Ethical Theory and Moral Practice

, Volume 14, Issue 5, pp 589–595 | Cite as

Same-Sex Marriage and Equality

Article
  • 3.3k Downloads

Abstract

Some argue that same-sex marriage is not an equal rights issue because, where same-sex marriage is illegal, heterosexuals and homosexuals have the exact same right to marry—i.e., the right to marry one adult of the opposite sex. I dispute this argument by pointing out that while societies that prohibit same-sex marriage equally permit individual heterosexuals and homosexuals to marry one adult of the opposite sex, same-sex couples in such societies are denied an important right that opposite-sex couples enjoy—i.e., the right to marry. I argue that the right to marry is fundamentally, not an individual right, but a couple’s collective right, analogous to assembly rights.

Keywords

Same-sex marriage Equality Discrimination Individual rights Collective rights Marriage rights 

References

  1. Buchanan A (1994) Liberalism and group rights. In: Coleman JL, Buchanan A (eds) In Harm’s way—essays in honour of Joel Feinberg. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp 1–15Google Scholar
  2. Feinberg J (1980) The nature and value of rights. J Value Inq 4:263–267Google Scholar
  3. Garrett J (2009a) Marriage unhitched from the state: a defense. Public Aff Q 23(2):161–180Google Scholar
  4. Garrett J (2009b) Public reasons for private vows: a response to Gilboa. Public Aff Q 23(3):261–273Google Scholar
  5. Jovanvic M (2010) Are there universal collective rights? Hum Rights Rev 11(1):17–44CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  6. Lazar S (2009) The nature and disvalue of injury. Res Publica 15(3):289–304CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Leybold-Johnson I (2010) Switzerland needs to ‘catch up’ on gay adoption. Swiss news world wide, available at www.swissinfo.ch/eng/swiss_news/Switzerland_needs_to_catch_up_on_gay_adoption.html?cid=9128510
  8. Margalit A, Raz J (1995) National self-determination. In: Kymlicka W (ed) The rights of minority cultures. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 79–92Google Scholar
  9. McDonough R (2005) Is same-sex marriage an equal rights issue? Public Aff Q 19(1):51–63Google Scholar
  10. Mohr R (2005) The long arc of justice. Columbia University Press, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  11. Nagel T (1995) Personal rights and public space. Philos Public Aff 24(2):83–107CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Stroll A (2009) A defense of same-sex marriage. Public Aff Q 23(4):343–355Google Scholar
  13. The Case for Gay Marriage (2004) Economist 370:9Google Scholar
  14. Wall S (2007) Collective rights and individual autonomy. Ethics 117(2):234–264CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Wellman CH (2005) Feinberg’s two concepts of rights. Leg Theory 11(3):213–226Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of PhilosophyBakersfield CollegeBakersfieldUSA

Personalised recommendations