Skip to main content

The Bee Battles: Karl von Frisch, Adrian Wenner and the Honey Bee Dance Language Controversy

Abstract

In 1967, American biologist Adrian Wenner (1928–) launched an extensive challenge to Karl von Frisch’s (1886–1982) theory that bees communicate to each other the direction and distance of food sources by a symbolic dance language. Wenner and various collaborators argued that bees locate foods solely by odors. Although the dispute had largely run its course by 1973 – von Frisch was awarded a Nobel Prize, while Wenner withdrew from active bee research – it offers us a rare window into mid-twentieth century discussions about animals, language, and cognition. Historians, sociologists, and scientists have commented on the debate and its outcome, but none has seriously questioned why von Frisch and Wenner pursued such different explanations of the bees’ dances. In this paper, I explore von Frisch and Wenner’s differing visions of animals and their behaviors and show how these contributed to their respective positions. Von Frisch’s early-twentieth-century training in experimental physiology disposed him to focus on individual animals, their abilities, and their behaviors’ evolutionary significance. Wenner, by contrast, was trained in mathematics and statistics and the Schneirla school of behavior. He viewed the bees’ behaviors probabilistically with an eye toward the entire hive and its surroundings and ultimately explained them in terms of simple stimulus–response conditioning. Finally, while the debate was resolved in von Frisch’s favor, he neither waged nor won the battle by himself. Instead, I show that practitioners, whose agendas ranged from the nascent fields of sociobiology to cognitive ethology, took up the cause of the communicating bees.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

References

Unpublished sources

  1. Von Frisch, Karl. Personal Papers. Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Munich. Nachlaß ANA 540, Folders: BI, Gould, James; BI, Griffin, Donald; BII, Griffin, Donald; BI, Hediger, Heini; BI, Jander, Rudolf; BI, Koehler, Otto; BII, Koehler, Otto; BI, Lindauer, Martin; BII, Mayr, Ernst; BII, Wenner, Adrian; Wenner, Adrian. Personal email correspondence with author, July 10, 2003

Published sources

  1. Allen Danielle (2004) “Burning The Fable of the Bees: The Incendiary Authority of Nature.” Daston Lorraine Vidal Fernando (Eds) The Moral Authority of Nature University of Chicago Press Chicago 74–99

    Google Scholar 

  2. Stuart A. Altman (1972) ArticleTitle“Without a Word’ Book Review of Non-Verbal Communication, Edited by Robert A. Hinde” Nature 240 361–362

    Google Scholar 

  3. Guy Ankerl Derk Perebooom (1974) ArticleTitle“Scientific Methods in Ethology, Letters” Science 185 814

    Google Scholar 

  4. Anonymous (1993) ArticleTitle“Adrian Wenner Retirement Announcement” American Bee Journal 133 237–238

    Google Scholar 

  5. Aristotle (1965) Historia animaliumLoeb classical library Heinemann London

    Google Scholar 

  6. Barry Barnes David Bloor (1982) “Relativism, Rationalism and the Sociology of Knowledge.” Hollins Martin Lukes Steven (Eds) Rationality and Relativism Basil Blackwell Oxford 21–47

    Google Scholar 

  7. Robert F Barsky ( 1997) Noam Chomsky: A Life of Dissent MIT Press Cambridge, MA

    Google Scholar 

  8. Richard Burkhardt SuffixJr. (1990) ArticleTitle“Karl von Frisch” Dictionary of Scientific Biography, Supplement II 17 312–320

    Google Scholar 

  9. Richard Burkhardt SuffixJr. (2004) Pattern of Behavior: Konrad Lorentz, Niko Tinbergen, and the Founding of Ethology University of Chicago Press Chicago

    Google Scholar 

  10. Burnett, D. Graham. 2002. “Mind in the Waters: John C. Lilly and the Communications Research Institute.” Conference paper presented at “Man and Beast: A Symposium in Honor of Naomi Schor. Yale University

  11. Buttel-Reepen, Hugo von. 1900. “Sind die Bienen Reiexmaschinen?” Biologisches Zentralblatt 20: 97–109, 130–144, 177–193, 209–224, 289–304.

  12. Hugo Buttel-Reepen Particlevon (1912) ArticleTitle“Entomolgischer Reisebrief aus Ceylon’s Bergen” Entomologische Mitteilungen 1 97–103

    Google Scholar 

  13. Hugo Buttel-Reepen Particlevon (1915) Leben und Wesen der Bienen Vieweg Braunschweig

    Google Scholar 

  14. John Clark (1998) ArticleTitle‘“The Complete Biography of Every Animal’: Ants, Bees, and Humanity in Nineteenth-Century England” Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 29 249–267

    Google Scholar 

  15. Coen, Deborah R. 2004. A Scientific Dynasty: Probability, Liberalism, and the Exner Family in Imperial Austria. PhD Dissertation, Harvard University

  16. Cohen-Cole, Jamie N. 2003. Thinking About Thinking in Cold War America. PhD Dissertation, Princeton University

  17. Eileen Crist (2004) ArticleTitle“Can an Insect Speak? The Case of the Honeybee Dance Language” Social Studies of Science 34 7–43 Occurrence Handle10.1177/0306312704040611

    Article  Google Scholar 

  18. Charles Darwin (1981 [1971]) The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex Princeton University Press Princeton

    Google Scholar 

  19. Demorest Davenport (1974) ArticleTitle‘Bee Language’ Letters Science 186 975–976

    Google Scholar 

  20. Richard Dawkins (1969) ArticleTitle‘“Bees are Easily Distracted’ Letters.” Science 165 751

    Google Scholar 

  21. Ute Deichmann (1996) Biologists under Hitler Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA

    Google Scholar 

  22. Donald A Dewsbury (1984) Comparative Psychology in the Twentieth Century. Hutchinson Ross Publishing Company Stroudsburg, PA

    Google Scholar 

  23. Jean-Marc. Drouin (1992) ArticleTitle“L’image des sociétés d’insectes en France à l’époque de la Revolution” Revue de Synthèse 4 113–144

    Google Scholar 

  24. Harald. Esch (1964) ArticleTitle“Beiträge zum Problem der Entfernungsweisung in den Schwänzeltänzen der Honigbienen” Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Physiologe 48 534–546

    Google Scholar 

  25. Bruce J. Falls (1992) “Playback: A Historical Perspective.” K. McGregor Peter (Eds) Playback and Studies of Animal Communication Plenum Press New York 11–33

    Google Scholar 

  26. William Feller (1968 [1950].) An Introduction to Probability Theory and its Applications EditionNumber3 Wiley New York

    Google Scholar 

  27. Auguste Forel (1910) Das Sinnesleben der Insekten Reinhardt München

    Google Scholar 

  28. Auguste Forel (1924 [1874]) Les Fourmis de la Suisse EditionNumber2 Imprimerie Coopérative La Chaux-de Fonds

    Google Scholar 

  29. Gottfried Samuel Fraenkel L. Gunn Donald (1961 [1940]) The Orientation of Animals, Kineses, Taxes and Compass Reactions Dover Publications New York

    Google Scholar 

  30. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1923a) ArticleTitle“Ein Zwergwels kommt wenn man ihm pfeift” Biologisches Zentralblatt 43 439–446

    Google Scholar 

  31. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1923b) ArticleTitle“Über die Sprache der Bienen. Eine tierpsychologische Untersuchung” Zoologische Jahrbücher. Abteilung für allgemeine Zoologie und Physiologie 40 439–446

    Google Scholar 

  32. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1927) Aus dem Leden der Bienen EditionNumber2 springer Berlin

    Google Scholar 

  33. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1948 [1927]) Aus dem Leben der Bienen EditionNumber4 Springer Wien

    Google Scholar 

  34. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1953) ArticleTitle‘“Sprache’ oder ‘Kommunication’ der Bienen? Psychologische Rundschau 4 235–236

    Google Scholar 

  35. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1965) Aus dem Leben der Bienen Springer Berlin

    Google Scholar 

  36. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1965) Tanzsprache und orientierung der Bienen Springer Berlin

    Google Scholar 

  37. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1966 [1927]) The Dancing Bees: An Account of the Life and Senses of the Honey Bee EditionNumber2 Methuen London

    Google Scholar 

  38. Karl Frisch Particlevon (1973 [1957]) Erinnerungen eines Biologen Springer Berlin

    Google Scholar 

  39. Karl Frisch Particlevon Adrian M Wenner Dennis L. Johnson (1967) ArticleTitle“Honeybees: Do They Use Direction and Distance Information Provided by Their Dancers?” Science 158 1072–1077

    Google Scholar 

  40. Linda Glaser ( 2003) Brilliant Bees. Illus. Gay Holland Millbrook Press Brookfield, CT

    Google Scholar 

  41. Gould, James L. 1975a. Honey Bee Communication: The Dance-Language Controversy. PhD Dissertation, Rockefeller University

  42. Linda Glaser (1975b) ArticleTitle“Honey Bee Recruitment: The Dance-Language Controversy” Science 189 685–693

    Google Scholar 

  43. James L Gould Carol G Gould (1988) The Honey Bee Scientific American Library, Freeman New York

    Google Scholar 

  44. James Gould Henerey Michael MacLeod Michael (1970) ArticleTitle“Communication of Direction by the Honey Bee” Science 169 544–554

    Google Scholar 

  45. John D. Greenwood (1999) ArticleTitle“Understanding the ‘Cognitive Revolution’ in Psychology” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 35 1–22 Occurrence Handle10.1002/(SICI)1520-6696(199924)35:1<1::AID-JHBS1>3.0.CO;2-4

    Article  Google Scholar 

  46. Donald R Griffin (1976) The Question of Animal Awareness: Evolutionary Continuity of Mental Experience. Rockefeller University Press New York

    Google Scholar 

  47. Donald R. Griffin Peter. Marler (1974) ArticleTitle“‘Scientific Methods in Ethology,’ Letters” Science 185 814

    Google Scholar 

  48. John B. S. Haldane Helen. Spurway (1954) ArticleTitle“A Statistical Analysis of Communication in ‘Apis Mellifera’ and a Comparison with Communication in Other Animalsa” Insectes Sociaux 1 247–283 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF02222949

    Article  Google Scholar 

  49. Randy A Harris (1993) The Linguistics Wars. Oxford University Press New York

    Google Scholar 

  50. Charles F Hockett (1958) A Course in Modern Linguistics Macmillan New York

    Google Scholar 

  51. Hoptro Montgomery, Georgina. “Place, Practice and Primatology: Clarence Ray Carpentes, Primate Communication and the Development of Field Methodology, 1931–1945.” Journal of the History of Biology 38(3): 495–533.

  52. Dennis L. Johnson (1967) ArticleTitle“Honey Bees: Do they use the Direction Information Contained in their Dance Maneuver?” Science 155 844–847

    Google Scholar 

  53. Dennis L. Johnson Adrian M. Wenner (1966) ArticleTitle“A Relationship Between Conditioning and Communication in Honey Bees” Animal Behavior 14 261–265

    Google Scholar 

  54. Kak, Subhash. 1991. “The Honey Bee Dance Language Controversy.” The Mankind Quarterly (Summer), 357–365.

  55. Lester Krames Patricia Pliner Thomas Alloway (Eds) (1974) Nonverbal Communication Plenum Press New York 133–169

    Google Scholar 

  56. Daniel Lehrman (1953) ArticleTitle“A Critique of Konrad Lorenz’s Theory of Instinctive Behavior” Quarterly Review of Biology 28 337–363 Occurrence Handle10.1086/399858

    Article  Google Scholar 

  57. John C Lilly ( 1961) Man and Dolphin Doubleday and Company Garden City, NY

    Google Scholar 

  58. Martin. Lindauer (1955) ArticleTitle“Schwarmbienen auf Wohnungssuche” Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Physiologie 37 263–324 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00303153

    Article  Google Scholar 

  59. Martin. Lindauer (1971 [1961]) Communication Among Social Bees Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA

    Google Scholar 

  60. Jan. Lindsten (Eds) (1992) “The Nobel Prize for Physiology or Medicine 1973 Presentation Speech.” Scientific Publishing Company Singapore 71–73

    Google Scholar 

  61. John. Lotz (1950) ArticleTitle“Speech and Language” The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 22 712–717 Occurrence Handle10.1121/1.1906676

    Article  Google Scholar 

  62. John. Lotz (1951) ArticleTitle‘“Karl von Frisch: Bees; Their Vision, Chemical Senses, and Language,’ Book Review.” Word 7 7 66–67

    Google Scholar 

  63. Arthur Lovejoy (1960 [1936]) The Great Chain of Being; A Study of the History of an Idea Harper & Brothers New York

    Google Scholar 

  64. John Lubbock ( 1883) Ameisen, Bienen und Wespen. Brockhaus Leipzig

    Google Scholar 

  65. Abigail J. Lustig (2004) “Ants and the Nature of nature in Auguste Forel, Erich Wasmann, and William Morton Wheeler.” Daston Lorraine Vidal Fernando (Eds) The Moral Authority of Nature University of Chicago Press Chicago

    Google Scholar 

  66. George. Mandler (2002) ArticleTitle“Origins of the Cognitive Revolution” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 38 339–353 Occurrence Handle10.1002/jhbs.10066

    Article  Google Scholar 

  67. Aubrey Manning (1979 [1967]) An Introduction to Animal Behaviour EditionNumber3 Addison-Wesley Reading, MA

    Google Scholar 

  68. Peter Marler Donald. Griffin (1973) ArticleTitle“The 1973 Nobel Prize for Physiology or Medicine” Science 182 464–466

    Google Scholar 

  69. Jeffrey. Merrick (1988) ArticleTitle“Royal Bees: The Gender Politics of the Bee in Early Modern Europe” Studies in Eighteenth-Century Culture 18 7–38

    Google Scholar 

  70. Lorus Milne Margery Milne (1962) The Senses of Animals and Men. Atheneum New York

    Google Scholar 

  71. Gregg Mitman (1999) Reel Nature: America’s Romance With Wildlife on Film. Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA

    Google Scholar 

  72. Gregg Mitman (2004) “Pachyderm Personalities: The Media of Science, Politics, and Conservation.” Daston Loraine Mitman Gregg (Eds) Thinking with Animals: New Perspectives on Anthropomorphism Columbia University Press New York

    Google Scholar 

  73. Munz, Tania. “Of Birds and Bees: Karl von Frisch, Konrad Lorenz, and the Science of Animals.” PhD Dissertation. Princeton University. In preparation

  74. Lynn K Nyhart (1995) Biology Takes Form: Animal Morphology and the German Universities, 1800–1900. University of Chicago Press Chicago

    Google Scholar 

  75. Philip J Pauly (1987) Controlling life: Jacques Loeb and the Engineering Ideal in Biology. Oxford University Press New York

    Google Scholar 

  76. Frederick R. Prete (1991) ArticleTitle“Can Females Rule the Hive? The Controversy over Honey Bee Gender Roles in Beekeeping Texts of the Sixteenth-Eighteenth Centuries” Journal of the History of Biology 24 113–144

    Google Scholar 

  77. Gregory. Radick (2000) ArticleTitle“Morgan’s Canon, Garner’s Phonograph, and the Evolutionary Origins of Language and Reason” The British Journal for the History of Science 33 3–23

    Google Scholar 

  78. Gregory. Radick (2003) “R. L. Garner and the Rise of the Edison Phonograph in Evolutionary Philology.” Gitelman Lisa B. Pingree Geoffrey (Eds) New Media, 1740–1915 MIT Press Cambridge, MA 175–206

    Google Scholar 

  79. Radick, Gregory. “Primate Language and the Playback Experiment, in 1890 and 1980.” Journal of the History of Biology 38(3): 461–493 (this issue).

  80. Géza. Révész (1953) ArticleTitle“Der Kampf um die sogenannte Tiersprache” Psychologische Rundschau 4 31–34

    Google Scholar 

  81. Robert J. Richards (1987) Darwin and the Emergence of Evolutionary Theories of Mind and Behavior. University of Chicago Press Chicago

    Google Scholar 

  82. Theodore C. Schneirla (1957) “The Concept of Development in Comparative Psychology.” B. Harris Dale (Eds) The Concept of Development; An Issue in the Study of Human Behavior University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis 78–108

    Google Scholar 

  83. Theodore C. Schneirla (1964 [1961]) “Instinctive Behavior, Maturation-Experience and Development.” R.F. Maier Norman C. Schneirla Theodore (Eds) Principles of Animal Psychology 1964 [1935] Dover Publications New York 555–579

    Google Scholar 

  84. Theodore C. Schneirla (1971) Army Ants: A Study in Social Organization Freeman and Company San Francisco: W.H

    Google Scholar 

  85. Theodore C. Schneirla (1972 [1953]) “The Concept of Levels in the Study of Social Phenomena.” R. Aronson Lester (Eds) et al. Selected Writings of T.C. Schneirla Freeman and Company San Francisco: W.H. 238–253

    Google Scholar 

  86. Thomas A. Sebeok (1963) ArticleTitle“Communication among Social Bees; Porpoises and Sonar; Man and Dolphin” Language 39 448–466

    Google Scholar 

  87. Thomas A. Sebeok (Eds) (1968) Animal Communication; Techniques of Study and Results of Research Indiana University Press Bloomington

    Google Scholar 

  88. Thomas A. Sebeok Alexandra Ramsay (Eds) (1969) Approaches to Animal Communication Mouton The Hague

    Google Scholar 

  89. Steven Shapin Simon Shaffer (1985) Leviathan and the Air-Pump: Hobbes, Boyle, and the Experimental Life Princeton University Press Princeton

    Google Scholar 

  90. Gaylord Simpson George (1966) ArticleTitle“The Biological Nature of Man” Science 152 472–478

    Google Scholar 

  91. Sleigh, Charlotte. 2000. Six Legs Better: A Cultural History of Entomology in the Late Nineteenth and Early Twentieth Century. PhD Dissertation, University of Cambridge

  92. Roger Smith (1997) The Norton History of the Human Sciences. W.W. Norton New York

    Google Scholar 

  93. Wolfgang. Steche (1957) ArticleTitle“Gelenkter Bienenflug durch ‘Attrappentänze’” Naturwissenschaften 44 598

    Google Scholar 

  94. Steche, Wolfgang. 1959. “How to talk to a Bee” Time (February 9), p. 34

  95. Klaus Taschwer Föger. Benedikt (2003) Konrad Lorenz Paul Zsolany Verlag Wien

    Google Scholar 

  96. Keith Thomas (1983) Man and the Natural World: Changing Attitudes in England 1500–1800. Allen Lane London

    Google Scholar 

  97. Thomas, Marion. “Are Animals Just Noisy Machines?: Louis Boutan and the Co-invention of Animal and Child Psychology in the French Third Republic.” Journal of the History of Biology 38(3): 425–460 (this issue).

  98. William Homan Thorpe (1979) The Origins and Rise of Ethology: the Science of the Natural Behaviour of Animals Praeger New York

    Google Scholar 

  99. Daniel P. Todes (2002) Pavlov’s Physiology Factor: Experiment, Interpretation, Laboratory Enterprise. Johns Hopkins University Press Baltimore

    Google Scholar 

  100. Veldink, Connie J. 1976. Paradigm Challenges in Modern Science: the Bee Language Controversy. PhD Dissertation, University of California, Santa Barbara

  101. Daniel P. Todes (1989) ArticleTitle“The Honey-Bee Language Controversy” Interdisciplinary Science Reviews 14 166–175

    Google Scholar 

  102. Frans B.M Waal Particlede (2001) The Ape and the Sushi Master: Cultural Reflections by a Primatologist. Basic Books New York

    Google Scholar 

  103. Erich. Wasmann (1909 [1899]) Die Psychischen Fähigkeiten der Ameisen EditionNumber2 Schweizerbart Stuttgart

    Google Scholar 

  104. Patrick H. Wells Adrian M. Wenner (1973) ArticleTitle“Do Honey Bees have a Language?” Nature 241 171–175 Occurrence Handle10.1038/241171a0

    Article  Google Scholar 

  105. Adrian M. Wenner (1961a) ArticleTitle“Division of Labor in a Honey Bee Colony – A Markov Process?” Journal of Theoretical Biology 1 324–327 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0022-5193(61)90034-0

    Article  Google Scholar 

  106. Wenner, Adrian M. 1961b. Sound Production During the Waggle Dance of the Honey Bee. PhD Dissertation, University of Michigan

  107. Adrian M. Wenner (1964) ArticleTitle“Sound Communication in Honeybees” Scientific American 210 116–124

    Google Scholar 

  108. Adrian M. Wenner (1967) ArticleTitle“Honey Bees: Do they use the Distance Information Contained in their Dance Maneuver?” Science 155 847–849

    Google Scholar 

  109. Adrian M. Wenner (1968) “Honey Bees.” Sebeok Thomas (Eds) Animal Communication: Techniques of Study and Methods of Research Indiana University Press Bloomington 217–243

    Google Scholar 

  110. Adrian M. Wenner (1974) “Information Transfer in Honey Bees: A Population Approach.” Krames Lester Pliner Patricia Alloway Thomas (Eds) Nonverbal Communication Plenum Press New York 133–169

    Google Scholar 

  111. Adrian M. Wenner (1997) “The Role of Controversy in Animal Behavior.” Greenberg Gary (Eds) Comparative Psychology of Invertebrates: The Field and Laboratory Study of Insect Behavior Garland Publishing New York 3–37

    Google Scholar 

  112. Wenner, Adrian M. 1999–2003. 1A. Read Me First A Chronology. BeeSource.Com. http://www.beesource.com/pov/wenner/readme.htm (accessed January 19, 2005)

  113. Adrian M. Wenner Johnson Dennis L. (1966) ArticleTitle“Simple Conditioning in Honey Bees” Animal Behavior 14 149–155

    Google Scholar 

  114. Adrian M. Wenner H. Wells Patrick (1990) Anatomy of a Controversy: The Question of a Language Among Bees Columbia University Press New York

    Google Scholar 

  115. Adrian M. Wenner Patrick H. Wells Johnson Dennis L. (1969) ArticleTitle“Honeybee Recruitment to Food Sources: Olfaction or Language?” Science 164 84–86

    Google Scholar 

  116. Adrian M. Wenner Rohif James F. (1967) ArticleTitle“An Analysis of the Waggle Dance and Recruitment in Honey Bees” Physiological Zoölogy 40 317–44

    Google Scholar 

  117. Edward O. Wilson (1971) The Insect Societies Belknap Press of Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA

    Google Scholar 

  118. Edward O. Wilson (1972a) ArticleTitle“Animal Communication” Scientific American 227 52–60

    Google Scholar 

  119. Edward O. Wilson (1972b) ArticleTitle“Letters” Scientific American 227 6 Occurrence Handle10.1038/scientificamerican0972-52

    Article  Google Scholar 

  120. Edward O. Wilson (1989 [1985]) “In the Queendom of the Ants: A Brief AFutobiography.” A. Dewsbury Donald (Eds) Studying Animal Behavior: Autobiographies of the Founders University of Chicago Press Chicago

    Google Scholar 

  121. Robert M. Young (1967) “Animal Soul.” Edwards Paul (Eds) Encyclopedia of Philosophy Vol. 1. Macmillan New York 122–127

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Tania Munz.

Additional information

Winner of the 2005 International Society for the History, Philosophy and Social Studies of Biology Marjorie Grene Graduate Student Essay Prize.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Munz, T. The Bee Battles: Karl von Frisch, Adrian Wenner and the Honey Bee Dance Language Controversy. J Hist Biol 38, 535–570 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10739-005-0552-1

Download citation

Keywords

  • Adrian Wenner
  • animal behavior
  • animal communication
  • animal consciousness
  • animal mind
  • honeybee dance language
  • Karl von Frisch