Advertisement

GeoJournal

, Volume 84, Issue 2, pp 345–366 | Cite as

Is ecotourism a panacea? Political ecology perspectives from the Sundarban Biosphere Reserve, India

  • Priyanka GhoshEmail author
  • Aditya Ghosh
Article

Abstract

Ecotourism is increasingly being promoted as an instrument that helps local socio-economic development and generate revenues to strengthen conservation of critically endangered biodiversity. It is often posited the magic bullet particularly across protected areas in the Global South. In theory, ecotourism can provide economic benefits to economically weaker communities living around protected areas and inspire them to protect the biodiversity in their own interest. This paper, however, provides empirical evidence that the so-called win–win is not an unqualified truism. With a case study on Sundarban Biosphere Reserve, world’s largest mangrove biodiversity and home of highly endangered Royal Bengal Tiger, this article examines complexities involved in ecotourism and urges the need to make it context-specific. It assesses ecotourism’s ability to provide livelihood alternatives to local communities and how can it help in conservation. The findings demonstrate an unequal, uneven, and skewed accumulation of benefits of ecotourism, often associated with market mechanisms of global environmental protection. As little as 36% of the interviewees claimed receiving direct or indirect benefits from ecotourism, the study finds. It failed to offer any benefits at all to the poorest and most marginal communities. On the contrary, it offered disproportionately larger returns to the remotely located capital invested in the local ecotourism facilities in the Sundarbans, thus defeating the principle behind the mechanism. In the area of conservation, tourism was blamed for increasing pollution and harming the health of the ecosystem by tourists who were considered ‘outsiders’ and insensitive to the ecology by the locals and conservation agencies alike.

Keywords

Ecotourism Political ecology Community-based conservation Sundarban Biosphere Reserve India 

Notes

Acknowledgements

We thank local communities of Gosaba for providing valuable information and time during the fieldwork. We also thank Dr. Tad Mutersbaugh and Dr. P. P. Karan at the University of Kentucky for their thoughtful comments on a very early draft of the paper which provided it a defined direction. We sincerely thank Dr. Jonathan Phillips and Lynn Phillips at the University of Kentucky for reviewing the final version of the article. We thank Ryan Cooper and Raghava Davuluri for lending their hand in map-making of the Sundarbans. The research was financially supported by the National Science Foundation, US (DDRI No. 1029993), and Association of American Geographers (AAG) Dissertation Research Grant 2012.

Compliance with ethical standards

Conflict of interest

We, the authors hereby declare that we have followed the accepted principles of ethical and professional conduct required by your journal. We also confirm that there is no way our manuscript is in possible conflict with the ethical standards required by the journal.

References

  1. Balmford, A., Beresford, J., Green, J., Naidoo, R., Walpole, M., & Manica, A. (2009). A global perspective on trends in nature-based tourism. PLoS Biology, 7(6), 1–6.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Banerjee, A. (2007). An evolution of the potential and limitations of ecotourism as a vehicle for biodiversity conservation and sustainable development in the protected areas of India. Ph.D. diss., University of Delaware, Delaware, USA.Google Scholar
  3. Banerjee, A. (2012). Is wildlife tourism benefiting Indian protected areas? A survey. Current Issues in Tourism, 15(3), 211–227.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Banerjee, A. (2013). Joint forest management in West Bengal. In O. Springate-Baginski & P. Blaikie (Eds.), Forests people and power: The political ecology of reform in South Asia (pp. 221–260). New York: Earthscan, Routledge.Google Scholar
  5. Bangladesh, I. U. C. N. (2001). The Bangladesh Sundarbans: A photoreal Sojourn. Dhaka: IUCN Bangladesh Country Office.Google Scholar
  6. Basu, K. (2010). Ecology and adaptation—A study in the Sundarban Biosphere Reserve. In G. K. Bera & V. S. Sahay (Eds.), In the Lagoons of the Gangetic Delta (pp. 65–82). New Delhi: Mittal Publications.Google Scholar
  7. Blamey, R. K. (2001). Principles of ecotourism. In D. B. Weaver (Ed.), The encyclopedia of ecotourism (pp. 5–22). New York: CABI Publishing.Google Scholar
  8. Bottrill, C., & Pearce, D. (1995). Ecotourism: Towards a key elements approach to operationalising the concept. Journal of Sustainable tourism, 3(1), 45–54.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Brandon, K. (1996). Ecotourism and conservation: A review of key issues. Washington, DC: World Bank.Google Scholar
  10. Bryant, R. L. (1998). Power, knowledge and political ecology in the third world: A review. Progress in Physical Geography, 22(1), 79–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Bryant, R. L. (2015). Reflecting on political ecology. In R. L. Bryant (Ed.), The international hand book of political ecology (pp. 14–24). Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Butcher, J. (2007). Ecotourism, NGOs and development: A critical analysis. New York: Routledge.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Ceballos-Lascuráin, H. (1996). Tourism, ecotourism, and protected areas: The state of nature-based tourism around the world and guidelines for its development. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Che, D. (2006). Developing ecotourism in first world, resource-dependent areas. Geoforum, 37(2), 212–226.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Danda, A. (2010). Sundarbans: Future imperfect: Climate adaptation report. New Delhi: World Wide Fund for Nature-India.Google Scholar
  16. Department of Tourism, Government of West Bengal. (2008). West Bengal Tourism Policy. Kolkata: Department of Tourism, Government of West Bengal.Google Scholar
  17. Directorate of Census Operations. (2011). District Census Handbook: South 24 Parganas, Series 20, Part XII A and B. Kolkata.Google Scholar
  18. Douglas, J. A. (2014). What’s political ecology got to do with tourism? Tourism Geographies, 16(1), 8–13.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Duffy, R. (2015). Nature-based tourism and neoliberalism: Concealing contradictions. Tourism Geographies, 17(4), 529–543.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Eaton, R. M. (1990). Human settlement and colonization in the Sundarbans, 1200–1750. Agriculture and Human Values, 7(2), 6–16.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Epler Wood, M., Gatz, F., & Lindberg, K. (1991). The Ecotourism Society: An action agenda. In J. Kusler (Ed.), Ecotourism and resource conservation (pp. 75–79). Selected papers from the 2nd International Symposium: Ecotourism and Resource Conservation, Omnipress, Madison.Google Scholar
  22. Fletcher, R. (2014). Romancing the wild: Cultural dimensions of ecotourism. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Fletcher, R., & Neves, K. (2012). Contradictions in tourism: The promise and pitfalls of ecotourism as a manifold capitalist fix. Environment and Society: Advances in Research, 3(1), 60–77.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Richards F. J., & Flint, E. P. (1990). Long-term transformations in the Sundarbans Wetland Forests of Bengal. Agriculture and Human Values (Spring), 17–33.Google Scholar
  25. Ghosh, A. K. (Ed.). (2008). Status of environment in West Bengal—A citizen’s report. Kolkata: ENDEV-Society for Environment and Development.Google Scholar
  26. Ghosh, P. (2013). Impacts of biodiversity conservation on rural livelihoods in and around the Sundarban Tiger Reserve (STR): A case study of struggles over access to forest-based resources In NMML occasional paper: Perspectives in Indian Development, New Series 13. New Delhi, India: Nehru Memorial Museum and Library. ISBN 81-87614- 73-0.Google Scholar
  27. Ghosh, P.. (2014). Subsistence and biodiversity conservation in the Sundarban Biosphere Reserve, West Bengal, India. Ph.D. diss., University of Kentucky, Lexington, USA. http://uknowledge.uky.edu/geography_etds/26.
  28. Ghosh, P. (2015). Conservation and conflicts in the Sundarban Biosphere Reserve, India. Geographical Review, 105(4), 429–440.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Ghosh, A. (2017). Sustainability conflicts in coastal India: Hazards, climate change and development discourse in Indian Sundarbans. Advances in Asian Human–Environment Research Series, Spinger-Nature. ISBN 978-3319638911.Google Scholar
  30. Gibson, T. D., Pelling, M., Ghosh, A., Matyas, D., Siddiqi, A., Solecki, W., et al. (2016). Pathways for transformation: Disaster risk management to enhance resilience to extreme events. Journal of Extreme Events, 3(1), 1671002-1–1671002-23.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Goodwin and Chaudhary. (2017). Eco-tourism dimensions and directions in India: An empirical study of Andhra Pradesh. Journal of Commerce & Management Thought, 8(3), 436–451.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Gopal, B., & Chauhan, M. (2006). Biodiversity and its conservation in the Sundarban mangrove ecosystem. Aquatic Sciences, 68(3), 338–354.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Gossling, S. (1999). Ecotourism: A means to safeguard biodiversity and ecosystem functions? Ecological Economics, 29(2), 303–320.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Gupta, J. (2015). Sunderbans damage riles green tribunal. The Times of India, January 23. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kolkata/Sunderbans-damage-riles-green-tribunal/articleshow/45972173.cms. Accessed May 9, 2017.
  35. Hackel, J. D. (1999). Community conservation and the future of Africa’s wildlife. Conservation Biology, 13(4), 726–734.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hannam, K. (2004). Tourism and forest management in India: The role of the state in limiting tourism development. Tourism Geographies, 6(3), 331–351.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Healy, R. G. (1994). ‘Tourist merchandise’ as a means of generating local benefits from ecotourism. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 2(3), 137–151.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hearne, R., & Santos, A. (2005). Tourists’ and locals’ preferences toward Eco-tourism development in the Maya Biosphere Reserve, Guatemala. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 7(3), 303–318.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Herrold-Menzies, M. (2006). Boating on the Sea of Grass: Western development ecotourism, and elite capture in Guizhou. China. Asian Geographer, 25(1–2), 109–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Jacobson, S. K., & Robles, R. (1992). Ecotourism, sustainable development, and conservation education: Development of a tour guide training program in Tortuguero, Costa Rica. Environmental Management, 16(6), 701–713.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Jalais, A. (2010). Forest of tigers: People, politics & environment in the Sundarbans. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
  42. Jhala, Y. V., Qureshi, Q., & Gopal, R. (Eds.). (2015). The status of tigers in India, 2014. New Delhi & Derahdun: National Tiger Conservation Authority & The Wildlife Institute of India.Google Scholar
  43. Jhala, Y. V., Qureshi, Q., Gopal, R., & Sinha, P. R. (Eds.). (2011). Status of the tigers, co-predators and prey in India, 2010. New Delhi: National Tiger Conservation Authority, Govt. of India, and Dehradun: Wildlife Institute of India.Google Scholar
  44. Jodha, N. S. (2000). Joint management of forests: Small gains. Economic and Political Weekly, 35(50), 4396–4399.Google Scholar
  45. Karanth, K. K., & DeFries, R. (2010). Nature-based tourism in Indian protected areas: New challenges for park management. Conservation Letters, 4(2), 1–13.Google Scholar
  46. Karanth, K. K., DeFries, R., Srivathsa, A., & Sankaraman, V. (2012). Wildlife tourists in India’s emerging economy: Potential for a conservation constituency. Oryx, 46(3), 382–390.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Karanth, K. K., & Krishnadas, M. (2011). Opportunity or threat to National Parks? Can wildlife tourism and conservation go hand-in-hand? The Hindu Survey of the Environment, 128–136.Google Scholar
  48. Karanth, K. K., & Nepal, S. K. (2012). Local residents perception of benefits and losses from protected areas in India and Nepal. Environmental Management, 49(2), 372–386.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. King, A. D., & Stewart, W. P. (1996). Ecotourism and commodification: Protecting people and places. Biodiversity and Conservation, 5(3), 293–305.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. Kumar, Suhas. (2002). Wildlife tourism in India: Need to tread with care. In B. D. Sharma (Ed.), Indian wildlife: Threats and preservation. New Delhi: Anmol Publications.Google Scholar
  51. Latour, B. (1993). We have never been modern. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
  52. Lindberg, K., & Hawkins, D. (Eds.). (1993). Ecotourism: A guide for planners and managers. North Bennington: The Ecotourism Society.Google Scholar
  53. Mandal, D. B. (Ed.). (2007). Man in biosphere: A case Study of Sundarban Biosphere Reserve. New Delhi: Gyan Publishing House.Google Scholar
  54. Masud, M. M., Aldakhil, A. M., Nassani, A. A., & Azam, M. N. (2017). Community-based ecotourism management for sustainable development of marine protected areas in Malaysia. Ocean and Coastal Management, 136, 104–112.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Misra, S., Maikhuri, R. K., Dhyani, D., & Rao, K. S. (2009). Assessment of traditional rights, local interference and natural resource management in Kedarnath Wildlife Sanctuary. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology, 16(6), 404–416.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Naha, D., Jhala, Y. V., Qureshi, Q., Roy, M., Sankar, K., & Gopal, R. (2016). Ranging, activity and habitat use by tigers in the mangrove forests of the Sundarban. PLoS ONE, 11(4), e0152119.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Narain, S., Singh, S., Panwar, H. S., & Gadgil, M. (2005). Joining the dots: The report of the Tiger Task Force. New Delhi: Government of India.Google Scholar
  58. Noy, C. (2008). Sampling knowledge: The hermeneutics of snowball sampling in qualitative research. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 11(4), 327–344.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Ojeda, D. (2012). Green pretexts: Ecotourism, neoliberal conservation and land grabbing in Tayrona National Natural Park. Columbia. Journal of Peasant Studies, 39(2), 357–375.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  60. Ostrom, E. (1999). Coping with tragedies of the commons. Annual review of political science, 2(1), 493–535.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  61. Rocheleau, D. E. (2008). Political ecology in the key of policy: From chains of explanation to webs of relation. Geoforum, 39(2), 716–727.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Ross, S., & Wall, G. (1999). Ecotourism: Towards congruence between theory and practice. Tourism Management, 20(1), 123–132.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Salum, A. L. (2009). Ecotourism and biodiversity conservation in Jozani-Chwaka Bay National Park, Zanzibar. African Journal of Ecology, 47, 166–170.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. Sarin, M. (2007). Empowerment and disempowerment of forest women in Uttarakhand, India. In M. Rangarajan (Ed.), Environmental issues in India (pp. 483–506). New Delhi: Dorling Kindersley.Google Scholar
  65. Sarin, M., Singh, N. M., Sundar, N., & Bhogal, R. K. (2003). Devolution as a threat to democratic decision-making in forestry? Findings from three states in India. London: Overseas Development Institute (Working Paper 197).Google Scholar
  66. Sarkar, R. (2008). Decentralized forest governance in Central Himalayas: A re-evaluation of outcomes. Economic and Political Weekly, 43(18), 54–63.Google Scholar
  67. Seema, P., Jojo, T. D., Freeda, M. S., Santosh, B., Sheetal, P., Gladwin, J., et al. (2006). White paper on eco-tourism policy. Bangalore: Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment (ATREE).Google Scholar
  68. Sekhar, N. U. (2003). Local people’s attitudes towards conservation and wildlife around Sariska Tiger Reserve, India. Journal of Environmental Management, 69(4), 339–347.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  69. Sen, A. (1999). Development as freedom. USA: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  70. Shoo, R. A., & Songorwa, A. N. (2013). Contribution of eco-tourism to nature conservation and improvement of livelihoods around Amani Nature Reserve. Tanzania. Journal of Ecotourism, 12(2), 75–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  71. Sinha, B. C., Qureshi, Q., Uniyal, V. K., & Sen, S. (2012). Economics of wildlife tourism—Contribution to livelihoods of communities around Kanha tiger reserve, India. Journal of Ecotourism.  https://doi.org/10.1080/14724049.2012.721785
  72. Sivaramakrishnan, K. (2000). Crafting the public sphere in the forests of West Bengal: Democracy, development, and political action. American Ethnologist, 27(2), 431–461.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  73. Stem, C., Lassoie, J., Lee, D., Deshler, D., & Schelhas, J. (2003). Community participation in ecotourism benefits: The link to conservation practices and perspectives. Society and Natural Resources, 16(5), 387–413.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Stone, M., & Wall, G. (2004). Ecotourism and community development: Case studies from Hainan, China. Environmental Management, 33(1), 12–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Stronza, A., & Gordillo, J. (2008). Community views of ecotourism. Annals of Tourism Research, 35(2), 448–468.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  76. STR Annual Report. (2007–2008). Conservator of Forest & Field Director, Sundarban Tiger Reserve. Canning, West Bengal, India: Directorate of Forests, Government of West Bengal.Google Scholar
  77. STR Annual Report. (2008–2009). Conservator of Forest & Field Director, Sundarban Tiger Reserve. Canning, West Bengal, India: Directorate of Forests, Government of West Bengal.Google Scholar
  78. STR Annual Report. (2009–2010). Conservator of Forest & Field Director, Sundarban Tiger Reserve. Canning, West Bengal, India: Directorate of Forests, Government of West Bengal.Google Scholar
  79. STR Annual Report. (2013–2014). Conservator of Forest & Field Director, Sundarban Tiger Reserve. Canning, West Bengal, India: Directorate of Forests, Government of West Bengal.Google Scholar
  80. STR Management Plan. (2000–2010). Kolkata: West Bengal Forest Department.Google Scholar
  81. Upadhyay, V. P., Ranjan, R., & Singh, J. S. (2002). Human–mangrove conflicts: The way out. Current Science, 83(11), 1328–1336.Google Scholar
  82. Wall, G. (1997). Is ecotourism sustainable? Environmental Management, 21(4), 483–491.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  83. Wallace, D. (1992). Is ‘eco’ tourism for real? Landscape Architect, 82, 34–36.Google Scholar
  84. Walpole, M. J., & Goodwin, H. J. (2000). Local economic impacts of dragon tourism in Indonesia. Annals of Tourism Research, 27(3), 559–576.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. Wells, M. P. (1996). The social role of protected areas in the new South Africa. Environmental Conservation, 23(4), 322–331.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. Wells, M., & Brandon, K. (with L. Hannah). (1992). People and parks: Linking protected area management with local communities. Washington, DC: The World Bank.Google Scholar
  87. Yuan, J., Dai, L., & Wang, Q. (2008). State-led ecotourism development and nature conservation: A case study of the Changbai Mountain Biosphere Reserve, China. Ecology and Society, 13(2), 55.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V., part of Springer Nature 2018

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of GeographyUniversity of KentuckyLexingtonUSA
  2. 2.Faculty of Sustainability, Institute of Ethics and Transdisciplinary Sustainability ResearchLeuphana UniversityLüneburgGermany

Personalised recommendations