Advertisement

Foundations of Chemistry

, Volume 15, Issue 2, pp 145–156 | Cite as

What did “theory” mean to nineteenth-century chemists?

  • Alan RockeEmail author
Article

Abstract

Some recent philosophers of science have argued that chemistry in the nineteenth century “largely lacked theoretical foundations, and showed little progress in supplying such foundations” until around 1900, or even later. In particular, nineteenth-century atomic theory, it is said, “played no useful part” in the crowning achievement of nineteenth-century chemistry, the powerful subdiscipline of organic chemistry. This paper offers a contrary view. The idea that chemistry only gained useful theoretical foundations when it began to merge with physics, it will be argued, is based on an implicit conception of scientific theory that is too narrow, and too exclusively oriented to the science of physics. A broader understanding of scientific theory, and one that is more appropriate to the science of chemistry, reveals the essential part that theory played in the development of chemistry in the nineteenth century. It also offers implications for our understanding of the nature of chemical theory today.

Keywords

Atomic theory Chemical atomism Theory 

Notes

Acknowledgments

I wish to thank Guillermo Restrepo, Joachim Schummer, Eric Scerri, Mi Gyung Kim, and the other speakers at the ISPC 2011 Summer Symposium in Bogota for their very helpful comments on this paper.

References

  1. Boltzmann, L.: Populäre Schriften. Barth, Leipzig (1905)Google Scholar
  2. Brock, W.: The Atomic Debates: Brodie and the Rejection of the Atomic Theory. Leicester University Press, Leicester (1967)Google Scholar
  3. Brown, T.L.: The metaphorical foundations of chemical explanation. In: Earley, J.E. (ed.) Chemical Explanation: Characteristics, Development, Autonomy, pp. 209–216. New York Academy of Sciences, New York (2003)Google Scholar
  4. Chalmers, A.: Transforming atomic chemistry into an experimental science: the limitations of Dalton’s Theory. Rutherford J. 1, 1–15 (2005-6)Google Scholar
  5. Chalmers, A.: The Scientist’s Atom and the Philosopher’s Stone: How Science Succeeded and Philosophy Failed to Gain Knowledge of Atoms. Springer, Heidelberg (2009)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Chalmers, A.: Review symposium of the scientist’s atom. Metascience 19, 349–371 (2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Christie, M., Christie, J.R.: ‘Laws’ and ‘Theories’ in chemistry do not obey the rules. In: Bhushan, N., Rosenfeld, S. (eds.) Of Minds and Molecules: New Philosophical Perspectives on Chemistry, pp. 34–50. Oxford University Press, New York (2000)Google Scholar
  8. Dumas, J.B.: Leçons de Philosophie Chimique. Bechet, Paris (1837)Google Scholar
  9. Earley, J.E. (ed.): Chemical Explanation: Characteristics, Development, Autonomy. New York Academy of Sciences, New York (2003)Google Scholar
  10. Kekulé, A.: On some points of chemical philosophy. Lab 1, 303–306 (1867)Google Scholar
  11. Kim, M.G.: The layers of chemical language. Hist. Sci. 30, 69–96, 397–437 (1992)Google Scholar
  12. Klein, U.: Experiments, Models, Paper Tools: Cultures of Organic Chemistry in the Nineteenth Century. Stanford University Press, Stanford (2003)Google Scholar
  13. Kopp, H.: Bemerkungen zur Volumtheorie, mit specieller Beziehung auf Herrn Prof. Schröder’s Schrift. Vieweg, Braunschweig (1844)Google Scholar
  14. Kopp, H.: Theoretische Chemie. Vieweg, Braunschweig (1863)Google Scholar
  15. Kopp, H.: Entwickelung der Chemie in der neueren Zeit. Oldenbourg, Munich (1873)Google Scholar
  16. Kopp, H.: MS letters to A.W. Hofmann and to F. Wöhler, held in the Sammlung Chemiker-Briefe and the Sammlung Wachs of the Berlin-Brandenburgische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Berlin (1873–1876)Google Scholar
  17. Kopp, H.: Aus der Molecular-Welt. Winter, Heidelberg (1882)Google Scholar
  18. Kragh, H.: Between physics and chemistry: Helmholtz’s route to a theory of chemical thermodynamics. In: Cahan, D. (ed.) Hermann von Helmholtz and the Foundations of Nineteenth-Century Science, pp. 403–431. University of California Press, Berkeley (1993)Google Scholar
  19. Needham, P.: When did atoms begin to do any explanatory work in chemistry? Int. Stud. Phil. Sci. 18, 199–219 (2004a)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Needham, P.: Has daltonian atomism provided chemistry with any explanations? Phil. Sci. 71, 1038–1047 (2004b)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Needham, P.: Review symposium of Alan Chalmers’s the scientist’s atom. Metascience 19, 349–371 (2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Planck, M.: Physikalische Abhandlungen und Vorträge. Vieweg, Braunschweig (1958)Google Scholar
  23. Rocke, A.: Atoms and equivalents: the early development of the chemical atomic theory. Hist. Stud. Phys. Sci. 7, 225–263 (1978)Google Scholar
  24. Rocke, A.: Chemical Atomism in the Nineteenth Century: From Dalton to Cannizzaro. Ohio State University Press, Columbus (1984)Google Scholar
  25. Rocke, A.: Nationalizing Science: Adolphe Wurtz and the Battle for French Chemistry. MIT Press, Cambridge (2001)Google Scholar
  26. Rocke, A.: Image and Reality: Kekulé, Kopp, and the Scientific Imagination. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (2010)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Rocke, A., Kopp, H.: From the molecular world, a nineteenth-century science fantasy. Springer, Heidelberg (2012)Google Scholar
  28. Schummer, J. (ed.): special issue of Hyle 5:2 (1999)Google Scholar
  29. Schummer, J. (ed.): special issue of Hyle 6:1 (2000)Google Scholar
  30. Tyndall, J.: Fragments of Science. Appleton, New York (1892)Google Scholar
  31. Williamson, A.: On the atomic theory. J. Chem. Soc. 22, 330–331 (1869)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Woody, A., Glymour, C.: Missing elements: what philosophers of science might discover in chemistry. In: Bhushan, N., Rosenfeld, S. (eds.) Of Minds and Molecules: New Philosophical Perspectives on Chemistry, pp. 17–33. Oxford University Press, New York (2000)Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Henry Eldridge Bourne Professor of History, Department of HistoryCase Western Reserve UniversityClevelandUSA

Personalised recommendations