Journal of Financial Services Research

, Volume 46, Issue 3, pp 235–269 | Cite as

Are Stars’ Opinions Worth More? The Relation Between Analyst Reputation and Recommendation Values



Using 1994–2009 data, we find that All-American (AA) analysts’ buy and sell portfolio alphas significantly exceed those of non-AAs by up to 0.6 % per month after risk-adjustments for investors with advance access to analyst recommendations. For investors without such access, top-rank AAs still earn significantly higher (by 0.3 %) monthly alphas in buy recommendations than others. AAs’ superior performance exists before (as well as after) they are elected, is not explained by market overreactions to stars, and is not significantly eroded after Reg-FD. Election to top-AA ranks predicts future performance in buy recommendations above and beyond other previously observable analyst characteristics. Institutional investors actively evaluate analysts and update the AA roster accordingly. Collectively, these results suggest that skill differences among analysts exist and AA election reflects institutional investors’ ability to evaluate and benefit from elected analysts’ superior skills. Other investors’ opportunity to profit from the stars’ opinions exists, but is limited due to their timing disadvantage.


Analyst reputation Star status Stock recommendations Institutional investors Performance evaluation 

JEL Classification

G1 G2 


  1. Altinkiliç O, Hansen R (2009) On the information role of stock recommendation revisions. J Account Econ 48:17–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Altinkiliç O, Balashov V, Hansen R (2010) Evidence that analysts are not important information-intermediaries, working paper, Freeman School of Business, Tulane UniversityGoogle Scholar
  3. Bagnoli M, Watts S, Zhang Y (2008) Reg-FD and the competitiveness of all-star analysts. J Account Public Policy 27:295–316CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bailey W, Li H, Mao C, Zhong R (2003) Regulation fair disclosure and earnings information: market, analyst, and corporate responses. J Financ 58:2487–2514CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Balakrishnan K, Schrand C, Vashishtha R (2011) Analyst recommendations and higher order beliefs: explaining bubbles and price drift, working paper. University of PennsylvaniaGoogle Scholar
  6. Barber B, Lehavy R, McNichols M, Trueman B (2001) Can investors profit from the prophets? Security analyst recommendations and stock returns. J Financ 56:531–563CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Barber B, Lehavy R, McNichols M, Trueman B (2006) Buys, holds, and sells: the distribution of investment banks' stock ratings and the implications for the profitability of analysts' recommendations. J Account Econ 41:87–117CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Barber B, Lehavy R, Trueman B (2007) Comparing the stock recommendation performance of investment banks and independent research firms. J Financ Econ 85:490–517CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Benabou R, Laroque G (1992) Using privileged information to manipulate markets: insiders, gurus, and credibility. Q J Econ 107:921–958CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Boni L, Womack K (2006) Analysts, industries, and price momentum. J Financ Quant Anal 41:85–109CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Bonner S, Hugon A, Walther B (2007) Investor reaction to celebrity analysts: the case of earnings forecast revisions. J Account Res 45:481–513CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Bradley D, Jordan B, Ritter JR (2003) The quiet period goes out with a bang. J Financ 58:1–36CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Bradley D, Jordan B, Ritter JR (2008) Analyst behavior following IPOs: the bubble period evidence. Rev Financ Stud 21:101–133CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Brown L and Huang K (2010) Forecast-recommendation consistency and earnings forecast quality, working paperGoogle Scholar
  15. Carhart M (1997) On persistence in mutual fund performance. J Financ 52:57–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Clarke J, Khorana A, Patel A, Rau R (2007) The impact of all-star analyst Job changes on their coverage choices and investment banking deal flow. J Account Econ 84:713–737Google Scholar
  17. Cliff M, Denis D (2004) Do initial public offering firms purchase analyst coverage with underpricing? J Financ 59:2871–2901CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cohen L, Frazzini A, Malloy C (2010) Sell-side school ties. J Financ 65:1409–1947CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Cooper R, Day T, Lewis C (2001) Following the leader: a study of individual analysts’ earnings forecasts. J Financ Econ 61:383–416CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Cowen A, Groysberg B, Healy P (2006) What types of analyst firms make more optimistic forecasts? J Account Econ 41:119–146CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Daniel K, Grinblatt M, Titman S, Wermers R (1997) Measuring mutual fund performance with characteristic-based benchmarks. J Financ 52:875–899CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Diamond DW (1989) Reputation acquisition in debt markets. J Polit Econ 97:828–862CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dini J (2001) “The all-America research team. (status of equity research’s future explored)”. The Institutional Investors Magazine (October 2001)Google Scholar
  24. Dunbar C (2000) Factors affecting investment bank initial public offering market share. J Financ Econ 55:3–41CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Elton E, Gruber M, Grossman S (1986) Discrete expectational data and portfolio performance. J Financ 41:699–713CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Emery D, Li X (2009) Are Wall Street analyst rankings popularity contest? J Financ Quant Anal 44:411–437CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Ertimur Y, Sunder J, Sunder S (2007) Measure for measure: the relation between forecast accuracy and recommendation profitability of analysts. JAccount Res 45:567–606CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. Fama E, French K (1993) Common risk factors in the return on bonds and stocks. J Financ Econ 33:3–53CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Fang L, Yasuda A (2009) The effectiveness of reputation as a disciplinary mechanism in sell-side research. Rev Financ Stud 22:3735–3777CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Gintschel A, Markov S (2004) The effectiveness of regulation FD. J Account Econ 37:293–314CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Gleason C, Lee C (2003) Analyst forecast revisions and market price discovery. Account Rev 78:193–225CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Gomes A, Gorton G, Madureira L (2007) SEC regulation fair disclosure, information, and the cost of capital. J Corp Finan 13:300–334CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. Green TC (2006) The value of client access to analyst recommendation. J Financ Quant Anal 41:1–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Grossman S, Stiglitz J (1980) On the impossibility of informationally efficient markets. Am Econ Rev 70:393–408Google Scholar
  35. Guan Y, Lu H, Wong F (2010) Conflict-of-interest reforms and brain drain in investment banks, working paperGoogle Scholar
  36. Hall J, Tacon P (2010) Forecast accuracy and stock recommendations. J Contemp Account Econ 6:18–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Hong H, Kubik JD (2003) Analyzing the analysts: career concerns and biased earnings forecasts. J Financ 58:313–351CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. Hong H, Kubik J, Solomon A (2000) Security analysts’ career concerns and herding of earnings forecasts. Rand J Econ 31:121–144CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Irvine P (2003) The incremental impact of analyst initiation of coverage. J Corp Finan 9:431–451CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Irvine P, Lipson M, Puckett A (2007) Tipping. Rev Financ Stud 20:741–768CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Jackson A (2005) Trade generation, reputation, and sell-side analysts. J Financ 60:673–717CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Jegadeesh N, Kim W (2006) Value of analyst recommendations: international evidence. J Financ Mark 9:274–309CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Jegadeesh N, Kim J, Krische S, Lee C (2004) Analyzing the analysts: when do recommendations add value? J Financ 59:1083–1124CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. Juergens J, Lindsey L (2009) Getting out early: an analysis of market making activity at the recommending analyst’s firm. J Financ 64:2327–2359CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  45. Kadan O, Madureira L, Wang R, Zach T (2009) Conflicts of interest and stock recommendations: the effect of global settlement and related regulations. Rev Financ Stud 22:4189–4217CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Kecskes A, Womack K (2010) Adds and drops of analyst coverage: does the stock market overreact? Working paperGoogle Scholar
  47. Kecskes, A., R. Michaely, K. Womack (2010) What drives the value of analysts’ recommendations: earnings estimates or discount rate estimates? Working paperGoogle Scholar
  48. Keim D, Madhavan A (1997) Transaction costs and investment style: an inter-exchange analysis of institutional equity trades. J Financ Econ 46:265–292CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Kramer L (2009) “The 2009 All-America Research Team: a time to rebuild”. The Institutional Investor Magazine (October 2009)Google Scholar
  50. Krigman L, Shaw WH, Womack K (2001) Why do firms switch underwriters? J Financ Econ 60:245–284CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Leone A, Wu J (2007) What does it take to become a superstar? Evidence from Institutional investor rankings of financial analysts, working paper. Simon School of Business, University of RochesterGoogle Scholar
  52. Li X (2005) The persistence of relative performance in stock recommendations of sell-side financial analysts. J Account Econ 40:129–152CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Lin H, McNichols MF (1998) Underwriting relationships, analysts earnings forecasts and investment recommendations. J Account Econ 25:101–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Liu X, Ritter J (2010) Local underwriter oligopolies and IPO underpricing. Working paper, University of FloridaGoogle Scholar
  55. Ljungqvist A, Marston F, Wilhelm WJ (2006) Competing for securities underwriting mandates: banking relationships and analyst recommendations. J Financ 61:301–340CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Ljungqvist A, Malloy C, Marston F (2009) Rewriting history. J Financ 64:1935–1960CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Loh R, Mian M (2006) Do accurate earnings forecasts facilitate superior investment recommendations? J Financ Econ 80:455–483CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Loh R, Stulz R (2011) When are analyst recommendation changes influential. Rev Financ Stud 24:593–627CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Loughran T, Ritter J (2004) Why has IPO underpricing changed over time? Financ Manag 2004:5–37Google Scholar
  60. Malmendier U, Shanthikumar D (2007) Do security analysts speak in two tongues? NBER working paperGoogle Scholar
  61. Mikhail M, Walther B, Willis R (2004) Do security analysts exhibit persistent differences in stock picking ability? J Financ Econ 74:67–91CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Mohanram P, Sunder S (2006) How has regulation FD affected the operations of financial analysts? Contemp Account Res 23:491–525CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Schack J (2004) “The 2004 All-America Research Team”. The Institutional Investor Magazine (October 2004)Google Scholar
  64. Sessa D (1999) All star analysts 1999 survey: Early mornings, late nights mark an analyst’s day. Wall Str J, June 29, R13Google Scholar
  65. Stickel S (1992) Reputation and performance among security analysts. J Financ 47:1811–1836CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. Stickel S (1995) The anatomy of the performance of buy and sell recommendations. Fin Anal J 51:25–39CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. Womack K (1996) Do brokerage analysts’ recommendations have investment value? J Financ 51:137–167CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.INSEADSingaporeSingapore
  2. 2.Graduate School of ManagementUniversity of California at DavisDavisUSA

Personalised recommendations