Hewett Cottrell Watson and Edward Forbes were two naturalists of the Victorian age. They were protagonists on a dispute that generated comment and serves as an illuminating case study of misunderstanding in priority issues. Watson accused Forbes of having plagiarized his original classification of the British plants into groups on the basis of their geographical distribution. This controversy originated mostly from a so-far-ignored basic difference in Watson’s and Forbes’ ideas about biogeographical regionalization. Watson’s classification of the British flora into groups of species with similar distribution was probably the first application of the concept of “regional chorotype.” By contrast, the biogeographical classification of the British flora proposed by Forbes belongs to the concept of “element,” because it was based on assumed species history (i.e. colonization routes). The two approaches may produce similar outcomes, but remain conceptually different. Although personal reasons may have contributed to exacerbate the Watson–Forbes controversy, failure in recognizing this distinction by its actors and their contemporaries, such as Hooker and Darwin, was the most important cause.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Subscribe to journal
Immediate online access to all issues from 2019. Subscription will auto renew annually.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Anonymus. 1846. “Notice of the ‘Annals and Magazine of Natural History’, No. 101 to 111, July 1845, to March, 1846.” Phytologist 2: 483–484.
Báez, J. C., Real, R., Vargas, J. M. and Flores-Moya, A. 2005. “Chorotypes of Seaweeds from the Western Mediterranean Sea and the Adriatic Sea: An Analysis Based on the Genera Audouinella (Rhodophyta), Cystoseira (Phaeophyceae) and Cladophora (Chlorophyta).” Phycological Research 53: 255–265.
Baroni Urbani, C., Ruffo, S. and Vigna Taglianti, A. 1978. “Materiali per una biogeografia italiana fondata su alcuni generi di Coleotteri Cicindelidi, Carabidi e Crisomelidi.” Memorie della Società Entomologica Italiana 56: 35–92.
Boulger, G. S. 1883. “Watson, Hewett Cottrell (1804–1881).” L. Stephen (ed.), Dictionary of National Biography, vol. 60. London: Smith, Elder & Co, pp. 7–9.
British Bryological Society. 2016. Vice-County Map of Britain and Ireland. http://rbg-web2.rbge.org.uk/bbs/Recording/vcmappage.htm.
Browne, J. 1983. The Secular Ark. Studies in the History of Biogeography, New Haven, CT and London: Yale University Press.
Browne, J. 1992. “A Science of Empire : British Biogeography Before Darwin.” Revue d’histoire des sciences 45: 453–475.
Egerton, F. N. 1972. “Edward Forbes, Jr. (1815–1854), Biogeography, Invertebrate Zoology, Invertebrate Paleontology.” C. C. Gillispie (ed.), Dictionary of Scientific Biography, vol. 5. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, pp. 66–68.
Egerton, F. N. 1976. “Hewett Cottrell Watson (1804–1881), Phytogeography, Evolution.” Dictionary of Scientific Biography 14: 189–191.
Egerton, F. N. 1979. “Hewett C. Watson, Great Britain’s First Phytogeographer.” Huntia 3: 87–102.
Egerton, F. 2003. Hewett Cottrell Watson: Victorian Plant Ecologist and Evolutionist. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Egerton, F. N. 2004. “Hewett Cottrell Watson (1804–1881), Botanist and Phrenologist.” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography 57: 617–619.
Egerton, F. N. 2010a. “History of Ecological Sciences, Part 35: Beginnings of British Marine Biology: Edward Forbes and Philip Gosse.” Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 91: 176–201.
Egerton, F. N. 2010b. “History of the Ecological Sciences, Part 36: Hewett Watson, Plant Geographer and Evolutionist.” Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 91: 294–312.
Egerton, F. N. 2012. Roots of Ecology: Antiquity to Haeckel. Berkeley:University of California Press.
Endersby, J. 2003. “Escaping Darwin’s Shadow.” Journal of the History of Biology 36: 385–403.
Fattorini, S. 2015. “On the Concept of Chorotype.” Journal of Biogeography 42: 2246–2251.
Ferrer-Castan, D. and Vetaas, O. R. 2003. “Floristic Variation, Chorological Types and Diversity: Do They Correspond at Broad and Local Scales?’ Diversity and Distribution 9: 221–235.
Forbes, E. 1846. “On the Connexion Between the Distribution of the Existing Fauna and Flora of the British Isles, and the Geological Changes Which Have Affected Their Area, Especially During the Epoch of the Northern Drift.” Memoirs of the Geological Survey of Great Britain 1: 336–432.
Gómez-González, S., Cavieres, L. A., Teneb, E. A. and Arroyo, J. 2004. “Biogeographical Analysis of Species of the Tribe Cytiseae (Fabaceae) in the Iberian Peninsula and Balearic Islands.” Journal of Biogeography 31: 1659–1671.
Hausdorf, B. and Hennig, C. 2003. “Biotic Element Analysis in Biogeography.” Systematic Biology 52: 717–723.
Jenkins, B. 2015. “Neptunism and Transformism: Robert Jameson and Other Evolutionary Theorists in Early Nineteenth-Century Scotland.” Journal of the History of Biology. doi:10.1007/s10739-015-9425-4.
Lomolino, M. V., Riddle, B. R., Whittaker, R. J. and Brown, J. H. 2010. Biogeography, 4th ed. Sunderland:Sinauer Associates Inc.
Lyell, C. 1830–1833. Principles of Geology: Being an Attempt to Explain the Former Changes of the Earth’s Surface, by Reference to Causes Now in Operation. London: John Murray.
Marquez, A. L., Real, R., Vargas, J. M. and Salvo, A. E. 1997. “On Identifying Common Distribution Patterns and Their Causal Factors: A Probabilistic Method Applied to Pteridophytes in the Iberian Peninsula.” Journal of Biogeography 24: 613–631.
Merritt, R., Moore, N. W. and Eversham, B. C. 1996, Atlas of the DRAGONFLIES of Britain and Ireland. ITE Research Publication No. 9. London: HMSO.
Merton, R. K. 1973. The Sociology of Science. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Mills, E. L. 1978. “Edward Forbes, John Gwyn Jefferies, and British Dredging Before the Challenger Expedition.” Journal of the Society for the Bibliography of Natural History 8: 507–536.
Mills, E. L. 1984. “A view of Edward Forbes, Naturalist.” Archives of Natural History 11: 365–383.
Mills, E. L. 2004. “Edward Forbes (1825–1854), Natural Historian.” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography 20: 273–275.
Olivero, J., Real, R. and Marquez, A. L. 2001. “Fuzzy Chorotypes as a Conceptual Tool to Improve Insight into Biogeographic Patterns.” Systematic Biology 60: 645–660.
Passalacqua, N. 2015. “On the Definition of Element, Chorotype and Component in Biogeography.” Journal of Biogeography 42: 611–618.
Real, R., Márquez, A. L., Estrada, A., Muñoz, A. R. and Vargas, J. M. 2008. “Modelling Chorotypes of Invasive Vertebrates in Mainland Spain.” Diversity and Distributions 14: 364–373.
Rehbock, P. F. 1983. The Philosophical Naturalists: Themes in Early Nineteenth-Century British Biology. Madison, Wisconsin: University of Wisconsin Press.
Sans-Fuentes, M. A. and Ventura, J. 2000. “Distribution Patterns of the Small Mammals (Insectivora and Rodentia) in a Transitional Zone Between the Eurosiberian and the Mediterranean Regions.” Journal of Biogeography 27: 755–764.
Seddon, B. 1971. Introduction to biogeography. London: Duckworth.
Stace, C. A., Ellis, R. G., Kent, D. H. and McCosh, D. J. 2003. Vice-County Census Catalogue of the Vascular Plants of Great Britain. London: Botanical Society of the British Isles.
Strevens, M. 2003. “The role of the Priority Rule in Science.” Journal of Philosophy 100: 55–79.
Vergas, J. M., Real, R. and Palomo, L. J. 1997. “On Identifying Significant Co-occurrence of Species in Space and Time.” Miscellania Zoologica 20: 49–58.
Vincent, P. 1990. The Biogeography of the British Isles. An Introduction. London: Routledge.
Watson, H. C. 1832. Outline of the Geographical Distribution of British plants. Edinburgh.
Watson, H. C. 1835. Remarks on the Geographical Distribution of British Plants. London: Longman.
Watson, H. C. 1847–1859. Cybele Britannica: or British Plants, and Their Geographical Relations. London: Longman.
About this article
Cite this article
Fattorini, S. The Watson–Forbes Biogeographical Controversy Untangled 170 Years Later. J Hist Biol 50, 473–496 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-016-9454-7
- Charles Darwin
- Hewett Cottrell Watson
- Edward Forbes
- Joseph Dalton Hooker