Abstract
More than 30 laboratories routinely monitor water along southern California's beaches for bacterial indicators of fecal contamination. Data from these efforts frequently are combined and compared even though three different methods (membrane filtration (MF), multiple tube fermentation (MTF), and chromogenic substrate (CS) methods) are used. To assess data comparability and quantify variability within method and across laboratories, 26 laboratories participated in an intercalibration exercise. Each laboratory processed three replicates from eight ambient water samples employing the method or methods they routinely use for water quality monitoring. Verification analyses also were conducted on a subset of wells from the CS analysis to confirm or exclude the presence of the target organism. Enterococci results were generally comparable across methods. Confirmation revealed a 9% false positive rate and a 4% false negative rate in the CS method for enterococci, though these errors were small in the context of within- and among-laboratory variability. Fecal coliforms also were comparable across all methods, though CS underestimated the other methods by about 10%, probably because it measures only E. coli, rather than the larger fecal coliform group measured by MF and MTF. CS overestimated total coliforms relative to the other methods by several fold and was found to have a 40% false positive rate in verification. Across-laboratory variability was small relative to within- and among-method variability, but only after data entry errors were corrected. One fifth of the laboratories committed data entry errors that were much larger than any method-related errors. These errors are particularly significant because these data were submitted in a test situation where laboratories were aware they would be under increased scrutiny. Under normal circumstances, it is unlikely that these errors would have been detected and managers would have been obliged to issue beach water quality warnings.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abbott, S., Caughley, B. and Scott, G.: 1998, ‘Evaluation of Enterolert for enumeration of enterococci in the marine environment’, New Zealand J. Mar. Freshwater Res. 32, 505–515.
APHA (American Public Health Association): 1995, Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater, 18th Edition, A. D. Eaton, L. S. Clesceri and A. E. Greenberg (eds), Washington, DC.
Bej, A. K., McCarty, S. C. and Atlas, R. M.: 1991, ‘Detection of coliform bacteria and Escherichia coli by multiplex polymerase chain reaction: Comparison with defined substrate and plating methods for water quality monitoring’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 57, 2429–2432.
Budnick, G. E., Howard, R. T. and Mayo, D. R.: 1996, ‘Evaluation of Enterolert for enumeration of enterococci in recreational waters’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 62, 3881–3884.
Conover, W. J. and Iman, R. L.: 1981, ‘Rank transform as a bridge between parametric and nonparametric statistics’, Am. Statistician 35, 125–141.
Covert, T. C., Shadix, L. C., Rice, E. W., Haines, J. R. and Freyberg, R. W.: 1989, ‘Evaluation of the autoanalysis Colilert test for detection and enumeration of total coliforms’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 55, 2443–2447.
Davies, C. M., Apte, S. C., Peterson, S. M. and Stauber, J. L.: 1995, ‘Possible interference of lactose-fermenting marine vibrios in coliform B-D-galactosidase assays’, J. Appl. Bacteriol. 78, 287–393.
Eckner, K. F.: 1998, ‘Comparison of membrane filtration and multiple-tube fermentation by Colilert and Enterolert methods for detection of waterborne coliform bacteria, Escherichia coli, and enterococci used in drinking and bathing water quality monitoring in southern Sweden’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64, 3079–3083.
Edberg, S. C., Allen, M. J., Smith, D. B. and Kriz, N. J.: 1990, ‘Enumeration of total coliforms and Escherichia coli from source water by defined substrate technology’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 8, 366–369.
Ferguson, D. M., Moore, D. F., Getrich, M. A. and M. H. Zhowandai: in press, ‘Enumeration and speciation of enterococci found in marine and intertidal sediments and coastal water in southern California’, Journal of Applied Microbiology.
Fleisher, J. M.: 1990, ‘The effects of measurement error on previously reported mathematical relationships between indicator organism density and swimming associated illness: A quantitative estimate of bias’, Int. J. Epidemiol. 19, 1100–1106.
Francy, D. S. and Darner, R. A.: 2000, ‘Comparison of methods for determining Escherichia coli concentrations in recreational waters’, Water Res. 24, 2770–2778.
Hidalgo, C., Reyes, J. and Goldschmidt, R.: 1977, ‘Induction and properties of B-galactosidase and B-galactosidase permease in Pseudomonas BAL-31’, J. Bacteriol. 129, 821–829.
Kinzelman, J., Ng, C., Jackson, E., Gradus, S. and Bagley, R.: 2003, ‘Enterococci as indicators of Lake Michigan recreational water quality: Comparison of two methodologies and their impacts on public health regulatory events’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 69, 92–96.
Landre, J. P., Gavriel, A. A. and Lamb, A. J.: 1998, ‘False-positive coliform reaction mediated by Aeromonas in the Colilert defined substrate technology system’, Lett. Appl. Microbiol. 26, 352–354.
Noble, R. T., Weisberg, S. B., Leecaster, M. K., McGee, C. D., Ritter, K., Walker, K. O. and Vainik, P. M.: 2003a, ‘Comparison of beach bacterial water quality indicator measurement methods’, Environ. Monit. Assess. 81, 301–312.
Noble, R. T., Moore, D. F., Leecaster, M., McGee, C. D. and Weisberg, S. B.: 2003b, ‘Comparison of total coliforms, fecal coliforms, and enterococci bacterial indicator response for ocean recreational water quality testing’, Water Res. 37, 1637–1643.
Palmer, C. J., Tsai, Y., Lang, A. L. and Sangermano, L. R.: 1993, ‘Evaluation of Colilert-marine water for detection of total coliforms and Escherichia coli in the marine environment’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 59, 786–790.
Pisciotta, J. M., Rath, D. F., Stanek, P. A., Flanery, D. M. and Harwood, V. J.: 2002, ‘Marine bacteria cause false-positive results in the Colilert-18 rapid identification test for Escherichia coli in Florida waters’, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 68, 539–544.
Schiff, K. C., Weisberg, S. B. and Raco-Rands, V. E.: 2002, ‘Inventory of ocean monitoring in the Southern California Bight’, Environ. Manage. 29, 871–876.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Griffith, J.F., Aumand, L.A., Lee, I.M. et al. Comparison and Verification of Bacterial Water Quality Indicator Measurement Methods Using Ambient Coastal Water Samples. Environ Monit Assess 116, 335–344 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-006-7571-z
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-006-7571-z