Edward O. Wilson’s recent decision to abandon kin selection theory has sent shockwaves throughout the biological sciences. Over the past two years, more than a hundred biologists have signed letters protesting his reversal. Making sense of Wilson’s decision and the controversy it has spawned requires familiarity with the historical record. This entails not only examining the conditions under which kin selection theory first emerged, but also the organicist tradition against which it rebelled. In similar fashion, one must not only examine Wilson’s long career, but also those thinkers who influenced him most, especially his intellectual grandfather, William Morton Wheeler (1865–1937). Wilson belongs to a long line of organicists, biologists whose research highlighted integration and coordination, many of whom struggled over the exact same biological riddles that have long defined Wilson’s career. Drawing inspiration (and sometimes ideas) from these intellectual forebears, Wilson is confident that he has finally identified the origin of the social impulse.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Price includes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
Abbot, Patrick, Abe, Jun, Alcock, John, Alizon, Samuel, Alpedrinha, Joao A.C., Andersson, Malte, Andre, Jean-Baptiste, van Baalen, Minus, Balloux, Francois, Balshine, Sigal, Barton, Nick, Beukeboom, Leo W., Biernaskie, Jay M., Bilde, Trine, Borgia, Gerald, Breed, Michael, Brown, Sam, Bshary, Redouan, Buckling, Angus, Burley, Nancy T., Burton-Chellew, Max N., Cant, Michael A., Chapuisat, Michel, Charnov, Eric L., Clutton-Brock, Tim, Cockburn, Andrew, Cole, Blaine J., Colegrave, Nick, Cosmides, Leda, Couzin, Iain D., Coyne, Jerry A., Creel, Scott, Crespi, Bernard, Curry, Robert L., Dall, Sasha R.X., Day, Troy, Dickinson, Janis L., Dugatkin, Lee Alan, El Mouden, Claire, Emlen, Stephen T., Evans, Jay, Ferriere, Regis, Field, Jeremy, Foitzik, Susanne, Foster, Kevin, Foster, William A., Fox, Charles W., Gadau, Juergen, Gandon, Sylvain, Gardner, Andy, Gardner, Michael G., Getty, Thomas, Goodisman, Michael A.D., Grafen, Alan, Grosberg, Rick, Grozinger, Christina M., Gouyon, Pierre-Henri, Gwynne, Darryl, Harvey, Paul H., Hatchwell, Ben J., Heinze, Jürgen, Helantera, Heikki, Helms, Ken R., Hill, Kim, Jiricny, Natalie, Johnstone, Rufus A., Kacelnik, Alex, Kiers, E. Toby, Kokko, Hanna, Komdeur, Jan, Korb, Judith, Kronauer, Daniel, Kümmerli, Rolf, Lehmann, Laurent, Linksvayer, Timothy A., Lion, Sébastien, Lyon, Bruce, Marshall, James A.R., McElreath, Richard, Michalakis, Yannis, Michod, Richard E., Mock, Douglas, Monnin, Thibaud, Montgomerie, Robert, Moore, Allen J., Mueller, Ulrich G., Noë, Ronald, Okasha, Samir, Pamilo, Pekka, Parker, Geoff A., Pedersen, Jes S., Pen, Ido, Pfennig, David, Queller, David C., Rankin, Daniel J., Reece, Sarah E., Reeve, Hudson K., Reuter, Max, Roberts, Gilbert, Robson, Simon K.A., Roze, Denis, Rousset, Francois, Rueppell, Olav, Sachs, Joel L., Santorelli, Lorenzo, Schmid-Hempel, Paul, Schwarz, Michael P., Scott-Phillips, Tom, Shellmann-Sherman, Janet, Sherman, Paul W., Shuker, David M., Smith, Jeff, Spagna, Joseph C., Strassmann, Beverly, Suarez, Andrew V., Sundström, Liselotte, Taborsky, Michael, Taylor, Peter, Thompson, Graham, Tooby, John, Tsutsui, Neil D., Tsuji, Kazuki, Turillazzi, Stefano, Úbeda, Francisco, Vargo, Edward L., Voelkl, Bernard, Wenseleers, Tom, West, Stuart A., West-Eberhard, Mary Jane, Westneat, David F., Wiernasz, Diane C., Wild, Geoff, Wrangham, Richard, Young, Andrew J., Zeh, David W., Zeh, Jeanne A., and Zink, Andrew. 2011. “Inclusive Fitness Theory and Eusociality.” Nature 471 (7339): E1–E4.
Alexander, Samuel. 1920. Space, Time and Deity. London: MacMillan and Company.
Allen, Elizabeth, Beckwith, Barbara, Beckwith, Jon, Chorover, Steven, Culver, David, Duncan, Margaret, Gould, Steven, Hubbard, Ruth, Inouye, Hiroshi, Leeds, Anthony, Lewontin, Richard, Madansky, Chuck, Miller, Larry, Pyeritz, Reed, Rosenthal, Miriam, and Schreier, Herb. 1975. “Against ‘Socibiology’.” New York Review of Books 22 (18): 43–44.
Borrello, Mark. 2005. “The Rise, Fall, and Resurrection of Group Selection.” Endeavour 29 (1): 43–47.
Borrello, Mark. 2010. Evolutionary Restraints: The Contentious History of Group Selection. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Broad, C.D. 1925. The Mind and Its Place in Nature. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company.
Broomsma, Jacobus J., Beekman, Madeleine, Cornwallis, Charlie K., Griffin, Ashleigh S., Holman, Luke, Hughes, William O.H., Keller, Laurent, Oldroyd, Benjamin P., and Ratnieks, Francis L.W. 2011. “Only Full-Sibling Families Evolved Eusociality.” Nature 471 (7339): e4–e5.
Brosius, Elizabeth. 1994. “In Pursuit of Prodryas persephone: Frank Carpenter and Fossil Insects.” Pysche 101: 119–126.
Buhs, Joshua Blu. 2004. The Fire Ant Wars: Nature, Science, and Public Policy in Twentieth-Century America. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Cannon, Walter Bradford. 1932. The Wisdom of the Body. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
Corning, Peter A. 2005. Holistic Darwinism: Synergy, Cybernetics, and the Bioeconomics of Evolution. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Darwin, Charles. 1872. The Origin of Species, 6th edn. London: John Murray.
Dawkins, R. 1976. The Selfish Gene. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dawkins, Richard. 1979. “12 Misunderstandings of Kin Selection.” Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie 51: 184–200.
Dugatkin, Lee Alan. 1997. Cooperation Among Animals: An Evolutionary Perspective. New York: Oxford University Press.
Dugatkin, Lee Alan. 2006. The Altruism Equation: Seven Scientists Search for the Origin of Goodness. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Eldakar, Omar Tonsi, and Wilson, David Sloan. 2011. “Eight Criticisms Not to Make About Group Selection.” Evolution 65 (6): 1523–1526.
Emerson, Alfred E. 1939. “Social Coordination and the Superorganism.” American Midland Naturalist 21 (1): 182–209.
Emerson, Alfred E. 1971. “A Biologist and His Times.” Science 172 (3984): 679.
Evans, Mary Alice, and Evans, Howard Ensign. 1970. William Morton Wheeler, Biologist. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Ferriere, Regis, and Michod, Richard E. 2011. “Inclusive Fitness in Evolution.” Nature 471 (7339): e6–e8.
French, Howard W. 2011. “E. O. Wilson’s Theory of Everything.” The Atlantic (November).
Gardner, Andy. 2011. “Kin Selection Under Blending Inheritance.” Journal of Theoretical Biology 284: 125–129.
Gardner, Andy, and Grafen, Alan. 2009. “Capturing the Superorganism: A Formal Theory of Group Adaptation.” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 22: 659–671.
Gardner, A., West, S. A., and Wild, G. 2011. “The Genetical Theory of Kin Selection.” Journal of Evolutionary Biology 24: 1020–1043.
Hamilton, W.D. 1964a. “The Genetical Evolution of Social Behavior I.” Journal of Theoretical Biology 7 (1): 1–16.
Hamilton, W.D. 1964b. “The Genetical Evolution of Social Behavior II.” Journal of Theoretical Biology 7 (1): 17–52.
Hamilton, W.D. 1975. “Innate Social Aptitudes of Man: An Approach from Evolutionary Genetics.” R. Fox (ed.), Biosocial Anthropology. London: Malaby Press, pp. 133–153.
Harman, Oren Solomon. 2010. The Price of Altruism: George Price and the Tragic Search for the Origins of Kindness. New York: W. W. Norton and Company.
Henderson, Lawrence J. 1917. The Order of Nature. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Herre, Edward Allen and Wcislo, William T. 2011. “In Defence of Inclusive Fitness Theory.” Nature 48: e8.
Hofstadter, Richard. 1944. Social Darwinism in American Thought. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Hölldobler, Bert, and Wilson, Edward O. 1990. The Ants. Cambridge: Belknap Press.
Hölldobler, Bert, and Wilson, Edward O. 1994. Journey to the Ants: A Story of Scientific Exploration. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Hölldobler, Bert, and Wilson, Edward O. 2008. The Superorganism: the Beauty, Elegance, and Strangeness of Insect Societies. New York: W. W. Norton and Company.
Jumonville, Neil. 2002. “The Cultural Politics of the Sociobiology Debate.” Journal of the History of Biology 35 (2): 569–593.
Lewontin, Richard C. 1976. “Sociobiology: A Caricature of Darwinism.” Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association 2 (1976): 22–23, 30.
Marshall, James A.R. 2011. “Group Selection and Kin Selection: Formally Equivalent Approaches.” Trends in Ecology and Evolution 26 (1): 325–332.
Maynard Smith, John. 1964. “Group Selection and Kin Selection.” Nature 201 (4924): 1145–1147.
Merchant, Carolyn. 1980. Death of Nature: Women, Ecology, and the Scientific Revolution. New York: Harper Collins.
Mitchell, Sandra. 1995. Sabine Maasen, Everett Mendelsohn, and Peter Weingart (eds.), The Superorganism Metaphor: Then and Now. Biology as Society, Society as Biology: Metaphors. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 231–247.
Mitman, Greg. 1992. The State of Nature: Ecology, Community, and American Social Thought. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Morgan, C. Lloyd. 1923. Emergent Evolution. London: Williams and Norgate, Ltd.
Moritz, Robin F.A., and Southwick, Edward E. 1992. Bees as Superorganisms: An Evolutionary Reality. New York: Springer-Verlag.
Nowak, Martin, and Highfield, Roger. 2011. Supercooperators: Altruism, Evolution, and Why We Need Each Other to Succeed. New York: Free Press.
Nowak, Martin, Tarnita, Corina, and Wilson, E.O. 2010. “The Evolution of Eusociality.” Nature 466 (7310): 1057–1062.
Okasha, Samir. 2005. “Multilevel Selection and the Major Transitions in Evolution.” Philosophy of Science 72 (5): 1013–1025.
Osborn, Henry Fairfield. 1894. “The Discussion Between Spencer and Weismann.” Psychological Review 1: 312–315.
Parker, George Howard. 1924. “Organic Determinism.” Science 59 (1537): 517–521.
Pennisi, Elizabeth. 2009. “Agreeing to Disagree.” Science 323 (5915): 706–708.
Price, George R. 1970. “Selection and Covariance.” Nature 227 (5257): 520–521.
Reeve, H. Kern, and Hölldobler, Bert. 2007. “The Emergence of a Superorganism Through Intergroup Competition.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States 104 (23): 9736–9740.
Ruse, Michael. 2004. “Adaptive Landscapes and Dynamic Equilibrium: The Spencerian Contribution to Twentieth-Century American Evolutionary Biology.” Abigail Lustig, Robert Richards, and Michael Ruse (eds.), Darwinian Heresies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ruse, Michael. 2013. The Gaia Hypothesis: Science on a Pagan Planet. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
Schneirla, Theodor. 1944. “A Unique Case of Circular Milling in Ants, Considered in Relation to Trail Following and the General Problem of Orientation.” American Museum Novitates 1253: 1–26.
Seeley, Thomas. 1989. “The Honey Bee Colony as a Superorganism.” American Scientist 77 (6): 546–553.
Segerstråle, Ullica. 2000. Defenders of the Truth: The Battle for Science in the Sociobiology Debate and Beyond. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sellars, Roy Wood. 1922. Evolutionary Naturalism. Chicago: The Open Court Publishing Company.
Sleigh, Charlotte. 2007. Six Legs Better: A Cultural History of Myrmecology. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press.
Smocovitis, Betty. 1992. “Unifying Biology: The Evolutionary Synthesis and Evolutionary Biology.” Journal of the History of Biology 25 (1): 1–65.
Smuts, Jan C. 1926. Holism and Evolution. New York: The MacMillan Company.
Sober, Elliott and Wilson, David Sloan. 1999. Unto Others: The Evolution and Psychology of Unselfish Behavior. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Sober, Elliott and Wilson, David Sloan. 2000. “Morality and ‘Unto Others': Response to Commentary Discussion.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 7 (1-2): 257–268.
Spaulding, E.G. 1918. The New Rationalism. New York: Henry Holt and Company.
Spencer, Herbert. 1860. “The Social Organism.” The Westminster Review XVII (143): 90–121.
Spencer, Herbert. 1881. The Principles of Sociology, vol. I. New York: Appleton and Company.
Spencer, Herbert. 1893c. “A Rejoinder to Professor Weismann.” The Contemporary Review 64: 893–912.
Spencer, Herbert. 1894. “Weismannism Once More.” The Contemporary Review 65: 592–608.
Strassman, Joan E., Page, Jr., Robert E., Robinson, Gene E., and Seeley, Thomas D. 2011. “Kin Selection and Eusociality.” Nature 471 (7339): e5–e6.
Strassmann, Joan E., and Queller, David C. 2010. “The Social Organism: Congresses, Parties and Committees.” Evolution 64 (3): 605–616.
Tschinkel, Walter S. 1999. “Sociometry and Sociogenesis of Colonies of the Harvester Ant.” Ecological Entomology 24 (2): 222–237.
Watson, James, and Crick, Francis. 1953. “A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid.” Nature 171 (1953): 737–738.
Weintraub, Pamela. 2011. E. O. Wilson’s Theory of Altruism Shakes up Understanding of Evolution. Discover Magazine (January–February).
Weismann, August. 1893a. “The All-Sufficiency of Natural Selection: A Reply to Herbert Spencer.” The Contemporary Review 64: 309–338.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1910. Ants: Their Structure, Development and Behavior. New York: Columbia University Press.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1911. “The Ant-Colony as an Organism.” Journal of Morphology 22: 307–326.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1918. “A Study of Some Ant Larvae, with a Consideration of the Origin and Meaning of the Social Habit among Insects.” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 57 (4): 293–343.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1920. “The Termitodoxa, or Biology and Society.” The Scientific Monthly 10 (2): 113–124.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1923. Social Life Among the Insects. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1926. “Emergent Evolution and the Social.” Science 64 (1662): 440–443.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1928a. Emergent Evolution and the Development of Societies. New York: Norton & Company.
Wheeler, William Morton. 1928b. The Social Insects: Their Origin and Evolution. London: Kegan, Paul, Trench, Trubner.
Whitehead, Alfred North. 1925. Science and the Modern World. New York: The MacMillan Company.
Whitman, Charles Otis. 1891. “Specialization and Organization: Companion Principles of All Progress – The Most Important Need of American Biology.” Biological Lectures Delivered at Marine Biological Laboratory. Boston: Ginn and Company.
Whitman, Charles Otis. 1894. “The Inadequacy of the Cell-Theory of Development.” Biological Lectures Delivered at the Marine Biological Laboratory of Wood’s Holl. Boston: Ginn and Company.
Wilson, Edward O. 1953. “The Origin and Evolution of Polymorphism in Ants.” The Quarterly Review of Biology 28 (2): 136–156.
Wilson, Edward O. 1967. “The Superorganism Concept and Beyond.” L’effet de Groupe Chez les Animaux 173: 27–39.
Wilson, Edward O. 1975. Sociobiology: The New Synthesis. Cambridge: Belknap Press.
Wilson, Edward O. 1976. “Academic Vigilantism and the Political Significance of Sociobiology.” BioScience 26 (3): 183, 187–190.
Wilson, Edward O. 1984. Biophilia. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Wilson, Edward O. 1992. “Dedication: Frank Morton Carpenter.” Psyche 99 (2–3): 241–244.
Wilson, Edward O. 1993. “Analyzing the Superorganism: The Legacy of Whitman and Wheeler.” Robert B. Barlow, Jr., John E. Dowling, and Gerald Weisseman (eds.), The Biological Century: Friday Evening Talks at the Marine Biological Laboratory. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Wilson, Edward O. 1994. Naturalist. Washington, DC: Island Press.
Wilson, Edward O. 2005. “Kin Selection as the Key to Altruism: Its Rise and Fall.” Social Research 72 (1): 159–166.
Wilson, Edward O. 2008. “One Giant Leap: How Insects Achieved Altruism and Colonial Life.” BioScience 58 (1): 17–25.
Wilson, Edward O. 2012. The Social Conquest of Earth. New York: Norton and Company.
Wilson, Edward O., and Hölldobler, Bert. 2005. “Eusociality: Origin and Consequences.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States 102 (38): 13367–13371.
Wilson, Edward O., and Michener, Charles D. 1982. Alfred Edwards Emerson National Academy of Science Biographical Memoirs. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences.
Wilson, David Sloan, and Sober, Eliot. 1989. “Reviving the Superorganism.” Journal of Theoretical Biology 136: 337–356.
Wilson, David Sloan, and Wilson, Edward O. 2007. “Rethinking the Theoretical Foundations of Sociobiology.” Quarterly Review of Biology 82 (4): 327–348.
Wilson, David Sloan, and Wilson, Edward O. 2008. “Evolution for the Good of the Group.” American Scientist 96 (5): 380–389.
About this article
Cite this article
Gibson, A.H. Edward O. Wilson and the Organicist Tradition. J Hist Biol 46, 599–630 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-012-9347-3
- E. O. Wilson
- Kin selection
- Multilevel selection
- Group selection