Assessing Societal Benefits and Trade-Offs of Tobacco in the Miombo Woodlands of Malawi
This study assesses the social, economic and environmental impacts and trade-offs of investment in tobacco in two districts in the Miombo woodlands of Malawi. Socioeconomic impacts were analyzed for stakeholder groups differentially affected by large-scale tobacco cultivation: those losing land to estates, those employed on estates, small-scale growers selling to the estates and small-scale wood suppliers. Tobacco growers emerge the biggest beneficiaries from the expansion of tobacco, with real returns among smallholders depending on the extent to which tobacco cultivation constricts or boosts other livelihood activities. Those losing land to tobacco estates are the major losers: efforts to recuperate their livelihoods prove less than adequate to offset the costs of land loss. Smallholder wood suppliers shared more or less the same outcome as employees in securing low returns, often inadequate for more than basic livelihood needs. The literature and fieldwork also document high rates of tobacco-induced deforestation from plantation expansion and unsustainable wood sourcing practices for tobacco drying and curing. Negative ecological externalities are born by local stakeholders and the public alike. We identify opportunities for leveraging more equitable and sustainable outcomes from land-based investments in forested landscapes.
KeywordsLarge-scale land acquisitions Tobacco Trade-offs Deforestation Malawi
- Abalu, G., Mucavele, F., N'gon'gola, D., van Rooyen, J., Kirsten, J. F., Van Zyl, J., Saasa, O. S., Simbi, T., Sithole G., and Vink, N. (1996) Comparative Analysis of Structural Adjustment Programs in Southern Africa, with Emphasis on Agriculture and Trade. SD Publication Series Technical Paper 23. Nairobi: USAID/REDSO/ESA/ANR. Available at: http://www.afr-sd.org/publications/23souafr.pdf (accessed Oct 29, 2013).
- Borras, S. M., Franco, J. C., Carranza, D., and Alano, M. L. (2011). The Fundamentally Flawed ‘Marginal Lands’ Narrative: Insights from the Philippines. Paper presented at the International Conference on Global Land Grabbing, Brighton, UK, 6–8 April 2011.Google Scholar
- Breag, C., and Harker, A. P. (1980). Tobacco. Report on a Visit to Malawi (6 February–13 April 1978) (Report 735). Tropical Products Institute, London.Google Scholar
- Bunderson, W. T., and Hayes, I. M. (1997). Sustainable Tobacco Production in Malawi: The Role of Supply and Demand. Paper presented at the seminar on “Malawi Tobacco and the Future”, Club Makokola, Mangochi, October 1997.Google Scholar
- Cavendish, W. (2002). Quantitative Methods for Estimating the Economic Value of Resource use to Rural Households. In Campbell, B. M., and Luckert, M. (eds.), Uncovering the Hidden Harvest: Valuation Methods for Woodland and Forest Resources. Earthscan, London, pp. 17–65.Google Scholar
- Cernea, M. (2004). Impoverishment Risks, Risk Management, and Reconstruction: A Model of Population Displacement and Resettlement. Paper presented at the UN Symposium on Hydropower and Sustainable Development, Beijing, October 27–29, 2004. Available at: http://www.communitymining.org/attachments/254_population_resettlement_IRR_MODEL_cernea.pdf (accessed April 24, 2013).
- Chifamba, O. and Chikwati, E. (2012). Zimbabwe: Tobacco curing and deforestation. Available at: http://allafrica.com/stories/201203160250.html?page=3 (accessed Oct 4, 2013).
- Chilongo, T. (2005). An Assessment of Smallholders’ Access to Produce Markets in Malawi: The Case of Kasungu RDP. In Takane, T. (ed.), Current Issues in Rural Development in Malawi. IDE, Japan, pp. 141–164.Google Scholar
- Chirwa, E. W. (2004). Access to Land, Growth and Poverty Reduction in Malawi. University of Malawi, Chancellor College.Google Scholar
- Colchester, M. (2010). Free, Prior and Informed Consent: Making FPIC Work for Forests and Peoples. TFD Research Paper 11. The Forests Dialogue, New Haven.Google Scholar
- de Schutter, O. (2011). The Green Rush: The Global Race for Farmland and the Rights of Land Users. Harvard International Law Journal 52(2): 503–559.Google Scholar
- FLEGT (2007). A Timber Legality Assurance System. FLEGT Briefing Notes 3. Available at: http://www.euflegt.efi.int/files/attachments/euflegt/efi_briefing_note_03_eng_221010.pdf (accessed April 24, 2013).
- Fraser, A. I., and Bowles, R. C. D. (1986). The Use of Wood by the Tobacco Industry in Malawi. International Forestry Science Consultancy, Edinburgh.Google Scholar
- Geist, H. (1997). How Tobacco Farming Contributes to Tropical Deforestation. Paper presented at the Tobacco Deliberation Group Meeting, National Committee for International Cooperation and Sustainable Development, Utrecht, 29 October 1997.Google Scholar
- Geist, H. (1999). Global assessment of deforestation related to tobacco farming. Tobacco Control 8: 8–28.Google Scholar
- Geist, H., Otanez, M., and Kapito, J. (2006). The Tobacco Industry in Malawi: A Globalized Driver of Local Land Change. In Lambin, E. F., and Giest, H. (eds.), Landuse and Land Cover Change: Local Processes and Globalized Impacts. Springer, Berlin, pp. 251–268.Google Scholar
- German, L. (2011). Trade-Offs Associated with Large-Scale Land Acquisitions (in the Forest Frontier): Towards a Metric to Support Policy Decisions. Paper presented at the World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty, April 18–20, 2011.Google Scholar
- German, L., Gumbo, D., and Schoneveld, G. (2013a). Large-Scale Investments in Chitemene Farmland: Exploring the Marginal Lands Narrative in Zambia’s Northern Province. QA-Rivista dell’Associazione Rossi-Doria 2(2013): 27p.Google Scholar
- German, L., Schoneveld, G. C., and Mwangi, E. (2013b). Contemporary Processes of Large-Scale Land Acquisition in Sub-Saharan Africa: Legal Deficiency or Elite Capture of the Rule Of Law? World Development 48:1–18.Google Scholar
- Gossage, S. J. (1997). Land Use on the Tobacco Estates of Malawi. Report of the Land Use Survey of Tobacco Estates in Malawi 1996. Estate Land Utilisation Study (ELUS), Lilongwe.Google Scholar
- Government of Malawi (2002). Malawi National Land Policy. Ministry of Lands, Physical Planning and Survey, Lilongwe.Google Scholar
- Jaffee, S. (2003). Malawi’s Tobacco Sector: Standing on One Leg is Better Than None. Africa Region Working Paper Series 55. World Bank, Washington D.C.Google Scholar
- Jomo, F., and Seria, N. (2010). Malawi to Boost Tobacco Export Earnings 20% as Quality Improves. Available at: http://www.businessweek.com/news/2010-03-31/malawi-to-boost-tobacco-export-earnings-20-as-quality-improves.html (accessed July 28, 2010).
- Koester, U., Olney, G., Mataya, C., and Chidzanja, T. (2004) Status and Prospects of Malawi’s Tobacco Industry: A Value Chain Analysis. A report prepared for the Emergency Drought Recovery Project, Ministry of Agriculture, Lilongwe.Google Scholar
- Maleta, M. (2004). Malawi – Tobacco Sector Performance Audit: Review of the Performance of Sector Institutions. Report Prepared for the Emergency Drought Recovery Project, Ministry of Agriculture, Lilongwe.Google Scholar
- Matthews, A., and Wilshaw, C. (1992). Fodya: The Malawi Tobacco Handbook. Central Africana Limited, Blantyre.Google Scholar
- Misana, S., Mung’ong’o, C., and Mukamuri, B. (1996). Miombo Woodlands in the Wider Context: Macroeconomic and Intersectoral Influences. In Campbell, B. (ed.), The Miombo in Transition: Woodlands and Welfare in Africa. Centre for International Forestry Research, Bogor.Google Scholar
- Moyo, S., O’Keefe, P., and Sill, M. (1993). The Southern African Environment: Profiles of the SADC Countries. ETC Foundation/Earthscan Publishers Ltd., London.Google Scholar
- Nsiku, N., and Botha, W. (2007). Tobacco Revenue Management: Malawi Case Study. International Institute for Sustainable Development, Winnipeg.Google Scholar
- Ota, A. B. (2001). Reconstructing Livelihood of the Displaced Families in Development Projects: Causes of Failure and Room for Reconstruction. Paper presented at the conference, ‘Livelihoods and Poverty Reduction: Lessons from Eastern India’, 25–27 September 2001. Available at: http://www.anthrobase.com/Txt/O/Ota_A_02.htm (accessed April 24, 2013).
- Poitras, J. (1999). Malawi tobacco industry and the environment. Trade and the Environment Database Case Study 252. Available at: http://www1.american.edu/ted/maltobac.htm (accessed Oct 4, 2013).
- Poulton, C., Kydd, J., and Kabame, D. (2007). Review of Experiences with Commercial Agriculture: Case Study on Malawi Tobacco. Centre for Environmental Policy, Imperial College, Kent.Google Scholar
- Takane, T. (2005). Risky Business: Smallholder Tobacco Production and Rural Livelihoods in Malawi. In Takane, T. (ed.), Current Issues in Rural Development in Malawi. IDE, Japan, pp. 133–174.Google Scholar
- Technoserve (2011). Outgrower Schemes—Enhancing Profitability. Technoserve Technical Brief. Technoserve, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
- Tsonga, E. W. (2004) An Analysis of The Performance of Malawi’s Tobacco Production and Exports. A report prepared for the Emergency Drought Recovery Project, Ministry of Agriculture, Irrigation and Food Security, Lilongwe.Google Scholar
- UNCTAD (2008). Identifying Core Elements in Investment Agreements in the APEC Region. UNCTAD Series on International Investment Policies for Development. United Nations, New York.Google Scholar
- UNCTAD (2013). Global Value Chains and Development: Investment and Value Added Trade in the Global Economy. United Nations, New York.Google Scholar
- World Bank (1997). Causes and Consequences of Tropical Deforestation. Environmentally Sustainable Development Division, World Bank, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
- World Bank (2005). Pathways to Greater Efficiency and Growth in The Malawi Tobacco Industry: A Poverty and Social Impact Analysis. World Bank, Washington D.C.Google Scholar