; however, there is a lack of research examining the efficacy of this legislation on restoring ecological structure and function in affected headwater streams. We compared water chemistry characteristics, rate of senescent white oak leaf litter processing, and invertebrate community composition of three first- and second-order streams draining surface mines reclaimed in accordance with SMCRA to that of streams draining three pre-SMCRA abandoned surface mines and three unmined reference watersheds within the Western Allegheny Plateau ecoregion of Ohio. Streams draining reclaimed and abandoned mines had lower pH, higher conductivity, and leaf processing rates that averaged 7 and 24 times lower, respectively, than reference streams. The invertebrate community composition of reclaimed streams differed in several respects from abandoned mine and reference streams, including a shift in proportional dominance from leaf shredding taxa to grazing and scraping taxa, such as gastropods. Although SMCRA has successfully mitigated some sources of water quality impairment, our results suggest that mine drainage remains a persistent barrier to the restoration of headwater stream ecology in mined landscapes.
Similar content being viewed by others
Data availability
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article [and its supplementary information files].
References
Abelho, M., 2001. From litterfall to breakdown in streams: a review. The Scientific World Journal 1: 180292.
Alexander, R. B., E. W. Boyer, R. A. Smith, G. E. Schwarz & R. B. Moore, 2007. The role of headwater streams in downstream water quality. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 43: 41–59.
Anderson, N. H. & J. R. Sedell, 1979. Detritus processing by macroinvertebrates in stream ecosystems. Annual Review of Entomology 24: 351–377.
Barnden, A. R. & J. S. Harding, 2005. Shredders and leaf breakdown in streams polluted by coal mining in the South Island, New Zealand. New Zealand Natural Sciences 30: 35–48.
Baudoin, J. M., F. Guérold, V. Felten, E. Chauvet, P. Wagner & P. Rousselle, 2008. Elevated aluminium concentration in acidified headwater streams lowers aquatic hyphomycete diversity and impairs leaf-litter breakdown. Microbial Ecology 56: 260–269.
Benfield, E. F., K. M. Fritz & S. D. Tiegs, 2017. Leaf litter breakdown. In Lamberti, G. A. (ed), Methods in Stream Ecology (3rd ed.), Volume 2: Ecosystem Function. Elsevier, Amsterdam.
Bier, R. L., K. A. Voss & E. S. Bernhardt, 2015. Bacterial community responses to a gradient of alkaline mountaintop mine drainage in Central Appalachian streams. The ISME Journal 9: 1378–1390.
Bott, T. L., J. K. Jackson, M. E. McTammany, J. D. Newbold, S. T. Rier, B. W. Sweeney & J. M. Battle, 2012. Abandoned coal mine drainage and its remediation: impacts on stream ecosystem structure and function. Ecological Applications 22: 2144–2163.
Bouchard, R. W., Jr., 2004. Guide to Aquatic Invertebrates of the Upper Midwest: Identification Manual for Students, Citizen Monitors, and Aquatic Resource Professionals, University of Minnesota, St. Paul:
Brady, J. K. & A. M. Turner, 2010. Species-specific effects of gastropods on leaf litter processing in pond mesocosms. Hydrobiologia 651: 93–100.
Braun, E. L., 1961. The Woody Plants of Ohio, Ohio State University Press, Columbus:
Canhoto, C. & M. Graça, 1995. Food value of introduced eucalypt leaves for a Mediterranean stream detritivore: Tipula lateralis. Freshwater Biology 34: 209–214.
Cavender, N., S. Byrd, C. L. Bechtoldt & J. M. Bauman, 2014. Vegetation communities of a coal reclamation site in southeastern Ohio. Northeastern Naturalist 21: 31–46.
Chergui, H. & E. Pattee, 1988. The effect of water current on the decomposition of dead leaves and needles. SIL Proceedings 23: 1294–1298.
Cianciolo, T. R., D. L. McLaughlin, C. E. Zipper, A. J. Timpano, D. J. Soucek & S. H. Shoenholtz, 2020. Impacts to water quality and biota persist in mining-influenced Appalachian streams. Science of the Total Environment 717: 137216.
Clark, E. V., C. E. Zipper, D. J. Soucek & W. L. Daniels, 2021. Contaminants in Appalachian water resources generated by non-acid-forming coal-mining materials. In Zipper, C. E. & J. Skousen (eds), Appalachia’s Coal-Mined Landscapes. Springer Nature, Cham.
Cormier, S. M., G. W. Suter II., L. Zheng & G. J. Pond, 2013. Assessing causation of the extirpation of stream macroinvertebrates by a mixture of ions. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 32: 277–287.
Cuffney, T. F., J. B. Wallace & G. J. Lugthart, 1990. Experimental evidence quantifying the role of benthic invertebrates in organic matter dynamics of headwater streams. Freshwater Biology 23: 281–299.
Daniels, W. L., C. E. Zipper, Z. W. Orndorff, J. Skousen, C. D. Barton, L. M. McDonald & M. A. Beck, 2016. Predicting total dissolved solids release from central Appalachian coal mine spoils. Environmental Pollution 216: 371–379.
DeVilbiss, S. E., M. K. Steele, B. L. Brown & B. D. Badgley, 2022. Stream bacterial diversity peaks at intermediate freshwater salinity and varies by salt type. Science of the Total Environment 840: 156690.
dos Santos Fonseca, A. L., I. Bianchini Jr., C. M. M. Pimenta, C. Botelho, P. Soares & N. Mangiavacchi, 2013. The flow velocity as driving force for decomposition of leaves and twigs. Hydrobiologia 703: 59–67.
Drover, D. R., C. E. Zipper, D. J. Soucek & S. H. Schoenholtz, 2019. Using density, dissimilarity, and taxonomic replacement to characterize mining-influenced benthic macroinvertebrate community alterations in central Appalachia. Ecological Indicators 106: 105535.
Encalada, A. C., J. Calles, V. Ferreira, C. M. Canhoto & M. A. Graca, 2010. Riparian land use and the relationship between the benthos and litter decomposition in tropical montane streams. Freshwater Biology 55: 1719–1733.
England, L. E. & A. D. Rosemond, 2004. Small reductions in forest cover weaken terrestrial-aquatic linkages in headwater streams. Freshwater Biology 49: 721–734.
Eriksson, K. A. & W. L. Daniels, 2021. Environmental implications of regional geology and coal mining in the Appalachians. In Zipper, C. E. & J. Skousen (eds), Appalachia’s Coal-Mined Landscapes. Springer, Cham.
Ferreira, V., A. Elosegi, S. D. Tiegs, D. von Schiller & R. Young, 2020. Organic matter decomposition and ecosystem metabolism as tools to assess the functional integrity of streams and rivers–a systematic review. Water 12: 3523.
Fisher, S. G. & G. E. Likens, 1973. Energy flow in bear brook, New Hampshire: an integrative approach to stream ecosystem metabolism. Ecological Monographs 43: 421–439.
Fritz, K. M., S. Fulton, B. R. Johnson, C. D. Barton, J. D. Jack, D. A. Word & R. A. Burke, 2010. Structural and functional characteristics of natural and constructed channels draining a reclaimed mountaintop removal and valley fill coal mine. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 29: 673–689.
Gessner, M. O. & E. Chauvet, 2002. A case for using litter breakdown to assess functional stream integrity. Ecological Applications 12: 498–510.
Giam, X., J. D. Olden & D. Simberloff, 2018. Impact of coal mining on stream biodiversity in the US and its regulatory implications. Nature Sustainability 1: 176–183.
Gordon, N. D., T. A. McMahon, B. L. Finlayson, C. J. Gippel & R. J. Nathan, 2004. Stream Hydrology: An Introduction for Ecologists, 2nd ed. Wiley, London:
Graça, M. A. S., 2001. The role of invertebrates on leaf litter decomposition in streams-a review. International Review of Hydrobiology 86: 383–393.
Gray, L. J. & J. V. Ward, 1983. Leaf litter breakdown in streams receiving treated and untreated metal mine drainage. Environment International 9: 135–138.
Griffith, M. B., S. B. Norton, L. C. Alexander, A. I. Pollard & S. D. LeDuc, 2012. The effects of mountaintop mines and valley fills on the physicochemical quality of stream ecosystems in the Central Appalachians: a review. Science of the Total Environment 417–418: 1–12.
Herlihy, A. T., P. R. Kaufmann, M. E. Mitch & D. D. Brown, 1990. Regional estimates of acid mine drainage impact on streams in the Mid-Atlantic and southeastern United States. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution 50: 91–107.
Hopkins, R. L., II., B. M. Altier, D. Haselman, A. D. Merry & J. J. White, 2013. Exploring the legacy effects of surface coal mining on stream chemistry. Hydrobiologia 713: 87–95.
Huryn, A. D., V. M. Butz Huryn, C. J. Arbuckle & L. Tsomides, 2002. Catchment land-use, macroinvertebrates and detritus processing in headwater streams: taxonomic richness versus function. Freshwater Biology 47: 401–415.
Johnson, K. S., P. C. Thompson, L. Gromen & J. Bowman, 2014. Use of leaf litter breakdown and macroinvertebrates to evaluate gradient of recovery in an acid mine impacted stream remediated with an active alkaline doser. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 186: 4111–4127.
Krenz, R. J., III., S. H. Shoenholtz & C. E. Zipper, 2016. Riparian subsidies and hierarchical effects of ecosystem structure on leaf breakdown in Appalachian coalfield constructed streams. Ecological Engineering 97: 389–399.
Kruse Daniels, N., J. A. LaBar & L. M. McDonald, 2021. Acid mine drainage in Appalachia: sources, legacy, and treatment. In Zipper, C. E. & J. Skousen (eds), Appalachia’s Coal-Mined Landscapes. Springer, Cham.
Lasier, P., P. Winger & K. Bogenrieder, 2000. Toxicity of manganese to Ceriodaphnia dubia and Hyalella azteca. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 38: 298–304.
Lindberg, T. T., E. S. Bernhardt, R. Bier, A. M. Helton, R. B. Merola, A. Vengosh & R. T. Di Giulio, 2011. Cumulative impacts of mountaintop mining on an Appalachian watershed. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108: 20929–20934.
MacDonald, L. H. & D. Coe, 2007. Influence of headwater streams on downstream reaches in forested areas. Forest Science 53: 148–168.
Maltby, L. & R. Booth, 1991. The effect of coal-mine effluent on fungal assemblages and leaf breakdown. Water Research 25: 247–250.
Martínez, A., A. Larrañaga, J. Pérez, E. Descals & J. Pozo, 2014. Temperature affects leaf litter decomposition in low-order forest streams: field and microcosm approaches. FEMS Microbiology Ecology 87: 257–267.
McCafferty, W. P., 1981. Aquatic Entomology: The Fisherman’s and Ecologists’ Illustrated Guide to Insects and Their Relatives, Science Books International, Boston:
Merovitch, G. T., Jr., N. P. Hitt, E. R. Merriam & J. W. Jones, 2021. Response of aquatic life to coal mining in Appalachia. In Zipper, C. E. & J. Skousen (eds), Appalachia’s Coal-Mined Landscapes. Springer, Cham.
Merritt, R. W., K. W. Cummins & M. B. Berg, 2008. An Introduction to the Aquatic Insects of North America, Kendall Hunt Publishing, Dubuque:
Montrie, C., 2003. To Save the Land and People, The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill:
Niyogi, D. K., J. S. Harding & K. S. Simon, 2013. Organic matter breakdown as a measure of stream health in New Zealand streams affected by acid mine drainage. Ecological Indicators 24: 510–517.
Oblinger Childress, C.J., 1985. Classification of stream basins in southeastern Ohio according to extent of surface coal mining. Water-resources investigations report. U.S. Geological Survey 84-4212.
ODNR (Ohio Department of Natural Resources), 2020. Mines of Ohio. Retrieved June 22, 2020, from https://gis.ohiodnr.gov/MapViewer/?config=OhioMines
OEPA (Ohio Environmental Protection Agency), 2018. Field methods for evaluating primary headwater streams in Ohio (Version 4.0). Ohio EPA Division of Surface Water, Columbus, OH.
Ostrofsky, M. L., 1997. Relationship between chemical characteristics of autumn-shed leaves and aquatic processing rates. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 16: 750–759.
Palmer, M. A. & K. L. Hondula, 2014. Restoration as mitigation: analysis of stream mitigation for coal mining impacts in southern Appalachia. Environmental Science & Technology 48: 10552–10560.
Petersen, R. C. & K. W. Cummins, 1974. Leaf processing in a woodland stream. Freshwater Biology 4: 343–368.
Petty, J. T., J. B. Fulton, M. P. Strager, G. T. Merovitch Jr., J. M. Stiles & P. F. Ziemkiewicz, 2010. Landscape indicators and thresholds of stream ecological impairment in an intensively mined Appalachian watershed. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 29: 1292–1309.
Petty, J. T., G. Gingerich, J. T. Anderson & P. F. Ziemkiewicz, 2013. Ecological function of constructed perennial stream channels on reclaimed surface coal mines. Hydrobiologia 720: 39–53.
Pfaff, C.L., D.R. Helsel, D.P. Johnson & C.G. Angelo, 1981. Assessment of water quality in streams draining coal-producing areas of Ohio. U.S. Geological Survey 81-409.
Pond, G. J., 2012. Biodiversity loss in Appalachian headwater streams (Kentucky, U.S.A.): Plecoptera and Trichoptera communities. Hydrobiologia 679: 97–117.
Pond, G., M. E. Passmore, F. A. Borsuk, L. Reynolds & C. J. Rose, 2008. Downstream effects of mountaintop coal mining: comparing biological conditions using family- and genus-level macroinvertebrate bioassessment tools. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27: 717–737.
Pond, G. J., M. E. Passmore, N. D. Pointon, J. K. Felbinger, C. A. Walker, K. J. Krock, J. B. Fulton & W. L. Nash, 2014. Long-term impacts on macroinvertebrates downstream of reclaimed mountaintop mining valley fills in central Appalachia. Environmental Management. 54: 919–933.
Sauer, F. G., M. Bundschuh, J. P. Zubrod, R. B. Schäfer, K. Thompson & B. J. Kefford, 2016. Effects of salinity on leaf breakdown: dryland salinity versus salinity from a coalmine. Aquatic Toxicology 177: 425–432.
Sayler, K.L., 2016. Western Allegheny Plateau ecoregion. In: Sayler, K.L., W. Acevedo & J.L. Taylor (eds). Status and trends of land change in the Eastern United States—1973 to 2000: U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1794–D
Schlief, J. & M. Mutz, 2006. Palatability of leaves conditioned in streams affected by mine drainage: a feeding experiment with Gammarus pulex (L.). Hydrobiologia 563: 445–452.
Simmons, J. A., E. R. Lawrence & T. G. Jones, 2005. Treated and untreated acid mine drainage effects on stream periphyton biomass, leaf decomposition, and macroinvertebrate diversity. Journal of Freshwater Ecology 20: 413–424.
Simmons, J. A., W. S. Currie, K. N. Eshleman, K. Kuers, S. Monteleone, T. L. Negley, B. R. Pohlad & C. L. Thomas, 2008. Forest to reclaimed mine land use change leads to altered ecosystem structure and function. Ecological Applications 18: 104–118.
Skousen, J. & C. E. Zipper, 2021. Coal mining and reclamation in Appalachia. In Zipper, C. E. & J. Skousen (eds), Appalachia’s Coal-Mined Landscapes. Springer Nature, Cham.
Skousen, J., C. E. Zipper, A. Rose, P. F. Ziemkiewicz, R. Nairin, L. M. McDonald & R. L. Kleinmann, 2017. Review of passive systems for acid mine drainage treatment. Mine Water and the Environment 36: 133–153.
Stevens, M. H. H. & K. W. Cummins, 1999. Effects of long-term disturbance on riparian vegetation and in-stream characteristics. Journal of Freshwater Ecology 14: 1–17.
Strosnider, W. H., J. Hugo, N. L. Shepherd, B. K. Holzbauer-Schweitzer, P. Hervé-Fernández, C. Wolkersdorfer & R. W. Nairn, 2020. A snapshot of coal mine drainage discharge limits for conductivity, sulfate, and manganese across the developed world. Mine Water and the Environment 39: 165–172.
Suberkropp, K., V. Gulis, A. D. Rosemond & J. P. Benstead, 2010. Ecosystem and physiological scales of microbial responses to nutrients in a detritus-based stream: results of a 5-year continuous enrichment. Limnology and Oceanography 55: 149–160.
Thorp, J. H. & A. P. Covich (eds), 2001. Ecology and Classification of North American Freshwater Invertebrates., 2nd ed. Academic Press, San Diego.
Timpano, A. J., S. H. Schoenholtz, D. J. Soucek & C. E. Zipper, 2018. Benthic macroinvertebrate community response to salinization in headwater streams in Appalachia USA over multiple years. Ecological Indicators 91: 645–656.
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency), 2007. Method 6010C. Inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry. In: SW-846. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC.
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency), 2011. A Field-Based Aquatic Life Benchmark for Conductivity in Central Appalachian Streams. EPA600-R-10-023F. Office of Research and Development, National Center for Environmental Assessment, Washington, DC.
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency), 2018. Final aquatic life ambient water quality criteria for aluminum. In: EPA-822-R-18–001. Office of Water, Washington, DC.
USEPA (United States Environmental Protection Agency), 2022. National recommended water quality criteria: aquatic life criteria table. https://www.epa.gov/wqc/national-recommended-water-quality-criteria-aquatic-life-criteria-table.
USGS (United States Geological Survey), 2020. Streamstats. https://streamstats.usgs.gov/ss/.
Valett, H. M. & D. T. Ely, 2019. Acidification, stress, and detrital processing: implications for ecosystem function in headwater streams. Hydrobiologia 826: 233–246.
Vander Vorste, R. V., A. J. Timpano, C. Cappellin, B. D. Badgley, C. E. Zipper & S. H. Schoenholtz, 2019. Microbial and macroinvertebrate communities, but not leaf decomposition, change along a mining-induced salinity gradient. Freshwater Biology 64: 671–684.
Vannote, R. L., G. W. Minshall, K. W. Cummins, J. R. Sedell & C. E. Cushing, 1980. The river continuum concept. Canadian Journal of Fisheries & Aquatic Sciences 37: 130–137.
Wallace, J. B., S. L. Eggert, J. L. Meyer & J. R. Webster, 1999. Effects of resource limitation on a detrital-based ecosystem. Ecological Monographs 69: 409–442.
Waters, D.D. & L.E. Roth, 1986. Soil survey of Tuscarawas County, Ohio. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service, Washington, D.C.
Zipper, C. E., J. A. Burger, J. G. Skousen, P. N. Angel, C. D. Barton, V. Davis & J. A. Franklin, 2011. Restoring forests and associated ecosystem services on Appalachian coal surface mines. Environmental Management 47: 751–765.
Zipper, C. E., M. B. Adams & J. Skousen, 2021. The Appalachian coalfield in historical context. In Zipper, C. E. & J. Skousen (eds), Appalachia’s Coal-mined Landscapes. Springer, Cham.
Acknowledgements
We thank Mr. Eric Reip, the Demuth, Dugan, and Lab Families, Jason and Shanda Mushrush, the Camp Tuscazoar Foundation, The Wilderness Center, and the Tuscarawas County Commissioners for allowing us access to their properties. We also thank Jody Brady and two anonymous reviewers for their suggestions, which greatly improved this manuscript.
Funding
No funding was received to support this research, and both authors certify that they have no affiliations with or involvement in any organization or entity with any financial interest or non-financial interest in the subject matter or materials discussed in this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors have no relevant financial or non-financial interests to disclose.
Additional information
Handling editor: Verónica Ferreira
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary Information
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Brady, J.K., Mushrush, J.A. Mine reclamation does not restore leaf processing in low-order streams. Hydrobiologia 850, 1189–1205 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10750-023-05154-1
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10750-023-05154-1