, Volume 74, Issue 3, pp 351–362 | Cite as

Vague Objects Without Ontically Indeterminate Identity

Original Article


The supporter of vague objects has been long challenged by the following ‘Argument from Identity’: 1) if there are vague objects, then there is ontically indeterminate identity; 2) there is no ontically indeterminate identity; therefore, 3) there are no vague objects. Some supporters of vague objects have argued that 1) is false. Noonan (Analysis 68: 174–176, 2008) grants that 1) does not hold in general, but claims that ontically indeterminate identity is indeed implied by the assumption that there are vague objects of a certain special kind (i.e. vague objects*). One can therefore formulate a ‘New Argument from Identity’: 1′) if there are vague objects*, then there is ontically indeterminate identity; 2) there is no ontically indeterminate identity; therefore, 3′) there are no vague objects*. Noonan’s strategy is to argue that premiss 1′) is inescapable, and, as a consequence, that Evans’s alleged defence of 2) is a real challenge for any supporter of vague objects. I object that a supporter of vague objects who grants the validity of Evans’s argument allegedly in favour of 2) should reject premiss 1′). The threat of the New Argument from Identity is thus avoided.


  1. Edgington, D. (1993). Wright and Sainsbury on higher-order vagueness. Analysis, 53, 193–200.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Edgongton, D. (2000). Indeterminacy de Re. Philosophical Topics, 28, 27–44.Google Scholar
  3. Evans, G. (1978). Can there be vague objects? Analysis, 38, 208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Heck, R. G. (1993). A note on the logic of (higher-order) vagueness. Analysis, 53, 201–208.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Heck, R. G. (1998). That there might be vague objects (so far as concerns logic). The Monist, 81, 274–296.Google Scholar
  6. Lewis, D. (1988). Vague identity: Evans misunderstood. Analysis, 48, 128–130.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Noonan, H. W. (2004). Are there vague objects? Analysis, 64, 131–134.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Noonan, H. W. (2008). Does ontic indeterminacy in boundaries entail ontic indeterminacy in identity? Analysis, 68, 174–176.Google Scholar
  9. Parsons, T., & Woodruff, P. B. (1995). Wordly indeterminacy of identity. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 95, 171–191.Google Scholar
  10. Parsons, T. (2000). Indeterminate identity. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  11. Sainsbury, M. (1989). What is a vague object? Analysis, 49, 99–103.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Shoemaker, S. (1963). Self-knowledge and self-identity. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
  13. Tye, M. (1990). Vague objects. Mind, 99, 535–557.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Tye, M. (2000). Vagueness and reality. Philosophical Topics, 28, 195–209.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2010

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Dipartimento di filosofiaUniversità degli Studi di MilanoMilanoItaly
  2. 2.MilanoItaly

Personalised recommendations