Students’ Note-Taking as a Knowledge-Construction Tool
Note-taking is the hegemonic study activity at university and, in many cases, the main ground for educational interaction between teacher and students. This observation has given rise to an increasing interest in studying students’ note-taking and its impact on learning. In broad terms, three lines of research have been developed in the last 40 years: the effects of note-taking and note-rewriting on some cognitive variables (attention, memory, comprehension, and so on); the relationship between quality of notes and significance of learning; and the changes in the teaching methodology which may enhance note-taking. However, the consideration of notes as a symbolic mediator which in certain educational conditions may promote knowledge construction and transformation and, ultimately, cognitive change has received much less attention.
In a preliminary study of descriptive nature we confirmed that in the context of our universities note-taking basically performed a register and external memory function with respect to the contents which were to be assessed by the teacher. Only a reduced part of the studied sample attached notes an eminently epistemic function, turning classroom sessions into truly learning situations involving a strategic use (that is, conscious and intentional) of the note-taking procedures using paraphrasing, inferences, analogies and other rhetorical resources.
Form students in the contextualised use of the different note-taking procedures so that they gradually acquired a “strategic knowledge” related to when and why a given type of note more suitably adjusted to the conditions of the note-taking context.
Turn students’ notes into a formative assessment tool through a process of external guidance and regulation carried out by the teacher with the objective of notes becoming a tool allowing for self-regulation of students’ own learning.
Establish note-taking teams in the classroom with the objective of promoting collaborative learning through the use of activities which emphasise interdependence and peer-assessment.
This text will present this project in detail analysing the results obtained and discussing the different degrees of influence which an intervention/approach such as the one outlined here may have on university teaching.
Keywordsconstruction tools formative assessment guidance system learning strategies note-taking strategic knowledge university education
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Boscolo, P., & Mason, L. (2001). Writing to learn, writing to transfer. In G. Rijlaarsdam (Series Ed.) & P. Tynjälä, L. Mason, & K. Lonka (Vol. Eds.), Writing as a learning tool: Integrating theory and practice, Studies in writing (Vol. 7, pp. 83–104). Netherlands: Kluwer Academic PublishersGoogle Scholar
- Castelló, M. (1999). El conocimiento que tienen los alumnos sobre la escritura. In J. I. Pozo & C. Monereo (Coords.), El aprendizaje estratégico, enseñar a aprender desde el currículo. Madrid: Santillana/Aula XXIGoogle Scholar
- Castelló, M., & Monereo, C. (1999). Como toman apuntes los estudiantes. Guide no. 4 of the Programme to support innovation in university teaching, Vice-rector of University quality, Autonomous University of BarcelonaGoogle Scholar
- Castelló, M., Monereo, C. 1999El conocimiento estratégico en la toma de apuntes: un estudio en la educación superiorInfancia y Aprendizaje882542Google Scholar
- Di Vesta, F. J., Gray, G. S. 1973Listening and notetaking: Immediate and delayed recall as functional of variations in thematic continuity, notetaking, and length of listening–review intervalsJournal of Educational Psychology64278287Google Scholar
- Faber, J. E., Morris, J. D., Lieberman, M. G. 2000The effect of note taking on ninth grade students’ comprehensionReading Psychology21257270Google Scholar
- Graves, D. H. 1983Writing: Teachers and children at workHeinemanNew HampshireGoogle Scholar
- Lemke, J. L. 1990Talking science: Language,, learning and valuesAblexNorwood, NJGoogle Scholar
- Lonka, K. 1997Explorations of constructive processes in student learningYliopistopainoHelsinkiGoogle Scholar
- Monereo, C. (Coord.), Barberà, E., Castelló, M., & Pérez Cabaní, M. L. (2001). Tomar apuntes: Un enfoque estratégico. Madrid: VisorGoogle Scholar
- Monereo, C., Pérez Cabaní, M. L. 1996La incidencia de la toma de apuntes sobre el aprendizaje significativo. Un estudio en enseñanza superiorInfancia y Aprendizaje736586Google Scholar
- Monereo, C., Carretero, R., Castelló, M., Gómez, I., & Pérez Cabaní, M. L. (1999). Toma de apuntes en estudiantes universitarios: Descripción de las condiciones de un scenario específico. In J. I. Pozo & C. Monereo (Coord.)., El aprendizaje estratégico. Enseñar a aprender desde el currículo. Madrid: SantillanaGoogle Scholar
- Perez Cabaní, M. L., Carretero, M. R., Palma, M., Rafel, E. 2000La evaluación de la calidad del aprendizaje en la universidadInfancia y Aprendizaje91530Google Scholar
- Shambaugh, R. N. (1994). Personalized meanings: The cognitive Potentials of visual notetaking. Communication presented at the Annual Eastern Educational Research Association Conference, Sarasota, FL, 9–12 FebruaryGoogle Scholar
- Slotte, V., Lonka, K. 2000
Note-taking and essay-writingTynjälä, P.Mason, L.Lonka, K. eds. Writing as a learning tool Integrating theory and practiceUniversity PressAmsterdamGoogle Scholar
- Stahl, N. A., King, J. R., Henk, W. A. 1991Enhancing students’ notetaking through training and evaluationJournal of Reading34614622Google Scholar
- Meter, P., Yokoi, L., Pressley, M. 1994College students’ theory of note-taking derived from their perceptions of note-takingJournal of Educational Psychology86323338Google Scholar
- Vigotsky, L. S. (1981). The genesis of higher mental functions. In J. V. Wertsch (comp.), The concept of activity in Soviet psychology (pp. 148–188). Armonk, NY: SharpeGoogle Scholar
- Wells, G. (1994). Text, talk and inquiry: Schooling as semiotic apprenticeship. In N. Bird et al. (comps), Language and Learning. Hong Kong: Institute for Language and Learning, Department of EducationGoogle Scholar