Concept mapping, mind mapping and argument mapping: what are the differences and do they matter?
- 12k Downloads
In recent years, academics and educators have begun to use software mapping tools for a number of education-related purposes. Typically, the tools are used to help impart critical and analytical skills to students, to enable students to see relationships between concepts, and also as a method of assessment. The common feature of all these tools is the use of diagrammatic relationships of various kinds in preference to written or verbal descriptions. Pictures and structured diagrams are thought to be more comprehensible than just words, and a clearer way to illustrate understanding of complex topics. Variants of these tools are available under different names: “concept mapping”, “mind mapping” and “argument mapping”. Sometimes these terms are used synonymously. However, as this paper will demonstrate, there are clear differences in each of these mapping tools. This paper offers an outline of the various types of tool available and their advantages and disadvantages. It argues that the choice of mapping tool largely depends on the purpose or aim for which the tool is used and that the tools may well be converging to offer educators as yet unrealised and potentially complementary functions.
KeywordsConcept mapping Mind mapping Computer-aided argument mapping Critical thinking Argument Inference-making Knowledge mapping
My thanks to Tim Beaumont and two anonymous reviewers from the journal for useful comments on earlier versions of this paper.
- Ahlberg, M. (1993). Concept maps, vee diagrams, and Rhetorical Argumentation (RA) analysis: Three educational theory-based tools to facilitate meaningful learning. Paper presented at the Third International Seminar on Misconceptions in Science and Mathematics, Cornell University. Available from.Google Scholar
- Ahlberg, M. (2004). Varieties of concept mapping. Paper presented at the First International Conference on Concept Mapping, Pamplona, Spain. Available from.Google Scholar
- Ausubel, D. P. (1963). The psychology of meaningful verbal learning. New York: Grune and Stratton.Google Scholar
- Baugh, N. G., & Mellott, K. G. (1998). Clinical concept mapping as preparation for student nurses’ clinical experiences. Journal of Nursing Education, 37(6), 253–256.Google Scholar
- Biggs, J. (1987). Student approaches to learning and studying. Hawthorn, Vic: Australian Council for Educational Research (ACER).Google Scholar
- Biktimirov, E. N., & Nilson, L. B. (2003). Mapping your course: Designing a graphic syllabus for introductory FINANCE. Journal of Education for Business, 78(July//August), 308–312.Google Scholar
- Biktimirov, E. N., & Nilson, L. B. (2006). Show Them the money: Using mind mapping in the introductory finance course. Journal of Financial Education, 32(Fall), 72–86.Google Scholar
- Buzan, T. (1974). Using both sides of your brain. New York: E. P. Dutton.Google Scholar
- Buzan, T., & Buzan, B. (2000). The mind map book. London: BBC Books.Google Scholar
- Cañas, A. J., Hill, G., Carff, R., Suri, N., Lott, J., & Eskridge, T. (2004). CMap tools: A knowledge modellign and sharing environment. In A. J. Cañas, J. D. Novak, & F. M. Gonzalez (Eds.), Concept maps theory, methodology, technology: First international conference on concept mapping (Vol. 1, pp. 125–133). Pamplona, Spain: Universidad Publica de Navarra.Google Scholar
- Concept Map. (2010). Retrieved 8/3/2010, Wikipedia, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Concept_map&oldid=139167845.
- Daley, B. J. (2004). Using concept maps in qualitative research. Paper presented at the First International Conference on Concept Mapping, Pamploma, Spain. Available from http://cmc.ihmc.us/papers/cmc2004-060.pdf.
- Edmonson, K. M. (1993, April 12-16). Concept mapping for the development of medical curricula. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Atlanta, Georgia. Available from.Google Scholar
- Entwistle, N. (1981). Styles of learning and teaching; an integrated outline of educational psychology for students, teachers and lecturers. Chichester: John Wiley.Google Scholar
- Farrand, P., Hussain, F., & Hennessy, E. (2002a). The efficacy of “mind map” study technique. Medical Education, 36(May), 426–431.Google Scholar
- Gouveia, V., & Valadares, J. (2004). Concept maps and the didactic role of assessment. Paper presented at the First International Conference on Concept Mapping.Google Scholar
- Harrell, M. (2008). iLogos. Retrieved 7/11/08, from http://www.phil.cmu.edu/projects/argument_mapping/.
- Harrell, M. (2011). Argument diagramming and critical thinking in introductory philosophy. Higher Education Research and Development, forthcoming.Google Scholar
- Hay, D., Wells, H., & Kinchin, I. (Forthcoming). Using concept maps to measure learning quality. Higher Education.Google Scholar
- Hoffman, E., Trott, J., & Neely, K. P. (2002). Concept mapping: A tool to bridge the disciplinary divide. Amercian Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 187(September), S41–S43.Google Scholar
- Horn, R. E. (1998). Mapping great debates: Can computers think? bainbridge island. WA: MacroVU Press.Google Scholar
- Irvine, H., Cooper, K., & Jones, G. (2005, 24th–25th November). Concept mapping to enhance student learning in a financial accounting subject. Paper presented at the Accounting Educators’ Forum, Sydney, NSW. Available from.Google Scholar
- Jarvis, P. (1992). Paradoxes of learning. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
- Jonassen, D. H., Reeves, T. C., Hong, N., Harvey, D., & Peters, K. (1997). Concept mapping as cognitive learning and assessment tools. Journal of Interactive Learning Research, 8(3–4), 289–308.Google Scholar
- Kolb, D., & Fry, R. (1975). Towards an applied theory of experiential learning. In C. L. Cooper (Ed.), Theories of group processes. London: Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
- Kulhavy, R. W., Lee, J. B., & Caterino, L. C. (1985). Conjoint retention of maps and related discourse. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 10, 683–699.Google Scholar
- List of Concept Mapping Software. (2008). Retrieved 30th November, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_concept_mapping_software&oldid=139133393.
- List of Mind Mapping Software. (2008). Retrieved 29 October, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=List_of_mind_mapping_software&oldid=139428677.
- Maas, J., & Leauby, B. A. (2005). Concept mapping: Exploring its value as a meaningful learning tool in accounting education. Global Perspectives of Accounting Education, 2, 75–98.Google Scholar
- Mayer, R. E., & Gallini, J. K. (1990). When is an illustration worth ten thousand words?. Journal of Educational Psychology, 82(December), 715–726.Google Scholar
- McClain, A. (1987). Improving lectures: Challenging both sides of the brain. Journal of Optometric Education, 13(Summer), 18–12.Google Scholar
- McGaghie, W. C., McCrimmon, D. R., Mitchell, G., Thompson, J. A., & Ravitch, M. (2000). Quantitative concept mapping in pulmonary physiology: Comparison of student and faculty knowledge structures. Advances in Physiology Education, 23(1), 72–81.Google Scholar
- Mealy, D. L., & Nist, S. L. (1989). Postsecondary teacher directed comprehension strategies. Journal of Reading, 32(6), 484–493.Google Scholar
- Mind Maps Made With Mind Mapping Tool. 8/3/2010, from http://www.mindmapexample.com/samples.php.
- Nassi, I., & Shneiderman, B. (1973). Flowchart techniques for structured programming. SIGPLAN Notices, 8(8).Google Scholar
- Nettleship, J. (1992). Active learning in economics: Mind maps and wall charts. Economics, 28(Summer), 69–71.Google Scholar
- Novak, J. D. (1981). Applying learning psychology and philosophy to biology teaching. The American Biology Teacher, 43(1), 12/20.Google Scholar
- Novak, J. D., & Cañas, A. J. (2006). The theory underlying concept maps and how to construct them. Technical Report IHMC Cmap Tools 2006-01 Retrieved 21/6/07, Florida Institute for Human and Machine Cognition, from http://cmap.ihmcus/Publications/ResearchPapers/TheoryUnderlyingConceptMaps.pdf.
- Novak, J. D., & Gowin, D. (1984). Learning how to learn. New York: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
- Paivio, A. (1971). Imagery and verbal processes. New York: Holt, Reinhart and Winston.Google Scholar
- Paivio, A. (1983). The empirical case for dual coding. In J. Yuille (Ed.), Imagery, memory and cognition. Hillsdale, N. J.: Lawrence Erlbaum.Google Scholar
- Pressley, M., Van Etten, S., Yokoi, L., Freebern, G., & VanMeter, P. (1998). The metacognition of college studentship: A grounded theory approach. In J. D. D. J. Hacker & A. C. Graesser (Eds.), Metacognition in theory and practice (pp. 347–367). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
- Rochecouste, J. (2005). Constructing taxonomies for student writing. Paper presented at the European Association for the Teaching of Academic Writing. from http://eataw2005.hau.gr/pages/about.htm.
- Schau, C., & Mattern, N. (1997). Use of map Techniques in teaching applied statistics courses. The American Statistician, 51(May), 171–175.Google Scholar
- Schwartz, N. H. (1988). Cognitive processing characteristics of maps: Implications for instruction. Educational and Psychological Research, 8, 93–101.Google Scholar
- Software for Mind mapping and Information Storage. (2008). Retrieved 30th October, from http://www.mind-mapping.org/.
- Tufte, E. R. (1983). The visual display of quantitative information (2nd ed. ed.). Cheshire, CT: Graphics Press.Google Scholar
- Twardy, C. (2004). Argument maps improve critical thinking. Teaching Philosophy, 27(2), 95–116.Google Scholar
- van der Laan, S., & Dean, G. (2006). Assessment to Encourage Meaningful Learning in Groups: Concept Mapping,. NZ: AAFANZ SIG Wellington.Google Scholar
- van Gelder, T. (2001). How to improve critical thinking using educational technology. Paper presented at the Meeting at the Crossroads: Proceedings of the 18th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education, University of Melbourne. Available from.Google Scholar
- van Gelder, T., Bissett, M., & Cumming, G. (2004). Enhancing expertise in informal reasoning. Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology, 58, 142–152.Google Scholar
- Walker, J., & King, P. (2002). Concept mapping as a form of student assessment and instruction. Paper presented at the 2002 American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference and Exposition. Available from.Google Scholar
- Wilkes, L., Cooper, K., Lewin, J., & Batts, J. (1999). Concept mapping: Promoting science learning in bn learners in Australia. The Journal of Continuing Education in Nursing, 30(1), 37–44.Google Scholar
- Zeilik, M. (nd). Classroom assessment techniques: Concept mapping. Retrieved 8/3/2010, from http://www.flaguide.org/cat/conmap/conmap1.php.