Ontological Frameworks for Scientific Theories
- 280 Downloads
A close examination of the literature on ontology may strike one with roughly two distinct senses of this word. According to the first of them, which we shall call traditional ontology, ontology is characterized as the a priori study of various “ontological categories”. In a second sense, which may be called naturalized ontology, ontology relies on our best scientific theories and from them it tries to derive the ultimate furniture of the world. From a methodological point of view these two senses of ontology are very far away. Here, we discuss a possible relationship between these senses and argue that they may be made compatible and complement each other. We also examine how logic, understood as a linguistic device dealing with the conceptual framework of a theory and its basic inference patterns must be taken into account in this kind of study. The idea guiding our proposal may be put as follows: naturalized ontology checks for the applicability of the ontological categories proposed by traditional ontology and give substantial feedback for it. The adequate expression of some of the resulting ontological frameworks may require a different logic. We conclude with a discussion of the case of orthodox quantum mechanics, arguing that this theory exemplifies the kind of relationship between the two senses of ontology. We also argue that the view proposed here may throw some light in ontological questions concerning this theory.
KeywordsOntology Ontological categories Naturalized Ontology Quantum mechanics
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Bitbol M. (1996) Mécanique quantique: Une introduction philosophique. Flammarion, ParisGoogle Scholar
- Chateaubriand O. (2003) Quine and ontology. Principia 7(1–2): 41–74Google Scholar
- da Costa N. C. A. (2002) Logic and Ontology. Principia 6(2): 279–298Google Scholar
- da Costa N. C. A. (1997) Logiques classiques et non classiques. Essai sur les fondements de la logique. Masson, ParisGoogle Scholar
- da Costa N. C. A., Béziau J.-Y., Bueno O. (1995) What is semantics? A brief note on a huge question. Sorites Electronic Quarterly of Analytical Philosophy 3: 43–47Google Scholar
- da Costa, N. C. A., Krause, D. e Bueno, O. (2006). Paraconsistent Logic and Paraconsistency. In D. Jacquette, editor of the volume on Philosophy of Logic; D. M. Gabbay, P. Thagard and J. Woods (eds.), Philosophy of logic: In the handbook of the philosophy of science series, (vol 5, pp. 655–781). Elsevier.Google Scholar
- French S. (1998) On the withering away of physical objects. In: Castellani E. (Ed.), Interpreting bodies: Classical and quantum objects in modern physics. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp 93–113Google Scholar
- French S., Krause D. (2006) Identity in physics: A historical, philosophical, and formal analysis. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Krause, D., & Arenhart, J. R. B. (2010). Structures and models of scientific theories: A discussion on quantum non-individuality: pre-print available in http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/5564/1/LogUniv.pdf.
- Krause, D., Arenhart, J. R. B., & Moraes, F. T. F. (2011). Axiomatiation and models of scientific theories. Foundations of Science. doi:10.1007/s10699-011-9226-y.
- Ladyman J., Ross D., Spurret D., Collier J. (2007) Everything must go: Metaphysics naturalized. Oxford University Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Lowe E. J. (1998) The possibility of metaphysics: Substance, identity and time. Clarendon Press, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Quine W. V. (1964) From a logical point of view. Harper and Row, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Quine W. V. (1992) Pursuit of truth, revised edition. Harvard University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
- Read S. (2006) Monism: The one true logic. In: DeVidi D., Kenyon T. (Eds.), A logical approach to philosophy: Essays in honor of Graham Solomon. Springer, Dordrecht, pp 193–209Google Scholar
- Rohrlich F. (1999) On the ontology of QFT. In: Cao T. Y. (Ed.), Conceptual foundations of quantum field theory. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 357–367Google Scholar
- van Inwagen, P. (2010). Metaphysics. The stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. (Fall 2010 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.), http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2010/entries/metaphysics/, accessed 12 October 2010.