Abstract
George Ellery Hale was a man of many dreams. One of his most persistent was to find the means to collect as much light as possible, but there is another element in his designs for the modern astrophysical observatory that has even greater significance, as it defines and distinguishes the practice of astrophysics from that of classical astronomy. Here we examine factors that either impeded or drove the acceptance of reflectors over refractors around the turn of the twentieth century at the outset of what may best be called the “Hale era.” This commenced in the late nineteenth century, when the first large multi-focus photographic reflectors emerged during the reign of the great refractors. It lasted through to the onset of World War II when astronomical practice was dominated by ten reflectors with mirrors between 60 and 100 in., and was about to add one more whose surface area would almost double that of all the rest combined. We will touch upon how design choice reflected both scientific priorities and technological limitations.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adams, W.S., Kohlschûtter, A.: Some spectral criteria for the determination of absolute stellar magnitudes. Contr. Mt. Wilson Obs. 89, 1–14 (1914)
Adams, W.S.: Some results of a study of the spectra of Sirius, Procyon, and Arcturus with high dispersion. ApJ 33, 64–71 (1911) doi:10.1086/141829
Adams, W.S.: Summary of the Year’s Work at Mount Wilson. PASP 43, 394–403 (1931). doi:10.1086/124172
Adams, W.S.: Sunspot lines in the spectrum of Arcturus. ApJ 24, 69–77 (1906). doi:10.1086/141374
Anon: Reflecting telescopes. Astron. Regist. 4, 318–319 (1866)
Lockyer, N.: Meeting of the royal astronomical society. Astron. Regist. 22, 139–142; 142 (1884)
Bell, L.: The Telescope. McGraw Hill, New York (1922)
Bennett, J.A.: On the power of penetrating into space: the telescopes of William Herschel. J. Hist. Astr. 7, 75–108 (1976)
Berendzen, R.: Geocentric to heliocentric to galactocentric to acentric: the continuing assault to the egocentric. Vistas Astron. 17, 65–83 (1975). doi:10.1016/0083-6656(75)90049-5
Blank, D., Andersen, G.: The telescope. Its history, technology, and future. J. Astron. Hist. Herit. 10, 247 (2007)
Cattell, J.M. (ed.): Frank Lawton Olcott Wadsworth. Am. Men of Sci., 5th edn., p. 1157. The Science Press, New York (1933)
Christie, W.H.M.: Award of the Gold Medal to Maurice Loewy. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 49, 247 (1889)
Clark, A.G.: Great telescopes of the future. A&A 12, 673–678 on 674–675 (1893)
DeVorkin, D.H.: Henry Norris Russell: Dean of American Astronomers. Princeton University Press, Princeton (2000)
DeVorkin, D.H.: The discovery and exploitation of spectroscopic parallaxes. In: Philip, A.G.D., Van Altena, W.F., Upgren, A.R. (eds.) Anni Mirabiles: A Symposium Celebrating the 90th Birthday of Dorrit Hoffleit, pp. 17–24. L. Davis Press, Schenectady, NY (1997)
Evans, D.S., Derral Mulholland, J.: Big and bright: a history of the McDonald observatory. University of Texas Press, Texas (1986)
Florence, R.: The Perfect Machine: Building the Palomar Telescope. Harper-Collins, New York (1994)
Forgan, J.B., et al.: Second Annual Report of the Visiting Committee of the Yerkes Observatory. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1902)
Gingerich, O., Welther, B.: Harlow Shapley and the Cepheids. Sky Telesc. 70, 540 (1985)
Glass, I.S.: Victorian Telescope Makers: The Lives and Letters of Thomas and Howard Grubb. IOP (Institute of Physics Press), Bristol (1997)
Hale, G.E.: Arthur Cowper Ranyard. ApJ 1, 168–169 (1895). doi:10.1086/140031
Hale, G.E.: Note on the Ranyard mounting for reflecting telescopes. ApJ 5, 148–149 (1897)
Hale, G.E.: Ten Year’s Work of A Mountain Observatory. Carnegie Institution of Washington Publ 235, Washington, DC (1915)
Hale, G.E.: The Study of Stellar Evolution. University of Chicago Press, Chicago (1908)
Hale, G.E.: T. Mendenhall, 1904. Hale Papers, Huntington Library and Archives, AIP Microfilm Edn.
Hale, G.E.: On the comparative value of refracting and reflecting telescopes for astrophysical investigation. ApJ 5, 119–131 (1897). doi:10.1086/140317
Jarrell, R.J.S.: Plaskett and the modern large reflecting telescope. J. Hist. Astr. 30, 359-390 (1999)
Jarrell, R.: The Telescope (1950). Encycl. Astron. Astrophys. 4, 3293–3298 (2001)
Johnson, H.L., Richards, W.L.: Optimum size of infrared photometric telescopes. ApJ 160, L111–L116 (1970). doi:10.1086/180540
Kapteyn, J.C.: The plan of selected Areas. In: Council Notes, MNRAS 74, pp. 348–352, on 348 (1914)
King, H.C.: H.C. King’s book: The History of the Telescope, 1959. Griffin, London. Reprinted, Dover Publishing, New York (1979)
Lankford, J.: Amateurs vs. professionals: the controversy over telescope size in late Victorian science. Isis 72, 11–28 (1981). doi:10.1086/352648
Learner, R.: Astronomy though the Telescope. Van Nostrand, New York (1981)
Lord Rosse to E. S. Holden, January 6, 1877. Holden Papers, Mary Lea Shane Archives, University of California, Santa Cruz
MacRobert, A.: Death of amateur astronomy... or new birth? Sky Telesc. 116, 33 (2008)
Meadows, A.J.: Meadows’s book: Science and Controversy: A Biography of Sir Norman Lockyer. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA (1972). Reprinted, MacMillan, London (2008)
Meinel, A.B.: Design of reflecting telescopes. In: Kuiper, G., Middlehurst, B. (eds.) Stars and Stellar Systems, vol. 1, pp. 25–42 (1960)
Misch, A., Sheehan, W.: Pioneering telescope turns 100. Sky Telesc. 116, 38–41 (2008)
Oke, J.B.: On the optimum size of optical telescopes. ApJ 162, L77–L78 (1970). doi:10.1086/180628
Osterbrock, D.E.: Pauper & Prince; Ritchey, Hale & Big American Telescopes, p. 68. Arizona, Tucson (1993)
Panek, R.: Seeing and Believing: How the Telescope Opened our Eyes and Minds to the Heavens. Viking, New York (1998)
Paul, R.: The Milky Way Galaxy and Statistical Cosmology 1890–1924. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1993)
Pickering, E. C. to G. E. Hale, nd circa December 1901. Reprinted in Report of the Visiting Committee of the Yerkes Observatory, October 1902, private circulation. p. 20
Pickering, E.C.: The future of astronomy. Pop. Sci. Mon. 75, 105–116 (1909)
Ritchey, G.W.: The two-foot reflecting telescope of the Yerkes Observatory. ApJ 217, 221 14 (November 1901)
Sandage, A.: The Mount Wilson Observatory, Breaking the Code of Cosmic Evolution. Volume 1 of the Centennial History of the Carnegie Institution of Washington, p. 161. Cambridge (2004)
Steinheil, C.A.: On the advantages to be derived from the use of silver mirrors for reflecting telescopes, and on a novel mode of mounting such instruments. MNRAS 19, 56–60 (1858). Translated from AN 1138
Thomsen, I.L.: In the grip of the big telescope age. JRASC 29 238, 238–240 (1935). Reprinted from Southern Stars (February 1935)
Turner, H.H.: Modern astronomy, being some account of the revolution of the last quarter of a century, pp. 46–47, 124–129. Constable, Westminster (1901)
Van de Kamp, P.: The galactocentric revolution, a reminiscent narrative. PASP 77, 325–335 (1965). doi:10.1086/128228
Van Helden, A.: Building large telescopes, 1900–1950. In: Gingerich, O. (ed.) Astrophysics and Twentieth-century Astronomy to 1950 part A, pp. 134–152. The General History of Astronomy 4A. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1984)
Wadsworth, F.L.O.: On a new form of mounting for reflecting telescopes devised by the late Arthur Cowper Ranyard. ApJ 5, 132–134 (1897). doi:10.1086/140318
Wadsworth, F.L.O.: Review of G. Johnstone Stoney. On the equipment of the astrophysical observatory of the future. ApJ 4, 238–243 (1986). doi:10.1086/140275
Warner, D.J., Ariail, R.: Alvan Clark & Sons, Artists in Optics, 2nd edn. Willmann-Bell, Inc, Richmond (1995)
Watson, F.: Stargazer: The Life and Times of the Telescope, p. 211. DaCapo, Cambridge (2004)
Woodbury, D.O.: The Glass Giant of Palomar, revised edn. Dodd, Mead, New York (1970)
Wright, H., Warnow, J.N., Weiner, C. (eds.): The Legacy of George Ellery Hale, p. 42. MIT, Cambridge (1972)
Wright, H.: Explorer of the Universe: A Biography of George Ellery Hale, revised edn. American Institute of Physics, Woodbury, NY (1994)
Wright, H.: Palomar, The World’s Largest Telescope. MacMillan, New York (1952)