Answering the Cost Assessment Scaling Challenge: Modelling the Annual Cost of European Computing Services for Research
ICT costs have been traditionally assessed using well-established methods such as full cost accounting or total cost of ownership. Within their specific, optimal application areas they provide very good tools for cost follow-up and strategic decision-making. However, as the scale and complexity of the system being analysed grows, these methods become less suitable. In particular, due to the complex funding structures, and the multi-supplier and cross-country nature of service provision, estimating the total costs of European computing services for research is perhaps one of the best examples of such complex, large-scale systems. Solving this challenge is crucial for the sustainability of these services: besides obvious technical budgeting challenges, difficulties in comparing the cost-effectiveness of different service delivery options make sustaining public support for funding more arduous than it should be. This paper presents a novel cost assessment methodology that addresses the above challenges and uses an in-depth analysis of the pan-European computing e-Infrastructure costs as a case study illustrating the use of the methodology. We also use this case study as an illustration of the kind of cost assessment issues that high-utilisation rate computing services should consider when choosing between different infrastructure options (for example comparing costs per core hour of in-house resources and public Cloud offerings).
KeywordsComputing cost In-house vs. cloud CAPEX OPEX Cost per core Utilization Depreciation HPC HTC E-Infrastructures
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- 1.Carlyle, A.G., et al: Cost-effective HPC: the community or the cloud. IEEE Conference on Cloud Computing Technology and Science (2010)Google Scholar
- 2.e- IRGSP2 EU deliverable D4.3 - Final legal issues report public, Members of the e-IRGSP2 Consortium, 28/01/2011Google Scholar
- 3.European Commission, Digital science in Horizon 2020, March 2013, http://ec.europa.eu/information_society/newsroom/cf/dae/document.cfm?doc_id=2124
- 4.European Grid Infrastructure (EGI), www.egi.eu
- 5.Hammond, M., Hawtin, R., Gillam, L., Oppenheim, C.: Cloud computing for research. Final Report, Curtis + Cartwright Consulting Ltd (7/7/2010) (2010)Google Scholar
- 6.Hawtin, R.M. Hammond, Gillam, L., Curtis, G.: Cost analysis of cloud computing for research (2012). Final Report to EPSRC and JISC, 22/2/2012, Curtis + Cartwright Consulting LtdGoogle Scholar
- 8.Kashef, Altmann: A cost model for Hybrid Clouds. In: Vanmechelen, K., Altmann, J., Rana, O.F. (eds.) GECON 2011, LNCS 7150, pp 46–60 (2012)Google Scholar
- 9.Magellan Final Report, December 2011 30. (http://science.energy.gov/~/media/ascr/pdf/program-documents/docs/Magellan_Final_Report.pdf)
- 10.Marston, et al: Cloud computing — The business perspective. Decis. Support. Syst. 51, 176–189 (2011)Google Scholar
- 11.Message-Passing Interface (MPI) specification: http://www.mpi-forum.org/.
- 14.NAS Parallel Benchmarks: http://www.nas.nasa.gov/Resources/Software/npb.html (accessed 25/05/2011)
- 15.Nazir, A, Sørensen, S.-A.: Cost benefit analysis of high performance computing infrastructuresPaper presented in Service Oriented Computing and Applications (SOCA) 2010 IEEE International Conference, Vol. 2010Google Scholar
- 16.OpenMP specification: http://openmp.org (accessed 25/05/2012)
- 18.Partnership for Advanced Computing in Europe (PRACE) [REF www.prace-ri.eu]
- 19.Risch, M, Altman, J.: Cost analysis of current grids and its implications for future grid markets. In: Altmann, J., Neumann, D., Fahringer, T. (eds.) GECON 2008, LNCS 5206, pp 13–27 (2008)Google Scholar
- 20.Smith, Preston M.M.S.: Purdue University, May 2011. A Cost-Benefit Analysis of a Campus Computing Grid. Major Professors: Jeffrey J. Evans, Kevin C. Dittman, and Carol X. SongGoogle Scholar
- 22.University of Washington Hyak Operating Costs and Comparison with Commercial Alternatives, http://escience.washington.edu/get-help-now/hyak-operating-costs-and-comparison-commercial-alternatives (accessed 18/07/2011)
- 23.Walker, E.: The real cost of a CPU hour. Computing Practices 43(4), 35–41 (2009)Google Scholar