Abstract
This paper describes the changing discourses of territory in Sri Lanka and their utility in conflict relations. The primordial homeland has been at the center of Sri Lanka’s armed struggle, in which both Sinhalese and Tamil nationalisms have used claims of ancient and ethnically determined territories to justify their right to self-determination, territorial sovereignty, and armed struggle. This identity–territory nexus based on historical argument has been destabilized in Sri Lanka, however. Scholarly findings suggest that historical linkages between ethnicity and territory in Sri Lanka are highly problematic and are no longer effectual means for adjudicating territorial desires in Sri Lanka and producing stable homelands. I argue that rights-based territorial discourses have emerged to enhance the old historical justifications for territorial authority. New narratives based upon fulfilling or denying human rights have been put to work linking authority to territory based upon moral fitness and unfitness, political legitimacy and illegitimacy, and ultimately, upon which political actor deserves to rule the territorially bound population under its control. The first part of the paper examines historical narratives linking national homelands to identity as well as scholarly work that deconstructs this linkage. In part two, external sovereignty and political legitimacy are discussed as the starting point for understanding how rights-based discourses justify territorial claims. In part three, accusations related to human rights violations are described as an important vehicle for shaming political adversaries, undermining their legitimacy, and making and unmaking territorial claims in Sri Lanka.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
B. Anderson (1991) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism Verso London
InstitutionalAuthorNameAsia Watch (1992) The Sri Lankan Conflict and Standards of Humanitarian Law 4 Issue 14 Asia Watch New York
A. Balasingham (1983) Liberation Tigers and Tamil Eelam Freedom Struggle Political Committee, LTTE Madras
S. Bose (1994) States, Nations, Sovereignty: Sri Lanka, India and the Tamil Eelam Movement Sage New Delhi
J.A. Camilleri (1990) Rethinking sovereignty in a shrinking, fragmented world R.B.J. Walker S.H. Mendlovitz (Eds) Contending Sovereignties: Redefining Political Community Lynne Rienner Boulder
H.P. Chattopadhyaya (1994) Ethnic Unrest in Modern Sri Lanka: An Account of Tamil – Sinhalese Race Relations MD Publications New Delhi
Colmey, J., 1992: In the Thick of a Jaffna Battle. Asiaweek, August 14, 1992
InstitutionalAuthorNameCommittee for Rational Development (1984) Sri Lanka, The Ethnic Conflict: Myths, Realities, and Perspectives Navrang New Delhi
R. Coomaraswamy (1994) Devolution, the law, and judicial construction S. Bastien (Eds) Devolution and Development in Sri Lanka International Centre for Ethnic Studies in association with Konark Publishers Colombo
C.R. De Silva (1998) The impact of nationalism on education: the schools take-over (1961) and the university admissions crisis M. Roberts (Eds) Collective Identities Revisited NumberInSeriesII Marga Institute Colombo
K.M. De Silva (1987) The ‘Traditional Homelands’ of the Tamils of Sri Lanka: A Historical Appraisal International Centre for Ethnic Studies Colombo
W. Geiger (1984) The Dipavamsa and Mahavamsa and Their Historical Development in Ceylon Trumpet Colombo
P.S. Ghosh (2003) Ethnicity versus Nationalism: The Devolution Discourse in Sri Lanka Sage New Delhi
A. Greenwald (1978) The relic in the spear: historiography and the Saga of Dutthagamani B.L. Smith (Eds) Religion and the Legitimation of Power in Sri Lanka Anima Chambersburg, PA
R.A.L.H. Gunawardana (1990) The people of the lion: the Sinhala identity and ideology in history and historiography J. Spencer (Eds) Sri Lanka: History and the Roots of Conflict Routledge London
A. Guneratne (2002) What’s in a name? Aryans and Dravidians in the making of Sri Lankan identities N. Silva (Eds) Hybrid Island: Cultural Crossings and the Invention of Identity in Sri Lanka Social Scientists’ Association Colombo
Hartshorne, R., 1950: The Functional Approach in Political Geography. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 40
H.-R. Dagmar (1994) The Tamil Tigers: Armed Struggle for Identity Franz Steiner Verlag Stuttgart
S.K. Hennayake (1992) ArticleTitleInteractive ethnonationalism: an alternative explanation of minority ethnonationalism Political Geography 11 526–49 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0962-6298(92)90054-W
J. Herz (1959) International Politics in the Atomic Age Columbia University Press New York
Hettiarachchi, K., 2003: Former Child Soldiers Face Uncertain Future. Inter Press Service. Available online at http://www.ipsnews.net/srilanka/note_1310.shtml
F.H. Hinsley (1986) Sovereignty EditionNumber2 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
P. Hirst G. Thompson (1996) Globalization in Question: The International Economy and the Possibilities of Governance Polity Press Cambridge
J. Hoffman (1998) Sovereignty University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis
R. Hoole D. Somasundaram K. Sritharan R. Thiranagama (1990) The Broken Palmyra: The Tamil Crisis in Sri Lanka – An Inside Account Sri Lanka Studies Institute Claremont, CA
Ignatieff, M., 2002: Will the Quest for Security Kill the Human Rights Era?. International Herald Tribune, 06 February
R.W. Jackman (1993) Power Without Force: The Political Capacity of Nation-States University of Michigan Press Ann Arbor
A. James (1986) Sovereign Statehood Allen and Unwin London
P. Jeganathan (1995) Authorizing history, ordering land: the conquest of Anuradhapura P. Jeganathan Q. Ismail (Eds) Unmaking the Nation: The Politics of Identity and History in Modern Sri Lanka Social Scientists’ Association Colombo
Kaiser, R.J., 1994: The Meaning of Homeland in the Study of Nationalism. In: The Geography of Nationalism in Russia and the USSR. Princeton University Press, Princeton
R.J. Kaiser J. Chinn (1995) Russians as the New Minority: Ethnicity and Nationalism in the Soviet Successor States Westview Boulder
J. Kane (2001) The Politics of Moral Capital Cambridge University Press Cambridge
B. Kapferer (1988) Legends of People, Myths of State: Violence, Intolerance and Political Culture in Sri Lanka and Australia Smithsonian Institute Press Washington and London
M. Keck K. Sikkink (1998) Activists Beyond Borders Cornell University Press Ithaca
Keenan, A., 2004: Bindunuwewa: Justice Undone? In: State of Human Rights 2004. Law and Society Trust, Colombo
S. Kelegama (1999) Economic costs of conflict in Sri Lanka R.I. Rotberg (Eds) Creating Peace in Sri Lanka: Civil War and Reconciliation Brookings Institution Press Washington DC
S. Kemper (1991) The Presence of the Past: Chronicles, Politics, and Culture in Sinhala Life Cornell University Press Ithaca, NY
M. Kleinfeld (2003) ArticleTitleStrategic troping in Sri Lanka: September eleventh and the consolidation of political position Geopolitics 8 IssueID3 105–26 Occurrence Handle10.1080/14650040412331307732
Kleinfeld, M., 2005: Depoliticizing Space in Sri Lanka: The Discursive Utility of the Child During Times of War. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Kentucky
Kois, L.M., Francis, D. and Rotberg, R.I., 1998: Sri Lanka’s Civil War and Prospects for Post-Conflict Resolution. WPF Report 18. World Peace Foundation, Cambridge, Mass
S. Krishna (1998) Postcolonial Insecurities: India, Sri Lanka, and the Question of Nationhood University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis
D. Little (1994) Sri Lanka: The Invention of Enmity United States Institute of Peace Washington, DC
C. Manogaran (1987) Ethnic Conflict and Reconciliation in Sri Lanka University of Hawaii Press Honolulu
C. Manogaran (1994) Colonization as politics: political use of space in Sri Lanka’s ethnic conflict C. Manogaran B. Pfaffenberger (Eds) The Sri Lankan Tamils: Ethnicity and Identity Westview Boulder
R. Mullerson (1997) Human Rights Diplomacy Routledge London
A.B. Murphy (1996) The sovereign state system as political-territorial ideal: historical and contemporary considerations T.J. Biersteker C. Weber (Eds) State Sovereignty as a Social Construct Cambridge University Press Cambridge
A.B. Murphy (1990) ArticleTitleHistorical justifications for territorial claims Annals of the Association of American Geographers 80 531–48 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1467-8306.1990.tb00316.x
E. Nissan R.L. Stirrat (1990) The generation of communal identities J. Spencer (Eds) Sri Lanka: History and the Roots of Conflict Routledge London
G. Obeyesekere (1979) The Vicissitudes of the Sinhala-Buddhist identity through time and change M. Roberts (Eds) Collective Identities Nationalisms and Protest in Modern Sri Lanka Marga Institute Colombo
Peiris G.H. (ed.), 2001: Clandestine Transactions of the LTTE and the Secessionist Campaign in Sri Lanka. Ethnic Studies Report, 19(1): 1–38.
InstitutionalAuthorNamePeople’s Forum (1986) A Suggested Peace Treaty to End the Eeylom War People’s Forum Jaffna
N. Perera (1999) Decolonizing Ceylon: Colonialism, Nationalism and the Politics of Space in Sri Lanka Oxford University Press New Delhi
S. Ponnambalam (1983) Sri Lanka: The National Question and the Tamil Liberation Struggle Zed Books London
D. Rajasingham-Senanayake (2002) Identity on the borderline: modernity, new ethnicities, and the unmaking of multiculturalism in Sri Lanka N. Silva (Eds) Hybrid Island: Cultural Crossings and the Invention of Identity in Sri Lanka Social Scientists’ Association Colombo
InstitutionalAuthorNameRefugee Council (2003) Sri Lanka: Internally Displaced Persons and Safe Returns Refugee Council London
T. Risse K. Sikkink (1999) The socialization of international human rights norms into domestic practices: introduction T. Risse S.C. Ropp K. Sikkink (Eds) The Power of Human Rights: International Norms and Domestic Change Cambridge University Press Cambridge
M. Roberts (2001) Sinala-ness and Sinhala Nationalism Marga Institute Colombo
V. Samaraweera (1997) Promoting Three Basic Freedoms: Towards Greater Freedom of Association, Assembly and Expression in Asia Law and Society Trust Colombo
D. Scott (1995) Dehistoricising history P. Jeganathan Q. Ismail (Eds) Unmaking the Nation: The Politics of Identity and History in Modern Sri Lanka Social Scientists’ Association Colombo
J.P. Senaratne (1997) Political Violence in Sri Lanka, 1977–1990: Riots, Insurrections, Counter-insurgencies, Foreign Intervention VU University Press Amsterdam
Silva, C., 2001: The Policy on the Restriction of Movement of People and Restriction on Items to be Shipped to the Conflict Areas. Report submitted to the UNDP Working Group of Programmatic Priorities
N. Silva (2002) Introduction N. Silva (Eds) Hybrid Island: Cultural Crossings and the Invention of Identity in Sri Lanka Social Scientists’ Association Colombo
B. Swan (1987) Sri Lankan Mosaic: Environment, Man, Continuity and Change Marga Institute Colombo
S.J. Tambiah (1986) Sri Lanka – Ethnic Fratricide and the Dismantling of Democracy Oxford University Press Delhi
S.J. Tambiah (1992) Buddhism Betrayed? University of Chicago Press Chicago
P.J. Taylor (1994) ArticleTitleTerritoriality in the modern world-system Progress in Human 18 151–62
P.J. Taylor (1995) ArticleTitleBeyond containers: internationality, interstateness, interterritoriality Progress in Human 19 1–15
InstitutionalAuthorName(TULF) Tamil United Liberation Front (1988) Towards Devolution of Power in Sri Lanka: Main Documents, August 1983 to October 1987 TULF Madras
J. Uyangoda (1994) The state and the process of devolution in Sri Lanka S. Bastien (Eds) Devolution and Development in Sri Lanka International Centre for Ethnic Studies in association with Konark Publishers Colombo
J. Uyangoda (1998) Biographies of a decaying nation-state M. Tiruchelvam C.S. Dattathreya (Eds) Culture and Politics of Identity in Sri Lanka International Centre for Ethnic Studies Colombo
A.M. Wachman (2001) ArticleTitleDoes the diplomacy of shame promote human rights in China? Third World Quarterly 22 IssueID2 257–81 Occurrence Handle10.1080/01436590120043309
Wickremasinghe, S., 1999: Emergency Rule. In Sri Lanka: State of Human Rights 1999. Law and Society Trust, Colombo
J.A. Wilson (1988) The Break-Up of Sri Lanka: The Sinhalese-Tamil Conflict University of Hawaii Press Honolulu
J.A. Wilson (1993) ArticleTitleEthnic strife in Sri Lanka: the politics of space Regional Politics and Policy 3 144–69
J.A. Wilson (2000) Sri Lankan Tamil Nationalism: Its Origins and Development in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries Penguin New Delhi
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kleinfeld, M. Destabilizing the identity–territory nexus: Rights-based discourse in Sri Lanka’s new political geography. GeoJournal 64, 287–295 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10708-005-5806-0
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10708-005-5806-0