Skip to main content

A meta-analysis of pesticide loss in runoff under conventional tillage and no-till management

Abstract

Global agricultural intensification has led to increased pesticide use (37-fold from 1960 to 2005) and soil erosion (14% since 2000). Conservation tillage, including no-till (NT), has been proposed as an alternative to conventional plow till (PT) to mitigate soil erosion, but past studies have reported mixed results on the effect of conservation tillage on pesticide loss. To explore the underlying factors of these differences, a meta-analysis was conducted using published data on pesticide concentration and load in agricultural runoff from NT and PT fields. Peer-reviewed articles (1985–2016) were compiled to build a database for analysis. Contrary to expectations, results showed greater concentration of atrazine, cyanazine, dicamba, and simazine in runoff from NT than PT fields. Further, we observed greater load of dicamba and metribuzin, but reduced load of alachlor from NT fields. Overall, the concentration and the load of pesticides were greater in runoff from NT fields, especially pesticides with high solubility and low affinity for solids. Thus, NT farming affects soil properties that control pesticide retention and interactions with soils, and ultimately their mobility in the environment. Future research is needed for a more complete understanding of pesticide-soil interactions in NT systems. This research could inform the selection of pesticides by farmers and improve the predictive power of pesticide transport models.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Fig. 5
Fig. 6

References

  1. Aguiar, T. R., Bortolozo, F. R., Hansel, F. A., Rasera, K., & Ferreira, M. T. (2015). Riparian buffer zones as pesticide filters of no-till crops. Environmental Science and Pollution Research International, 22(14), 10618–10626..

  2. Alletto, L., Coquet, Y., Benoit, P., Heddadj, D., & Barriuso, E. (2010). Tillage management effects on pesticide fate in soils. A review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development, 30(2), 367–400.

  3. Basta, N. T., Huhnke, R. L., & Stiegler, J. H. (1997). Atrazine runoff from conservation tillage systems: a simulated rainfall study. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 52(1), 44–48.

  4. Battaglin, W. A., Sandstrom, M. W., Kuivila, K. M., Kolpin, D. W., & Meyer, M. T. (2011). Occurrence of azoxystrobin, propiconazole, and selected other fungicides in US streams, 2005–2006. Water, Air, & Soil Pollution, 218(1–4), 307–322.

  5. Baughman, T. A., Shaw, D. R., Webster, E. P., & Boyette, M. (2001). Effect of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum) tillage systems on off-site movement of fluometuron, norflurazon, and sediment in runoff. Weed Technology, 15(1), 184–189.

  6. Berenzen, N., Lentzen-Godding, A., Probst, M., Schulz, H., Schulz, R., & Liess, M. (2005). A comparison of predicted and measured levels of runoff-related pesticide concentrations in small lowland streams on a landscape level. Chemosphere, 58(5), 683–691.

  7. Blackshaw, R. E., Larney, F. O., Lindwall, C. W., & Kozub, G. C. (1994). Crop rotation and tillage effects on weed populations on the semi-arid Canadian prairies. Weed Technology, 8(2), 231–237.

  8. Bollag, J. M., Myers, C. J., & Minard, R. D. (1992). Biological and chemical interactions of pesticides with soil organic matter. Science of the Total Environment, 123, 205–217.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  9. Bruand, A., & Tessier, D. (2000). Water retention properties of the clay in soils developed on clayey sediments: significance of parent material and soil history. European Journal of Soil Science, 51(4), 679–688.

  10. Bundy, L. G., Andraski, T. W., & Powell, J. M. (2001). Management practice effects on phosphorus losses in runoff in corn production systems. Journal of Environmental Quality, 30(5), 1822–1828.

  11. Carter, A. (2000). How pesticides get into water-and proposed reduction measures. Pesticide Outlook, 11(4), 149–156.

  12. Coche, A. G. (1985). Simple methods for aquaculture: soil and freshwater fish culture. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

    Google Scholar 

  13. Conservation Technology Information Center. (2016a). Crop Residue Management Survey – 2006. http://www.ctic.org/media/pdf/2006%20CRM%20summary.pdf. Accessed 1 December 2016.

  14. Conservation Technology Information Center. (2016b). 2008 Amendment to the National Crop Residue Management Survey Summary. http://www.ctic.org/media/pdf/National%20Summary%202008%20(Amendment).pdf. Accessed 1 December 2016.

  15. Cope, O. B. (1966). Contamination of the freshwater ecosystem by pesticides. Journal of Applied Ecology, 3, 33–44.

  16. Curtis, P. S., & Wang, X. (1998). A meta-analysis of elevated CO2 effects on woody plant mass, form, and physiology. Oecologia, 113(3), 299–313.

  17. Daryanto, S., Wang, L., & Jacinthe, P. A. (2015). Global synthesis of drought effects on food legume production. PloS one, 10(6), pe0127401.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  18. Daryanto, S., Wang, L., & Jacinthe, P. A. (2017). Impacts of no-tillage management on nitrate loss from corn, soybean and wheat cultivation: a meta-analysis. Scientific Reports, 7(1), 12117.

  19. Donigian, A. S., & Carsel, R. F. (1987). Modeling the impact of conservation tillage practices on pesticide concentrations in ground and surface waters. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 6(4), 241–250.

  20. Duiker, S. W., & Myers, J. C. (2016). Better soils with the no-till system: a publication to help farmers understand the effects of no-till systems on the soil. Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, USA: Pennsylvania Conservation Partnership. https://vtechworks.lib.vt.edu/bitstream/handle/10919/68815/4533_Duiker2005_better_soils_with_noTill.pdf?sequence=1. Accessed in April 1 2017.

  21. Elias, D., & Bernot, M. J. (2014). Effects of atrazine, metolachlor, carbaryl and chlorothalonil on benthic microbes and their nutrient dynamics. PloS one, 9(10), pe109190.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  22. Elliott, J. A., Cessna, A. J., Nicholaichuk, W., & Tollefson, L. C. (2000). Leaching rates and preferential flow of selected herbicides through tilled and untilled. Journal of Environmental Quality, 29(5), 1650–1656. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq2000.00472425002900050036x.

    CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  23. Felsot, A. S., Mitchell, J. K., & Kenimer, A. L. (1990). Assessment of management practices for reducing pesticide runoff from sloping cropland in Illinois. Journal of Environmental Quality, 19(3), 539–545. https://doi.org/10.2134/jeq1990.00472425001900030031x.

    CAS  Article  Google Scholar 

  24. Fernandez-Cornejo, J., Nehring, R. F., Osteen, C., Wechsler, S., Martin, A., & Vialou, A. (2014). Pesticide use in US agriculture: 21 selected crops, 1960–2008. https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/publications/43854/46734_eib124.pdf?v=41830. Accessed 1 November 2017.

  25. Fiener, P., Auerswald, K., & Van Oost, K. (2011). Spatio-temporal patterns in land use and management affecting surface runoff response of agricultural catchments—a review. Earth-Science Reviews, 106(1), 92–104.

  26. Fuller, J. B., & Hester, K. (1999). Comparing the sample-weighted and unweighted meta-analysis: an applied perspective. Journal of Management, 25(6), 803–828.

  27. Gallagher, E. P., Canada, A. T., & Di Giulio, R. T. (1992). The protective role of glutathione in chlorothalonil-induced toxicity to channel catfish. Aquatic Toxicology, 23(3), 155–168.

  28. Gaynor, J., & Bissonnette, D. (1992). The effect of conservation tillage practices on the losses of phosphorus and herbicides in surface and subsurface drainage waters. Ontario: Agriculture Canada Research Station.

    Google Scholar 

  29. Gaynor, J. D., MacTavish, D. C., & Fidlay, W. I. (1995). Organic chemicals in the environment. Journal of Environmental Quality, 24(2), 246–256.

  30. Gebhardt, M. R., Daniel, T. C., Schweizer, E. E., & Allmaras, R. R. (1985). Conservation tillage. Science, 230(4726), 625–631.

  31. Glenn, S., & Angle, J. S. (1987). Atrazine and simazine in runoff from conventional and no-till corn watersheds. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 18(4), 273–280.

  32. Grube, A., Donaldson, D., Kiely, T., & Wu, L. (2011). Pesticides industry sales and usage. Washington: U.S. EPA.

    Google Scholar 

  33. Gurevitch, J., & Hedges, L. V. (1999). Statistical issues in ecological meta-analyses. Ecology, 80(4), 1142–1149.

  34. Hall, J. K., & Mumma, R. O. (1994). Dicamba mobility in conventionally tilled and non-tilled soil. Soil and Tillage Research, 30(1), 3–17.

  35. Hall, J. K., Murray, M. R., & Hartwig, N. L. (1989). Herbicide leaching and distribution in tilled and untilled soil. Journal of Environmental Quality, 18(4), 439–445.

  36. Hall, J. K., Mumma, R. O., & Watts, D. W. (1991). Leaching and runoff losses of herbicides in a tilled and untilled field. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 37(4), 303–314.

  37. Hansen, N. C., Moncrief, J. F., Gupta, S. C., Capel, P. D., & Olness, A. E. (2001). Herbicide banding and tillage system interactions on runoff losses of alachlor and cyanazine. Journal of Environmental Quality, 30(6), 2120–2126.

  38. Hayes, T. B., Stuart, A. A., Mendoza, M., Collins, A., Noriega, N., Vonk, A., Johnston, G., Liu, R., & Kpodzo, D. (2006). Characterization of atrazine-induced gonadal malformations in African clawed frogs (Xenopus laevis) and comparisons with effects of an androgen antagonist (cyproterone acetate) and exogenous estrogen (17-beta-estradiol): support for the demasculinization/feminization hypothesis. Environmental Health Perspectives, 114(Suppl 1), 134.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  39. Hernández, A. F., Parrón, T., Tsatsakis, A. M., Requena, M., Alarcón, R., & López-Guarnido, O. (2013). Toxic effects of pesticide mixtures at a molecular level: their relevance to human health. Toxicology, 307, 136–145.

  40. Holland, J. M. (2004). The environmental consequences of adopting conservation tillage in Europe: reviewing the evidence. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 103(1), 1–25.

  41. Horneck, D. A., Sullivan, D. M., Owen, J. S., & Hart, J. M. (2011). Soil test interpretation guide. Oregon: Oregon State University, Extension Service.

    Google Scholar 

  42. Houck, O. A. (2002). The clean water act TMDL program: law, policy, and implementation. Washington, D.C. USA: Environmental Law Institute.

    Google Scholar 

  43. Isensee, A. R., & Sadeghi, A. M. (1993). Impact of tillage practice on runoff and pesticide transport. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 48(6), 523–527.

    Google Scholar 

  44. Kah, M., & Brown, C. D. (2006). Adsorption of ionisable pesticides in soils. In Reviews of environmental contamination and toxicology (pp. 149–217). New York: Springer.

  45. Karlen, D. L., Wollenhaupt, N. C., Erbach, D. C., Berry, E. C., Swan, J. B., Eash, N. S., & Jordahl, J. L. (1994). Long-term tillage effects on soil quality. Soil and Tillage Research, 32(4), 313–327.

  46. Kenimer, A. L., Mostaghimi, S., Young, R. W., Dillaha, T. A., & Shanholtz, V. O. (1987). Effects of residue cover on pesticide losses from conventional and no-tillage systems. Transactions of the ASAE, 30(4), 953–959.

  47. Kessel, C., Venterea, R., Six, J., Adviento-Borbe, M. A., Linquist, B., & Groenigen, K. J. (2013). Climate, duration, and N placement determine N2O emissions in reduced tillage systems: a meta-analysis. Global Change Biology, 19(1), 33–44.

  48. Knowler, D., & Bradshaw, B. (2007). Farmers’ adoption of conservation agriculture: a review and synthesis of recent research. Food Policy, 32(1), 25–48.

  49. Koskinen, W. C., & Clay, S. A. (1997). Factors affecting atrazine fate in north central US soils. In Reviews of environmental contamination and toxicology (pp. 117–165). New York: Springer.

  50. Larson, S. J., Gilliom, R. J. & Capel, P. D. (1999). Pesticides in streams of the United States: initial results from the national water-quality assessment program (No. 98-4222). Sacramento, California, USA: US Department of the Interior, US Geological Survey; Branch of Information Services.

  51. Lennartz, B., Louchart, X., Voltz, M., & Andrieux, P. (1997). Diuron and simazine losses to runoff water in Mediterranean vineyards. Journal of Environmental Quality, 26(6), 1493–1502.

  52. Levanon, D., Codling, E. E., Meisinger, J. J., & Starr, J. L. (1993). Mobility of agrochemicals through soil from two tillage systems. Journal of Environmental Quality, 22(1), 155–161. .

  53. Lewis, K. A., Tzilivakis, J., Warner, D., & Green, A. (2016). An international database for pesticide risk assessments and management. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal, 22(4), 1050–1064.

  54. Linde, C.D. (1994). Physico-chemical properties and environmental fate of pesticides. Environmental Hazards Assessment Program, State of California, Environmental Protection Agency, USA. http://www.cdpr.ca.gov/docs/emon/pubs/ehapreps/eh9403.pdf. Accessed 1 December 2016.

  55. Locke, M. A., Zablotowicz, R. M., Reddy, K. N., & Steinriede, R. W. (2008). Tillage management to mitigate herbicide loss in runoff under simulated rainfall conditions. Chemosphere, 70(8), 1422–1428.

  56. Logan, T. J., Lal, R., & Dick, W. A. (1991). Tillage systems and soil properties in North America. Soil and Tillage Research, 20(2–4), 241–270.

  57. Logan, T. J., Eckert, D. J., & Beak, D. G. (1994). Tillage, crop and climatic effects of runoff and tile drainage losses of nitrate and four herbicides. Soil and Tillage Research, 30(1), 75–103.

  58. Lu, X., Wang, L., & McCabe, M. F. (2016). Elevated CO2 as a driver of global dryland greening. Scientific Reports, 6(1), 20716.

  59. McDaniel, M. D., Tiemann, L. K., & Grandy, A. S. (2014). Does agricultural crop diversity enhance soil microbial biomass and organic matter dynamics? A meta-analysis. Ecological Applications, 24(3), 560–570.

  60. McMahon, T. A., Halstead, N. T., Johnson, S., Raffel, T. R., Romansic, J. M., Crumrine, P. W., & Rohr, J. R. (2012). Fungicide-induced declines of freshwater biodiversity modify ecosystem functions and services. Ecology Letters, 15(7), 714–722.

  61. Mickelson, S. K., Boyd, P., Baker, J. L., & Ahmed, S. I. (2001). Tillage and herbicide incorporation effects on residue cover, runoff, erosion, and herbicide loss. Soil and Tillage Research, 60(1), 55–66.

  62. Mishra, J. S., & Singh, V. P. (2012). Tillage and weed control effects on productivity of a dry seeded rice–wheat system on a Vertisol in Central India. Soil and Tillage Research, 123, 11–20.

  63. Moore, M. T., Kröger, R., Locke, M. A., Lizotte, R. E., Testa, S., & Cooper, C. M. (2014). Diazinon and permethrin mitigation across a grass–wetland buffer. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 93(5), 574–579.

  64. Myers, J. L., Wagger, M. G., & Leidy, R. B. (1995). Chemical movement in relation to tillage system and simulated rainfall intensity. Journal of Environmental Quality, 24(6), 1183–1192.

  65. Nakagawa, S., & Lagisz, M. (2016). Visualizing unbiased and biased unweighted meta-analyses. Journal of Evolutionary Biology, 29(10), 1914–1916.

  66. Ochsner, T. E., Stephens, B. M., Koskinen, W. C., & Kookana, R. S. (2006). Sorption of a hydrophilic pesticide. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 70(6), 1991–1997.

  67. Pantone, D. J., Potter, K. N., Torbert, H. A., & Morrison, J. E. (1996). Atrazine loss in runoff from no-tillage and chisel-tillage systems on a Houston black clay soil. Journal of Environmental Quality, 25(3), 572–577.

  68. Pedersen, J. A., Yeager, M. A., & Suffet, I. H. (2006). Organophosphorus insecticides in agricultural and residential runoff: field observations and implications for total maximum daily load development. Environmental Science & Technology, 40(7), 2120–2127.

  69. Phillips, R. E., Thomas, G. W., Blevins, R. L., Frye, W. W., & Phillips, S. H. (1980). No-tillage agriculture. Science, 208(4448), 1108–1113.

  70. Reddy, K. N., & Locke, M. A. (1998). Sulfentrazone sorption, desorption, and mineralization in soils from two tillage systems. Weed Science, 494-500.

  71. Reddy, K. N., Zablotowicz, R. M., & Locke, M. A. (1995). Chlorimuron adsorption, desorption, and degradation in soils from conventional tillage and no-tillage systems. Journal of Environmental Quality, 24(4), 760–767.

  72. Reddy, K. N., Locke, M. A., & Gaston, L. A. (1997). Tillage and cover crop effects on cyanazine adsorption and desorption kinetics. Soil Science, 162(7), 501–509.

  73. Rice, P. J., McConnell, L. L., Heighton, L. P., Sadeghi, A. M., Isensee, A. R., Teasdale, J. R., Abdul-Baki, A. A., Harman-Fetcho, J. A., & Hapeman, C. J. (2001). Runoff loss of pesticides and soil. Journal of Environmental Quality, 30(5), 1808–1821.

  74. Rinsky, J. L., Hopenhayn, C., Golla, V., Browning, S., & Bush, H. M. (2012). Atrazine exposure in public drinking water and preterm birth. Public Health Reports, 127(1), 72–80.

  75. Sauer, T. J., & Daniel, T. C. (1987). Effect of tillage system on runoff losses of surface-applied pesticides. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 51(2), 410–415.

  76. Sheng, G., Yang, Y., Huang, M., & Yang, K. (2005). Influence of pH on pesticide sorption by soil containing wheat residue-derived char. Environmental Pollution, 134(3), 457–463.

  77. Shipitalo, M. J., & Owens, L. B. (2006). Tillage system, application rate, and extreme event effects on herbicide losses in surface runoff. Journal of Environmental Quality, 35(6), 2186–2194.

  78. Shipitalo, M. J., & Owens, L. B. (2011). Comparative losses of glyphosate and selected residual herbicides in surface runoff from conservation-tilled watersheds planted with corn or soybean. Journal of Environmental Quality, 40(4), 1281–1289.

  79. Shipitalo, M. J., Edwards, W. M., & Owens, L. B. (1997). Herbicide losses in runoff from conservation-tilled watersheds in a corn-soybean rotation. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 61(1), 267–272.

  80. Shipitalo, M. J., Malone, R. W., & Owens, L. B. (2008). Impact of glyphosate-tolerant soybean and glufosinate-tolerant corn production on herbicide losses in surface runoff. Journal of Environmental Quality, 37(2), 401–408.

  81. Spiertz, J. H. J., & Ewert, F. (2009). Crop production and resource use to meet the growing demand for food, feed and fuel: opportunities and constraints. NJAS-Wageningen Journal of Life Sciences, 56(4), 281–300.

  82. Staff, S. S. D. (2017). Soil Survey Manual. In C. Ditzler, K. Scheffe, & H. C. Monger (Eds.), USDA Handbook 18. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.

    Google Scholar 

  83. Stephan, C. E., Mount, D. I., Hansen, D. J., Gentile, J. H., Chapman, G. A., & Brungs, W. A. (1985). Guidelines for deriving numerical national water quality criteria for the protection of aquatic organisms and their uses (p. 98). Duluth: US Environmental Protection Agency.

    Google Scholar 

  84. Teasdale, J. R., Beste, C. E., & Potts, W. E. (1991). Response of weeds to tillage and cover crop residue. Weed Science, 39(2), 195–199.

  85. Thomas, G. A., Dalal, R. C., & Standley, J. (2007). No-till effects on organic matter, pH, cation exchange capacity and nutrient distribution in a Luvisol in the semi-arid subtropics. Soil and Tillage Research, 94(2), 295–304.

  86. Tilman, D., Fargione, J., Wolff, B., D’Antonio, C., Dobson, A., Howarth, R., Schindler, D., Schlesinger, W. H., Simberloff, D., & Swackhamer, D. (2001). Forecasting agriculturally driven global environmental change. Science, 292(5515), 281–284.

  87. Triplett, G. B., Conner, B. J., & Edwards, W. M. (1978). Transport of atrazine and simazine in runoff from conventional and no-tillage corn. Journal of Environmental Quality, 7(1), 77–84.

  88. United States Department of Agriculture. (2002). World Agricultural Production. Circular Series WAP 08-02. Washington D.C.: USDA–Foreign Agriculture Service.

    Google Scholar 

  89. United States Department of Agriculture. (2016). World Agricultural Production. Circular Series WAP 11-17. Washington D.C.: USDA–Foreign Agriculture Service.

    Google Scholar 

  90. United States Department of Agriculture-Natural Resources Conservation Service. (2016). Residue and Tillage management. USDA–NRCS. https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/national/programs/?cid=nrcs144p2_027311. Accessed 1 December 2016.

  91. United States Environmental Protection Agency. (2016). Aquatic life ambient water quality criteria for carbaryl. EPA/820/R-12/007. Washington, DC: Office of Water, Science and Technology.

    Google Scholar 

  92. University of Hertfordshire, Pesticides Properties Database. (2017). Pesticides properties database. Agriculture & Environment Research Unit (AERU) at University of Hertfordshire. Hertfordshire, UK. http://sitem.herts.ac.uk/aeru/ppdb/en/index.htm. Accessed 1 December 2016.

  93. Warnemuende, E. A., Patterson, J. P., Smith, D. R., & Huang, C. H. (2007). Effects of tilling no-till soil on losses of atrazine and glyphosate to runoff water under variable intensity simulated rainfall. Soil and Tillage Research, 95(1), 19–26.

  94. Watanabe, H., Watermeier, N. L., Steichen, J. M., Barnes, P., & Phong, T. K. (2007). Impacts of tillage and application methods on atrazine and alachlor losses from upland fields. Weed Biology and Management, 7(1), 44–54.

  95. Wauchope, R. D., Buttler, T. M., Hornsby, A. G., Augustijn-Beckers, P. W. M., & Burt, J. P. (1992). The SCS/ARS/CES pesticide properties database for environmental decision-making. In Reviews of environmental contamination and toxicology (pp. 1-155). New York: Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4612-2862-2_1.

  96. Wik, M., Pingali, P. & Broca, S. (2008). Global agricultural performance: past trends and future prospects. Background paper for the World Development Report. Washington, DC, USA: World Bank. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.697.2420&rep=rep1&type=pdfAccessed 1 December 2016.

  97. World Health Organization. (2002). Genomics and world health: report of the Advisory Committee on Health Research. Geneva: World Health Organization.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Acknowledgments

This research was supported by grants from the Indiana Water Resources Research Center (104B grant, 4107-73618) and USDA-NIFA (2014-51130-22492). The authors thank Dr. Stefani Daryanto for assistance with the MetaWin software package.

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Pierre-Andre Jacinthe.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Elias, D., Wang, L. & Jacinthe, PA. A meta-analysis of pesticide loss in runoff under conventional tillage and no-till management. Environ Monit Assess 190, 79 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-017-6441-1

Download citation

Keywords

  • Tillage
  • Octanol-water partition coefficient
  • Solubility
  • pH
  • Soil organic matter
  • Texture